That damn physics. Always getting in the way. LOLWell the laws of physics will teach them dear.
That damn physics. Always getting in the way. LOLWell the laws of physics will teach them dear.
I legit don't need them. Your one size fits all is idiotic.
A thought experiment. You live in Alabama. You go to Montreal once a year during the winter for pooning. Do you change your tires. No. Because you are not doing enough driving to warrent it and you can always time your trips to avoid accumulations on the major streets.
It would be a bit like saying that anybody who doesn't go out in a full hazmat suit or full on NBC gear is an idiot. That someone who works all day surrounded by people t the heights of covid infectability needs the same masking as a triple vaxxed home body who never leaves the house except for a quick trip to the shops for groceries and lotto tickets twice a week. The former needs all the PPE, the latter can get away with a surgical mask. I went N95 recently but the cost difference in minimal and you get used to the fit pretty quick, also I am a bit paranoid about getting the covid.
What I meant when I said "idiots who don't think they need them" is the people who say, I live in Toronto and it doesn't snow very much. Or the ones who say I don't need them because I know how to drive in the snow. Or the ones who say I have AWD so I don't need them. If you have the ability to leave your car parked during a snow storm, then fine. But when it snows, many continue to drive thinking they'll be okay.
You have people who drive to work in the morning and don't bother to check the weather. Then get stuck in the snow or worse, cause a collision because their all-seasons didn't provide adequate braking and they slid into another vehicle. Even when the roads are clear and dry but it's -15 C. winter tires provide much better adhesion. If you need to stop in a panic, your all seasons and masterful skills behind the wheel are going to help you. In fact, all-seasons aren't designed for temperatures below 7 C.
For those who are saying even cars with winter tires were getting stuck. Well yeah, Monday's snowfall was the most we've had in over 20 years so it's understandable. But even a 10-15 cm snowfall can cause havoc when you have tons of cars with all seasons on the roads. It comes down to physics...
The bold is mostly someone who does know how to drive and give proper distance based on road conditions, not because they are driving an AWD car.
And I was the first one to say with snow tires even other cars were getting stuck. I said that because the snow tire brigade seems to go on and on about it was the fault of those with out snow tires causing all the issues on Monday. No it was the snow that caused issue. For everyone. Snow tires or not.
This debate is useless. Those with snow tires will always think themselves better and elite and feel they can drive better and usually drive like lunatics with this over confident sense of safety, putting more at risk with their driving then a person with all season/AWD and driving with conditions considered.
9/10 (and only say 9 because Monday was the first storm I drove in within the last 5 years and I had zero trouble because I know how to drive properly, even in those conditions) I don’t have to drive in storms. I can wait for the roads to be cleaned completely before I set my tires on the road, yet I’m somehow this horrible irresponsible driver because I don’t have snows.
Just because you have snow tires does not mean you can’t get stuck, can’t lose control, can’t cause an accident, etc. and to think like that makes you a greater risk on the road in my opinion. The over confidence is the problem with most of the vocal pro snow tires people.
Who said you're a horrible irresponsible driver because you don’t have snows? I didn't go back through every post in this thread, maybe you could point it out. Also, who said you can't get stuck with winter tires?
What I'm saying is, while you may be an excellent driver, there's no denying the fact that the stopping distance of a car with winter tires can be up to 30 to 40% shorter than one with all-season tires. Where that makes a difference, is when you have to slow or stop in a hurry. Someone loses control, pulls out in front of you etc. Would you say the same thing about seatbelts? Why would you need to wear one, you're an excellent driver, right?
The number one thing that makes people overconfident is AWD. It enables you to accelerate faster than 2WD vehicles, but it doesn't stop any faster, especially on all-seasons. So many drivers of AWD vehicles feel even less need to have winter tires on them. My Cop friends (and I have many) tell me, an extremely high percentage vehicles collisions on snow covered roads involve cars with all season tires. One friend who works for the OPP says when it comes to single vehicles in the ditch, it's often an AWD vehicle with all-seasons on it. Overconfidence + a lack of grip = the ditch.
It is an implication made. You read enough of these threads and that is the basic attitude. Sorry. I should have clarified that.
And to be clear, if I was driving to work everyday, I would have snows on. I would of course be safe.
I would disagree with overconfident AWD. At least in comparison to those with AWD/4x4 and snows. So many big SUVs and trucks flying by people at outrageous speed for the road conditions but they think they are untouchable to accidents or ditches
You and I basically agree though. Snows are better, but not everyone needs them. You are reasonable and I appreciate it. Every year this thread comes up and many feel that no matter what your driving requirements are, you needs snows and if you don’t have them, you are irresponsible. I don’t drive in snow so I don’t need them.
Decisions are normally based on an individual’s experience and or knowledge.
Have been driving for over 50 years, over 45 in Toronto, never used snow tires until a few years ago.
Have never had an accident in winter, and I normally drive above speed limit, and travelled for over 20 years to and from work on the 401 or QEW an average of 45 minutes one way trip.
In the driveway are an accord and odyssey, reason for me trying the winter tires was because my daughter got her license. First tried it on the accord and after experiencing it for one winter , installed winters on the Odyssey also. Control was the much improved.
Will never go back, as the winters improved stopping, steering and general control in snowy and cold weathers.
The added control helps me sleep knowing I have the better driving tires for winter and lower risk for the family members.
Driving during our winters with winter tires has never made me think that I am superior, better or smarter than another, just my decision to protect my family a bit more.
I like reading posts like this. You've seen the light. It's all about having great control and stopping power. I could never go back to all-seasons in the winter.
I'll also say, you don't have to buy super expensive winter tires. Even brands like Sailun offer excellent tires at a very reasonable price. I put a set of those on my wife's car. It's the 4th year with them and while they're wearing down, they're still very good. I think I paid $85 a tire. She should get one more winter out of them.
You said if you drove everyday (meaning public transit was not an option) then you would buy winter tires. That's the right mentality, the right attitude to have. But many think all-seasons are just fine in the winter. In reality, they're not that bad until you encounter snow and ice. I said all-seasons are not designed for temperatures below 7 C. While that's true, I've driven in -15 C. temperatures with my all-seasons and they were fine. Not much difference than my winters on clear roads. But once the snow and ice hits, there's no comparison whatsoever.
I don't believe in mandating winter tires in Ontario like they do in Quebec. For starters, there's just not enough tires available and lots of people live downtown and don't drive much in the winter. So it's not really fair/practical to them.