US physically hacks 100,000 foreign computers

If you think that a great power should conduct its military planning, economic planning and foreign policy without quality intelligence, than I am very, very glad that you have no influence on policy.

It is not gathering intelligence that is the problem. It is getting caught that is.

A military man like you must know the value of occupying the high ground.
 
It is not gathering intelligence that is the problem. It is getting caught that is.

A military man like you must know the value of occupying the high ground.

The high ground, if you are referring to the "moral" high ground is certainly well occupied by the United States on many issues. Eventually all types of intelligence get "caught", then a new generation occurs and around we go again.

But your comment has some real value to it. I am pleased to see that you think that this was legitimate intelligence gathering, and that it is in the best interests of the United States not to get caught. Which means, logically, that you think that what Mr. Snowdon did in revealing this type of information was to harm the best interests of the United States by revealing legitimate foreign intelligence gathering.
 
But your comment has some real value to it. I am pleased to see that you think that this was legitimate intelligence gathering, and that it is in the best interests of the United States not to get caught. Which means, logically, that you think that what Mr. Snowdon did in revealing this type of information was to harm the best interests of the United States by revealing legitimate foreign intelligence gathering.

You are drawing too sweeping generalizations. I think that some of the activities were "legitimite" although this may not be the best choice of a word. Maybe generally accepted as necessary is a better way of putting it. I think other activities were downright stupid, and that a large percentage of it was uncalled for and utterly useless.

I hope this does not take away any of your pleasure.
 
It is not gathering intelligence that is the problem. It is getting caught that is.
You can of course thank that friend of the SVR Edward Snowden for this.

Nor is there any way to defend it as "whistle blowing" it rather is exposing legitimate foreign intelligence activities of the United States this of course is a major violation of the Espionage Act.

However, I fully agree that giving out Top Secret code word clearances in very box of Cracker Jack was highly foolish. Likewise although it is very difficult in the current day of thumb drives etc. . . but what ever happened to the there must be two people in the room at all times rule at least four of the more recent espionage cases involved the breaking of or absence of this rule.
 
You can of course thank that friend of the SVR Edward Snowden for this.

Nor is there any way to defend it as "whistle blowing" it rather is exposing legitimate foreign intelligence activities of the United States this of course is a major violation of the Espionage Act.

What is 'legitimate' foreign intelligence activities?
Do you really think these acts are legal in the countries where they are occurring?
Do you think it would be legal for China or Russia to do the same to the US?

As Snowden has put it, the US is now spying more, on US citizens and foreigners, then big brother in 1984.
 
US physically hacks 100,000 foreign computers


NSA spies have inserted circuitry into computers in China, Russia, EU, India, Saudi and Pakistan to gain intelligence.

Last updated: 15 Jan 2014 10:50
The United States has implanted devices in nearly 100,000 computers to spy on institutions such as the Chinese and Russian military, EU trade groups and agencies within Saudi Arabia, India and Pakistan.

The New York Times on Tuesday cited documents from the National Security Agency, computer experts and US officials stating that the NSA uses radio wave technology to gain access to otherwise encrypted computers or machines that are not connected to the internet.

The Times reported that the agency has been inserting tiny circuit boards into computers for several years. The technology allows non-internet connected computers to be hacked, and bypasses encryption and anti-spyware systems that otherwise prevent hacking over the world wide web.

The NSA calls the effort an "active defence"' and has used the technology to monitor units of the Chinese and Russian armies, drug cartels, trade institutions inside the European Union, and US allies including Saudi Arabia, India and Pakistan, the Times reported.

Among the most frequent targets has been the Chinese army, the Times reported.

The United States has accused the Chinese Army of launching regular attacks on American industrial and military targets, often to steal secrets or intellectual property.

US officials have protested when Chinese attackers have placed similar software on computer systems of US companies or government agencies.

The NSA said the technology has not been used in computers in the US.

"NSA's activities are focused and specifically deployed against - and only against - valid foreign intelligence targets in response to intelligence requirements,'' Vanee Vines, an agency spokeswoman, said in a statement to the Times.

"We do not use foreign intelligence capabilities to steal the trade secrets of foreign companies on behalf of - or give intelligence we collect to - US companies to enhance their international competitiveness or increase their bottom line.''


so much for the land of the free
 
What is 'legitimate' foreign intelligence activities?
Do you really think these acts are legal in the countries where they are occurring?
Do you think it would be legal for China or Russia to do the same to the US?

