Except all seasons do me fine because I adjust. Seems silly to run a second set of tires and have them switched for 250 km a month of city driving almost all on smooth pavement and perhaps 250 km a month of a longer drive for a good day and on those trips I am sure friction keeps them tires warm enough.
Hell there are times when roads are covered and I go out but in my small berg we don't get rush hour and generally traffic is really light. Ontario is a big place, and there are 15 million people with varying needs. Why spend the money on something I will not improve my life or my safety in any way because I adult when I drive.
This whole everyone must get winter tires is bullshit. Some people who don't have them should. Some people have them and act like tards because they think they are bullet proof. Then there are people like Singham who just looks at his car and it behaves.
Actually I went from a 2013 model of a car to a 2021 rental with winter tires and I noticed no difference, today I brought it in and replaced it with the same model but with normal tires [the tires were unbalanced] again I noticed no difference. Not because there isn't a difference but I guess I adjust. I am actually not very impressed with the winter tires at all.
Well, I'm really not trying to force anyone to do anything, but I'll leave you with a few words.
With or without winter tires, of course people should adjust. But winter tires reduce your stopping distance by about 30% on average. So even if you drive so slowly that you can stop in 6ft with your all seasons, winters would reduce that to 4ft. And if it's critical breaking at any speed at all, even say 40km/hr, you're most likely far above that and seeing an even greater difference.
There are other advantages. Lateral stability if you hit an ice patch or any other situation with even slightly increased g-forces, for example.
It's also been proven that driving slower than the flow of traffic turns you into an even bigger hazard than people at an excessive rate of speed, and in order for you to be "as safe" as someone with winters, you need to be at a speed that's compensates by giving you 30% better stopping. Which means that not only are you putting a bigger hazard for everyone on the road by needing to be slower, they'll also be performing 30% better than you.
If you're driving slow enough to reduce your stopping distance to 21ft, their's is 14ft. If you can stop in 12ft, their's is 8ft. And so on. So you're a bigger hazard and have worse performance. You're not just making a decision for yourself, you're make a decision for everyone on the road.
This is why I say it's like choosing to buy discount brakes. Being able to operate safely at the same speed as surrounding traffic and having the best traction and braking performance possible is what makes you the safest not only for yourself but for everyone around you.
With shitty brakes you can also compensate by driving slowly, but you also then pose a greater hazard.
You say it won't improve your safety, but the science is very clear that it will unless the temperate rarely dips below 7. And it improves the safety of everyone else on the road with you.
Like I said, it's about $150/year when you average it out. And yes, two days a year you'll need to go get them swapped if you can't do it yourself, but that's never taken me more than an hour. It's your decision, but no matter how much you attempt to compensate, you'll be a bigger hazard than if you had winters both to yourself, because of your reduced braking and handling, and to everyone else on the road, because of your inability to operate in accordance with the flow of traffic.
It's that simple. People rationalize all kinds of behaviour and claim they're better than everyone else because of their ability and decisions, but you're still less safe than you could be compared to yourself. And given how many people die or are injured in car accidents, I personally don't think it's worth the risk for $150/yr. That's such a cheap, easy mitigation.
PS. Anecdotes aren't science. We're far too horrendous at evaluating things any outliers always exist. The science is very clear -- winters make you far safer on snowy, icy, or just plain colder roads.
Anyway, that's my peace said. I've got nothing else to add to the discussion.