US navy destroyer collides with cargo ship - 7 sailors missing

Perhaps you have to have some familiarity with the COLREGS (The International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea 1972) but what Dave posted is straight forward enough.

Now another factor is that no vessel ever has an absolute right of way, indeed Rules 2 and 17 provide that you must take action to avoid a collision. As the mnemonic goes "To act as caution says is proper, Ease her, turn her, back her, stop her."

The theory that muslim extremists get hold of a fully loaded containership and rams a US Navy destroyer is beyond ridiculous. The chances of a large containership being able to purposely hit a US Navy destroyer is nil.

Think! If a US Navy destroyer is vulnerable to enemy containerships, the US Navy needs to revise many of their tactics.
 
Look at the photographs again. The collision seemingly occurred with the ACX Crystal abaft the beam of the Fitzgerald
Incorrect. "Abaft the beam" means: Further aft than the beam (midpoint or widest part of the ship): a relative bearing of greater than 90 degrees from the bow (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glossary_of_nautical_terms). The damage to the Fitz was directly below the bridge and the forward SPY-1 radar array. This is CLEARLY in the forward half of the ship.
Here's a picture of where the collision occurred: https://media3.s-nbcnews.com/j/news...6be82702d3de26edb3c2.nbcnews-ux-2880-1000.jpg
Here'a a picture of the entire Fitzgerald: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipe...px-Valiant_Shield_2012_120912-N-TX154-258.jpg


so it wasn't a T-Bone (in which case the damage to the ACX Crystal would be a crushed in bow, (and clearly not from forward of the beam of the Fitzgerald in which case the damage to the ACX Crystal would have been on her Starboard bow) as it was a sideswipe.
It clearly was forward of the beam of the Fitzgerald! The bow of the ACX Crystal was indeed damaged and badly torn. The peak of the Crystal's bow was ABOVE the decks of the Fitzgerald, it is believed that the Crystal approached the Fitz at close to 10-20 degrees (bow on) and hit the Fitz initially one deck above the main deck level (this is where the Crystal received the tear in her bow and damage to her bulbous bow was below the waterline). Because one or both of the ships had begun to maneuver to avoid the collision (Fitz moving to the port and/or Crystal moving to the starboard) and that the Fitz was moving faster at the time of the collision, it is theorized that the Fitz's momentum continued to carry her forward as her bow moved to the port, causing and the left side of the Crystal's bow to hit the superstructure and roll-off it. That's why the Fitz's superstructure looks crushed and flattened rather than torn away.

Another indicator is the Crystal's anchor. It appears undamaged and the hawse is only scraped. Both items are much stronger that the plates on the destroyer - if it was a glancing blow the anchor would have shredded the side of the Fitzgerald. The anchor is shaped like a giant cleave.

Here'a an image: http://i2.cdn.cnn.com/cnnnext/dam/a...argo-ship-uss-fitzgerald-0617-exlarge-169.jpg <-- notice the tear in her hull which extends from port to starboard.
What we can't see is the damage to the bulbous bow (because it's underwater), but reports are it's crushed inward.


Now there are different ways that could have occurred, the closest to your scenario being one or both ships attempted to avoid the collision at the last moment.
Only one needed to be maneuvering, but both would have had the same effect. Keep in mind that the Fitz is capable of much tighter turns than the Crystal and the theory is the Fitz was traveling faster.

I'm relaying what I'm reading on a navy chat board. It a collection of x-navy people and military enthusiasts. This is the groups current working theory.
 
The theory that muslim extremists get hold of a fully loaded containership and rams a US Navy destroyer is beyond ridiculous. The chances of a large containership being able to purposely hit a US Navy destroyer is nil.
You are focusing on Dave's second two paragraphs, I was concentrating on his first two paragraphs. It was not clear until now that you were doing so.
 
Bottom Line Promo, a very through investigation has already started and all we outside that investigation are doing is speculating.

The final report will be publicly released and there will be a press conference as to the findings.
 
I think you are confused. The collision occurred between a US destroyer and a Philippine flagged cargo ship.

As silent as a destroyer can run, possible testing new stealth technologies
Umm. Do you think a submarine was involved, you seem to keep going back to sound, sonar and subs? No sub was involved.
An Arleigh Burke-class destroyer is not stealthy, although it has a few stealthy constructs (tripod vs solid mask). It was designed in the early 1980s, Americans have only just begun in the last 10 years to design serious stealth into their main warships.

