Toronto versus Vancouver?

johnhenrygalt said:
Of what "system" do you speak? And how do you calculate the 17 billion figure? Remember, if a company is HQed in Toronto but has operations all over the country, don't make the mistake of considering corporate taxes paid by that company as taxes "coming from" Toronto. Also remember, much tax money can be spent outside of Toronto, but for the benefit of Torontonians. For example, Canada's trade missions abroad are for the benefit of Canadian business, much of which is based in Toronto. The entire provincial highway system, with Toronto at the hub, is for Toronto's benefit, without which the flow of goods to and from Toronto would not be possible. The border control points at Windsor and Niagara Falls are not "in" Toronto, but it is through these points that Toronto-made goods are exported to the USA. I would expect that most of the commercial traffic through these crossings are headed to or from Toronto. The federal prison is in Kingston, but how many of its inmates committed crimes in Toronto? Queen's University is also in Kingston, but how many of its students are either from Toronto or will work in Toronto after graduation.



None of which would do Toronto any good without the highways, railroads and shipping lanes that allow food, goods and materials into Toronto and allow Toronto to transport its finished wares.

No, I'm talking about tax imbalances.

The GTA actually contributes 24 billion MORE to the system than it ever gets back. (2004 figures)

That money goes to build roads in Northern Manitoba, or a nice new school in some small town where there is a population of 1,200, or a hospital in Nepean Ontario, whatever.

The GTA is a net payer each and every year into the system.

But you don't have to believe me, believe the Fraser Institute....

http://www.fraserinstitute.org/commerce.web/product_files/SharetheWealth.pdf
 
Toronto IS the center of the Canadian universe in Canada.

Not Vancouver, Calgary, Ottawa, Montreal etc.

That's just the way it is. There's nothing wrong with the other cities, each has it's own characteristics -- but, it's not Toronto.
 
james t kirk said:
But you don't have to believe me, believe the Fraser Institute....

http://www.fraserinstitute.org/commerce.web/product_files/SharetheWealth.pdf

That study makes the classic error of allocating expenditures to the geographical place of the expense. For example, money spent on the repair and maintenance of a stretch of highway from Toronto to Windsor is not for the benefit of the farmer whose field is adjacent to the highway; it is for the benefit of Torontonians who are the majority of the highway users.

The study allocates money spent on civil servant salaries to the place of work of the civil servant. But the civil servant in Ottawa (to the extent that his work is useful) is working for the benefit of all Canadians, the largest grouping of which is in Toronto. Same thing for the out-of-town universities catering mostly to students from Toronto.

As for defense expenditures, the study would allocate all of the expenses relating to the Cold Lake military base to Northern Alberta. Yet these soldiers ostensibly serve all Canadians.

When Ontario was building nuclear power plants, these weren't for the benefit of the communities where the plants were built. Ontario built these plants to service Toronto. Does anyone really want the nuclear power plants in downtown Toronto so that the money "stays in the GTA". Of course not, but using the Fraser Institute's methodology, this would be government money leaving the GTA.
 
The Coors billboards will now be taken down. In a way I'm glad Coors didn't get away with using Toronto in their campaign. It is one thing for westerners to joke about us but it becomes a bit different when this type of rivalry escalates its way onto billboards. The downside is that westerners will now play this up as if all Torontonians are a bunch of whining pussies who can't take a joke. We should have just ignored this.

http://www.cbc.ca/consumer/story/2009/08/18/billboard-ad-coors-light-british-columbia-toronto.html
 
johnhenrygalt said:
That study makes the classic error of allocating expenditures to the geographical place of the expense. For example, money spent on the repair and maintenance of a stretch of highway from Toronto to Windsor is not for the benefit of the farmer whose field is adjacent to the highway; it is for the benefit of Torontonians who are the majority of the highway users.

The study allocates money spent on civil servant salaries to the place of work of the civil servant. But the civil servant in Ottawa (to the extent that his work is useful) is working for the benefit of all Canadians, the largest grouping of which is in Toronto. Same thing for the out-of-town universities catering mostly to students from Toronto.

As for defense expenditures, the study would allocate all of the expenses relating to the Cold Lake military base to Northern Alberta. Yet these soldiers ostensibly serve all Canadians.

When Ontario was building nuclear power plants, these weren't for the benefit of the communities where the plants were built. Ontario built these plants to service Toronto. Does anyone really want the nuclear power plants in downtown Toronto so that the money "stays in the GTA". Of course not, but using the Fraser Institute's methodology, this would be government money leaving the GTA.

