Trudeau on Tax Avoidance

Not to be disrespectful, but I think you need to learn a bit more about business organization structures and the way they are taxed before we could continue this discussion. You should have a solid understanding of this before you form an opinion about the effect or wisdom of the Liberal tax reform agenda.

nah that is too boring. I know enough to know that avoidance mean using loopholes to subvert the intent of tax policy.I also know that tax laws are often vague and encourage this sort of self serving interpretation . So I have no problem with the govt tightening up the laws to limit this where it deems fit.
 
Sure tax avoidance needs to be reduced. One of the things the budget did was to disallow the incorporation of doctors and other professional under partnerships to defer and avoid taxes. The was allowed in the past but has now been disallowed. For Ontario alone this will probably result in 2-3 billion in federal and provincial taxes.

Or thousands of doctors leaving the country to earn the income their profession commands without giving more than half to the government

Every action has a reaction.
2-3 Billion extra extracted from doctors will defiantly make them as a group think twice about their options
We have a shortage of doctors in Ontario / Canada
Did Justin just turn that shortage into a health crisis? just as the demand for health care is going to increase dramatically (demographics, - the aging / graying baby boomers)

Ready shoot aim

Reduction of avoidance means closing loopholes so that tax policy can operate as intended. Favorable small business tax rates are to incentivize entrepreneurship.
Then why in the world did Justin not cut the small business tax as promised during the election?
small business is the single largest employer of Canadians
Any tax cut there would result in more jobs. It was the easiest most straightforward way to create jobs
Instead he is going to spend $100 B hoping for maybe a 0.5% bump in GDP for two years

Doctors and lawyers do not really meet that description.

Keep tax targeting them and they will take their skills elsewhere


Tax policy needs to be carefully thought out.
Your basic premise that maximizing tax revenues will allow for bigger government and the nanny state is a utopian ideal which will never be realized
Every action has a reaction
 
One of the things the budget did was to disallow the incorporation of doctors and other professional under partnerships to defer and avoid taxes.
Interesting. Is it just doctors and lawyers or does it include other professionals and tradespeople? What about plumbers, electricians, Heating and AC, etc.?
 
To compensate, you'd have to drastically hike personal income taxes or slash spending,
The problem is that a dollar of income earned by a corporation is taxed at say 50% so that leaves 50 cents to be dividend to the shareholders and then it is taxed again. That dollar is taxed twice, although the dividend tax credit is suppose to relieve this double taxation but I don't believe it.
 
Tax avoidance by people and companies may not be illegal but it can be a distortion of tax policy. So funding cra to identify these loopholes so they can be closed is also part of the plan. He's bright enough to take expert advice and understand a leader is not a technocrat.

Shit. I can't believe I agree with Notty.

Whether it's loopholes or secret accounts it is intentional actions to avoid ones 'fair share'. Nothing wrong with following the intent of the rules to reduce your taxes such as RRSP deductions but when it comes to accountants intentionally looking for deductions that shouldn't apply we should be closing loopholes.


(and I don't blame the accountants who find legal loopholes)
 
I am hoping that he hits the tax evaders hard in the groin. The previous Government reduced the number of CRA agencies, making it ever more difficult to close any of the loopholes.
 
I am hoping that he hits the tax evaders hard in the groin. The previous Government reduced the number of CRA agencies, making it ever more difficult to close any of the loopholes.

You hope the present government hits tax payers hard because the previous government (which you hate) attempted to make government more efficient?
That is not what I define as sound logical motivation for a successful policy

What you call tax evasion is likely another's view of sound financial planning using tax avoidance which is legal
 
Efficient means the job gets done effectively. Cuts to the CRA made them less effective though at a lower cost.

most people who have to deal with staff reductions tend to feel that way.
That is nature and to be expected

However anyone who says a government run organization operates efficiently is not being honest
There will always be an opportunity to drive costs savings in any government operation & shame on those who do not try because of politics
 
You hope the present government hits tax payers hard because the previous government (which you hate) attempted to make government more efficient?
That is not what I define as sound logical motivation for a successful policy

What you call tax evasion is likely another's view of sound financial planning using tax avoidance which is legal

No, he said he hopes that the government hits the tax avoiders hard.
Everyone should pay their fair share.

As the Panama Papers have shown, the rich are avoiding and evading paying their fair share.
If they did, it would take the pressure off the rest of us.
 