Every ship and sub has a radar signature, maybe they wanted to determine the extent of this signature on this particular class of destroyer
The first Arleigh Burke-class destroyer was launched in 1991. In 26 years and >75 ships I'm sure the Navy has this figured out. The Fitzgerald was a Flight 1 ship.

What is the radar signature of a submarine at 100 feet?

Sound travels much further through water than it does through air
Your point? The Crystal does not have sonar. If the Fitz was doing sound testing with another ship or sub, this does not require her to turn off her radar or not keep vigilant for other ships in the area.

It is more likely that the destroyer was on some kind of testing of new equipment or rendez vous with another ship than routine patrol.
Maybe. But if it's early phase testing, that tends to get done in controlled conditions and it still doesn't excuse the Fitz from being vigilant.
 
Bottom Line Promo, a very through investigation has already started and all we outside that investigation are doing is speculating.

The final report will be publicly released and there will be a press conference as to the findings.

Hopefully by people who actually know what "Abaft the beam" actually means.

Google is a great thing Aardy, but it does require a basic understanding of the subject matter.
 
Read the rest of the International Maritime Law. On another board it was quoted that this starboard rule only applies if the other ship was on something like a steady course and the U turn and "attack" could shift the liability to the PI ship.
There are many qualifiers. Anchor vs power vs sail. Speed and angle of overtake, etc. It's certainly conceivable that the Crystal suffered from problems with her steering gear (might explain the previous erratic maneuvering) - that's a good point and something no-one has mentioned on my other board. However, in general, commercial ships aren't allowed to get close to military ships unless it's being escorted. As a general rule of thumb 3-5 nautical miles in open ocean. At standard cruise speeds of 10-15 knots, that should allow 6-10+ minutes of reaction time.

Also we do not know how fast the Fritz was going. There are some speculative reports it was "on station" and close to dead in the water. If true, it would not be able to roar up the engines and move fast enough to avoid the T bone attack.
I hadn't read that. The leading theories on my board is that the Fitz was traveling faster than the Crystal and that the Crystal's bow rolled-off the Fitz superstructure. Keep in mind that the Fitz should/may have had 6+ minutes of reaction time, although the main diesels may have been at idle, they can still accelerate the ship very rapidly - that's one of the design requirements for the class.

ISIS is very active in PI and the Fritz had one of the most sophisticated missile defense systems against a North Korea missile attack. A perfect traget and opportunity if it was ISIS inspired. Takes the ship out of commission for maybe a year.

If the Fritz saw the ship coming and could not manuver fast enough out of the way have no idea what defensees thewould have. They have missiles to shoot down missiles and planes and probably lots of guns. But do they have something big enough to fire at the oncoming vessel. Do they sink it? Maybe it was out of control and U.S. may not want to sink it.

This all took a short time for decisions to be made. It will eventually come out maybe in a year after the investigation.
The Fitz indeed has a 5" main deck gun, but it would take ALLOT of hits to sink a cargo ship. The main anti-ship weapon are the Harpoon missiles in the VLS just forward of the damaged area. I doubt very much that the Fitz could launch those without orders.

The Crystal is back in port, if indeed it was being operated by terrorists, pretty sure we'd have heard that by now.
 
Don't know if any of you guys have actually been aboard a warship underway. The fact that the Captain was in his quarters (if true, and seems likely if he was injured when the bridge and Ops room seems intact) means there was nothing important going on and most probably a relatively junior officer had the watch. Yes, there are lookouts aboard the warship, but it's very probable that no one was looking out the window on the container ship. The watch officer would very likely have had standing orders to call (wake) the Captain and give him a CPA on any ship approaching within a certain parameter which this one most certainly would have met. This is why Captains are always exhausted, they get no continuous sleep. The fact that the warship was hit on its starboard side does not bode well for the warship's crew. The Captain will most certainly be charged and very likely found culpable. That's why he is the Captain. The poor SOB's who were on lookout, and the Officer of the Watch will likely also face trial and disciplinary action, the watch officer's career is most certainly over. It's the navy way. As Voltaire said of the English: "in this country, it is good to kill an admiral from time to time, in order to encourage the others". Sad that those sailors lost their lives. The world is a dangerous place, and the sea perilous.
 
