danmand said:OK, I am happy to engage in arguments with you:
You are right about the motivation, but from what I have read, the perpetrators
were not in any way highly trined like the Seals or the Rangers. They had
difficulty following elementary flight training.
Another point is how they managed to take over 4 airplanes by merely
using box cutters.
You have 20 seamen on a container ship fight off pirates
armed with machine guns, but airplane captains give up their "ship" to
people armed with box cutters.
Some of these captains were former marine pilots etc.
I am not arguing, that you could not succeed in capturing an airplane that way,
only that a 100% success rate is astonishing.
I agree that they are not comparable to our "elite" military units. But they had intense purpose-specific training. And their motivation cannot be ignored; this was, after all, a suicide mission.
Taking over a plane with boxcutters was obviously, at the time, very easy. Merely overpower a few female and/or likely homosexual (sorry, couldn't resist) flight attendants, surprise the flight crew, cut their throats (likely all in less than 20 seconds, thank you very much) and then lock yourself into the cockpit.
The potential capabilities of the flight crew notwithstanding, they likely had no opportunity to defend themselves. The pilots didn't "give up" anything. They were ambushed and murdered. This is why commercial airliners have "hardened" cockpit doors today.
The passengers and cabin crew did not resist further because they had no idea of the "ultimate objective". For all they knew, they were going to Cuba. The United 93 passengers resisted only after learning the fate of the WTC planes.
Seamen on a ship have the advantage of seeing the pirates' boats approaching.
Flight training? They simply learned as little as they needed to know to successfully point the airplanes at the buildings. They were obviously "proficient enough".
100% success? Wasn't there a fourth plane (ostensibly headed for the WHite House) that crashed into a field in Pennsylvania? Is a 75% success rate more believable for you?