Cold Lake, highways, etc. have economic benefit to the geographic regions they are included in. Huge benefits. Just try to close a base in a Minister's riding and see what happens. Same with universities, etc. Sure, others benefit some, but the locals benefit most. More jobs, more spending, more tourists, travellers, etc. So not as off-base as you would have it appear.
 
johnhenrygalt said:
That study makes the classic error of allocating expenditures to the geographical place of the expense. For example, money spent on the repair and maintenance of a stretch of highway from Toronto to Windsor is not for the benefit of the farmer whose field is adjacent to the highway; it is for the benefit of Torontonians who are the majority of the highway users.

The study allocates money spent on civil servant salaries to the place of work of the civil servant. But the civil servant in Ottawa (to the extent that his work is useful) is working for the benefit of all Canadians, the largest grouping of which is in Toronto. Same thing for the out-of-town universities catering mostly to students from Toronto.

As for defense expenditures, the study would allocate all of the expenses relating to the Cold Lake military base to Northern Alberta. Yet these soldiers ostensibly serve all Canadians.

When Ontario was building nuclear power plants, these weren't for the benefit of the communities where the plants were built. Ontario built these plants to service Toronto. Does anyone really want the nuclear power plants in downtown Toronto so that the money "stays in the GTA". Of course not, but using the Fraser Institute's methodology, this would be government money leaving the GTA.


So basically, what you are saying is that the entire country works selflessy for the good of their fellow Canadians, except those selfish Torontonians who only do things for themselves. You're just another envious, Toronto-hater trying hard to manipulate the facts to suit your position. Your arguement is full of more shit than all the cattle in Alberta!

I apologize for being so crass... but the 'Fuck you Toronto" you're sending out is pretty clear, despite your attempt to dress it up pretty with supposed economic & demographic "facts". We Torontontians have been taking this sort of shit for so long, despite all the hard work we do, that we've become pretty astute at smelling it.

Canadians think we're cold... we're busy & tired!! How about you work 18 hour days, every day, with the pressure of it being "all the money" that we're working with (usually the case as HQ's of businesses & major banks are generally here); get stopped on the street multiple times per day by people NOT from here (who came here because there is more pan-handling profit to be made) asking for charity then verbally accost you if you refuse; dealing with traffic and arrogance of people NOT from here who come here every day to work, clog up & destroy the roads then go home to their picturesque little towns and pay property taxes there and do nothing but complain about how much they hate Toronto; then because we are busy, tired, & now offended / sad / feelings hurt / taken advantage of, we do our best to help out the occasional tourist who finds our manner unpleasant because we are in a rush, or tired, or whatever! Damn!!

Exactly how many times do you other Canadians expect us Torontonians to keep bending over? For those of you that have ACTUALLY come here, you treat Toronto this way then are surprised when we're not nice to you? Are you f-ing kidding me??? The funny thing is, WE ARE STILL NICE TO YOU!!!! Fuck! STAY HOME & SHUT UP!


Okay... I'm done.
 
A.J. Raven said:
So basically, what you are saying is that the entire country works selflessy for the good of their fellow Canadians, except those selfish Torontonians who only do things for themselves.

No, not at all. Next time try reading what I wrote and you will know what I am "saying" (actually writing, but let's not quibble). Why would you erroneously presume that I meant anything other than what I actually wrote?

Okay... I'm done.

Good, but you really should have quit before you started.
 
johnhenrygalt said:
Good, but you really should have quit before you started.

You're likely right. But it is a CONSTANT barrage of negativity in this country. Every day is another "Toronto sucks" or "People in Toronto..." - it never ends!! Just tired of it.
 
moresex4me said:
Cold Lake, highways, etc. have economic benefit to the geographic regions they are included in. Huge benefits. Just try to close a base in a Minister's riding and see what happens. Same with universities, etc. Sure, others benefit some, but the locals benefit most. More jobs, more spending, more tourists, travellers, etc. So not as off-base as you would have it appear.

When a particular dollar, in either the public or private sector, is spent, it is difficult to determine with any measureable accuracy exactly "where" the dollar was spent. A stretch of the 401 is repaired. Was the money spent at the place of repair? Was it spent where the contruction company is based? Was it spent at the place where the construction firm got its supplies? Was a portion of it spent on the lawyers and accountants who papered up the transaction? Was it spent on the engineering firm whose methods will be used in making the repair?

