union pearson express train...$27.50???

Sorry, I've got not involvement in the UP project, nor do I, nor have I ever been involved with SNC Lavalin. (Who originally were going to design, build, finance the project in what has become affectionately known as P3 partnerships, which seldom work. When the SNC daydream fell apart, the entire project was mandated to Metrolinx to complete and bring to fruition.)

You make me laugh because you are woefully ignorant of how infrastructure is built and like so many other ignorant people think that "the politicians" are to blame and somehow there is graft or corruption in there.

Let me give you the Coles Notes version of how public infrastructure is built in Canada and Ontario and Toronto.

1. The politicians come up with a want (maybe it's a new subway, or LRT, or it's a railway to the airport)

2. Purchasing will put out a Request for Proposals to qualified Engineering Consultants (like SNC, or AECOM, or Hatch, or AMEC, or any number of firms.) to do a "study" for discussion purposes. At this time, some very preliminary budgets are conjured up. Unfortunately, fools often think that this is what it should cost and fools will bray away about infrastructure projects being 4 times over budget because they use the initial budgets that were based on no design whatsoever to say that everything is over budget by 400 percent.

3. Next step is the Environmental Assessment. Again, invite qualified firms, or publically tender, but again the lowest bidder is selected to do the work. The Environmental Assessment takes forever and it does exactly what its name implies - looks at the impacts to the environment and establishes the criteria that the final design must have. At this time, there are usually several alternative designs concepts (not detailed design) drawn up and again, cost estimates are put together.

5. Next step is Preliminary Design. Again, invite qualified firms, or publically tender, but again, lowest bidder is selected. A preferred design will be selected and again project costs are estimated, this time with some greater accuracy, but in no way completely accurate.

6. Next step is Detailed Design producing tender drawings and specs suitable for tendering to construction by qualified Contractors. Again, lowest bidder is selected. (There is no second prize by the way.) At this time, a final design is detailed. It can be thousands of drawings and a spec a metre thick. At this time, an Engineer's cost estimate will be put together. A good Engineer will put together a cost estimate that should rank him Number 2 or 3 when the construction tenders come in.

7. Tender for Construction. Again, low bid gets the job. Prices should be equal or less than the Engineer's estimate done in step 6, but often times they are actually higher because Contractors know more about pricing a job than Engineers. This should be "THE BUDGET" for the job, not the budget that was arrived at in stage 1 which fools always get hung up on.

8. Construction proceeds and yes, there are ALWAYS extra costs. The question is how much extra. If you have a damn good Engineer in Step 6, and I mean DAMN GOOD (and they are out there, but unfortunately, they are usually not the lowest bid), your final construction cost should be within 10 percent of your budget. If you have a design that is full of holes and mistakes, the sky is the limit in terms of extra costs.


So through it all mon ami, the lowest bid gets the job.

So tell me, please, enlighten me, as to how the politicians are somehow responsible for cost over runs?

Everything and I mean everything is publically tendered with low bid getting the job. Politicians do not hand out contracts to their buddies despite public perception to the contrary.

All of the above can take years, even decades and the reason it takes so long is that because the public has to be consulted at ever step of the process and that takes time.

Thanks for the coles notes, its no different that I knew of and participate in.

Lowest bid gets the job haha...JTK, you make me laugh. You of all people should know that means nothing, its a formality on paper, not a reality.
You of all people should know there are very limited respondents for a project like this, and once more you should know there is no full disclosure on profit, on wages on where the workers come from, squat.

Politicans are certainly to blame, because they buy shit without smelling it first.

I commend your defending $10,000 per meter of track, but surely even you can see that is grossly over priced.
Lastly, the ride may cost you $27, but really if there are 4million tax payers in ontario thats about $375 per tax payer, for something that 2% of the population will ever use. Theres nothing special about the train or the service, that a go line couldn't do - or use the money for expansion and updating.

