The Truth On Iraq: It's Devastated

There is no way that US will disregard the elections even if the majority of Sunnis boycott the vote (or are unable to vote).
Plus, its not really their election to declare invalid.
What the Allawi government and United States will do is devise some way to compensate the lack of Sunni votes by electing Sunni representatives themselves.

Progress will take time especially with so much chaos.
There are regions in Iraq that have had little trouble and lot of oppurtunity to rebuild but since there is no violence there is little coverage.
Many Iraqis are working with the Americans not because they "adore" the Americans but because they believe in a better Iraq. Whatever their feelings/beliefs about the Americans; at least most Iraqis know that the Americans are trying to rebuild and reconstuct Iraq.
The insurgents on the other hand have no clear plan for the future of Iraq. When they speak, its only about violence and vengeance and nothing about progress. That is why most most normal Iraqis will not side with the insurgents (at least no willingly).

Just look at the election workers risking their lives in Iraq; as well as the policeman, the government workers and the soldiers. All their lives are at great risk. When interviewed they admit that they do it for the paycheck but they always add that they also do it for their nation and for the future of their children.

The situation is dire in Iraq but by giving into the insurgents, Iraqis know that they will be digging a bigger hole than the one they are currently stuck in.
 
As for the "Salvador Solution" or the return of the "Phoenix Program"; that is not going to happen.
I doubt that it was going to be seriously considered by the Pentagon leadership.
Chances are some general in the Pentagon brought it up, it was discussed and then rejected; then someone in the press picked it up and blew it out porportion (as they usually do with issues that really don't seem to be relevant)
 
Mcluhan,

I guess we'll assume you don't have a view on what to do next, just a catalog of what is wrong.

Answer score: OTB 1, Mcluhan 0

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
Mcluhan,

I guess we'll assume you don't have a view on what to do next, just a catalog of what is wrong.

Answer score: OTB 1, Mcluhan 0

OTB

My, aren't we the demanding one! OTB, I don't know about you, but I usually try to first define what is wrong before I go about suggesting how to fix a problem.

Oops..forgot..you voted for the moron. lol

This is a particulary difficult problem..and as I don't have nukes, i'm thinking about it. This is a colossal mess. You will hear from me eventually on it. (be a little patient) :)
 
Mcluhan,

You ask me a question and I answer it - I ask you one and you go into deflection mode. If you don't know just say so.

What do nukes have to do with it?

OTB
 
OTB, I asked you why you supported the 'Invasion' and you came up with 12 very wishy-washy reasons...sounded like off the cuff. Fine. I was gentle with you. Now you ask me to put forward a solution to this overwhelming mess of GLOBAL proportion, that "your" boys made. And you jump up and down when you you don't get a prompt answer back. Comical. As I said, i'm thinking about it. I'd prefer not to give a half-baked answer.
 
onthebottom said:
Mcluhan,

I guess we'll assume you don't have a view on what to do next, just a catalog of what is wrong.

Answer score: OTB 1, Mcluhan 0

OTB

Him and some others here,remind me of the two old guys from the Muppet Show, that always sat on the balcony and made fun and complained about everything.
It is so much easier to comlain about something, than to do anything about it.

It amazes me that the very same people that applauded the end of apartheid in South Africa, where a minority ruled the majority. Do nothing else than explain and justify the Sunni's power hold over a Shia majority.
Being all things equal, shouldn't we support the Shia, just as we have supportrd any other struggle of majority oppression?

NO, we can't do that here, because the mean and oppressive Americans are involved.
 
langeweile said:
It amazes me that the very same people that applauded the end of apartheid in South Africa, where a minority ruled the majority. Do nothing else than explain and justify the Sunni's power hold over a Shia majority.
Being all things equal, shouldn't we support the Shia, just as we have supportrd any other struggle of majority oppression?

NO, we can't do that here, because the mean and oppressive Americans are involved.


You said you lived in Africa???

The USA was in support of the apartheit regime in South Africa, allowing it to aquire nuclear weapons technology. That is one reason why Mandela and the current governmant of South Africa are very sceptical (to use a diplomatic term) of the intentions of the US in the Middle East
 
Mcluhan,

Take your time, after all it is easier to ask questions and critisize than it is to answer them and suggest a solution;-)

As for my "half baked" answer and your predictably spun response - I'll respond when I can use something other than my thumbs.

OTB
 
langeweile said:
Him and some others here,remind me of the two old guys from the Muppet Show, that always sat on the balcony and made fun and complained about everything.

Doesn't surprise me you watch the Muppets.

Actually, I was wondering to myself yesterday if I am indeed guilty of harboring unnaturally angry feelings toward dubbya. Then I took stock of my reactions to past Presidents of your Republic. Nixon generated a big negative response from me personally. I thought Clinton was a brilliant politician, Regan a great actor (after he became a politician). The rest fall somewhere in between. I can't count JFK because I was in Grade six when he was assassinated.

I have actually sat at the table with heads of state. So I am not completely without terms of reference, on a personal level.

