toronto catholic board trustees

Pay a politician $5,000, and he'll think stealing $10,000 is a lot of money.
Pay a politician $50,000, and he'll think stealing $100,000 is a lot of money.
I prefer the cheap crooks.

The best way to reduce the size of government is to stop feeding the government money.
 
Last edited:
oldjones said:
You're absolutely right, and I have no sympathy for them either. But what quality of person willingly takes on such a job for $5000 a year? I find it revealing that Harris—whose only other elected job was school trustee—decided trustees were worth only $5K. Presumably he was evaluating his own performance. Anyway, that's what the Catholic Board got: cheap crooks.

But if anyone cares to fix it, ae first step might be to offer pay worthy of the job we want them to do. We get the pols we deserve.

What's the difference between cheap crooks and expensive crooks. Being unhappy with your salary is no excise for stealing. It is a part-time job worthy of part-time pay. If you don't like it, then resign.
 
oldjones said:
Of course at least some of this is because they're expected to do the job for $5,000 a year. So they look for other ways to fatten up their pay envelopes to something fairer. Naturally some turn out to be way too greedy and have no concept of fair. There are some in every crowd. Just like there are some who did not pad their expenses.

As for the five thou' that's all Slasher Harris thought the job was worth. Because that's all he thought his job was worth when he was a school trustee, no doubt.

Since voters do such a crappy job of picking, ya gotta at least pay the folks they elect enough to make them—most of them, anyway—ashamed to steal.

This is, may I remind you, a part-time job. Most, if not all, have real jobs, and the money they receive as trustees is more of an honorarium than pay. I have known personally some of these trustees, and I don't think that some of theme even deserve the $5K that they are paid.
 
I have known many very hard working Trustees some of which held the positions when the pay and expenses were zero ! They were there because of a dedication to the students and their education . These expenses are ridiculous and should be investigated for possible legal action. Most boards have better financial controls in place to prevent this from occurring and I believe from the ones I know personally that most Trustees have more integrity than to commit this type of fraud. You can check with your own board for the expenses of your local trustee and adjust your vote accordingly . I for one have had a lot of exposure to many very hard working Trustees and have a great deal of respect for their work and dedication.

Boo
 
xdog said:
What's the difference between cheap crooks and expensive crooks. Being unhappy with your salary is no excise for stealing. It is a part-time job worthy of part-time pay. If you don't like it, then resign.
Cheap crooks are the kind Harris made sure would fill the Trustee's jobs. If pols are gonna be crooked, as many are, I'd rather they were at least as smart as Harper's in-out guys, or Chrétien's adscammers. At least guys like that get some work done while feathering their nests.

But I'll say it again: we get the pols we deserve. If you supervise any workers, how successful is underpaying and vilifying them at getting good work from them?
 
shakenbake said:
This is, may I remind you, a part-time job. Most, if not all, have real jobs, and the money they receive as trustees is more of an honorarium than pay. I have known personally some of these trustees, and I don't think that some of theme even deserve the $5K that they are paid.
Do you really think a $850 million corporation's board should be filled with cheaply-paid part-timers? Name any corporation of like size that pays it's board so poorly. And whose shareholders expect board members to answer every phonecall and attend every cookie day.

"But my phonecall was only twenty minutes and cookie day comes once a year." Yeah, times millions of parents and more than two hundred schools. And that's before they read a single budget document. Part-time, sure.

Get it straight: Fiddling expenses is wrong. But we set up the conditions that encouraged it, and we voted the cheap crooks into those conditions. Maybe instead of useless but traditional finger-pointing and namecalling it might pay us to give a bit of thought before voting for people who promise only to cut costs and ask them "How?"

Think about it the next time someone promises to get tough on crime without telling you how they'll pay for the extra police, prosecutors, courtrooms, jails, penitentiaries and parole officers that will require.

Or tells you the school system costs too much, and he'll send you a two hundred dollar cheque to prove it.

