Trudeau on Tax Avoidance

Ok, please show me the math (or the money).

Let say I own shares of Canadian Pacific ("CP"). Let say CP earns $100 income and pays $50 in taxes so now has $50 left which CP pays to me as a dividend. I am taxed on the $50 dividend. How is that not double taxation? (Yes, I know about the gross-up and credit but I think it is deficient.)

I guess you don't have much of a background in business or taxes. Thankfully we have a CPA look after my companies accounts instead of you.
 
I use to play softball with a bunch of medical and nursing students. They all said they would leave Canada to go to the U.S. when they graduate. It's a shame because Canada subsidized part of their education but we can't force them to stay in Canada against their will.

One nurse I know left for California.

I know a nurse that has been waiting for a full time position for a few years now. So there are quite a few waiting to snap up these positions. Also, now a German doctor who had to go back to school and scored the highest marks at the Toronto University. She is now a Specialist and at one time wanted to leave Canada as she had to start from scratch although she qualified to be a GP in Bavaria. Really we should be relaxing the Educational Qualifications from a number of well recognised universities. She paid her own way for something paid for 100% by the German Government.
 
David Cameron said he would disclose his tax return(s). Trudeau should do the same.

How many other previous Governments did so? David Cameron is under scrutiny because his own family was involved in the Panama scandal. Why should Trudeau automatically do so? Sure he will if he has to. But why are you only particularly interested in Trudeau's tax returns?
 
If you look hard enough you will come to the realization that the people bever_hunter wants to hit in the groin likly pay more in taxes in one year than you & bever_hunter will pay in a lifetime


"Their fair share" is a very subjective definition. In bever_hunters world it implies a witch hunt
Everyone should pay what the tax laws require




Avoidance is legal, evasion is not
If it is legal then you need to look for a different source to fund the nanny state




You need to think about property rights and realize attacking & tax-targeting our most sucessful citizens is not a good economic plan.
Particularly when the primary motivation is to pay for what you want. The Nanny state

ie. the nanny state

You are not putting on your thinking glasses. That is great if the rich are paying their fair share of the taxes and have nothing to worry about. My gripe were those that play the system and end up paying a lot less than the struggling middle income earners. So stop your usual daft presumptions.
 
And where are doctors gonna go? The USA? Not as easy as you think. They have NO SHORTAGE of doctors,
Really?

U.S. faces 90,000 doctor shortage by 2025, medical school association warns

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...age-by-2025-medical-school-association-warns/
The United States faces a shortage of as many as 90,000 physicians by 2025, including a critical need for specialists to treat an aging population that will increasingly live with chronic disease, the association that represents medical schools and teaching hospitals reported Tuesday

Imagine how the doctor in Ontario getting taxed @ a 55% marginal rate views warm sunny Arizona which will apply a 4.5% marginal rate on the next dollar he earns.
He may also ponder how getting paid in green backs is an added bonus+ the limits on his career earnings are far less restricted in the USA

I bet Justin's team did not bring this up in consultation, so to be fair to him, he has never given this any thought at all.
Ready, shoot, aim


other then that no other country on the planet pays their doctors the retarded amounts they are paid in the USA and Canada.
You mean what the market will bear?
They save lives

So as usual you are talking nonsense about these people leaving.
It is most defiantly not nonsense !


Most people are NOT as willing to leave as you think or as conservatives love to preach. Where is the exodus you said will happen when the Ontario libs created the new tax bracket?

I guarantee you that if the net result is an extra $2-3 B in taxes annually collected from Doctors and lawyers there will be some that move on
I would guess 5-10% would be a big problem. Much more than that we will have a disaster

That is a lot of money and a very significant burden on a small yet vital group of high performing citizens

Given our projected demand for health care this tax policy could turn into a nightmare

The facts just do not seem to support your cross your fingers and hope doctors do not leave approach

Ready shoot aim
 
I don't mind paying taxes as long as what I am paying to the authorities is being spent efficiently, effectively and honestly. I think we all know that to not be the case, in particular here in Ontario since 2003.
I also want someone to acknowledge in our government that the tax burden we face is comprised of much more than just income, social security and general sales taxes. There's fuel taxes. Sin taxes. Property taxes. Land transfer taxes. Customs and excise taxes. Estate taxes. Automobile taxes (drivers license, license plate, tire tax, gas guzzler tax). Recycling/environmental fees. Airport improvement fees. Hydro debt retirement charges. CRTC fees on telephone, internet and cable. Culture taxes i.e. music royalties. I'm sure I'm missing quite a few others.
Tax freedom day in Canada as a whole was June 10 in 2015. That means our overall tax burden is somewhere around 43%.
In Ontario any individual in excess of $200,000 in income is paying marginal tax rates up to 53%. That is pure THEFT. Do you really think a guy working in Toronto and making $225,000 per year with a stay at home wife and 3 kids is that well off that he should pay 53 cents on every extra dollar he makes to the government?
 