My senses tells me this rail was only built to satisfy PAN-AM and any future bids for the Olympics. I can't wait to see the national vs international usership (there's probably jack shit way to track that ...because..the......were....)..but time will tell.
 
Thanks for the coles notes, its no different that I knew of and participate in.

Lowest bid gets the job haha...JTK, you make me laugh. You of all people should know that means nothing, its a formality on paper, not a reality.
You of all people should know there are very limited respondents for a project like this, and once more you should know there is no full disclosure on profit, on wages on where the workers come from, squat.

Politicans are certainly to blame, because they buy shit without smelling it first.

I commend your defending $10,000 per meter of track, but surely even you can see that is grossly over priced.
Lastly, the ride may cost you $27, but really if there are 4million tax payers in ontario thats about $375 per tax payer, for something that 2% of the population will ever use. Theres nothing special about the train or the service, that a go line couldn't do - or use the money for expansion and updating.

My senses tells me this rail was only built to satisfy PAN-AM and any future bids for the Olympics. I can't wait to see the national vs international usership (there's probably jack shit way to track that ...because..the......were....)..but time will tell.

A "formality on paper"??

Really? Explain to me what that means, cause I'm afraid I don't get it. (You do realize that the contract to build the airport express was not a single contract, more like more than 200 individual contracts to individual contractors. For example, there was one contract to build the new rail over rail bridge at Toronto West Diamond, there was another contract to build the new bridges at Black Creek, and another to build the new bridges at Eglinton, and one for signal bridges, at least 20 for various segments of track construction, etc. etc. etc.)

And do you know that there actually IS full disclosure as to worker's wages on these projects?

You clearly don't know what you're talking about because if you did no anything about the line to the airport, you would know that there was a single track (which was removed and replaced) and three new parallel tracks have been added for a total of four tracks.

Better redo your math.
 
Sorry, I've got not involvement in the UP project, nor do I, nor have I ever been involved with SNC Lavalin. (Who originally were going to design, build, finance the project in what has become affectionately known as P3 partnerships, which seldom work. When the SNC daydream fell apart, the entire project was mandated to Metrolinx to complete and bring to fruition.)

You make me laugh because you are woefully ignorant of how infrastructure is built and like so many other ignorant people think that "the politicians" are to blame and somehow there is graft or corruption in there.

Let me give you the Coles Notes version of how public infrastructure is built in Canada and Ontario and Toronto.

1. The politicians come up with a want (maybe it's a new subway, or LRT, or it's a railway to the airport)

2. Purchasing will put out a Request for Proposals to qualified Engineering Consultants (like SNC, or AECOM, or Hatch, or AMEC, or any number of firms.) to do a "study" for discussion purposes. At this time, some very preliminary budgets are conjured up. Unfortunately, fools often think that this is what it should cost and fools will bray away about infrastructure projects being 4 times over budget because they use the initial budgets that were based on no design whatsoever to say that everything is over budget by 400 percent.

3. Next step is the Environmental Assessment. Again, invite qualified firms, or publically tender, but again the lowest bidder is selected to do the work. The Environmental Assessment takes forever and it does exactly what its name implies - looks at the impacts to the environment and establishes the criteria that the final design must have. At this time, there are usually several alternative designs concepts (not detailed design) drawn up and again, cost estimates are put together.

5. Next step is Preliminary Design. Again, invite qualified firms, or publically tender, but again, lowest bidder is selected. A preferred design will be selected and again project costs are estimated, this time with some greater accuracy, but in no way completely accurate.

6. Next step is Detailed Design producing tender drawings and specs suitable for tendering to construction by qualified Contractors. Again, lowest bidder is selected. (There is no second prize by the way.) At this time, a final design is detailed. It can be thousands of drawings and a spec a metre thick. At this time, an Engineer's cost estimate will be put together. A good Engineer will put together a cost estimate that should rank him Number 2 or 3 when the construction tenders come in.

