My point, which you totally ignored and can not refute, is that comparing the number of gun deaths to vehicular deaths is not valid for the reasons I pointed out.Cars are just as much a part of American culture as guns. Both have shaped America and it wasn't just the end user that has lead to how they are used in society is today. Ever wonder why Los Angeles has such a poor public transportation system? It's because of the actions of large corporations and corruption in the local government at the time that made vehicles a necessity. There's several documentaries on it. Guns also served an enormous function in society. The colonies depended on them for food and defense. You did not go anywhere without one if you were travelling west. Your life depended on it. All walks of life were involved in the industry. Winchester was originally a shirt maker. John Browning was a devout Mormon. Remington was a devout Christian. Add on top of that that many of the designs requested by the American military that had a huge impact on the outcome of WWII and it's hard to separate it from society. The Browning M2 50 cal is still in use today and is approaching 100 years old. Soldiers kept their M1 Garands, 1911's and M1 Carbines when they came home and used the rifles for hunting. Canadians also brought home their rifles, but they were bolt actions and not a revolutionary state of the art semi auto.
It's a legacy that carries on in the same way the Samurai sword does in Japan. There's no possible way to remove it from their society. Hollywood won't let it.
My point, which you totally ignored and can not refute, is that comparing the number of gun deaths to vehicular deaths is not valid for the reasons I pointed out.Guns were necessary at the creation of our society, and as human nature has it, guns will always be required for the maintenance of our society.
When times are good, guns seem unnecessary. When times are bad, the last thing you want is for only military and cops to have guns. We've inherited a prosperous society passed down several generations. We know nothing other than good times. But the world constantly shows us that things can change on a dime. Trump became president, remember? Nobody knows what the future holds.
You're being childish.
You and I aren't free to do whatever we please. Some of the restrictions on freedom make sense while others don't. But is it too hard to understand why some people don't see the need for regular citizens to have guns? You don't have to agree with it but surely you can see the other side of the argument.
You keep talking about law abiding gun owners and how great they are BUT you are skipping over the fact that you and I both know not everyone can be trusted with a gun and the current state of affairs don't do enough to ensure that guns stay out of the wrong hands.
Annnd we're done
Thanks for the correction.
The difference between guns and cars as I see it, is that cars serve an enormous function in our society along with trucks and buses. No one can deny how much we rely on transportation. Our society could not function without them. One can hardly say the same about guns. So it should be considered an unfortunate bi-product of something that benefits every single human. It is the exact same as accepting some possible side effects from a medication that we need to take.
The other factor that mitigates the comparative number of deaths between guns and cars is amount of usage. More people use cars than guns. As well those "more people" use their cars more often than people who use guns. As well, a vehicle is usually in use for longer periods of time than a gun is used. So more people, using cars more frequently and for longer time frames intuitively means that the number of vehicular deaths would be waaay below gun deaths on a relative basis. I don't know how this could be calculated accurately but it is clearly evident that for the amount they are used cars are much safer than guns. Add on the higher level of importance that vehicles are to out society than guns and it is clear that there is very little validity to comparing the number of gun deaths to vehicular deaths on an absolute basis.
I know I got into debates with fuji on this one but I firmly stand by my viewpoint.
Even more basically it is overall usage, taking into account #of users, frequency of use and duration of use. No comparison.Maybe a simpler way to say it is that on any given day how many cars are on the roads vs how many people are walking around with guns.
I think it is safe to say there are more cars on the road then guns on the street unless gun owners are carrying more than one gun at a time.
I'm basing this on the first google article I could find which uses Florida a state with concealed carry laws which estimates 1.4 million people have permits and the state has a population of 20 million. And 16 million have driver's licences in FLA.
Even more basically it is overall usage, taking into account #of users, frequency of use and duration of use. No comparison.
Just taking a wild stab but I'd say overall usage of vehicles is somewhere around 50X greater than for guns. Maybe even more.
Just for clarification, this in and of itself, is not a condemnation of guns. It is simply an argument to discredit those arguments that compare the number of vehicular deaths vs. those via firearms as a rationale for justifying gun use.
In a world where people aren't compelled to justify other freedoms, why should they have to justify a right in the United States?
Actually you do have to justify your freedoms. For example, you can't go around saying anything you want at work without consequences.
For example, to bring it back to guns there are people in Canada who can carry a concealed gun if they can justify it. There are many examples in life where you have to provide a reason and you can't just use the defense of "I don't have to justify myself"
Furthermore, if that's the best argument you've got it's pretty weak.
LOL, the entire gun control argument is about passing the buck. Talk about weak.
No it's not. It is very simple, many people die unnecessarily by guns. With fewer guns there would be fewer deaths. For example, 7000 kids are injured and 3000 are killed in the US thanks to gun accidents.
Weak is being so narrowminded that you can't find another hobby to satisfy whatever guns provide you with.
There are many examples of things like asbestos, lead, agent orange and ddt where they served a purpose but their health risks outweigh their benefits. Guns are no different. Heck there's even talk about sugar taxes and regulations of sugar content in food..... aren't the fatties ruining it for the rest of us? No. Because we'd all be better off with less sugar in our diets.
Great point.In a world where people aren't compelled to justify other freedoms, why should they have to justify a right in the United States?
Because maybe lots of other people do.Why should I have to find another hobby if I haven't put anyone in danger?
My point, which you totally ignored and can not refute, is that comparing the number of gun deaths to vehicular deaths is not valid for the reasons I pointed out.
Rural Ontario in 2017 is not the same rural Ontario of my early childhood where we use to leave our doors unlocked even at night. Too many migrants from the big cities.Actually crime is on the rise in rural Canada. The cbc just did a report on that. I think we sometimes idealize living in the country and country folk
No it's not. It is very simple, many people die unnecessarily by guns. With fewer guns there would be fewer deaths. For example, 7000 kids are injured and 3000 are killed in the US thanks to gun accidents.
Weak is being so narrowminded that you can't find another hobby to satisfy whatever guns provide you with.
There are many examples of things like asbestos, lead, agent orange and ddt where they served a purpose but their health risks outweigh their benefits. Guns are no different. Heck there's even talk about sugar taxes and regulations of sugar content in food..... aren't the fatties ruining it for the rest of us? No. Because we'd all be better off with less sugar in our diets.
Didn't say I had a solution. All I was doing was trying to put an end to the fallacious vehicle analogy.I am not refuting your claim.
In the end, a death is a death.
So how you expect the issue to be solved?