US physically hacks 100,000 foreign computers

I wonder if dan cares when China, Russia, Pakistan, etc. spy on the US?


Actually a stupid question. I know he doesn't.

I don't care about who spies. It does not bother me.
 
Do you honestly believe that the intelligence services of the PRC do not target the U.S.A. and Canada?

Your statements reek of Henry L. Stimson before he saw the error of his ways.

Of course they do, and that's also illegal.
Or are you suggesting its legal for the US and not anyone else?
 
I don't care about who spies. It does not bother me. ....

Umm, then why did you create the thread?


The openness of North American culture makes it more likely that our spying gets publicized. In China and Russia, anyone who complains just goes away. Would killing suspected whistle-blowers be a system you would prefer?
 
Acting like Nigerian scammers and hijacking computers is very much illegal.
As is intercepting email and phone data.

Do you think that China is also entitled to spy on the US and Canada in the same way?
I assume that you'd be fine with it, if you don't mind the US reading your email, checking your browsing history and tracking your phone gps data.

I think the United States would try to stop Chinese intelligence gathering. I absolutely expect China to try and gather intelligence on the United States and Canada, and I expect our governments to try and foil those attempts.

You use the term "illegal" without knowing its meaning, or defining it properly. Are you suggesting the NSA should be bound by the laws of Pakistan?

But try to answer some of the questions. What is legitimate intelligence gathering?

And should a nation devise its intelligence gathering strategy based on the laws of other nations?

That is what you are advocating?
 
I think the United States would try to stop Chinese intelligence gathering. I absolutely expect China to try and gather intelligence on the United States and Canada, and I expect our governments to try and foil those attempts.

You use the term "illegal" without knowing its meaning, or defining it properly. Are you suggesting the NSA should be bound by the laws of Pakistan?

But try to answer some of the questions. What is legitimate intelligence gathering?

And should a nation devise its intelligence gathering strategy based on the laws of other nations?

That is what you are advocating?

We've always had spying, but that doesn't make it legal.
Talk to Jonathan Pollard, he'll tell you why its illegal.

Its all part of the creeping police state that right wing governments are implementing. Britain has a few really heinous moves going on, from the great wall of Cameron (nationwide firewalling just like in China) to a bill that's going to allow police to arrest and detain anyone on suspicion of future activities. In the US, police have been funding offices by stopping and stealing (legally confiscating) items from police, so much that there is now a movement called 'contempt of cop'. Excellent article at the cbc on it (would never get published by corporate media here).
http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/contempt-of-cop-america-s-defiance-revolution-1.2498082

Invasion of privacy, from logging phone calls and gps data, hijacking computers, tracking email and web surfacing is illegal. Spying that uses these techniques is illegal.
Even in the US, despite its move towards a police state. Have you forgotten why Nixon resigned?

Are you really backing the moves towards a new police state?
 
We've always had spying, but that doesn't make it legal.
Talk to Jonathan Pollard, he'll tell you why its illegal.

Its all part of the creeping police state that right wing governments are implementing. Britain has a few really heinous moves going on, from the great wall of Cameron (nationwide firewalling just like in China) to a bill that's going to allow police to arrest and detain anyone on suspicion of future activities. In the US, police have been funding offices by stopping and stealing (legally confiscating) items from police, so much that there is now a movement called 'contempt of cop'. Excellent article at the cbc on it (would never get published by corporate media here).
http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/contempt-of-cop-america-s-defiance-revolution-1.2498082

Invasion of privacy, from logging phone calls and gps data, hijacking computers, tracking email and web surfacing is illegal. Spying that uses these techniques is illegal.
Even in the US, despite its move towards a police state. Have you forgotten why Nixon resigned?

Are you really backing the moves towards a new police state?

Of course not. But the more power you give government, total, the more power they can use against you.

If you give government power by creating a massive social safety net, if you give government power by allowing them to police your speech, if you give government power period, then you're giving government power to spy on you as well.

The inherent solution suggested by your "conservatives spy on us" would be to never, ever, ever elect in in a conservative government anywhere in the world. And that is as stupid and unrealistic solution as can exist. This is not a world without costs. Which is more valuable to you: the social safety net and PC watchdogging or your privacy rights? Because you can't have both.

WRT international spying, you're in luck: those nasty conservatives don't believe in the "borders don't really exist" hippie nonsense you subscribe to, so you CAN convince them to spy on nasty furriners and not spy domestically.

Your posts are a mess of illogical "want" rather than a logical understanding of the balance of forces inherent in government power.
 
We've always had spying, but that doesn't make it legal.
Which has what to do with what? Are you proposing that no state should spy on another state or a non-state actor unless that state or non-state actor gives its permission? :confused:

Further as to your comment about the U.K. you are aware that this blocking of "child porn" is strongly supported by the left of center and feminist groups are you not?
 
We've always had spying, but that doesn't make it legal.
Talk to Jonathan Pollard, he'll tell you why its illegal.

Its all part of the creeping police state that right wing governments are implementing. Britain has a few really heinous moves going on, from the great wall of Cameron (nationwide firewalling just like in China) to a bill that's going to allow police to arrest and detain anyone on suspicion of future activities. In the US, police have been funding offices by stopping and stealing (legally confiscating) items from police, so much that there is now a movement called 'contempt of cop'. Excellent article at the cbc on it (would never get published by corporate media here).
http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/contempt-of-cop-america-s-defiance-revolution-1.2498082

Invasion of privacy, from logging phone calls and gps data, hijacking computers, tracking email and web surfacing is illegal. Spying that uses these techniques is illegal.
Even in the US, despite its move towards a police state. Have you forgotten why Nixon resigned?

Are you really backing the moves towards a new police state?

Actually that doesn't make it clear at all why you think this activity is illegal. What laws do you say have been broken by these acts?

This has nothing to do with Nixon and being the coward you are, you still fail to answer the decisive questions. No surprise, you are simply an anti-american rabid dog.

But I will do you the courtesy of answering yours. A police state is one that tramples on the rights of its own citizens and does not have adequate structures in place, or any structures to protect those rights. None of this has anything to do with foreign intelligence gathering.

You want the US to set it's policy blindly, because you hate the nation and want it to fail.

But I will ask again in the hope you grow a pair:

Should a nation guide its foreign intelligence gathering activities based on the laws of countries they are gathering intelligence on?