BTW: What is your source for saying, "Most, if not all, have real[sic] jobs,"? I couldn't find any such info on the Board's website, but I'm not a great researcher. Presumably you're better. Or did you perhaps mean: Most, if not all, could and perhaps do have jobs in the private sector and still do their trustee work, if the Toronto Board was the size of say North Bay's?

Note: At $25hr (which is way below even junior management rates) the five thou' buys 200 hours. Allowing a two week vacation to make the arithmetic easier, that's four hours a week. Betcha the parent's complaints alone take that time, never mind the meetings, and they still haven't read a page of their close to billion-dollar budget (Haven't filled out an expense sheet either) at their $25 rate. 'Course if the guy makes say $75 at his 'real' job and he can't claim a lunch w/o a hassle, where do you think he'll put his best efforts?

So turning it around: To serve on the board of a $850,000,000 corporation, how much per hour is fair? How many hours do you as a shareholder expect the board member to devote to the corporation over a year? Any perks or expenses above and beyond? Like meals, taxis, air tickets and hotels or office expenses that corporate board members get f'rinstance.
 
markvee said:
Pay a politician $5,000, and he'll think stealing $10,000 is a lot of money.
Pay a politician $50,000, and he'll think stealing $100,000 is a lot of money.
I prefer the cheap crooks.

pizzaboo said:
I have known many very hard working Trustees some of which held the positions when the pay and expenses were zero ! They were there because of a dedication to the students and their education.

oldjones said:
Cheap crooks are the kind Harris made sure would fill the Trustee's jobs. If pols are gonna be crooked, as many are, I'd rather they were at least as smart as Harper's in-out guys, or Chrétien's adscammers. At least guys like that get some work done while feathering their nests.
It looks as if the solution is to go back to paying zero. With zero pay, we got dedicated hard working trustees. With six figure MP pay and a gold plated pension, we got a hundred million dollar sponsorship scandal and some work done.

Of course, we could let the public decide the pay for the politicians through a referendum at election time. The pay could apply for the term following the next election, so that no one could claim to be misled about compensation.
 
Last edited:
oldjones said:
Do you really think a $850 million corporation's board should be filled with cheaply-paid part-timers? Name any corporation of like size that pays it's board so poorly. And whose shareholders expect board members to answer every phonecall and attend every cookie day.

"But my phonecall was only twenty minutes and cookie day comes once a year." Yeah, times millions of parents and more than two hundred schools. And that's before they read a single budget document. Part-time, sure.

Get it straight: Fiddling expenses is wrong. But we set up the conditions that encouraged it, and we voted the cheap crooks into those conditions. Maybe instead of useless but traditional finger-pointing and namecalling it might pay us to give a bit of thought before voting for people who promise only to cut costs and ask them "How?"

Think about it the next time someone promises to get tough on crime without telling you how they'll pay for the extra police, prosecutors, courtrooms, jails, penitentiaries and parole officers that will require.

Or tells you the school system costs too much, and he'll send you a two hundred dollar cheque to prove it.

BTW: What is your source for saying, "Most, if not all, have real[sic] jobs,"? I couldn't find any such info on the Board's website, but I'm not a great researcher. Presumably you're better. Or did you perhaps mean: Most, if not all, could and perhaps do have jobs in the private sector and still do their trustee work, if the Toronto Board was the size of say North Bay's?

Note: At $25hr (which is way below even junior management rates) the five thou' buys 200 hours. Allowing a two week vacation to make the arithmetic easier, that's four hours a week. Betcha the parent's complaints alone take that time, never mind the meetings, and they still haven't read a page of their close to billion-dollar budget (Haven't filled out an expense sheet either) at their $25 rate. 'Course if the guy makes say $75 at his 'real' job and he can't claim a lunch w/o a hassle, where do you think he'll put his best efforts?

