Unions - Pros & Cons in Sun Articles

Unions are a hindrance to business.
Canadian laws protect workers and there is no need for unions at all.

Unions encourage mediocre or substandard work.

the TTC wouldn't need to be in such need for cash if the union wasn't there. we would have a balanced budget if the government workers were not unionized. Ford/GM would not be in such trouble and maybe able to compete better with the Japanese automakers if there wasn't a union.
 
Yeah, those union bastards really did a number on some really good companies: Nortel, BreX, Lehman Bros, WaMu, AIG, Bear Sterns, etc.
 
simplyaguy said:
Unions are a hindrance to business.
Canadian laws protect workers and there is no need for unions at all.

Unions encourage mediocre or substandard work.

the TTC wouldn't need to be in such need for cash if the union wasn't there. we would have a balanced budget if the government workers were not unionized. Ford/GM would not be in such trouble and maybe able to compete better with the Japanese automakers if there wasn't a union.

Really?

So the answer to the North American Auto Dilema is cheaper cars than the Japanese?

Boy, who would have thunk it could be so simple!

Hey wait, North American cars ARE ALREADY FAR CHEAPER than Japanese, with tons of incentives, yet people still don't want to buy them.

Last time I checked, the guys on the line didn't design the fucking cars or make the decisions as to the level of QUALITY to build.

What was your arguement again? :rolleyes:
 
simplyaguy said:
Unions are a hindrance to business.
Canadian laws protect workers and there is no need for unions at all.

Unions encourage mediocre or substandard work.

the TTC wouldn't need to be in such need for cash if the union wasn't there. we would have a balanced budget if the government workers were not unionized. Ford/GM would not be in such trouble and maybe able to compete better with the Japanese automakers if there wasn't a union.

Really?

So the answer to the North American Auto Dilema is cheaper cars than the Japanese?

Boy, who would have thunk it could be so simple!

Hey wait, North American cars ARE ALREADY FAR CHEAPER than Japanese, with tons of incentives, yet people still don't want to buy them.

Last time I checked, the guys on the line didn't design the fucking cars or make the decisions as to the level of QUALITY to build.

What was your arguement again? :rolleyes:

BTW, where do you think those labour laws came from in the first place - Management?

I've got a bridge for sale in Brooklyn if you're interested.
 
seth gecko said:
Yeah, those union bastards really did a number on some really good companies: Nortel, BreX, Lehman Bros, WaMu, AIG, Bear Sterns, etc.

Yes, and non-union companies have done numbers on thousands, no millions of employees - overworked, underpaid, fired without cause, etc etc. I'm all for a free labour market and economic growth, but in this age of the mega corporation it's too easy for people to be treated like dirt. Unions (with limited power) may be he lesser of two evils.
 
Ah here we go, the union/no union debate again.

1) Unions were needed way back in the day when workers were used abused and treated like pieces of meat while the fat cats grew rich off their blood sweat and tears.

2) Unions are NO LONGER NEEDED because they forced companies and governments to create laws protecting worker's rights.

3) Unions sole purpose now is to get as much as humanly possible for their workers in the short term. Unions and unionized workers have no long term foresight and as long as they get their outrageous wages now, who gives a rat's ass if the company is out of business in 5 yrs and ALL those unionized workers are out of a job? Hey, a garbage man made $60K a year for 5 yrs......

4) Unions are stiffling the economy. Any public service sector that is unionized would be out of business long long ago if it wasn't for the constant influx of capital by the tax man.

5) Unions are in place so that an uneducated person can make as much, if not more, than one with skills, training and a university education.

6) Unions allow the lazy non-productive worker to make as much as the dedicated, skilled, and hard working worker.

7) Unions allow a the writing of a specific contract and, in detail, describe what can and cannot be done to a worker who breaks the law/rules etc. (but in most cases a manager can't do squat to a worker anyways so...).

8) Unions have NO business in a "free market society" because of their stranglehold and tactics do not allow any freedom by ALL workers, just unionized ones. For eg: a unionized company that wants to hire more people. If a person wants to do the same job, but for less money, the union doesn't allow it. That is NOT free market, that is extortion.
 
BTW James: the reason GM is on the ropes now is solely due to the outrageous contracts they signed over the years. I believe now, they are paying just as many people NOT TO WORK as they are paying people to ACTUALLY work.

The majority of North American vehicles are the same, if not better quality than many imports. It is only the perceived value of imports that determines the value of that product.

