tboy said:
Bud? What the heck you talking about "labour being typically a very small percentage in the cost of manufactured goods"???
It is a widely known and statisically proven fact that (in NA at least) labour costs are a LARGE part of the cost of any goods or services. Wage rate is only the tip of the iceberg: you have the UI costs, health benefits, HR Depts, payroll processing, and don't even get me started on the infrastructure that is needed to support a staff. You have washrooms, break rooms, lighting, a/c, etc etc etc. The GM of the last big company I worked for showed me paperwork that roughly stated that for every dollar they pay a worker, another 25 - 30 % gets tacked on....
Tboy, I'm not sure of your business background, but you're just plain wrong. In manufacturing, labour costs (inclusive of benefits and indirect labour costs) generally run between 5% and 20% of the cost of manufactured goods. Raw materials, energy, marketing and other costs make up the vast
majority of the cost. As a result, a 10% hit to the cost of labour only makes up to a 2% hit on the bottom line. My knowledge comes from working in the field, but I'm sure you'd find plenty of backup for this on the net if you want to spend the time. Now, things are different in the service sector where labour costs are the largest cost of service delivery. Interestingly, unions have made little headway in the service sector (outside of the public service).
tboy said:
The problem with your "competition" scenario is a) if both companies are unionized then the customer will pay more than they have to for the goods, which passes that cost onto NON union workers (consumers) and or they go offshore. Which equates to loss of business to union companies which equates to manufacturers closing. (which IS happening NOW).
or b) If one company is unionized and the other isn't, the non-union company can produce the item cheaper and gets the business. The union company then continues to lose business to non-union companies until such a time that it closes it's doors (and I have personally seen this happen). Then when that happens (the union company goes tits up) the union then goes after the non-union company, does the same thing, and it closes it's doors also until there is no more companies to unionize and no more work...
Sorry TBoy, I just couldn't follow your logic here. All companies attempt to pass their costs onto the consumer, but that doesn't mean they don't compete. Don't imagine for a second that a company in a competitive market doesn't have bargaining power in its union negotiations, it does. Bear in mind, as well, that unions compete with each other for members, and are quite happy to undercut each other if that's what it takes to win their own competition.
Also, unions are aware when there is non-union competition. Unless people are acting in a suicidal way, that is taken into account in a union's bargaining position. Yes, sometimes unions (or companies) sometimes price themselves out of business. No system is immune from that sort of bad business judgement (it certainly isn't the object of union to put a company out of business. If it does, it will never collect enough dues to cover the original organizing costs!)
Don't get me wrong, I'm not "pro-union". However, my issue with trade unionism is more cultural. I think unions retard individual responsibility, entrepreneurial activity, and recognition based on individual merit. I think their values weaken Canada as a culture.
However, I don't buy the cost analysis you've put forward.