So turning it around: To serve on the board of a $850,000,000 corporation, how much per hour is fair? How many hours do you as a shareholder expect the board member to devote to the corporation over a year? Any perks or expenses above and beyond? Like meals, taxis, air tickets and hotels or office expenses that corporate board members get f'rinstance.
School Board Trustee a real job? Give me a break! I have known more than my fair share of Sparate School Board trustees in TO and have not been impressed with their lack of knowledge of the Board or of the educational system. Just what kinds of serious and far-reaching decisions do these people make, anyway, in their part-time jobs? I went to more than a couple of their meetings and was disgusted by their behaviour. It was so bad that I very seriously considered never to send any of my kids to a separate school in TO.

Then again, wasn't it the Separate School Board that went bankrupt a few years ago and had to be bailed out by the government at least once in the last fifteen years? The same situation at the York Region Separate School Board in 1994, when I was a student teacher assigned to one of their schools and witnessed the nonsense first-hand at the front lines. The waste of money and resources, and the petty politics in that school!

Anyway, the bottom line is that the corruption must stop and that these elected 'officials' who we are to trust must be held accountable.

End of my venting, whew!
 
shakenbake said:
School Board Trustee a real job? Give me a break! I have known more than my fair share of Sparate School Board trustees in TO and have not been impressed with their lack of knowledge of the Board or of the educational system. Just what kinds of serious and far-reaching decisions do these people make, anyway, in their part-time jobs? I went to more than a couple of their meetings and was disgusted by their behaviour. It was so bad that I very seriously considered never to send any of my kids to a separate school in TO.

Then again, wasn't it the Separate School Board that went bankrupt a few years ago and had to be bailed out by the government at least once in the last fifteen years?
Bingo! Bankruptcy's kinda "serious and far reaching" wouldn't you say? Guess they shoulda put in a few more hours
The same situation at the York Region Separate School Board in 1994, when I was a student teacher assigned to one of their schools and witnessed the nonsense first-hand at the front lines. The waste of money and resources, and the petty politics in that school!Anyway, the bottom line is that the corruption must stop and that these elected 'officials' who we are to trust must be held accountable.

End of my venting, whew!
If it was that bad when you taught, and it's still that bad, surely the real bottom line is: Not electing bozos in the first place. You want good people you gotta pick 'em, and you gotta pay 'em. Basically the Catholic Board seems to have gotten what they picked and paid for. But then, it seems you don't think the job's a real one anyway, so what's the difference?
 
oldjones said:
Bingo! Bankruptcy's kinda "serious and far reaching" wouldn't you say? Guess they shoulda put in a few more hours
If it was that bad when you taught, and it's still that bad, surely the real bottom line is: Not electing bozos in the first place. You want good people you gotta pick 'em, and you gotta pay 'em. Basically the Catholic Board seems to have gotten what they picked and paid for. But then, it seems you don't think the job's a real one anyway, so what's the difference?

You hit the nail on the head. The real problem is attracting the suitable candidates. People like Maria Rizzo and Christine Nuziata, who were mentioned in a link above, and one was the trustee in the area where I used to live, didn't give a rat's ass about the schools. Very few people take the school trustee election seriously. These candidates merely won a popularity contest to get in. The old adage, we get the government we deserve, is so true.
 
oldjones said:
Bingo! Bankruptcy's kinda "serious and far reaching" wouldn't you say? Guess they shoulda put in a few more hours
If it was that bad when you taught, and it's still that bad, surely the real bottom line is: Not electing bozos in the first place. You want good people you gotta pick 'em, and you gotta pay 'em. Basically the Catholic Board seems to have gotten what they picked and paid for. But then, it seems you don't think the job's a real one anyway, so what's the difference?
Paying Ken Lay seven figures didn't keep Enron out of bankruptcy.

I agree about the part that voters should pick wisely.

I disagree with the notion that capable people will not run for office without the promise of exuberant pay and benefits.
 
markvee said:
Paying Ken Lay seven figures didn't keep Enron out of bankruptcy.