I have driven imports (toyota and honda) and driven North American (pontiac ford) and I have not noticed ONE difference in the quality of either. Of all the vehicles I have driven I have yet to have any problems with any of them, foreign or domestic.
 
I don't know what you just said Dick but one thing is for certain:

manufacturing jobs were highly unionized.
Unionized factory jobs increased production costs dramatically.
Manufacturing jobs and companies are in a rapid decline due to costs of production and have moved offshore.

Those are undeniable facts proving that unions are only after the money short term, I have said this all my life: I would rather make $25.00 an hour, every day, of every week, for 35 yrs than make $75.00 an hour for 3 yrs. In the end? My way I'd end up with a better life and earn more money.
 
The union movement is a great business to be in. Captive customers (members), legislative support ( closed shops in Canada) , tax free and zero accountability. They don't even have to make financial statements available to the public. Rule by intimidation.

Great scam. More Wall St than Wall St
 
train said:
The union movement is a great business to be in. Captive customers (members), legislative support ( closed shops in Canada) , tax free and zero accountability. They don't even have to make financial statements available to the public. Rule by intimidation.

Great scam. More Wall St than Wall St

Try that in any other business practise and one would find themselves on the fast train to the showers with Bubba.....
 
I disagree with both articles

kbluejayk said:
Con (Edward Greenspan)

http://www.torontosun.com/comment/columnists/edward_greenspan/2008/09/22/6835701-sun.html

Pro (Jim Slotek)

http://www.winnipegsun.com/Comment/2008/09/29/6915476-sun.html
(This one was also in the Toronto Sun today.)

Good articles by these two Sun columnists!

The truth is that unions do not significantly hinder competitiveness, as long as the employer has competitors. Unions (and management) become reasonable quite quickly when a labour dispute results in customers shifting work to a competitor. Of course, if the competitor is unionized, their union would also have to be a "competitor" to the one striking for there to be cost differentiation (based on labour costs). Further, although union and non-union wages/labour costs can often be dramatically different in the manufacturing sector, the reason that can occur is that labour costs are typically a very small percentage of the overall cost of manufactured goods. Productivity is the greatest determinent of wages in that sector, not "fairness".

On the other hand, unions have no place in non-competitive sectors, especially where the government has created a monopoly (e.g. public service). None of the mechanisms which operate to set market based rates can operate in that environment. Unions like the ATU can simply hold the public hostage with no accountability. Likewise, for employers like school boards. Interestingly, it is only in the public sector that unions have shown any growth in the last 10 years.
 
Bud Plug said:
The truth is that unions do not significantly hinder competitiveness, as long as the employer has competitors. Unions (and management) become reasonable quite quickly when a labour dispute results in customers shifting work to a competitor. Of course, if the competitor is unionized, their union would also have to be a "competitor" to the one striking for there to be cost differentiation (based on labour costs). Further, although union and non-union wages/labour costs can often be dramatically different in the manufacturing sector, the reason that can occur is that labour costs are typically a very small percentage of the overall cost of manufactured goods. Productivity is the greatest determinent of wages in that sector, not "fairness".

On the other hand, unions have no place in non-competitive sectors, especially where the government has created a monopoly (e.g. public service). None of the mechanisms which operate to set market based rates can operate in that environment. Unions like the ATU can simply hold the public hostage with no accountability. Likewise, for employers like school boards. Interestingly, it is only in the public sector that unions have shown any growth in the last 10 years.

Bud? What the heck you talking about "labour being typically a very small percentage in the cost of manufactured goods"???

It is a widely known and statisically proven fact that (in NA at least) labour costs are a LARGE part of the cost of any goods or services. Wage rate is only the tip of the iceberg: you have the UI costs, health benefits, HR Depts, payroll processing, and don't even get me started on the infrastructure that is needed to support a staff. You have washrooms, break rooms, lighting, a/c, etc etc etc. The GM of the last big company I worked for showed me paperwork that roughly stated that for every dollar they pay a worker, another 25 - 30 % gets tacked on.....

Now couple that with a union workforce who (arguably) staff 30% of the workers who are low or non-producers and your overhead skyrockets.

The problem with your "competition" scenario is a) if both companies are unionized then the customer will pay more than they have to for the goods, which passes that cost onto NON union workers (consumers) and or they go offshore. Which equates to loss of business to union companies which equates to manufacturers closing. (which IS happening NOW).

or b) If one company is unionized and the other isn't, the non-union company can produce the item cheaper and gets the business. The union company then continues to lose business to non-union companies until such a time that it closes it's doors (and I have personally seen this happen). Then when that happens (the union company goes tits up) the union then goes after the non-union company, does the same thing, and it closes it's doors also until there is no more companies to unionize and no more work.

