tires with retractable studs

Why dont you people READ!! it is RETRACTABLE, why do they have to be removed in the summer? Studs are not there when retracted inside! Also, how do you know it makes noise? It is supposed to be same as summer tired when studs are retracted!
They are CHEAPER compared to keeping two sets of tires summer and winter and having to change them twice a year! I did the math. So it is both economical and convinient, and dont make noise when studs are retracted!
AGAIN The thread is NOT about studded tires! It is about RETRACTABLE STUDDED TIRES.
 
my car is rear wheel drive! it is very hard to control in the snow even with the snow tire. I change to summer tire when winter ends because i hate the way snow tire rides. it makes noise and less stable when driven fast on dry pavement. And the added cost of changing tires twice a year. Retractable seems the perfect solution. Somebody should have came up with it earlier.

If I just buy it from other province get them shipped here and install them myself. there is no way coppers can tell when your driving. I just dont see this law being enforceble. Most of the time it is retracted, so cops cant see the studs. when it's heavy snow, there will be so many accidents, i think cops have better things to do than stopping cars with studs tires.
My car is rear wheel drive too. I have a set of Blizzaks on it and it's fine for winter driving.

Unless you can somehow 100% guarantee that you will only use the studs when the car is on ice then you will be damaging the roads. Studded tires in all forms are illegal becuase of this. There is no practical way to constantly monitor the ground to see if you're on ice thick enough to protect the road from the studs. That is why retractable studded tires are illegal.

Most reputable places will not ship studded tires to Ontario and if they do they will only ship them to an approved installer in Northern Ontario.
 
The thread is NOT about studded tires! It is about RETRACTABLE STUDDED TIRES.

All you need to know is that it's a studded tire and studded tires are illegal in Southern Ontario. If you want to use them anyway that's your call and you can make your arguments about their harmlessness in court if it comes to that.

Anyway, I googled the company that makes these tires and they say that in the states of Oregon, Washington, Idaho, Nevada and Montana, - state highway laws banning the use of studded tires have been amended to allow for the use of retractable studded tires.

If enough people make noise Ontario assembly might amend their highway laws to allow retractable studs some day.
 
Last edited:
Also, how do you know it makes noise?


They will make more noise when the studs are extended - which is what I think the other posters were getting at. So if you drive merrily by a cop with your studs extended there is the potential that he may notice.
 
Also, how do you know it makes noise?
Studded tires were very pretty common in NY before they were banned because they were ripping up the roads.
When the studs are extended they makes a very noticeable clicking sound that only gets louder the faster you drive.
 
Why dont you people READ!! it is RETRACTABLE, why do they have to be removed in the summer? Studs are not there when retracted inside! Also, how do you know it makes noise? It is supposed to be same as summer tired when studs are retracted!
They are CHEAPER compared to keeping two sets of tires summer and winter and having to change them twice a year! I did the math. So it is both economical and convinient, and dont make noise when studs are retracted!
AGAIN The thread is NOT about studded tires! It is about RETRACTABLE STUDDED TIRES.

Last I heard I was reading just fine. The fct that the tires have retractable studs does not change the rubber comnpound of the tires which is the real difference in tires for winter driving. The rubber is much softer and will wear out very fast on dry pavement.
 
Why dont you people READ!! it is RETRACTABLE, why do they have to be removed in the summer? Studs are not there when retracted inside! Also, how do you know it makes noise? It is supposed to be same as summer tired when studs are retracted!
They are CHEAPER compared to keeping two sets of tires summer and winter and having to change them twice a year! I did the math. So it is both economical and convinient, and dont make noise when studs are retracted!
AGAIN The thread is NOT about studded tires! It is about RETRACTABLE STUDDED TIRES.

If you make the tire change part of a proper rotation practice you won't spend anything extra. Any garage that charges you a special price for switching a set of winter tires and it's more than a rotation is taking your money. The only extra cost incurred is the price of 4 steel wheels ($100/$200). As stated by someone else the tire compounds of winter tires are different and they will wear quicker in the summer therefore you'll spend extra money replacing them sooner.
 
They will make more noise when the studs are extended - which is what I think the other posters were getting at. So if you drive merrily by a cop with your studs extended there is the potential that he may notice.

Unless their painted black you'll also see them. The tips will be nice and bright and shiny as well.
 
my car is rear wheel drive! it is very hard to control in the snow even with the snow tire. I change to summer tire when winter ends because i hate the way snow tire rides. it makes noise and less stable when driven fast on dry pavement. And the added cost of changing tires twice a year. Retractable seems the perfect solution. Somebody should have came up with it earlier.

If I just buy it from other province get them shipped here and install them myself. there is no way coppers can tell when your driving. I just dont see this law being enforceble. Most of the time it is retracted, so cops cant see the studs. when it's heavy snow, there will be so many accidents, i think cops have better things to do than stopping cars with studs tires.
1) Why rear-wheel drive when you say it's more than you can handle in the half-year we can expect snowy roads? Shifting up and using a higher gear when starting/accelerating in snow can help, but your backend getting away means you're using too much gas. I'm sure it's a fine car, but all the makeup you add to a lemon won't make it a peach. You need to learn lemonade techiniques.

2) If you hate the sound of snows on dry pavement, you'd better get a noise-guarantee on your retractable studs. Even retracted, the mechanism's still there to make noise. And make fore a harder ride.

