Transgender Beauties

"... the pageant’s right and ability to express “the ideal vision of American womanhood.”

I agree in that it is a contest specifying the best in a certain defined set of entry parameters. It does not set out to judge anyone not meeting those parameters. I don't meet the parameters and I'm not offended. If transgender is allowed, why not men in drag, old ladies, etc. If you are not allowed to define parameters in contests such as sports - women's sports would disappear and their ability to compete in sports severely limited.

Nothing is cut and dry - is there a problem if “the ideal vision of American womanhood.” is not black or transgender ?

It must hard to be a judge trying to enforce individual rights and stopping society degenerating into chaos.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bushdoc and Darts
FguskBWWQAA_5vh.jpg
 
If you are not allowed to define parameters in contests such as sports - women's sports would disappear and their ability to compete in sports severely limited.
Men competing in women sports because they can't be competitive in men's is the only reason they "identity". It's goddamn ridiculous and the women who've competed their entire lives, dedicated hours, days, weeks, months, years to get to where they are and these so called "men" come along who can't win against other men, are left to wonder why they've wasted their entire lives when their sanctioning organizations allow this just so today's SJWs won't scream and cry unfairness.

I hate this world they've forced upon people. You have a dick, go compete with others who have dicks. Otherwise, go home and cry in your pillow.
 
  • Like
Reactions: johnd5050
Men competing in women sports because they can't be competitive in men's is the only reason they "identity". It's goddamn ridiculous and the women who've competed their entire lives, dedicated hours, days, weeks, months, years to get to where they are and these so called "men" come along who can't win against other men, are left to wonder why they've wasted their entire lives when their sanctioning organizations allow this just so today's SJWs won't scream and cry unfairness.

I hate this world they've forced upon people. You have a dick, go compete with others who have dicks. Otherwise, go home and cry in your pillow.
A beauty pageant is nothing like an athletic competition. A trans woman has no advantage over XX chromosome women in a beauty contest. In fact, they are probably at a disadvantage.

A trans woman has a lot of advantages in athletic competitions.

I hope I didn't upset any righties.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bushdoc
No man can be as naturally beautiful as a woman can be. He needs a lot of work and hormone therapy. And then there's the lifelong need for artificial biological enhancement to remain "looking" like a woman. You're still male. Your chromosomes say so. Cut off whatever and surgically add whatever. You're still biologically male.
Period.
 
No man can be as naturally beautiful as a woman can be. He needs a lot of work and hormone therapy. And then there's the lifelong need for artificial biological enhancement to remain "looking" like a woman. You're still male. Your chromosomes say so. Cut off whatever and surgically add whatever. You're still biologically male.
Period.
Which means that they have no advantage in a beauty pageant against women. Thanks for agreeing.
 
No man can be as naturally beautiful as a woman can be. He needs a lot of work and hormone therapy. And then there's the lifelong need for artificial biological enhancement to remain "looking" like a woman. You're still male. Your chromosomes say so. Cut off whatever and surgically add whatever. You're still biologically male.
Period.
Why so mad bro? LOL
 
Beauty Pageants are privately owned entertainment corporations. The ownership can make any eligibility rules they want to. Some pageants exclude women who are or have been married, those who have given birth, or those who have appeared naked in a film or in published literature. No one has a "Right" to compete in a pageant, if they do not meet all of the eligibility requirements.

An Escort Agency could also refuse to hire a transgendered person. They could also not be successfully sued for discriminatory hiring practices.

I think we're going to see more situations where Trans people try to use the Civil court system for nuisance suits, where they intentionally try to include themselves in some group where they aren't wanted, in the hope of walking away rich. We might even see some 'ambulance chaser' law firm franchises specializing in Trans discrimination suits.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: HotDogWater
Which means that they have no advantage in a beauty pageant against women. Thanks for agreeing.
I really appreciate the input of some SP's but when they leave a laugh emoji at an opinion they find hateful, discriminatory or anything else they feel does not suit their agendas, they have to laugh at us. Perhaps we shouldn't be so empathetic in some reviews (as I've been accused of) and leave our real thoughts with no filters or empathy attached. It would get us banned tbh. I try to leave my real thoughts on subjects. My real review thoughts. And it just seems that a certain group if ladies here; and it seems to be the BBW's, take the most offence and chime in, which we all have a right to, but they just can't seem to let it go and want to pound us in to submission. Perhaps not in this case (yet) but JFC.

Anyway, another to put on the ignore list.
 
I think I have some pretty liberal views, but beauty pageants are exclusive by their nature, and they're among the least important things in the world to me.

What sticks out to me about the story is the confidence of this contestant. She's been able to compete in the Miss Montana USA pageant, and she's done that multiple times, and sounds like she finished dead last. So then she thinks, "that means I'm ready for Miss USA"?

But she's said one of the reasons she got into pageants was just to bring attention to trans issues, and inspire other trans people, rather than winning. Which sounds like an altruistic motive.

Sorry, it's a beauty pageant. They can exclude who they want and you can't demand they let you in just to use it as a platform, knowing you have no chance to really compete.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Y_Diner
A beauty pageant is nothing like an athletic competition. A trans woman has no advantage over XX chromosome women in a beauty contest. In fact, they are probably at a disadvantage.

A trans woman has a lot of advantages in athletic competitions.

I hope I didn't upset any righties.

You (or possibly me) miss the point. ' A trans woman has no advantage over XX chromosome women in a beauty contest. ' Neither does a man in a wheel chair but why make a circus out of a contest by not letting the organizers determine who enters ? A paraplegic has no advantage in a Mr Universe contest so should he be allowed to enter ? I am not a fan of any contests based on appearance but obviously there are fans so knock yourself out.

As for upsetting righties. It is all relative. I find myself to the left of most 'righties' and to the right of most 'lefties'. To me it's a circle and lefties & righties are basically the the same type of crazy at the polar end. Their way is the only way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ref
I think there should be different beauty contests for trans women. I don’t think it is fair to either group to compete against the other given all of the prejudices and biases that exist around this topic.
 
I think there should be different beauty contests for trans women. I don’t think it is fair to either group to compete against the other given all of the prejudices and biases that exist around this topic.
This is exactly how I feel. female male trans gender ..........stop having transgender compete with women they weren't born a woman there stronger than women give them there own category to compete with tyhejmselves like other genders do.
 
This is a tough one. As has been mentioned, a trans person has no advantage in a pageant. I think personally, why not let them enter. But the problem would arise if they then claim discrimination if they don’t win. In athletics, they should not compete as women. That’s not fair. But I don’t make the rules, just putting in my opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bushdoc and Y_Diner