Here's another situation with union companies (and this is direct experience). The company I worked for often had so much work the production shop had to work late. Often there was only a few little things that needed to be done to complete an order, work for one guy. But the union rules stated that a) a 4 hr minimum applied b) two guys were needed even if there was only work for one and if they worked more than x hours, we needed to feed them.

Know what we did? We sent work out to suppliers instead of doing it in house. Know what happened? The guys made NO overtime instead of SOME overtime.

it got to the point where we started farming out a lot of work and I worked for another company that closed production entirely and all they have is a sales office now. That's unionization for you: rape a company until it can no longer stay in business......
 
Unions are still absolutely needed. Sure it's easy to say that there are rights protecting works but good like trying to fight a large corporation by yourself if they wronged you. At the same time unions need to becareful that they don't bite the hand that feeds them. They need to walk a fine line between getting the mostg for their memebrs and staying relevant.
 
SilentLeviathan said:
Unions are still absolutely needed. Sure it's easy to say that there are rights protecting works but good like trying to fight a large corporation by yourself if they wronged you. At the same time unions need to becareful that they don't bite the hand that feeds them. They need to walk a fine line between getting the mostg for their memebrs and staying relevant.

That's true SL but then again, what is the supposed "wrong"? I know people that sued corporations because the inside of the hot pocket they put in the microwave burned them......(wtf did they think it was going to be...cold?) or that young lady that sued (burger king?) because the manager let a supposed cop on the phone have her strip.....BOTH are instances where a "wrong" being sued for is ludicrous.

See, the thing is: in the real world, if you don't like the way you're treated in your job, or the hours, or the pay, you leave and find something that suits you.

Another thing wrong with unions is the fact that middle managment CAN'T unionize. We were/are the ones that put in 40 hrs a week without pay, deal with irate customers because their order can't be filled by the union guys on their scheduled 50th 15 minute break......

I say ok then, EVERYONE get unionized, let's all pay $28.00 for a big mac meal, $40.00 per litre for gas and $12.00 for a loaf of bread cuz that's what things will cost when everyone is making $20.00 an hour......
 
I agree that unions are outdated and, in the most part, not needed anymore. In large part, they have been a major contributing factor to the manufacturing decline that we are seeing in NA.

Take and example of a company that is down the road from my office. Ledco was a stamping plant that manufactured parts for the Big Three and last year, had it's doors shut because of the CAW. Everyone there was given the option to take a 25% pay cut, or have the plant shut down. Management all agreed to take the pay cut. The workers tried to negotiate it, but eventually agreed to take the cut as well (better than being unemployed). The CAW stepped in and would not let them take the pay cut, because the CAW has a no wage or benefit cut policy. Two days later, the plant was closed. The parent company couldn't afford to compete, while under the current operating costs.
http://www.570news.com/news/topstory/article.jsp?content=20080124_081034_8084
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYLAkOJRsH4

I DO, however, seem to disagree with the fact that there are certain verticals, where unions are still a benefit. Public safety and most public service positions are places where the benefit of a union is important. In many of these cases, the process of fighting any contract disputes would be daunting, because you would, in fact, be fighting the government and would have no higher power to turn to.
 
tboy said:
Bud? What the heck you talking about "labour being typically a very small percentage in the cost of manufactured goods"???

It is a widely known and statisically proven fact that (in NA at least) labour costs are a LARGE part of the cost of any goods or services. Wage rate is only the tip of the iceberg: you have the UI costs, health benefits, HR Depts, payroll processing, and don't even get me started on the infrastructure that is needed to support a staff. You have washrooms, break rooms, lighting, a/c, etc etc etc. The GM of the last big company I worked for showed me paperwork that roughly stated that for every dollar they pay a worker, another 25 - 30 % gets tacked on....

Tboy, I'm not sure of your business background, but you're just plain wrong. In manufacturing, labour costs (inclusive of benefits and indirect labour costs) generally run between 5% and 20% of the cost of manufactured goods. Raw materials, energy, marketing and other costs make up the vast
majority of the cost. As a result, a 10% hit to the cost of labour only makes up to a 2% hit on the bottom line. My knowledge comes from working in the field, but I'm sure you'd find plenty of backup for this on the net if you want to spend the time. Now, things are different in the service sector where labour costs are the largest cost of service delivery. Interestingly, unions have made little headway in the service sector (outside of the public service).

tboy said:
The problem with your "competition" scenario is a) if both companies are unionized then the customer will pay more than they have to for the goods, which passes that cost onto NON union workers (consumers) and or they go offshore. Which equates to loss of business to union companies which equates to manufacturers closing. (which IS happening NOW).

or b) If one company is unionized and the other isn't, the non-union company can produce the item cheaper and gets the business. The union company then continues to lose business to non-union companies until such a time that it closes it's doors (and I have personally seen this happen). Then when that happens (the union company goes tits up) the union then goes after the non-union company, does the same thing, and it closes it's doors also until there is no more companies to unionize and no more work...

