US navy destroyer collides with cargo ship - 7 sailors missing

Are you suggesting that a highly manoeuvrable modern destroyer managed to run into a slow moving large container ship because the destroyer captain was a republican/ democrat party member ?
Your statement was

The secret's out ... state of the art destroyer can't be sunk by high speed modern weaponry but just float a low speed vessel near it and it's doomed.

To which I wrote that I presume that your statement was made purely for political effect, rather than actual thought as to how the casualty might have occurred.

Seven Sailors are dead, a high flying naval officer's career is highly likely over (even though he is seriously injured and was asleep at the time), others are likely to face courts martial. This is not at all humorous.
 
. . .In past incidents involving ship mishaps, the captain of the U.S. destroyer and/or the captain of the cargo ship were probably getting a BBBJTICM and got distracted.
Not at all funny. The Captain (who up until this point had been a high flyer) was seriously injured and was asleep at the time of the collision, regardless, this will almost certainly be his last command and he is almost certain to be retired early.
 
Someone fucked up big time. Really sad situation.
 
Someone fucked up big time. Really sad situation.
It does seem that way. The question at this point is whom. Looking at the photographs I can see two completely different scenarios involving each of the ships being privileged and burdened which could fit the photographs, and that isn't taking into account strange situations.

Bottom line it is a tragedy, sailors are dead, careers are highly likely over, and it will be awhile before we know what happened.
 
My guess is that they were on classified maneuvers to rendez vous with a sub or ship. They were running silent, which means all unnecessary activity must cease and crewmen must not make any noise. They may have been running without sonar or radar to avoid detection.The course the ship was taking made a acute sudden turn with a second sudden turn ad a short time later a quick about face. This information provided may not even be the actual location or course of the ship.


LOL. You kill me. The Fitzgerald was running "silent" was it? The USS Fitzgerald is not a stealth ship, it has the radar signature of a ...... 505 foot, 9000 ton, Navy Destroyer with a massive superstructure and mask stacked with radars and antennas. But I'm sure the crewman being quiet made all the difference.

Don't you think that if a US Destroyer was running without radar at night, they would post look-outs? The Crystal is a 730 foot, 40,000 ton cargo ship that had 2000+ cargo containers stacked 100 ft+ above the water. No reports (yet) of fog, rain or anything else that could impact visibility. Pretty tough mountain to miss.

All commercial ocean-going ships are required to have redundant radars + often navigation radar, but it's not uncommon for one or both radars to be degraded or broken on poorly run ship lines (I have no idea if Olympic Steamship is a poor company or not). In addition, cargo ships have very small crews (20 on the Crystal) so the only look-outs tend to be the 2-3 people on the bridge (at 2AM maybe only 1-2). My point: it's conceivable that the Crystal didn't see the Fitzgerald till the last minute. But it's completely unrealistic that the well-trained professional crew of a Navy Destroyer were not aware of the cargo ship. Since the collision did happen, there's got to be more to this story than they are telling us.

You do realize the unusual track provided in post 7 was of the ACX Crystal, not the USS Fitzgerald?
 
It does seem that way. The question at this point is whom. Looking at the photographs I can see two completely different scenarios involving each of the ships being privileged and burdened which could fit the photographs, and that isn't taking into account strange situations.

Bottom line it is a tragedy, sailors are dead, careers are highly likely over, and it will be awhile before we know what happened.

The pictures indicate that the Crystal rammed the Fitzgerald bow-on (t-boned the Fitzgerald) - you will note there is no damage 50' to either side of the main damage, this means the ships were not side-to-side. The Crystal's bow smashed the superstructure and the bulbous bow did damage below the waterline.

You will also note the damage is on the right (starboard) side of the Fitzgerald. That means the Crystal was on the starboard side of the destroyer. Maritime law requires that the Fitzgerald must yield right-of-way to the Crystal (i.e. maneuver to avoid collisions AND only cross the Crystal's course to the stern).

On the surface, this collision looks to be the fault of the USS Fitzgerald. Since I'm a believer in the high quality and capabilities of US Navy ships and crew training, I still believe there is more to the story.
 
LOL. You kill me. The Fitzgerald was running "silent" was it? The USS Fitzgerald is not a stealth ship, it has the radar signature of a ...... 505 foot, 9000 ton, Navy Destroyer with a massive superstructure and mask stacked with radars and antennas. But I'm sure the crewman being quiet made all the difference.

Don't you think that if a US Destroyer was running without radar at night, they would post look-outs? The Crystal is a 730 foot, 40,000 ton cargo ship that had 2000+ cargo containers stacked 100 ft+ above the water. No reports (yet) of fog, rain or anything else that could impact visibility. Pretty tough mountain to miss.

