Tboy:
I've owned nothing but smart phones of various makes since 2004. I wouldn't own anything else. Like you I dislike Apple as a company and the my shit don't stink attitude of apple users. But, I did get an iPhone last year and I have to say it's freaking awesome. Yes, there are things I don't like about it. I didn't like the lack of a keyboard, but I got used to the on screen one and it's not as bad as I thought it would be. The lack of a replaceable battery is a big downer and the camera is garbage (it's actually pretty good in daylight, but it sucks in low light at the lack of a flash really hurts it. My last nokia phone had a camera/flash as good as my normal digital camera). I also really dislike the way that Apple make is so hard to customize it and the worst think of all is the iTunes software which above all else would give me reason to switch to another phone.
I never had any intention of buying a regular mac computer and owning the iphone has solidified that, once a decent alternative comes in the next year or two I will probably switch away from the iphone.
That said, it IS an amazing phone. It really is. No other phone has close to the amount of software that the iphone does. Yes there's lots of shit to wade through but there's a good or excellent app to do just about anything you can imagine on it. Give it a try, a real try before you slag it off.
I'm in the same boat. I am not an Apple lover and used Blackberry and other keyboard equipped phones but I ended up with Apple 3Gs because it not only is an awesome product feature-wise but it has apps. This reminds me of so many different format wars (e.g. VHS vs Beta Max/ 8 track/ cassette,Apple vs PC) and the winner always ended up as the one that had the most content to use with it. iPhone has apps - great apps and it seems that the entire world is writing apps for iPhone. If any company is writing an as a service for their customers (food, transportation, software houses, etc) they will always write for the iPhone first (and many times only iPhone).
I agree - Tboy obviously has a big chip on his shoulder that was very well summarized in his first post. Fine - do your own homework - but if you want to actually use one device for the widest variety of functionality in your day-to-day life - visit the iPhone store and take a serious look at it. I did and because of my purchase I know Blackberry users who can't wait to get rid of them. Not because it doesn't work - just because of the lack of useful apps it has. As far as the keyboard goes - try the keyboard on landscape - the keys are easier to type the the Blackberry for me (the leap was even easier when I thought about how much I actually type using the keyboard).
Apps - great apps if you are traveling, cooking, ... living an active life. Are you a pilot - AOPA has a free app (for members) that lists all the details (including runway layouts and services) for over 5,00 airports across NA. Do you like listening to police dispatches - 99 cents gives your iPhone the ability to listen to emergency services real time all around the world. Flying abroad ? There are apps available to log your flight details and delays, free apps from most cities you visit detailing everything including public transit schedules. Electronics ? There are apps for antenna design, turning your iPhone into a highly accurate signal generator, etc. Or maybe you are now interested in earthquakes - there is an app that allows you to monitor them from all over the world.
BTW: The GPS with compass sounds funny until you actually use it. Turn it on in a strange city and it not only tells you where you are but tells you if you are facing the proper direction to get to where you want to go.
If I recommended a few apps for those crazy enough to end up purchasing an IPhone 3Gs - The free app 'Dictation' by Dragon. It is amazingly accurate (if you speak clear English) at taking dictation and converting it to text which then can be used in SMS, e-mail or pasted on any other application. Metro News - up to date and free. Great for those traveling that would like a quick summary of what is going on at home. Dictionary / Thesaurus is free and handy to use.
Of course instead or this toy I could just carry maps, books, newspapers and write letters instead of phoning - I mean do I really need this device ?. ... hmm-m Yeah I do !