Tax avoidance is a crime.
No It most certainly is not
Tax evasion is a crime
Tax avoidance is sound financial planning by minimizing the tax burden within the laws of the tax code

Come on you and I know that the average Canadian just fills out the tax form and offers very little mainly in RRSPs and TFSA accounts to evade taxation.
Avoid taxation


It is quite common to have owners of Businesses and the very rich find ways of minimising their actual salaries to sometimes pay virtually minimal taxes.
Within the rules
So it is just prudent tax planning

the rules are generally designed to encourage the owners to re-invest in their business & hopefully grow and hire more people

Yes, that is great tax evasion but when they are actually making two and three time the salaries of the average household income and paying even less taxes,
You bias and grade 11 thinking are showing here
If they make 2X , 3X take home they pay more than the average

If their legal deductions, related to running a small business such as the use of autos, travel expenses, new equipment, entertaining clients etc, reduces that income they are taking less home

then we know there are some loopholes in the system that accountants exploit.
These deductions (loopholes as you describe them) were put in place to encourage growth in business
Did you not want farmers to buy new tractors on occasion to increase their productivity?
Did you prefer that an east coast fishing Captain make do with an aging seine net, so you can squeeze an extra $20 K/year of taxes out of him to fund your nanny state?
Do you expected the myriad of small tech start ups to not buy office furniture and PCs for their newly hired staff, or do you prefer they just pay more taxes ?

I call it loopholes and closing down these CRA agencies has not made it more efficient, but has succeeded in making the very rich more efficient in exploiting the loopholes that exist in the present setup.
What you call them ?
You start with the premise that legitimate deductions are wrong despite being legal and that anyone who makes a reasonable income MUST BE taxed to max in order to pay for what you want, the nanny state

Any government run organization has some fat
Shame on any government who does not evaluate where costs can be reduced.
if you are going to tax to the max at least do not be extremely wasteful with Canadians tax dollars
 
Anyone who claims that cutting jobs makes any organization better at their jobs is completely dishonest.

Cutting jobs will not make the employees better at their jobs
However making the organization more effective is the goal and if there is waste then it should go
Any government run organization carries excessive costs.
Please do not try and argue this is not so

There will never be enough CRA agents to completely police all Canadians tax returns
The trick to maintain a level of investigations which ensures all Canadians are very aware of the consequences of tax evasion
That tends to ensure a relatively large % of our GDP is available for government to spend

Staffing up to turn the CRA from a cost centre into a revenue center by targeting our most successful citizens is not sound policy
Particularly when such a move is motivated by the need to fund the nanny state
 
Cutting jobs will not make the employees better at their jobs
However making the organization more effective is the goal and if there is waste then it should go...

And randomly slashing the payroll (or cutting the least senior) will not make anything more effective. Odds are the employees will actually be worse at their jobs because they will be responsible not only for their own duties but the duties of those who were fired.
 
And randomly slashing the payroll (or cutting the least senior) will not make anything more effective. Odds are the employees will actually be worse at their jobs because they will be responsible not only for their own duties but the duties of those who were fired.

Funny
I do not recall the word "randomly" being used to describe the right sizing of CRA
Technology has played a much bigger role in the filing and processing of returns

As with all organizations big productivity gains via technology results in re-examining staffing levels
As a taxpayer you should be very concerned if this re-examination did not occur

Please do not loose track of the purpose of CRA. It is to administer and monitor tax returns, collect and distribute taxes and returns due
Enforcement of the tax laws is also a duty.

The purpose of the CRA is not to employ a specified number of employees nor is it primary responsibility to ensure employees are happy in their work

More importantly its purpose is certainly not to put right any perceived injustice of inequality by staffing up for a tax avoidance witch hunt
 
No It most certainly is not
Tax evasion is a crime
Tax avoidance is sound financial planning by minimizing the tax burden within the laws of the tax code


Avoid taxation



Within the rules
So it is just prudent tax planning

the rules are generally designed to encourage the owners to re-invest in their business & hopefully grow and hire more people


You bias and grade 11 thinking are showing here
If they make 2X , 3X take home they pay more than the average

If their legal deductions, related to running a small business such as the use of autos, travel expenses, new equipment, entertaining clients etc, reduces that income they are taking less home


These deductions (loopholes as you describe them) were put in place to encourage growth in business
Did you not want farmers to buy new tractors on occasion to increase their productivity?
Did you prefer that an east coast fishing Captain make do with an aging seine net, so you can squeeze an extra $20 K/year of taxes out of him to fund your nanny state?
Do you expected the myriad of small tech start ups to not buy office furniture and PCs for their newly hired staff, or do you prefer they just pay more taxes ?