All commercial ocean-going ships are required to have redundant radars + often navigation radar, but it's not uncommon for one or both radars to be degraded or broken on poorly run ship lines (I have no idea if Olympic Steamship is a poor company or not). In addition, cargo ships have very small crews (20 on the Crystal) so the only look-outs tend to be the 2-3 people on the bridge (at 2AM maybe only 1-2). My point: it's conceivable that the Crystal didn't see the Fitzgerald till the last minute. But it's completely unrealistic that the well-trained professional crew of a Navy Destroyer were not aware of the cargo ship. Since the collision did happen, there's got to be more to this story than they are telling us.

You do realize the unusual track provided in post 7 was of the ACX Crystal, not the USS Fitzgerald?
Remember that its Ceiling Cat you're talking to
 
That means the Crystal was on the starboard side of the destroyer. Maritime law requires that the Fitzgerald must yield right-of-way to the Crystal (i.e. maneuver to avoid collisions AND only cross the Crystal's course to the stern).

Read the rest of the International Maritime Law. On another board it was quoted that this starboard rule only applies if the other ship was on something like a steady course and the U turn and "attack" could shift the liability to the PI ship.

Also we do not know how fast the Fritz was going. There are some speculative reports it was "on station" and close to dead in the water. If true, it would not be able to roar up the engines and move fast enough to avoid the T bone attack.

ISIS is very active in PI and the Fritz had one of the most sophisticated missile defense systems against a North Korea missile attack. A perfect traget and opportunity if it was ISIS inspired. Takes the ship out of commission for maybe a year.

If the Fritz saw the ship coming and could not manuver fast enough out of the way have no idea what defensees thewould have. They have missiles to shoot down missiles and planes and probably lots of guns. But do they have something big enough to fire at the oncoming vessel. Do they sink it? Maybe it was out of control and U.S. may not want to sink it.

This all took a short time for decisions to be made. It will eventually come out maybe in a year after the investigation.
 
LOL. You kill me. The Fitzgerald was running "silent" was it? As silent as a destroyer can run, possible testing new stealth technologies The USS Fitzgerald is not a stealth ship, it has the radar signature of a ...... 505 foot, 9000 ton, Every ship and sub has a radar signature, maybe they wanted to determine the extent of this signature on this particular class of destroyer Navy Destroyer with a massive superstructure and mask stacked with radars and antennas. But I'm sure the crewman being quiet made all the difference. Sound travels much further through water than it does through air.
Don't you think that if a US Destroyer was running without radar at night, they would post look-outs? I am sure they did, evidently they missed the approaching container ship. The Crystal is a 730 foot, 40,000 ton cargo ship that had 2000+ cargo containers stacked 100 ft+ above the water. No reports (yet) of fog, rain or anything else that could impact visibility. Pretty tough mountain to miss. I think you are backing my hypothesis that we are not getting the full story.

All commercial ocean-going ships are required to have redundant radars + often navigation radar, but it's not uncommon for one or both radars to be degraded or broken on poorly run ship lines (I have no idea if Olympic Steamship is a poor company or not). In addition, cargo ships have very small crews (20 on the Crystal) so the only look-outs tend to be the 2-3 people on the bridge (at 2AM maybe only 1-2). My point: it's conceivable that the Crystal didn't see the Fitzgerald till the last minute. But it's completely unrealistic that the well-trained professional crew of a Navy Destroyer were not aware of the cargo ship. Since the collision did happen, there's got to be more to this story than they are telling us. It is more likely that the destroyer was on some kind of testing of new equipment or rendez vous with another ship than routine patrol.

You do realize the unusual track provided in post 7 was of the ACX Crystal, not the USS Fitzgerald?

Could it be that they were testing stealth technologies or even remote crew technologies?

Remember that its Ceiling Cat you're talking to

Another gem from Unemployed man, he has to put his 2 cents into every thread. Every day he will have put his buck or two into this forum.
 
Read the rest of the International Maritime Law. On another board it was quoted that this starboard rule only applies if the other ship was on something like a steady course and the U turn and "attack" could shift the liability to the PI ship.

Also we do not know how fast the Fritz was going. There are some speculative reports it was "on station" and close to dead in the water. If true, it would not be able to roar up the engines and move fast enough to avoid the T bone attack.

ISIS is very active in PI and the Fritz had one of the most sophisticated missile defense systems against a North Korea missile attack. A perfect traget and opportunity if it was ISIS inspired. Takes the ship out of commission for maybe a year.