7. Tender for Construction. Again, low bid gets the job. Prices should be equal or less than the Engineer's estimate done in step 6, but often times they are actually higher because Contractors know more about pricing a job than Engineers. This should be "THE BUDGET" for the job, not the budget that was arrived at in stage 1 which fools always get hung up on.

8. Construction proceeds and yes, there are ALWAYS extra costs. The question is how much extra. If you have a damn good Engineer in Step 6, and I mean DAMN GOOD (and they are out there, but unfortunately, they are usually not the lowest bid), your final construction cost should be within 10 percent of your budget. If you have a design that is full of holes and mistakes, the sky is the limit in terms of extra costs.


So through it all mon ami, the lowest bid gets the job.

So tell me, please, enlighten me, as to how the politicians are somehow responsible for cost over runs?

Everything and I mean everything is publically tendered with low bid getting the job. Politicians do not hand out contracts to their buddies despite public perception to the contrary.

All of the above can take years, even decades and the reason it takes so long is that because the public has to be consulted at ever step of the process and that takes time.
What is the purpose for an evironmental assessment in a built up area like toronto? Curious
 
What is the purpose for an evironmental assessment in a built up area like toronto? Curious

If we ignore the environment it will go away

But assuming you are semi-serious there are lots of things to consider, eg water tables to prevent killing off humans or wildlife in the area
 
What is the purpose for an evironmental assessment in a built up area like toronto? Curious

In addition to what the above poster stated, this is the phase when there is a lot of consultation with the public. (Door to door, Public Information Centres, etc.)

There are laws in Ontario which for better or worse mandate that certain projects must go through an Environmental Assessment and it can take years - even decades. (It's gone too far in my opinion.)

The problem is that you can get one guy who decides he's going to put the brakes on a large infrastructure project and if he's determined enough, he can do it and he can do it by manipulating the laws during the EA phase more so than during the detailed design phase and unless he wants to lay down in front of a D-9 during the construction phase.
 
OMFG

I did not even realize this at first but this just underlines the sheer absurdity of the UP

http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/201...ts_up_express_train_prepares_for_takeoff.html

"The UP Express will run on the Kitchener GO line from Union Station until a point near Highway 427 and Goreway Rd., where it will branch off onto a newly built 3-kilometre rail spur."

Yup the ENTIRE rail line EXCEPT for a short 3KM spur is ON THE FUCKING GO TRANSIT RAILS

So someone please explain to me WHY we need to spend 65 million purchasing new trains from Japan?
WHY this UP is so much more expensive than GO?
And exactly WHY they could not simply have designated a new GO train for airport trips in the first place?

I'm not so much upset at the GO lines being used and frankly, I'm glad they've used a Japanese train. Considering how badly Bombardier shit the bed with the roll out delays for the new street cars (there are 6 total running, when all of them were supposed to be in place by now) which all won't be operational til 2017, I'm surprised if they get any new business from Toronto at all. Healthy competition is a good thing in my opinion.

As for the price, the planning committee is out of their minds. What couple would pay to drag their luggage onto the subway to get to union just so they can drag it onto the UP and thru the airport when a limo service will pick you up at your door and handle your luggage for you for the same price? Make the fare $10 flat fee and then they will see ridership increase.
 
I'm not so much upset at the GO lines being used and frankly, I'm glad they've used a Japanese train. Considering how badly Bombardier shit the bed with the roll out delays for the new street cars (there are 6 total running, when all of them were supposed to be in place by now) which all won't be operational til 2017, I'm surprised if they get any new business from Toronto at all. Healthy competition is a good thing in my opinion.

As for the price, the planning committee is out of their minds. What couple would pay to drag their luggage onto the subway to get to union just so they can drag it onto the UP and thru the airport when a limo service will pick you up at your door and handle your luggage for you for the same price? Make the fare $10 flat fee and then they will see ridership increase.

I doubt that $27 would get off the Gardner. From downtown, I am guessing at least $50 to $70 by limo.
 