As Snowden has put it, the US is now spying more, on US citizens and foreigners, then big brother in 1984.

Feel free to answer your own questions. Do you think this is not legitimate intelligence gathering?

Should a nation direct its intelligence gathering or national security activities based on what is legal in another country? You do realize how absurd that idea is don't you?
 
Last edited:
You are drawing too sweeping generalizations. I think that some of the activities were "legitimite" although this may not be the best choice of a word. Maybe generally accepted as necessary is a better way of putting it. I think other activities were downright stupid, and that a large percentage of it was uncalled for and utterly useless.

I hope this does not take away any of your pleasure.

Not at all. Your position sinks Snowdon. Your position was that intelligence gathering is legitimate only getting caught is the problem.

It appears that you have changed sides.

Your conclusions about the quality of the intelligence obtained, or its useful, seem a tad underinformed. What intelligence was gained?
 
Not at all. Your position sinks Snowdon. Your position was that intelligence gathering is legitimate only getting caught is the problem.

It appears that you have changed sides.

Your conclusions about the quality of the intelligence obtained, or its useful, seem a tad underinformed. What intelligence was gained?

I have no interest in defending or sinking Snowden. I will leave that to You and Aardvark to argue with others. He is in Russia.

I think a more pertinent discussion is if the NSA is helping or hindering the interests of the US.

PS: Please do not think I would be stupid enough to take your bait.
 
I have no interest in defending or sinking Snowden. I will leave that to You and Aardvark to argue with others. He is in Russia.

I think a more pertinent discussion is if the NSA is helping or hindering the interests of the US.

Which you must agree is impossible to evaluate without knowing the quality of the intelligence obtained, and if there will be any long term negatives to this disclosure, other than the end of this specific program, if it was still active.
 
Which you must agree is impossible to evaluate without knowing the quality of the intelligence obtained, and if there will be any long term negatives to this disclosure, other than the end of this specific program, if it was still active.

Fair enough. But we can make some judgements about the activities and their potentials. If they over-reach their benefit/risk gets worse.
 
Why is this in a newspaper....or even news.

I would expect this would happen.

Pretty much, yeah.

Do you really think Canada doesn't have a couple of feelers out with people in the US? That Canada doesn't keep an eye on the US, doesn't pay attention to whether the US is going to change its attitude towards Canada?

And if Canada doesn't have those feelers out, it Canada isn't paying attention, then the Canadian government is being criminally negligent. Do you really think France isn't spying on Germany, that Germany isn't spying on the Brits, that the Brits aren't spying on Italy? They're not priority desks, I'm sure, but you keep a base level of intelligence gathering on everyone you can afford to keep an eye on. And in the US's case, that could easily mean an office or two dedicated to every major nation, allied or not.

Done right, done well, and done out of the limelight but through the tacit understanding of each government, it's even a stabilizing force.

I mean, really, Canada shares a nearly NINE THOUSAND KM demilitarized border with the US. Canada doesn't have anyone paying attention to whether the US is going to invade or not? Waiting for there to be a problem to insert intelligence assets is a bad idea. A couple of million dedicated to making sure that border stays safe is fairly smart, isn't it? Paranoid as hell, yes. But still the smart thing to do.
 
Feel free to answer your own questions. Do you think this is not legitimate intelligence gathering?

Acting like Nigerian scammers and hijacking computers is very much illegal.
As is intercepting email and phone data.

Do you think that China is also entitled to spy on the US and Canada in the same way?
I assume that you'd be fine with it, if you don't mind the US reading your email, checking your browsing history and tracking your phone gps data.
 
Do you think that China is also entitled to spy on the US and Canada in the same way?
Do you honestly believe that the intelligence services of the PRC do not target the U.S.A. and Canada?

Your statements reek of Henry L. Stimson before he saw the error of his ways.
 
Do you honestly believe that the intelligence services of the PRC do not target the U.S.A. and Canada?

Your statements reek of Henry L. Stimson before he saw the error of his ways.

Exactly.

Everyone spies on everyone else. Now, the US has certain abilities that most/all other countries don't have. But whether you like it or not, that's true of a lot of things. Is it embarrassing, is it news to the average man on the street, is it a great opportunity for various nations' politicians to grandstand and do their best "I'm shocked, SHOCKED that such a thing occurs!!!"? Oh, yeah. But it really means nothing more than that.
 
I wonder if dan cares when China, Russia, Pakistan, etc. spy on the US?


Actually a stupid question. I know he doesn't.