Two More Mass Shootings

http://www.livescience.com/39813-gun-ownership-increases-firearms-deaths.html

Past studies have shown that gun owners are much likelier to be shot with their own weapons than they are to use it to thwart a crime. Other research has shown that gun laws are linked with lower rates of firearms deaths

Gun ownership rates were strongly correlated with higher death rates from firearms

In contrast, the incidence of major depression was only weakly linked to firearms-related deaths. (Data on other conditions such as schizophrenia were not widely available.)
And crime didn't seem to be correlated at all with gun ownership rates. That suggests purchasing a gun doesn't have an effect on overall crime rates, which include both violent and non-violent crimes.
"We can show that guns don't make a nation safer," Bangalore told LiveScience

Still, it's difficult to say that gun ownership actually causes more gun violence


I will concede this statement above. But all it means is more research is necessary.

In other words it may be too soon for either one of us to say we are right. Which is why I have maintained that if you show me proof I will change. You on the other hand have already made up your mind..... or am I wrong about that?
 
We've already gone over that pure number of guns and gun crime is not the only factor. The decline could be for other reasons.

Age 4 or 24 the people are still being killed or injured. The age doesn't concern me.

As for police support I googled it and it is mixed some support it and some don't. If it was definitive wouldn't it be across the board?

Yes, it's not the only factor, yet here you are, using numbers as cudgel; ramming the gun control narrative down people's throats, as a roundabout way to justify lowering lawful ownership rates, when those don't have a significant affect on gun crime. Again, like lowing drunk driving by making it harder for sober people to own and operate private vehicles.

Dead is dead, I agree. But 4 to 24 certainly matters if your narrative is that children are endangered by lawful gun ownership, especially when a large portion of that 4 to 24 wasn't lawful to begin with.

LE support is mixed, no shit. So is support for stronger gun control measures, "if it was definitive, wouldn't it be across the board?" You'd think that if there was so much support behind it, there wouldn't be all these panic buys of guns and ammo flying off the shelves whenever there's even a hint of new legislation. But no, ownership is up, sensationalism and hysterics are up, yet violence is down.
 
http://www.livescience.com/39813-gun-ownership-increases-firearms-deaths.html

Past studies have shown that gun owners are much likelier to be shot with their own weapons than they are to use it to thwart a crime. Other research has shown that gun laws are linked with lower rates of firearms deaths

Gun ownership rates were strongly correlated with higher death rates from firearms

In contrast, the incidence of major depression was only weakly linked to firearms-related deaths. (Data on other conditions such as schizophrenia were not widely available.)
And crime didn't seem to be correlated at all with gun ownership rates. That suggests purchasing a gun doesn't have an effect on overall crime rates, which include both violent and non-violent crimes.
"We can show that guns don't make a nation safer," Bangalore told LiveScience

Still, it's difficult to say that gun ownership actually causes more gun violence


I will concede this statement above. But all it means is more research is necessary.

In other words it may be too soon for either one of us to say we are right. Which is why I have maintained that if you show me proof I will change. You on the other hand have already made up your mind..... or am I wrong about that?

I certainly have taken my stance, I'll never apologize for that. But you know who else made up their mind before the study even began? The Center for Disease Control:

https://www.google.ca/amp/s/www.for...-should-not-receive-gun-research-funding/amp/

Which is the reason why is was defunded; they were working towards a foregone conclusion which aimed to stigmatize lawful gun ownership. Shit, one of their recent studies backfired:

http://www.gunsandammo.com/politics/cdc-gun-research-backfires-on-obama/

So all there really is to fall back on is a "sky is falling" 33K, which also includes (heavily) suicides and already criminal uses, none of which, would be prevented by "universal background checks", "assault weapon bans", or any other knee jerk, band-aid solutions, recently proposed.
 
More breaking news.

We've already established that comparing cars to guns is not valid.

Try something else.