What you call them ?
You start with the premise that legitimate deductions are wrong despite being legal and that anyone who makes a reasonable income MUST BE taxed to max in order to pay for what you want, the nanny state

Any government run organization has some fat
Shame on any government who does not evaluate where costs can be reduced.
if you are going to tax to the max at least do not be extremely wasteful with Canadians tax dollars

Okay I mixed the two i.e. evasion and avoidance as I was in a hurry and did not review prior to posting. But just to get something that I know for a fact that happens, is that dinners with families and friends are expensed as if they are business expenses. There are renovation expenses on owners own properties that are somehow tweaked to look like they are rental properties. Gas mileage etc for personal use is another common expense. You are delusional if you think that when business men share the salaries with their stay at home wives and not the full salaries, but the minimal amounts that it is acceptable. But the previous Harpo Government were not looking for efficiency, but as we all know a false premise of so called balancing the budget when they closed down the agencies. This has compromised the work of the CRA agencies and Mr. Trudeau was right to reinstate it along with increasing the budget to combat the laundering of funds into tax free havens. As usual a biased right winger will not agree.
 
Okay I mixed the two i.e. evasion and avoidance as I was in a hurry and did not review prior to posting.
No that was a Freudian slip that happened multiple times
You view taxation as the vehicle to address inequality & shame on you for that


But just to get something that I know for a fact that happens, is that dinners with families and friends are expensed as if they are business expenses. There are renovation expenses on owners own properties that are somehow tweaked to look like they are rental properties. Gas mileage etc for personal use is another common expense. You are delusional if you think that when business men share the salaries with their stay at home wives and not the full salaries, but the minimal amounts that it is acceptable.
Good luck policing that
& at what incremental value ?
What a dope!

Again if you had a clue you would know that business have lots of checks and balances and there are usually other interested parties , partners, boards of directors suppliers creditors, who tend to limit that sort of activity

No way will re-instating CRA cuts put an absolute stop to those who push the limits

A tax professional once said the trick is not be to aggressive when filing a tax return. The CRA is reasonable and expects filers to be reasonable as well
If you file a business loss for five-seven years running, they will ask the reasonable question, well how are you still in business?
Then they will take a special interest in your file and if your revenue is enough to support a business they will then take a real close look at the expenses claimed
A tax audit is the equivalent of proctology procedure without anesthetic. Only a fool puts themselves in that position.

However if you claim a reasonable amount they allow the deduction

If you think staffing up of CRA will put an end to what you consider inappropriate, then you will be real disappointed
However I suspect both you and Justin see the CRA as the route to address social issues & that is not its purpose


But the previous Harpo Government were not looking for efficiency, but as we all know a false premise of so called balancing the budget when they closed down the agencies.
Says you
Prove that it was not simply a matter of technology driving efficacies which made these closures possible with the aim of saving the taxpayer a penny or two off the 50 cents the governments takes for every dollar earned
This has compromised the work of the CRA agencies
Prove that
Was there a direct link to incremental $Billions not collected specifically because of these closures?
Was there a direct link to a delay in millions of Canadian tax returns not being processed in a timely manner, specifically because of these closures?

and Mr. Trudeau was right to reinstate it along with increasing the budget to combat the laundering of funds into tax free havens. As usual a biased right winger will not agree.
Too bad it is motivated by his inability to control spending and desire to implement the nanny state
 
Really?





Imagine how the doctor in Ontario getting taxed @ a 55% marginal rate views warm sunny Arizona which will apply a 4.5% marginal rate on the next dollar he earns.
He may also ponder how getting paid in green backs is an added bonus+ the limits on his career earnings are far less restricted in the USA

I bet Justin's team did not bring this up in consultation, so to be fair to him, he has never given this any thought at all.
Ready, shoot, aim



You mean what the market will bear?
They save lives


It is most defiantly not nonsense !