3) ignoring just how many retract/extend cycles the tires are good for (but it's another guarantee to get) how well do you think they're likely to perform the first time you need them, if you spent a summer clogging them with road tar and dirt, discarded bubblegum and other shit? How do you clean those little holes, and who do you pay how much to do it?

4) Quite right cops have better things to do than try to keep our road taxes low by ticketting for tire studs. The best thing they could do on winter days would be 24 hour license suspensions and tows for people driving beyond their capabilities like they can w/ alcohol. But tire studs make the law easier to enforce, like breathalysers.

Driving on snow and ice is a skill that needs to be learned. Every car and tire type's different, but they didn't turn the key and set out on the trip. You did. Like not driving after drinking, you have to know when you're outmatched and to stay off the roads.
 
The fine for driving in Ontario with studded tires in southern Ontario is up to $1000, even if you are from the north and do a short trip to TO, you're SOL, if you get caught. It's really easy to tell the sound of studs on a vehicle. It sound like tiny metal rattles as the vehicle goes by you on dry pavement. If you think the studs are going to retract all the time, every time, nah. You say your trying to save money the possible fines plus the $100/150 premium your going to pay over comparable regular winter tires, for this technology negates that thought.
 
If you make the tire change part of a proper rotation practice you won't spend anything extra. Any garage that charges you a special price for switching a set of winter tires and it's more than a rotation is taking your money. The only extra cost incurred is the price of 4 steel wheels ($100/$200). As stated by someone else the tire compounds of winter tires are different and they will wear quicker in the summer therefore you'll spend extra money replacing them sooner.

The tires she is talking about are all-seasons w/ retractable studs, not winter tires. Which means she's going to have worse luck driving with them than she did with proper winter tires unless she drives with the studs extended.
 
Just Gotta Ask?

The tires she is talking about are all-seasons w/ retractable studs,

LOL!!!
Just curious.
WTF! How do you extend the studs?

When it snows, do you pull them out with tweezers each snowfall?
Then push them all back in when roads are dry?....:D
 
LOL!!!
Just curious.
WTF! How do you extend the studs?

When it snows, do you pull them out with tweezers each snowfall?
Then push them all back in when roads are dry?....:D

Did you even read the link I posted? The extending / retracting actions are powered by the air pressure inside the tire, remotely controlled by wireless. Each time it comes out and goes back in, a little air pressure is lost. After 20 times of use, you just need to pump air into the tires. Seems pretty easy no? Agreed it is an untested technology, and has potential of getting caught.
I guess I will wait a couple of years after it comes out before getting one just to make sure they are safe.
 
Did you even read the link I posted?

I just didn't want to look through the whole thread for the answer.
I don't know, it's new untested technology, plus it deals with winter weather conditions which put the most stress on vehicle parts. I'd wait also on this one to.
 
The fine for driving in Ontario with studded tires in southern Ontario is up to $1000, even if you are from the north and do a short trip to TO, you're SOL, if you get caught.

When can I use my studded tires?
Northern Ontario residents can use studded tires with lightweight studs, anywhere in Ontario, from October 1 to April 30 inclusive. Using illegal studs, driving outside the legal time period, and Southern Ontario residents using studs on their vehicles can result in fines of up to $1,000.
 
When can I use my studded tires?
Northern Ontario residents can use studded tires with lightweight studs, anywhere in Ontario, from October 1 to April 30 inclusive. Using illegal studs, driving outside the legal time period, and Southern Ontario residents using studs on their vehicles can result in fines of up to $1,000.

does it mean that if I get a PO box in northern ON I can legally use studded tires?
 
does it mean that if I get a PO box in northern ON I can legally use studded tires?


Originally Posted by blackrock13
The fine for driving in Ontario with studded tires in southern Ontario is up to $1000, even if you are from the north and do a short trip to TO, you're SOL, if you get caught.


Not in Southern Ontario.
 
Originally Posted by blackrock13
The fine for driving in Ontario with studded tires in southern Ontario is up to $1000, even if you are from the north and do a short trip to TO, you're SOL, if you get caught.
Not in Southern Ontario.

Northern Ontario residents can drive with their studded tires in southern Ontario:

When can I use my studded tires?

Northern Ontario residents can use studded tires with lightweight studs, anywhere in Ontario, from October 1 to April 30 inclusive. Using illegal studs, driving outside the legal time period, and Southern Ontario residents using studs on their vehicles can result in fines of up to $1,000.


Do out-of-province visitors face fines if they have heavy (steel) studs on their vehicles?

No, as long as they do not stay longer than 30 days. The stud weight regulation does not apply to visitors. Similarly to Northern residents, they can use studded tires, in the legal period, anywhere in Ontario.

Have a look at: http://www.mto.gov.on.ca/english/faq/vehicle.shtml#studs
 
does it mean that if I get a PO box in northern ON I can legally use studded tires?

http://www.mto.gov.on.ca/english/faq/driver.shtml

What information do I need to change my address online?
To identify you, the ministry will need your driver's licence or Registrant Identification Number (RIN), your full name and old address (as it appears on driver's licence or vehicle permit).

You will also need your new address including street number, street name, apartment number or lot concession (if applicable), township and rural route, city and postal code. The ministry requires a complete residential address — a post office box is not sufficient.


Can my vehicle address be different from my driver's licence?
An Ontario residential address is required on drivers' licences and vehicle permits. If you change the address on your driver's licence, the address on your vehicle permit will be automatically changed (and vice versa). However, the vehicle must be registered in your name for this change to take effect.