I agree about the part that voters should pick wisely.

I disagree with the notion that capable people will not run for office without the promise of exuberant pay and benefits.
enron's bankruptcy was the result of a fraud engineered by andrew fastow the CFO
 
Andrew Fastow received an eight or nine figure salary.

Higher salary is not a guarantee of competence or integrity.

The integrity lapses of those receiving high salary tend to involve stealing more obscene sums of money.
 
buckwheat1 said:
some of them should be fired for abuse of funds, they aren't board employees they are voted in at the municipal election time, so I guess they serve a 4 year term now.

totally agree, i dont know why gov doesnt step in
 
markvee said:
There should be a recall procedure for all elected offices.

Yeah, that's a great idea. Then every time a politician who actually has some balls and makes a tough decision, he'll get recalled by whoever doesn't like the answer. Instead of elections every 4 years (or whatever), we'll have elections every 6 months. Great idea. :rolleyes:

We already have a recall procedure. It's call an election.
 
oldjones said:
Get it straight: Fiddling expenses is wrong. But we set up the conditions that encouraged it, and we voted the cheap crooks into those conditions. Maybe instead of useless but traditional finger-pointing and namecalling it might pay us to give a bit of thought before voting for people who promise only to cut costs and ask them "How?"

You're like a breath of fresh air. Finally, someone who gets it! :)

While I agree that there were definitely abuses going on, some of them listed in the newspapers were being misrepresented and taken out of context. But there's definitely a problem, and the problem is a lack of an expense policy and/or enforcement of it.

I thought the trustees had their pay slashed dramatically by the Harris government to the current (too) low rates? IIRC, they were overpaid in the past but as things usually go, the pendulum swung too far the other way and now they're underpaid.

For what it's worth, I've also heard that school trustee positions are the entry point for someone who wants to get into politics. Combine that with a measly pittance of a salary and I'm not surprised by the meager ethics of the people in question.

Really, it all boils down to two things:

1) The Board needs a better expense policy and enforce it; and

2) The Board needs to do a better job of recruiting/screening trustees (which likely requires commensurate compensation for the job duties entailed, rather than the chicken feed being tossed to them now).
 
markvee said:
The best way to reduce the size of government is to stop feeding the government money.

Wow, you're just full of smug/dumb answers. :rolleyes:

The best way to get your services slashed to nothing is to stop feeding the government money.

Where do you think roads, schools, hospitals, electricity, etc., etc., etc., come from? The magic pixies that visit you in your dreams?

You're probably one of those fools who thinks Harris did a great job.
 
Keebler Elf said:
Then every time a politician who actually has some balls and makes a tough decision, he'll get recalled by whoever doesn't like the answer.
It took quite some balls to give those millions in untendered contracts to those ad agencies for little or no work.

I think that the electorate, which is us by the way, would exercise the power of recall wisely.

In a representative democracy, the elected representatives should be representing us at all times.

If the electorate can not be trusted to recall a politican wisely, why should the electorate be trusted to elect the representatives in the first place?
 
Keebler Elf said:
Wow, you're just full of smug/dumb answers. :rolleyes:

The best way to get your services slashed to nothing is to stop feeding the government money.

Where do you think roads, schools, hospitals, electricity, etc., etc., etc., come from? The magic pixies that visit you in your dreams?

You're probably one of those fools who thinks Harris did a great job.
I did not support Harris. You probably supported Nixon. How do you like having your politician preferences presumed?

I have no problem with funding for roads and schools, but I have a problem with the billions that went missing from Human Resources Development Canada, the billions that were spent on the gun registry, and the billions that are being spent on new military acquisitions when the country is facing the real possibility of a recession and should be focused on repaying debt so that it is not inherited by our children.

I don’t agree with the notion that paying trustees more will attract fewer thieves or more honest people to run for trustee, but following this notion has the potential for overspending on trustee compensation.