No city can exist without a hinterland. With a few exceptions, the city is usually part of the same political entity as its primary hinterland. An interdependance is created rendering studies such as the one referred to in an above post flawed unless the study acknowledges the limitations of its methodology.
 
You information is flawed, especially the Windsor / Toronto higway example & examples like it. The MAJORITY of users are NOT Torontonians, as Torontonians live & work in Toronto. Majority of users are those who live outside Toronto and use it daily to commute to Toronto for work. In this region, Toronto is a destination city, filled with all those things cities offer - like theatre, sporting events, festivals, conventions, etc... Torontontonians are already in Toronto, and not many have to travel outside since Toronto is also a central location of business. With all your "smart-sounding" posts, it seems this would have been obvious to you.

Because of your disdain for Toronto you are likely going to tell me I am wrong, but I'm not. I am a Torontonian. My friends live here. I've lived here my entire life and I know more people who come here than I know people who live here that go somewhere else.

EVERYONE benefits from these things in the Hinterland, regardless of how much you maintain that only Torontonians benefit. The point you are missing is that EVERYONE benefits from what Toronto does, except Toronto.
 
A.J. Raven said:
You're likely right. But it is a CONSTANT barrage of negativity in this country. Every day is another "Toronto sucks" or "People in Toronto..." - it never ends!! Just tired of it.

I've never really considered the negativity to be that prominent. If we added up the "Quebec sucks", "Albertans are ignorant rednecks", "BCers are potheads", and "Toronto sucks" comments, Toronto probably gets a little more than it's fair share of abuse, but not by much.
 
johnhenrygalt said:
I've never really considered the negativity to be that prominent. If we added up the "Quebec sucks", "Albertans are ignorant rednecks", "BCers are potheads", and "Toronto sucks" comments, Toronto probably gets a little more than it's fair share of abuse, but not by much.


"BCer's are potheads" doesn't belong in that list, as it seems to be a flag of pride for BCer's. The others I have never thought or said. The people I know are the same. The worst we would think or say is about Quebec & how we sometimes feel they purposefully make it difficult for us when we visit, specifically in regards to language issues.

Being on the receiving end of the negativity about Toronto, just by being a Torontonian, I am telling you it is excessively negative... and not just by little bit. If it was just by a little do you think a documentary would have been made about it? It's got to the point where it has become as unifying for (other) Canadians as hockey & Timmies.


PS: So as a Torontonian, here are my honest thoughts about the other regions of my country:

BC: I imagine going to BC is like going to a resort / spa run by young people so it is always a "hip" & "cool" place to relax and have a great time!

Alberta: I think it must be just like Texas, but not so Republican with a big shot of sophistication - smart cowboys, not rednecks.

Saskatchewan: The biggest sky and the widest land - probably the best place in the world to watch a sunrise or sunset.

Manitoba: Cold - like most of Ontario. The best place to be to get in touch and learn more about the native cultures and difficulties in blending our culture with theirs.

Yukon: Real, untouched wilderness - a place to be protected.

Northwest Territories: Tundra & polar bears - a place to be revered & protected.

Nunivut: Finally a region where the native culture in our Country can thrive and be included in the Canadian "conversation".

Quebec: The best of what Europe would offer, only closer. We are a better country for them being a part of it. I just wish I could speak the language, or they were more forgiving of me not being able to speak it.

Newfoundland: Recently, very happy for their economic success. In the past, felt bad they were so isolated. Definately a treasure.

Nova Scotia: A perfect mix of Maritime culture and big city life.

PEI: Anne of Green Gables, the best potatoes & the birthplace of Confederation. Canada's romanticized version of Washington D.C. - A place to look up to.

New Brunswick: An inconspicuous place with wonderful environmental treasures.


Generally, I feel safe in saying my friends here in toronto feel the same way. So when all we get is hate, pardon us for feeling like shit.
 
A.J. Raven said:
You information is flawed, especially the Windsor / Toronto higway example & examples like it. The MAJORITY of users are NOT Torontonians, as Torontonians live & work in Toronto. Majority of users are those who live outside Toronto and use it daily to commute to Toronto for work.

If you read the study, you would have noticed that it referred to the so-called "GTA", which included much more than Toronto. Moreover, when calculating the GTA's income taxes paid, the authors of the study allocated it to the place of work, not the place of residence. So for purposes of the study, the commuter's tax burden is considered part of the GTA's tax burden.

