To tip or not to tip?

thecoolguyms72

New member
Jan 18, 2003
1,247
0
0
54
Windsor
Let's pretend this is an hypothetical situation at a club that could be in Anywheretown with the NoName DancerGirl. I go to a club and very shortly after I sit down a girl comes up to me. She does the proposition of "fun". I tell her I just got there, then the waitress brings my drink while she is sitting there. She then says she is leaving soon and would give me a dance and oral for a set fee. The fee is more than reasonable so I say okay, even though that isn't what I went there for.

We go up, she seems fairly nice, does a dance somewhat awkwardly as the damn chairs at this club are shitty for a lapdance. The song ends, and she says to "get it out", at which point I'm am barely semi-hard, which I know is not a good thing for a good BJ for me, especially CBJ. Either way it's a BJ, things could be much worse. So, she starts at the task, not a bad job, but not great at all. Within a few songs, off I go and I tuck back in.

I stand up so I can pay and do the "walk of shame" to the washroom to do the flush. I reach for the money and she says, "what have you got for me?" I tell her I have the money we discussed and she says, "No tip?" Why negotiate a set fee if you just want more? Negotiate for more if you want more and then I'll decide if I want to pay. So, I say no, hand her the money and walk to the washroom.

My question is, was I rude in not tipping or rather being shamed into tipping? Do you guys automatically tip regardless of how it went? Do you come across this often? What do you do? I felt a bit like an ass, but more upset by it. I know that I will not go to the VIP with her again, if it were a real story that is. ;)
 
The guilt factor will always play into it. Especially when you're dealing with the person face to face.

I would feel the same way if a waiter/waitress were standing there when I left them no tip even if the service didn't warrant it.

However, if you can detach the personal element and look at it as a tip for a reward of good service then the lack of tip when not warranted is perfectably acceptable.

For the record, I probably would have caved as I have a hard time with that.
 
LOL I'd have a hard time with getting a BJ in a club never mind giving or not giving her a tip DOH
 
if she gave you a blowjob then she got all the tip she needs? no?
 
tboy said:
LOL I'd have a hard time with getting a BJ in a club never mind giving or not giving her a tip DOH

To each their own, tboy. Remember, it is an hypothetical situation. As Chris Rock said, "There is no sex in the VIP!"

red said:
if she gave you a blowjob then she got all the tip she needs? no?

I agree, red, that was my thought. I was actually going to say that to her, but it would have just been lost on her. I couldn't be bothered.
 
the way I usually see it is this: tip for a service where the server is not well compensated, especially if this said compensation is based on tips. The best example of this are waitors/waitresses. Dancers and MPs tend to keep most of their fees. Now with that said, I have tipped MPs before, but that is because I enjoyed their company and wanted to show my gratitude.

so no, i don't think you were rude. There was no need to show any gratitude according to your post. I believe the dancer was rude in asking for one.
 
1HandInMyPocket said:
the way I usually see it is this: tip for a service where the server is not well compensated, especially if this said compensation is based on tips. The best example of this are waitors/waitresses. Dancers and MPs tend to keep most of their fees. Now with that said, I have tipped MPs before, but that is because I enjoyed their company and wanted to show my gratitude.

so no, i don't think you were rude. There was no need to show any gratitude according to your post. I believe the dancer was rude in asking for one.

That is the exact reason I didn't tip. First, she keeps all of the money I hand her, she doesn't directly share it with the club like an MP does with the parlour. Second, we negotiated a set fee, I would think that she negotiated in good faith. Third, if you have to ask for a tip, you didn't do all that great. I'm not a cheap guy. In fact, when a girl does a great job and isn't money hungry and begging for a tip, I will usually tip. The dichotomy is that most times when I tip she doesn't count it because it's not a priority for her and doesn't realize I tipped her. It's a double edged sword, so to speak.
 
It doesn't matter to me what service I'm receiving, if the server hasn't done such a good job that I feel reallllly happy........no tip. They work there for a set wage. If that is to low don't keep working there. Or start to provide superior service.
 
athaire said:
It doesn't matter to me what service I'm receiving, if the server hasn't done such a good job that I feel reallllly happy........no tip. They work there for a set wage. If that is to low don't keep working there. Or start to provide superior service.

my thoughts exactly. everyone needs to earn a tip not to expect one.
 
LMAO at "walk of shame to the bathroom"
 
thecoolguyms72 said:
First, she keeps all of the money I hand her, she doesn't directly share it with the club like an MP does with the parlour.

Not true. She pays a floor fee to be there.

That said, when a stripper negotiates a rate with you that is generally understood to include the full cost, including her floor fee. I don't tip strippers either.
 
thecoolguyms72 said:
My question is, was I rude in not tipping or rather being shamed into tipping? Do you guys automatically tip regardless of how it went? Do you come across this often? What do you do?

I'm more of an SP guy, but I've had some experience with "extras" at an SC. As an aside, as an American, I am shocked--shocked I tell you--at how much sex goes on at Canadian SC's. But not shocked enough not to partake, lol. For you guys who can get off in this venue, I tip my hat to you. I generally find it very uncomfortable.

Anyway, the principles of tipping remain the same. You were not rude, and if anything, she was rude for asking. That said, I don't fault her--you don't get many things in life unless you ask, and if she is successful even 10% of the time with such a blatant request, she is way ahead.

IMO, to tip automatically denigrates the whole purpose of tipping in the first place. I have no problem with tipping an sp if I feel she has given me above average service. If I feel the service has been extraordinary, I tip even more. But if I feel the service was average, there is no tip. I received the services I contracted for, but not much more.