Toronto Star article: Traffic tickets

alexmst

New member
Dec 27, 2004
6,939
1
0
Jun 06, 2009 04:30 AM

Ken Gallinger

http://www.thestar.com/living/article/644450

Full disclosure: I occasionally talk to myself. So this week's question doesn't come from a reader. It comes from a debate inside my own head. Here it is:

Q: I recently got a ticket for failing to obey a "Stop" sign. Well, I've "accidentally" run a few stop signs in my time – but this time I was, in my opinion, innocent. "I stopped, dammit!" I told the cop – but he was apparently having a bad day. So he growled back, saying, "not for long enough." Psshaw! So I decided to fight it. Following the procedure on the City of Toronto website, I scheduled a "first attendance" with the prosecutor, and showed up, bristling with righteous indignation, ready to tell my story.

I discovered that 20 other people had appointments with that prosecutor at the same time. We were told to line up at her office door like cattle. I mooed a bit, and obeyed.

We were taken in one at a time and told not to close the door because we wouldn't be staying long enough to bother. The prosecutor (if that's who she was – we were never introduced) looked up my name on a computer printout, and said, "I can cut the fine to $40 (from $110) and reduce the points."

"But wait," quoth I. "Don't you want to hear my story?" She replied: "I don't have time for stories. You have two choices. Take the cheap way out, or go to trial in a year or so." Then she went on, "If I were you I'd go to trial. The cop will never show up for a little charge like this, and you'll get off."

"Holy crap!" thought I. She doesn't care if I'm guilty – she's just trying to clear the backlog in the office. So I paid the 40 bucks and walked. From what I could tell, most of the other 19 people in the lineup did the same thing. Why not? Over. Done. No one ever asked if I did it – no one cared.

The waiting room was packed, and, judging by their behaviour, I was one of just a few who were there for the first time. I felt like a rookie in a game dominated by veterans – they knew where to stand, what to say, how the system worked. They'd had lots of tickets before, and already knew that you'd be a darned fool to pay one, when all you have to do is walk in the door, put up with a little rudeness from the staff, and get it reduced or waived.

So, great ethics guru, my question is this: can this be right?

A: The answer is obvious. "Of course not." You were, essentially, bribed by the system to go away quietly. Accepting the deal made you complicitous in the scam.

Is this an efficient and cost-effective way to clear up backlogs and send people away happy? Perhaps. But is it right? Hardly. No wonder so many people today are cynical about the judicial system.

Justice would be as well served if, instead of seeing a prosecutor, you'd visited a kangaroo at the zoo.

ethical@sympatico.ca
 
Yes, the system sucks.

You have to ask yourself, is it worth $110 or $40 to go to all this trouble to fight a ticket. The time to wait to be heard, the aggravation and stress?
 
So what's the alternative? We pump millions and millions into hiring more court personnel so you can fight your $40 ticket? Talk about a waste of our tax dollars.

Personally I'd like to see higher fines for people who fight their ticket and lose.
 
Talking about tickets...

I did some shopping this afternoon, and Parking Enforcement came into the mall parking lot. He then proceeded to hand out $250 tickets to people that were parked in the "Fire Route" area.

Some people are going to be very pissed that they did not take the time to walk 1 minute to drop off their dry cleaning.
 
Keebler Elf said:
So what's the alternative? We pump millions and millions into hiring more court personnel so you can fight your $40 ticket? Talk about a waste of our tax dollars.

Personally I'd like to see higher fines for people who fight their ticket and lose.

I thought we were all assumed to be not guilty until proved otherwise.

If a cop issues you a ticket because he/she is having a bad day, do you just rollover and die? If I was innocent of a charge/ticket, I would like to be able to have my day in court. However, as noted by others, there is a financial cost if you know you are guilty and just want to waste the courts time. Also, some of these charges/tickets are just plain ridiculous and stupid and deserve to get time wasted in court.
 
Never!

NEVER, EVER , EVER PAY FOR A TICKET!!

NEVER!!

Even if they plea bargain it down to $40.00 from $110.00!

It's not about the fine of the ticket. Your Insurance premiums will go up.

It's about the fact that you PAID for it and therefore that registers you as guilty! The Insurance companies look up your records incessantly and then your premiums go up and you end up paying MORE in PERPETUITY. Hundreds, may a couple of thousand more depending on your insurance company.

The civil servant in the OP even said so: "Go to trial"! Damned right!

At trial, either the cop won't show up or it'll get thrown out. End of story.

Even if worse comes to worse, this has never failed me: on the day of the trial, ask a friend of yours to attend in your behalf. Let the friend ask for a postponement only. Not cancellation, only postponement. You couldn't attend due to family emergency or whatever and wanted to make sure an agent on your behalf attended to show due responsibility. At that point, it'll either get thrown out or, on at the outside, it will get rescheduled at six or eight months later. This gives you plenty of time to contact a ticket/trial agent who you will pay the same amount of the original ticket. I know some good ones.