Sorry TBoy, I just couldn't follow your logic here. All companies attempt to pass their costs onto the consumer, but that doesn't mean they don't compete. Don't imagine for a second that a company in a competitive market doesn't have bargaining power in its union negotiations, it does. Bear in mind, as well, that unions compete with each other for members, and are quite happy to undercut each other if that's what it takes to win their own competition.

Also, unions are aware when there is non-union competition. Unless people are acting in a suicidal way, that is taken into account in a union's bargaining position. Yes, sometimes unions (or companies) sometimes price themselves out of business. No system is immune from that sort of bad business judgement (it certainly isn't the object of union to put a company out of business. If it does, it will never collect enough dues to cover the original organizing costs!)

Don't get me wrong, I'm not "pro-union". However, my issue with trade unionism is more cultural. I think unions retard individual responsibility, entrepreneurial activity, and recognition based on individual merit. I think their values weaken Canada as a culture.

However, I don't buy the cost analysis you've put forward.
 
Sorry you couldn't follow it but you do get the gist of it in your statement: "unless people are acting in a suicidal way". that is precisely what unions do (at least the ones I've been exposed to).

For eg: remember back when Chrysler was on the ropes and shut down all their plants? The governments stepped in with massive grants to keep them up and running. Well remember what happened two weeks after they reopened their Canadian Plants? The union struck.......that is 100% suicidal to extort money from a company that was already in financial troubles and it seemed they wanted their slice of the public funds that allowed Chrysler to remain in business.

Yes companies compete but a unionized company's costs are higher, therefore they pass those costs onto their customers, and not many customers like to pay more than they have to for their items, so the non union company has lower costs to pass on therefore can have lower selling prices therefore sell more.

As for unions being aware of "non-union" competition, they are, and they fight tooth and nail to attack those companies as well because it is those companies that cause their membership to lose their jobs and therefore reduce the dues they collect.

Now as for your labour cost example, sorry, but every manufacturing industry I have been in the labour costs outweigh the material costs by about 100%. Now I don't know about the auto industry or basic goods (steel, aluminum, plywood, etc) but I consider myself to be in a manufacturing type industry (cabinetry) and have been involved in the trade show booth manufacturing industry and I can tell you: the basic materials (plywood, MDF, veneers, laminates) all cost next to nothing. It is the labour to put them all together that costs the big money and believe me, I was directly involved in the estimating, purchasing and cost analysis so I know. In fact, if I hadn't reformatted my HDD after I left the last company, I could have shown you a spreadsheet on the last few projects I worked on.

For eg: the last big one I worked on consisted of 3 permanant exhibits in 3 locations in the US. The total selling price was $4.5 M US (back when US was running at 1.4). The total cost of materials for all 3 was running at about $200K Cdn when I left and there was only one more to complete. The total labour cost to date was running at about $800K Cdn. That is 40 guys, 40 hrs per week for 10 weeks at $50.00 an hour (skilled carpenters).
 
tboy said:
Now as for your labour cost example, sorry, but every manufacturing industry I have been in the labour costs outweigh the material costs by about 100%. Now I don't know about the auto industry or basic goods (steel, aluminum, plywood, etc) but I consider myself to be in a manufacturing type industry (cabinetry) and have been involved in the trade show booth manufacturing industry and I can tell you: the basic materials (plywood, MDF, veneers, laminates) all cost next to nothing. It is the labour to put them all together that costs the big money and believe me, I was directly involved in the estimating, purchasing and cost analysis so I know. In fact, if I hadn't reformatted my HDD after I left the last company, I could have shown you a spreadsheet on the last few projects I worked on.

Check the Industry Canada website. Lots of good stats regarding production costs, including labour costs, by industry. Their stats have production labour as 6% of manufactured costs in the auto industry (this may be slightly, but not signficantly low if it doesn't include indirect labour costs). Raw materials often are not the most significant costs. Capital costs (factory, tooling), energy (depending on the manufacturing process), and certainly marketing often are the larger components of manufactured cost.