What does "becoming a member" mean?
As long as you can register as Yogi Bear or something it's no big deal. If they want registration with real name and address and phone # etc; well, that's a recipe for disaster since eventually the cops will charge the agency with something or other, get a search warrant and post the client list on a public website somewhere.
Eliot Spitzer was ratted out due to his membership in the "Emperor's Club".