johnhenrygalt said:Of what "system" do you speak? And how do you calculate the 17 billion figure? Remember, if a company is HQed in Toronto but has operations all over the country, don't make the mistake of considering corporate taxes paid by that company as taxes "coming from" Toronto. Also remember, much tax money can be spent outside of Toronto, but for the benefit of Torontonians. For example, Canada's trade missions abroad are for the benefit of Canadian business, much of which is based in Toronto. The entire provincial highway system, with Toronto at the hub, is for Toronto's benefit, without which the flow of goods to and from Toronto would not be possible. The border control points at Windsor and Niagara Falls are not "in" Toronto, but it is through these points that Toronto-made goods are exported to the USA. I would expect that most of the commercial traffic through these crossings are headed to or from Toronto. The federal prison is in Kingston, but how many of its inmates committed crimes in Toronto? Queen's University is also in Kingston, but how many of its students are either from Toronto or will work in Toronto after graduation.
None of which would do Toronto any good without the highways, railroads and shipping lanes that allow food, goods and materials into Toronto and allow Toronto to transport its finished wares.
No, I'm talking about tax imbalances.
The GTA actually contributes 24 billion MORE to the system than it ever gets back. (2004 figures)
That money goes to build roads in Northern Manitoba, or a nice new school in some small town where there is a population of 1,200, or a hospital in Nepean Ontario, whatever.
The GTA is a net payer each and every year into the system.
But you don't have to believe me, believe the Fraser Institute....
http://www.fraserinstitute.org/commerce.web/product_files/SharetheWealth.pdf