If you wanted to look just at those living in Toronto proper, you would have to subtract the income taxes paid by the commuters.

Because of your disdain for Toronto you are likely going to tell me I am wrong, but I'm not.

I have no disdain for Toronto, so yes - on that point you are wrong. My complaint is with the assertion that "Toronto" pays out $24B more into the "system" than it receives. The methodology used to calculate the $24B figure is flawed. And the Fraser Institute isn't even based in Toronto - it's based in Vancouver (there is a Toronto office though).
 
Um...

Whoever posted the numbers about equalisation payments...is Quebec REALLY getting 8 billion+ dollars?! Did I read that right? The people who always bitch and moan about wanting to leave this country get $8 billion?!

We're bitching about west vs east, Toronto sucks...Vancouver licks hippie balls... and this is ok?! I feel a vein getting ready to burst in my head...(and not the good one!)

OP
 
johnhenrygalt said:
If you read the study, you would have noticed that it referred to the so-called "GTA", which included much more than Toronto. Moreover, when calculating the GTA's income taxes paid, the authors of the study allocated it to the place of work, not the place of residence. So for purposes of the study, the commuter's tax burden is considered part of the GTA's tax burden.

If you wanted to look just at those living in Toronto proper, you would have to subtract the income taxes paid by the commuters.



I have no disdain for Toronto, so yes - on that point you are wrong. My complaint is with the assertion that "Toronto" pays out $24B more into the "system" than it receives. The methodology used to calculate the $24B figure is flawed. And the Fraser Institute isn't even based in Toronto - it's based in Vancouver (there is a Toronto office though).

The study is SERIOULY flawed if it allocated the tax paid by location of work, because that is not what ACTUALLY occurs. If a commutor (a non-GTA resident) lives in Oakville or London, then their taxes go to Oakville & London. Perhaps you should look at studies based in reality, not fantasy.


***I am getting confused about which study YOU are referring to. You mentioned one, then someone else mentioned the Fraiser one.
MY POINT is that Toronto contibutes a significantly larger amount of money then other parts of the country, then people take all their taxes back to the cities they live in, while using all the amenties of Toronto, on a daily basis, not contributing to the upkeep of those amenities through their taxes, and then bitching about how terrible Toronto is. You keep saying that only Toronto benefits from regional infrastruture. I am saying that the country benefits from Toronto yet is constantly being bashed by those who readily take those benefits. That is my only point.
 
I love Toronto, Ontario and Canada, I do not take exception to this ad. It's Coors after all, a company that funded and advocated National Socialism in America - even after WW II began. They produce weak, tasteless swill that has to be chilled to sub-zero to me made palatable. No one with any shread of self-esteem would be caught drinking this crap.

Stay thirsty my Torontonian friends.
 
As someone who was born and raised in B.C., I can't say I ever recall any animosity towards Toronto, we were all busy hating Quebecs guts:D .
 
I think that billboard is right... Torontoians can be cold and stiff when compared to places like Vancouver and Montreal.... esp the ladies... go to Montreal and smile at a girl and she smiles back. Do it in Toronto and chances are you get attitude back instead of a smile!
 
A.J. Raven said:
The study is SERIOULY flawed if it allocated the tax paid by location of work, because that is not what ACTUALLY occurs. If a commutor (a non-GTA resident) lives in Oakville or London, then their taxes go to Oakville & London. Perhaps you should look at studies based in reality, not fantasy.


***I am getting confused about which study YOU are referring to. You mentioned one, then someone else mentioned the Fraiser one.
MY POINT is that Toronto contibutes a significantly larger amount of money then other parts of the country, then people take all their taxes back to the cities they live in, while using all the amenties of Toronto, on a daily basis, not contributing to the upkeep of those amenities through their taxes, and then bitching about how terrible Toronto is. You keep saying that only Toronto benefits from regional infrastruture. I am saying that the country benefits from Toronto yet is constantly being bashed by those who readily take those benefits. That is my only point.

Two words for you on all those GTA'ers working in Toronto: business tax. That's right, paid for by their employers. And I'm talking city-run tax here that goes straight to the city's coffers, not income tax, federal or provincial.

And on another note, the last study I saw on commuting showed just as many people leaving the city proper for work as coming in. Think of the explosive growth in Markham, Richmond Hill, Vaughan, Mississauga and Brampton.

Regardless, great city, best in Canada, and everyone likes sniping at the top dog.