If the Fritz saw the ship coming and could not manuver fast enough out of the way have no idea what defensees thewould have. They have missiles to shoot down missiles and planes and probably lots of guns. But do they have something big enough to fire at the oncoming vessel. Do they sink it? Maybe it was out of control and U.S. may not want to sink it.

This all took a short time for decisions to be made. It will eventually come out maybe in a year after the investigation.

?????????????????????????????????????????????????????
 
?????????????????????????????????????????????????????

The bottom line is the the general public does no know what really happened and if we will ever know.
 
My guess is that they were on classified maneuvers to rendez vous with a sub or ship. They were running silent, which means all unnecessary activity must cease and crewmen must not make any noise. They may have been running without sonar or radar to avoid detection.The course the ship was taking made a acute sudden turn with a second sudden turn ad a short time later a quick about face. This information provided may not even be the actual location or course of the ship.

Are you thinkng Aardvark posted the destroyer's track? He did label it; the ACX Crystal is the container ship, and it's the one that made the sudden turns drawn on the map. It's routine to keep the courses of warships secret, and it's unlikely anyone outside the Navy will have that detailed info until the inquiry.

What we do know: The container ship sustained damage to the bow, and the destroyer was crushed amidships, killing and injuring sailors and officers in their quarters. That suggests the destroyer was rammed while crossing, confident of having right of way, while the cargo ship proceeded in similar confidence. As Aardvark has said, certainty about which ship was obliged to keep clear will come out at the inquiry.
 
The pictures indicate that the Crystal rammed the Fitzgerald bow-on (t-boned the Fitzgerald) - you will note there is no damage 50' to either side of the main damage, this means the ships were not side-to-side. The Crystal's bow smashed the superstructure and the bulbous bow did damage below the waterline.

You will also note the damage is on the right (starboard) side of the Fitzgerald. That means the Crystal was on the starboard side of the destroyer. Maritime law requires that the Fitzgerald must yield right-of-way to the Crystal (i.e. maneuver to avoid collisions AND only cross the Crystal's course to the stern).

On the surface, this collision looks to be the fault of the USS Fitzgerald. Since I'm a believer in the high quality and capabilities of US Navy ships and crew training, I still believe there is more to the story.
Look at the photographs again. The collision seemingly occurred with the ACX Crystal abaft the beam of the Fitzgerald so it wasn't a T-Bone (in which case the damage to the ACX Crystal would be a crushed in bow, (and clearly not from forward of the beam of the Fitzgerald in which case the damage to the ACX Crystal would have been on her Starboard bow) as it was a sideswipe. Now there are different ways that could have occurred, the closest to your scenario being one or both ships attempted to avoid the collision at the last moment.

One rumor going around is that the ACX Crystal was on autopilot at the time. But at this point we just don't know.
 
Still boils down to a US destroyer getting run over by a container carrier,...except for the lose of lives,...really is hilarious.
 
Read the rest of the International Maritime Law. On another board it was quoted that this starboard rule only applies if the other ship was on something like a steady course and the U turn and "attack" could shift the liability to the PI ship.

Also we do not know how fast the Fritz was going. There are some speculative reports it was "on station" and close to dead in the water. If true, it would not be able to roar up the engines and move fast enough to avoid the T bone attack.

ISIS is very active in PI and the Fritz had one of the most sophisticated missile defense systems against a North Korea missile attack. A perfect traget and opportunity if it was ISIS inspired. Takes the ship out of commission for maybe a year.

If the Fritz saw the ship coming and could not manuver fast enough out of the way have no idea what defensees thewould have. They have missiles to shoot down missiles and planes and probably lots of guns. But do they have something big enough to fire at the oncoming vessel. Do they sink it? Maybe it was out of control and U.S. may not want to sink it.

This all took a short time for decisions to be made. It will eventually come out maybe in a year after the investigation.
?????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Perhaps you have to have some familiarity with the COLREGS (The International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea 1972) but what Dave posted is straight forward enough.

Now another factor is that no vessel ever has an absolute right of way, indeed Rules 2 and 17 provide that you must take action to avoid a collision. As the mnemonic goes "To act as caution says is proper, Ease her, turn her, back her, stop her."
 
it is known from GPS data that the ACX Crystal engaged in some erratic maneuvering including at least two U-turns at speed (14 1/2 kts) before the collision.


Track of the ACX Crystal

417F0AF000000578-4612334-image-a-11_1497708031094.jpg
Looks like purposeful Crazy Ivan maneuvering, perhaps as a decoy for test tracking by the Fitz?