As I recall, you brought up the car comparison:

More guns will keep them safer.

Just like putting more cars on the 401 will improve traffic.

But since it no longer fits your narrative, I guess you had to abandon ship. Fine, let's use another example to illustrate your hypocrisy; maybe something that hits closer to home. As a hobbyist, do you feel guilty about trafficking-in-persons, underage protitution and sex slavery?
 
As I recall, you brought up the car comparison:
You are delusional. Somebody used the old and tired "but cars kill more people than guns" argument and I refuted it.

And it defies logic that if I am anti-gun I would bring up car deaths.


But since it no longer fits your narrative, I guess you had to abandon ship. Fine, let's use another example to illustrate your hypocrisy; maybe something that hits closer to home.
Comparing guns to cars was never my narrative. My narrative is showing that it is a fallacious argument when I see it.

protitution
You got me. I admit that I am pro tits.
 
You are delusional. Somebody used the old and tired "but cars kill more people than guns" argument and I refuted it.

And it defies logic that if I am anti-gun I would bring up car deaths.



Comparing guns to cars was never my narrative. My narrative is showing that it is a fallacious argument when I see it.


You got me. I admit that I am pro tits.

Look back at the thread chief, your car/gun comparison was the first reply and second message in the entire thread.

I too, also love refuting fallicious arguments, like the one about how, after an exorbitant amount of mental gymnastics, my lawful firearms ownership somehow causes gun violence. I just like reframing things with examples of things they care about, to illustrate people's own hypocrisy to themselves.
 
I wasn't relating cars to guns in terms of danger. I talked about cars and traffic.

When somebody tried to justify gun injuries by comparing them to the dangers of cars is when I started refuting that line of debate.
 
Fourth, even if that 250K was correct there's no way to know if a gun was absolutely necessary. I mean how many times has a trained martial artist talked their way out of a situation instead of having to use MA?

There are about 85 million legal handgun owners in the US and most have a handgun for self defense. How many trained martial artists in the US? No where near 85 million.

Many muggings are perpetrated by drug addicted people so they can get some cash to get drugs. They don't care about you being nice to them.

Guns are mainly a deterrent. Criminals take the easiest path and will avoid people who are armed. A gun need not even be pulled. Putting up a 'gun free zone' sign will invite criminals for sure.
 
There are about 85 million legal handgun owners in the US and most have a handgun for self defense. How many trained martial artists in the US? No where near 85 million.

Many muggings are perpetrated by drug addicted people so they can get some cash to get drugs. They don't care about you being nice to them.

Guns are mainly a deterrent. Criminals take the easiest path and will avoid people who are armed. A gun need not even be pulled. Putting up a 'gun free zone' sign will invite criminals for sure.

But the majority of murders are done by people who know each other. So why do we keep talking about muggers and home invaders?
 
I certainly have taken my stance, I'll never apologize for that. But you know who else made up their mind before the study even began? The Center for Disease Control:

https://www.google.ca/amp/s/www.for...-should-not-receive-gun-research-funding/amp/

Which is the reason why is was defunded; they were working towards a foregone conclusion which aimed to stigmatize lawful gun ownership. Shit, one of their recent studies backfired:

http://www.gunsandammo.com/politics/cdc-gun-research-backfires-on-obama/

So all there really is to fall back on is a "sky is falling" 33K, which also includes (heavily) suicides and already criminal uses, none of which, would be prevented by "universal background checks", "assault weapon bans", or any other knee jerk, band-aid solutions, recently proposed.

so background checks wouldn't have caught people with mental health/suicidal thoughts?

weapons bans wouldn't reduce kids getting hurt or crimes of passions?
 
Homeowners, or anybody else for that matter, have the right to defend themselves, or others under their care, using reasonable force under the Criminal Code of Canada. Despite such mottos 'Serve and protect', it is not the job of police to defend citizens, except through the application of deterrence. There cannot be a cop on every doorstep.