I guarantee you that if the net result is an extra $2-3 B in taxes annually collected from Doctors and lawyers there will be some that move on
I would guess 5-10% would be a big problem. Much more than that we will have a disaster

That is a lot of money and a very significant burden on a small yet vital group of high performing citizens

Given our projected demand for health care this tax policy could turn into a nightmare

The facts just do not seem to support your cross your fingers and hope doctors do not leave approach

Ready shoot aim

Ahh a medical school association who's future depends on getting funding to train more doctors. Yeah right, whatever. The tooth fairy would be more credible.

As for what the market will bear, what bizarre fantasy is it of yours that the publicly funded medical system full of unionized player is market driven? Even is the US medical system is some bizarre distortion of a well functioning market system. So once again R U B B I S H!!!!

Some doctors save lives some take lives. There are many options to delivering medical care while massively reducing our reliance on doctors.

Nice places never have shortages of doctors, its only shitholes where doctors do not want to live that have shortages. Like Pine Bluff AR for example.
 
Ahh a medical school association who's future depends on getting funding to train more doctors. Yeah right, whatever. The tooth fairy would be more credible.
https://www.google.ca/?gws_rd=ssl#q=us+faces+shortage+of+doctors

https://www.aamc.org/download/426260/data/physiciansupplyanddemandthrough2025keyfindings.pdf
Total physician demand is projected to grow by up to 17 percent,
By 2025, demand for physicians will exceed supply by a range of 46,000 to 90,000
The physician shortage will persist under every likely scenario

http://fortune.com/2014/03/04/americas-painful-doctor-shortage-is-threatening-health-care-reform/
America's painful doctor shortage is threatening health care reform

http://theconversation.com/facing-a...e-medical-school-grads-on-the-sidelines-54230
Facing a physician shortage, can we leave medical school grads on the sidelines?

As for what the market will bear, what bizarre fantasy is it of yours that the publicly funded medical system full of unionized player is market driven?
The free market
If you specialize in the states you can make more money in 2-3 years than you can in a decade in Canada and you get to keep way more than 45% of it

The bottom line is that US doctors compensation will look just that much better if as you say 2-3 B in incremental taxation takes place


Even is the US medical system is some bizarre distortion of a well functioning market system. So once again R U B B I S H!!!!
..

Yeah nobody has ever heard of a rich doctor in the US
??????

Some doctors save lives some take lives. There are many options to delivering medical care while massively reducing our reliance on doctors.

That is just plain scary
We have an aging population that have paid taxes all their lives & have been reassured they will receive quality health care.

are you advocating that the government should default on its commitment in order to justify the driving of doctors out the country via excessive taxation.
You must really despise and really want to punish the rich


Nice places never have shortages of doctors, its only shitholes where doctors do not want to live that have shortages. Like Pine Bluff AR for example.
85% of Canada is butt-fcuk wilderness with thousands of small towns where there is only one doctor

Lets see practise medicine in Vulcan Alberta and get taxed @ 55% or consider San Diego, where the sun is shining, it is warm all year around, get paid way more and taxed far less

Ready Shoot Aim
 
Funny
I do not recall the word "randomly" being used to describe the right sizing of CRA...

So what basis did the use to implement Harper's cuts. Did they do performance reviews and fire the bad workers or did they just randomly fire the least senior?
 
So what basis did the use to implement Harper's cuts. Did they do performance reviews and fire the bad workers or did they just randomly fire the least senior?

Come on you know better
I am sure they had to follow some sort of union dictated lowest seniority rule.
It is the public sector, merit is meaningless

Kind of tough to blame Mr. Harper if the union rules dictate the mediocre rise to the top

Either way if there was an opportunity to downsize government because of technological advances he has an obligation to examine it and given what he campaigned on he also had the obligation to act on it

But do not fear, Justin will push those staff levels up, they will be needed for the witch hunt
 
Come on you know better
I am sure they had to follow some sort of union dictated lowest seniority rule....

So knowing the rules, Harper decided to make cuts that were not based on merit. How does firing fully competent workers make a company more efficient?
 
Come on you know better
I am sure they had to follow some sort of union dictated lowest seniority rule.
It is the public sector, merit is meaningless

Kind of tough to blame Mr. Harper if the union rules dictate the mediocre rise to the top

Either way if there was an opportunity to downsize government because of technological advances he has an obligation to examine it and given what he campaigned on he also had the obligation to act on it

But do not fear, Justin will push those staff levels up, they will be needed for the witch hunt

KPMG and the Panama papers, both will require some work.
There should be an investigation into KPMG's stalled court case along with the politically motivated audits on environmental charities under Harper.
And there should be staff hired to investigate the Panama papers, the revenue they gain through those audits would most likely more then cover the new hires.