Or thousands of doctors leaving the country to earn the income their profession commands without giving more than half to the government

Every action has a reaction.
2-3 Billion extra extracted from doctors will defiantly make them as a group think twice about their options
We have a shortage of doctors in Ontario / Canada
Did Justin just turn that shortage into a health crisis? just as the demand for health care is going to increase dramatically (demographics, - the aging / graying baby boomers)

Ready shoot aim


Then why in the world did Justin not cut the small business tax as promised during the election?
small business is the single largest employer of Canadians
Any tax cut there would result in more jobs. It was the easiest most straightforward way to create jobs
Instead he is going to spend $100 B hoping for maybe a 0.5% bump in GDP for two years



Keep tax targeting them and they will take their skills elsewhere


Tax policy needs to be carefully thought out.
Your basic premise that maximizing tax revenues will allow for bigger government and the nanny state is a utopian ideal which will never be realized
Every action has a reaction

And where are doctors gonna go? The USA? Not as easy as you think. They have NO SHORTAGE of doctors, other then that no other country on the planet pays their doctors the retarded amounts they are paid in the USA and Canada. So as usual you are talking nonsense about these people leaving. Most people are NOT as willing to leave as you think or as conservatives love to preach. Where is the exodus you said will happen when the Ontario libs created the new tax bracket?
 
The problem is that a dollar of income earned by a corporation is taxed at say 50% so that leaves 50 cents to be dividend to the shareholders and then it is taxed again. That dollar is taxed twice, although the dividend tax credit is suppose to relieve this double taxation but I don't believe it.

That is not correct small business rate is 15.5% and tax rules are structured to avoid double taxation and it does --- just do the math as we have done at our firm demonstrating this to clients.
Considerations on dividends versus salary are:
do we want write off in company for salaries
does the shareholder want CPP or RRSP room
then salary
do we want minimum taxes in the hands of the shareholder then dividends
 
You hope the present government hits tax payers hard because the previous government (which you hate) attempted to make government more efficient?
That is not what I define as sound logical motivation for a successful policy

What you call tax evasion is likely another's view of sound financial planning using tax avoidance which is legal

Tax avoidance is a crime. Come on you and I know that the average Canadian just fills out the tax form and offers very little mainly in RRSPs and TFSA accounts to evade taxation. It is quite common to have owners of Businesses and the very rich find ways of minimising their actual salaries to sometimes pay virtually minimal taxes. Yes, that is great tax evasion but when they are actually making two and three time the salaries of the average household income and paying even less taxes, then we know there are some loopholes in the system that accountants exploit. I call it loopholes and closing down these CRA agencies has not made it more efficient, but has succeeded in making the very rich more efficient in exploiting the loopholes that exist in the present setup.
 
And where are doctors gonna go? The USA? Not as easy as you think. They have NO SHORTAGE of doctors, other then that no other country on the planet pays their doctors the retarded amounts they are paid in the USA and Canada. So as usual you are talking nonsense about these people leaving. Most people are NOT as willing to leave as you think or as conservatives love to preach. Where is the exodus you said will happen when the Ontario libs created the new tax bracket?

It is the usual biased view of the right wingies who suddenly think that Canadians are being over taxed by the Government. The reality is that these are the same people who complain the most when their services are compromised as a result of the cuts in services. We have doctors who are driving taxis and performing other menial services so there should be no shortage in that Department. What LaRue fails to mention is that an average doctor earned $376,000 in Ontario in 2013. Where are they going to find that kind of cash outside North America? There are more American doctors working in Canada then ever before.
 
Our tax system is all screwed up. I think that dividends received by little guys like me should be tax-free since the corporation has already paid tax on the income. No double taxation! Also, interest income should be tax free to encourage savings. Capital gains should be tax free to encourage risk investments. On the other hand, the HST should be raised to 25% like they do in Europe.
 
There are more American doctors working in Canada then ever before.
I use to play softball with a bunch of medical and nursing students. They all said they would leave Canada to go to the U.S. when they graduate. It's a shame because Canada subsidized part of their education but we can't force them to stay in Canada against their will.

One nurse I know left for California.
 
just do the math as we have done at our firm demonstrating this to clients.
Ok, please show me the math (or the money).

Let say I own shares of Canadian Pacific ("CP"). Let say CP earns $100 income and pays $50 in taxes so now has $50 left which CP pays to me as a dividend. I am taxed on the $50 dividend. How is that not double taxation? (Yes, I know about the gross-up and credit but I think it is deficient.)
 
No, he said he hopes that the government hits the tax avoiders hard.
If you look hard enough you will come to the realization that the people bever_hunter wants to hit in the groin likly pay more in taxes in one year than you & bever_hunter will pay in a lifetime

Everyone should pay their fair share.
"Their fair share" is a very subjective definition. In bever_hunters world it implies a witch hunt
Everyone should pay what the tax laws require



As the Panama Papers have shown, the rich are avoiding and evading paying their fair share.
Avoidance is legal, evasion is not
If it is legal then you need to look for a different source to fund the nanny state


If they did, it would take the pressure off the rest of us.

You need to think about property rights and realize attacking & tax-targeting our most sucessful citizens is not a good economic plan.
Particularly when the primary motivation is to pay for what you want. The Nanny state

ie. the nanny state
 
most people who have to deal with staff reductions tend to feel that way.
That is nature and to be expected

However anyone who says a government run organization operates efficiently is not being honest
There will always be an opportunity to drive costs savings in any government operation & shame on those who do not try because of politics

Anyone who claims that cutting jobs makes any organization better at their jobs is completely dishonest.