If an intruder is in your house, and you feel threatened, you have no obligation to retreat. You have the right to use deadly force against deadly force. If you are confronted by a person who refuses to turn back, who you think can kill you with his bare hands, you have the right to shoot him in self defence. If you do that, be sure to fire a warning shot after you shoot the intruder.

So yes, it is your job to defend yourself against criminals who are attacking you.

I believe Canadian law only allows you to use an appropriate level of force and only if there is no other recourse. You taking the time to go to your gun safe, loading your weapons and then shooting an unarmed intruder would result in a hard time in court proving legitimate self defense. Some US jurisdictions might allow you to shoot anyone on your property but not in Canada.
 
If I'm misunderstanding you please clarify. So if you're not actually advocating "gun spot checks" then you agree there's nothing further to be done, right? Somehow, I doubt that's your actual position because we're back to "checks for illegal gun owners". What does that mean to you, warrantless home inspections? What are your criteria for selecting which individuals are subject to these checks? For the sake of intellectual consistency, were you at least as supportive of "carding"?

I have stated repeatedly that I find Canadian gun laws reasonable. US Federal and most state laws on the other hand...

It seems your paranoia about 'gun grabbers' has you reading something else. I was simply 'shooting' down the comparison to drunk drivers.
 
I believe Canadian law only allows you to use an appropriate level of force and only if there is no other recourse. You taking the time to go to your gun safe, loading your weapons and then shooting an unarmed intruder would result in a hard time in court proving legitimate self defense. Some US jurisdictions might allow you to shoot anyone on your property but not in Canada.

I did say reasonable. That doesn't mean that you can only use a gun unless confronted with a gun. Being confronted with a knife doesn't mean you can only use a knife to defend yourself. You are not obligated to retreat in the face of an intruder in your dwelling house. Queensberry rules don't apply to self defense. You can get killed by someone's bare hands and the law does not expect you to find out first. In a physical altercation, A 90 pound woman will not stand a chance against a 250 pound man, nor a 65 year old man against a 25 year old. An intruder in my house who will not retreat and will continue to advance towards me is a mortal threat. That is especially true concerning intruders who are under the influence of drugs or insane. But how are you to find out until it's too late?

What is illegal is to shoot someone who's retreating. The invader must be advancing on you or a person you wish to defend. A warning shot is in order.

That being said, Crowns in Ontario seem to have been instructed by the Attorney General's office to prosecute self-defense cases using a gun, whatever the circumstances. Cases of legitimate defense using a firearm have been thrown out of court, but not before the accused turned down successive plea bargains, not before the Crown has postponed court hearings on multiple occasions in order to drive legal costs to insane levels to make the accused accept such a plea bargain, and not until a few tens of thousands of dollars have been spent in legal fees. So they will get you anyway with something that is a virtual fine.
 
I have stated repeatedly that I find Canadian gun laws reasonable. US Federal and most state laws on the other hand...

It seems your paranoia about 'gun grabbers' has you reading something else. I was simply 'shooting' down the comparison to drunk drivers.

Canadian laws which you don't even understand even after multiple attempts of explanation. In Canada, we have eliminated at least a large portion of unnecessary and invasive tracking; I am no longer under any obligation to report the transfer of a non-restricted firearm through a governmental intermidary and they do not track which non-restricted firearms I currently or previously possed.

Any sort of legislation which was even recently proposed in the United States fell into one of two categories: 1) prohibition based largely on cosmetic features or misunderstandings of function or 2) invasive tracking.
 
No and no.

Right because kids will find illegal guns to accidentally shoot themselves with be it 4 or 24?

So suicide has no warning signs that we can detect? Shouldn't we add something like if you've been admitted to a hospital for suicide you can't buy a gun?
 
What do law abiding citizen have to hide?

We might as well get these out of the way:

anti-gun-bingo.gif

anti-gun-bingo-extended-play.gif