The system is awful. Use the same rules of the system to YOUR advantage!

But never, ever, ever pay for a ticket and give greedy insurance companies more reason to screw you out of you hard earned cash!!!
 
Worf said:
I thought we were all assumed to be not guilty until proved otherwise.

You are.

And if you choose to fight it and lose (i.e., you are found guilty), I think you should pay twice the penalty.
 
Bridgeman said:
At trial, either the cop won't show up or it'll get thrown out.

Why do people still fall for that old wives tale. Since 2006, the number of now shows necessitated a change in regs;TPS officers are expected to attend scheduled court dates or face a penalty. The days of the officer not showing up are long gone.
 
Keebler Elf said:
So what's the alternative? We pump millions and millions into hiring more court personnel so you can fight your $40 ticket? Talk about a waste of our tax dollars.

Personally I'd like to see higher fines for people who fight their ticket and lose.


That is an idiotic statement.
 
Keebler Elf said:
So what's the alternative? We pump millions and millions into hiring more court personnel so you can fight your $40 ticket? Talk about a waste of our tax dollars.

Personally I'd like to see higher fines for people who fight their ticket and lose.
Maybe we can start with the alternative of making sure cops only give tickets they are willing to stand behind. Not end of month revenue generating traps or I'm in a bad mood tickets. Maybe then courts wouldn't be swamped with people who feel they are innocent and want to fight the charge.
 
alexmst said:
Q: I recently got a ticket for failing to obey a "Stop" sign. Well, I've "accidentally" run a few stop signs in my time – but this time I was, in my opinion, innocent. "I stopped, dammit!" I told the cop – but he was apparently having a bad day. So he growled back, saying, "not for long enough." Psshaw! So I decided to fight it.

Actually the real mistake that the person in this article mad, was accepting any offer from the crown.

The cop's charge of "not stoping long enough" is irrelevant, the HTA does not state how long one must stop for at any stop sign. As long as the car came to a complete stop even for a microsecond, its a perfectly legal stop.

It's one of the easiest charges to fight at trial.
 
Keebler Elf said:
And if you choose to fight it and lose (i.e., you are found guilty), I think you should pay twice the penalty.

I could agree with that IF you also agree that a person who WINS their case is entitled to full reimbursment on their costs of transportation, parking and unpaid time off work for both the trial date and the day they had to request the trial in person.
 
masterchief said:
Why do people still fall for that old wives tale. Since 2006, the number of now shows necessitated a change in regs;TPS officers are expected to attend scheduled court dates or face a penalty. The days of the officer not showing up are long gone.

Exactly. It is a rarity for an officer not to show up in court anymore.

But to the defence of Bridgeman, he only stated that if the officer does not show up that it will be thrown out of court (which it will).

IMHO, I would fight is as well. Bridgeman makes a great point in regards to insurance premiums rising even if you have one ticket, it also goes by the severity of the charge (obviously).
 
I just went through the same process. Failing to stop at a stop sign reduced to improper turn. No points and the insurance company has it marked as a minor infraction. No rate increase for minor infractions.
 
At the end of the day, traffic fines are nothing more than a means to take more of our money. I call it "road tax"... :rolleyes: What I hate is when the try and use this as a means to preach "safety precautions". They (Police/ province et al) have no interest in making it safer, or else they would just legislate speed governors similar to what they are doing to trucks... If everyone suddenly drove the speed limit and followed all the rest of the traffic "laws" the province would go bankrupt!

The fact that insurance companies use this as a means to jack up our premiums is complete BS, but it is what it is. Nothing we can do about it since it is all completely legislated. (Having insurance is mandatory... and ALL insurance companies have pretty much the same standard in this regard.)
 
DshRipRock said:
I just went through the same process. Failing to stop at a stop sign reduced to improper turn. No points and the insurance company has it marked as a minor infraction. No rate increase for minor infractions.


My insurance went up for not having my insurance papers with me during a random check. Cant get any minor than that

They should stop points loss for such tickets as seat belts. People would just pay the fine, it would unplug the courts and the courts would get the money instead of the para legals.

I understand cops get paid overtime to appear in court. Why would they not appear for such easy money ?
 
masterchief said:
No they should not, come on in this day and age why would you not be wearing your seatbelt while driving?


You completely missed my point

EVERYONE FIGHTS IT BECAUSE THEY KNOW THEY CAN GET IT REDUCED

This plugs up the courts and gives the revenue to the para legals instead of the courts after the the courts and the police spent revenue for the charge and nothing is achieved except the para legals make six figures

See my point now?