Hopefully by people who actually know what "Abaft the beam" actually means.

Google is a great thing Aardy, but it does require a basic understanding of the subject matter.
We shall see when the report comes out. It still appears to me from the photgraphs that the ACX Crystal struck the U.S.S. Fitzgerald from a bearing which was Aft of the Starboard Beam of the Fitzgerald. Now it is indeed possible if the Fitzgerald was moving at a fairly high speed that there was pivoting after the collision which gave this effect.

As said we just don't have enough information and I'm going to wait for the board's report.
 
Don't know if any of you guys have actually been aboard a warship underway. The fact that the Captain was in his quarters (if true, and seems likely if he was injured when the bridge and Ops room seems intact) means there was nothing important going on and most probably a relatively junior officer had the watch. Yes, there are lookouts aboard the warship, but it's very probable that no one was looking out the window on the container ship. The watch officer would very likely have had standing orders to call (wake) the Captain and give him a CPA on any ship approaching within a certain parameter which this one most certainly would have met. This is why Captains are always exhausted, they get no continuous sleep. The fact that the warship was hit on its starboard side does not bode well for the warship's crew. The Captain will most certainly be charged and very likely found culpable. That's why he is the Captain. The poor SOB's who were on lookout, and the Officer of the Watch will likely also face trial and disciplinary action, the watch officer's career is most certainly over. It's the navy way. As Voltaire said of the English: "in this country, it is good to kill an admiral from time to time, in order to encourage the others". Sad that those sailors lost their lives. The world is a dangerous place, and the sea perilous.

CNN article by Rear Admiral John Kirby, U.S.N. (ret.) on these very points. http://www.cnn.com/2017/06/17/opinions/uss-fitzgerald-this-much-we-know-kirby/index.html
 
We shall see when the report comes out. It still appears to me from the photgraphs that the ACX Crystal struck the U.S.S. Fitzgerald from a bearing which was Aft of the Starboard Beam of the Fitzgerald. Now it is indeed possible if the Fitzgerald was moving at a fairly high speed that there was pivoting after the collision which gave this effect.

"bearing which was aft of the starboard beam" This has a different meaning than your first statement and yes, many people on my other board belief the Crystal may have overtaken from astern and either side-swiped the Fitz at an angle of ~25-45 degrees (not really supported by the damage on both ships) or steered towards the Fitz at the last moment. In both these scenarios the Crystal would be at fault.

But it doesn't explain why the Fitz would allow a commercial ship to get so close on the open sea and not start maneuvering to avoid the collision earlier. I hate to think a 100+ foot tall 40,000 ton cargo ship could just sneak-up on an American Destroyer undetected in perfect weather conditions. The Fitz's standard surface search radar has a range of 56nm. Even a pair of eyeballs would give a 5-6 mile warning range at deck level and Navy bridge crews are taught to look out the windows often .... however to see to the rear of the ship, the bridge crew would have to get out on the bridge wings and look. There are cameras, but I have no idea how effective they are at range at night. That would allow the Fitz at least 10 minutes of reaction time if being approached from the rear quarters.

3wire made an EXCELLENT point, if anything unusual was going on (ship was near stopped, testing, running emissions quiet) the Captain would not be in his bunk. This implies the ship was at normal routine.

Maybe they need to put a crows next back on Navy ships?

Here's a recent update: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4617742/Shambolic-start-probe-USS-Fitzgerald-collision.html
Seems to be a fair bit of contradictory information including time of collision.
Interesting theory about the Crystal being on autopilot.

As said we just don't have enough information and I'm going to wait for the board's report.
Fair enough. But it didn't stop you commenting 14 times already in this thread. :devilish:
 
ISIS is very active in PI and the Fritz had one of the most sophisticated missile defense systems against a North Korea missile attack. A perfect traget and opportunity if it was ISIS inspired. Takes the ship out of commission for maybe a year.

With Muslims anything is possible.
 
This incident just gave Denmark back the position of important naval power, a position she lost centuries ago.

Denmark has one of the largest and most modern fleet of containerships in the world.
 
Are British battleships equipped with lasers?

200.webp