Think the Liberals are going to blame UP Express failure on polls. Almost everyone in this thread was saying the fee was too high.

From the poll: "The poll of 892 randomly selected Toronto residents found nine per cent of respondents have already used the train". "Metrolinx said the service was attracting about 3,250 riders per day.".

From the poll 9% of 3 million people in Toronto is 270000 unique UP riders in 6 weeks, or 6430 riders per day. Poll makes no sense.
 
In addition to what the above poster stated, this is the phase when there is a lot of consultation with the public. (Door to door, Public Information Centres, etc.)

There are laws in Ontario which for better or worse mandate that certain projects must go through an Environmental Assessment and it can take years - even decades. (It's gone too far in my opinion.)

The problem is that you can get one guy who decides he's going to put the brakes on a large infrastructure project and if he's determined enough, he can do it and he can do it by manipulating the laws during the EA phase more so than during the detailed design phase and unless he wants to lay down in front of a D-9 during the construction phase.

We should get rid of it for developments in cities
 
I doubt that $27 would get off the Gardner. From downtown, I am guessing at least $50 to $70 by limo.

Yes, in my post I say it costs a couple the same to ride a limo as it does to take the train, with a lot less hassle
 
This train is leaving from Union. I believe it's targeting business travelers. Those customers will look at the service from a time/convenience perspective and will not be bothered by the fare.
 
This train is leaving from Union. I believe it's targeting business travelers. Those customers will look at the service from a time/convenience perspective and will not be bothered by the fare.

Agreed.

The service isn't targeted to the regular family of 4 or even 2. Compared to other cities, the price isn't that much more expensive. Having said that, I think $20 is the sweet spot and should attract more casual travelers.
 
This train is leaving from Union. I believe it's targeting business travelers. Those customers will look at the service from a time/convenience perspective and will not be bothered by the fare.

Business travelers take limos/cabs because they get you door to door and they expense the charges. The UP Express is destined to fail, as in continually lose money.
 
From the poll: "The poll of 892 randomly selected Toronto residents found nine per cent of respondents have already used the train". "Metrolinx said the service was attracting about 3,250 riders per day.".

From the poll 9% of 3 million people in Toronto is 270000 unique UP riders in 6 weeks, or 6430 riders per day. Poll makes no sense.

Yep, makes no sense. I'm guessing they have a more targeted list than randomly choosing from 3 milliion. Maybe a list of those who flew out of Pearson.

Note the 3250 will include vistors to Toronto and repeat riders, so makes it more off.
 
Business travelers take limos/cabs because they get you door to door and they expense the charges. The UP Express is destined to fail, as in continually lose money.

As a business traveler that comes to Toronto, i disagree. To the extent that i now have no hesitation booking a flight to Pearson instead of being limited to porter / billy bishop. Don't underestimate the value of being able to get to the financial district in 25 minutes. Thats way quicker than you'll get taking a limo from the airport.... hell it takes me a good 15-20 from the island airport sometimes.

Yes, you expense the charges either way, but when the UP is both faster and cheaper, its a no brainer. Not to mention wifi, and the fact that many companies are more expense conscious than ever.
 
As a business traveler that comes to Toronto, i disagree. To the extent that i now have no hesitation booking a flight to Pearson instead of being limited to porter / billy bishop. Don't underestimate the value of being able to get to the financial district in 25 minutes. Thats way quicker than you'll get taking a limo from the airport.... hell it takes me a good 15-20 from the island airport sometimes.

Yes, you expense the charges either way, but when the UP is both faster and cheaper, its a no brainer. Not to mention wifi, and the fact that many companies are more expense conscious than ever.

And yet its empty? But the airport aint
 
heard on radio- train is running at 90% empty?
Just heard the same report.... what a colossal waste of $$$. (except for the a$$holes that got some sort of kickback of course...)

Why do we put up with this crap over and over!