Incidently, I never bothered to watch MM's 911 flick, because I am just not all that caught up in reveling in the egg throwing, however, there is something about watching the highjacking of your political process that I find threatening..especially when done by a moron. I thought your country was better than that. I am more concerned for future of the American people than you might care to think. Bush just brings out some kind of special disgust in me and, except for Nixon, I have never previously spoken out (in public or otherwise) against an American President.

As this is a 'Canadian forum' on Canadian Turf, I feel comfortable speaking my mind on this particular subject. I would not for example get on a US board and start bashing your President. Anyway, there are enough American's who do that better than I could ever attempt.

This is a global problem now. It affects all of us. Because I don't side with your particular view, doesn't mean that I don't listen to it. I am not close minded. Bush will eventually go. He will be remembered as the worst President the US ever had (hopefully there will be no others to compare).

And yes, there isn't much I can do about, except speak. If my thoughts offend you, I suggest don't listen. Just turn up the volume on the muppets, and have another beer.
 
onthebottom said:
Mcluhan,

Take your time, after all it is easier to ask questions and critisize than it is to answer them and suggest a solution;-)

As for my "half baked" answer and your predictably spun response - I'll respond when I can use something other than my thumbs.

OTB

I never said your response was 'half baked' ...I said it was 'wish-washy'.

So now I am 'predictable'...lol. Okay...if you say so.

Take a pill OTB..your neck is flushing.
 
As I said in another thread, the very last possible line of moral defense for the war was that Iraqis would be better off - ie not getting killed as much - without Sadaam. There is now ample and credible evidence that this is not the case, and some indication that it may never be the case.

As far as the idea being advanced that "we reasonbly thought he had WMD's therefore we were right to invade even if he didn't have them" - this is ludicrous. Those who were in the best position to know whether Sadaam had such weapons or not - Hans Blix and Scott Ritter, among many others - we screaming prior to the war that he did not. In any court in the world the case for "justifiable invasion" would be nullified by this level of willful ignorance.

As far as I'm concerned, 'nuff said.
 
bbking said:
OK you sold me DM. Sadaam is still alive - lets give him the keys to the country and say sorry it was big mistake.



bbk

The hilarity of this statement is, there are no doubt many Iraqis saying the same thing - and who in their right mind could blame them?
 
Drunken Master said:
The hilarity of this statement is, there are no doubt many Iraqis saying the same thing - and who in their right mind could blame them?

Yep, no doubt. What some people seem to miss, (not surprisingly) is that Saddam built the country's educational system, medical and trans infrastructure into a show case, as compared to the Arab states. They ignor this point, because saddam was a fascist.

BTW, where did he get all those WMD? Ask Rummy...he sold them.
 
bbking said:
Gee... I was so mistaken, I didn't understand that he was such a great guy - must be American propaganda that mislead me.

bbk

Yes, I think we can forgive the US for not publically extolling the virtues of Saddam's Iraq during his rise to power, and for that matter, how they assisted with it. The fact that he was a ruthless dictator is not the issue. The fact that the US precipitated an intellegence failure by twisting the CIA, lied to their public, then invaded Iraq in an illegal, unprovoked war, had 110,000 civilian morts, destroyed a few cities the size of Cleveland along with half the country's infrastructure supporting a population of 25 million, and 'by accident' caused an unprecidented, uncontrolled hot bed for the growth of international terrorism is probably more of an issue.

But then that's just how I see it. It's probably just spin.
 
Mcluhan said:
Yep, no doubt. What some people seem to miss, (not surprisingly) is that Saddam built the country's educational system, medical and trans infrastructure into a show case, as compared to the Arab states. They ignor this point, because saddam was a fascist.

BTW, where did he get all those WMD? Ask Rummy...he sold them.

Well not exactly....

Saddam's regime let much of Iraq's infrastructure fall apart during the last twenty years. Power plants, water purification plants, oil refineries, etc.... these industries have not had new equipment/parts since the seventies.
With the American invasion and the subsequent looting and insurgency; trying to fix what needed fixing a long long time ago has been quite the task.

Education and Health was mostly doled out to Iraqis who were loyal to Saddam. Shittes in the South and the Kurds in the North did not recieve any of benefits and were left to fend for themselves.

Saddam spent most his nation's money on himself, his family and cronies and on his military. Spending on the Iraqi people and on the nation's infrastructure (and other needs) was not at all an important priority to him.
 
Manji said:
Well not exactly....

Saddam's regime let much of Iraq's infrastructure fall apart during the last twenty years. Power plants, water purification plants, oil refineries, etc.... these industries have not had new equipment/parts since the seventies.
With the American invasion and the subsequent looting and insurgency; trying to fix what needed fixing a long long time ago has been quite the task.

Education and Health was mostly doled out to Iraqis who were loyal to Saddam. Shittes in the South and the Kurds in the North did not recieve any of benefits and were left to fend for themselves.

Saddam spent most his nation's money on himself, his family and cronies and on his military. Spending on the Iraqi people and on the nation's infrastructure (and other needs) was not at all an important priority to him.

Manji..there you go re-writing history *again*. Of course it fell apart in the last few years...they where under sanctions, since 1991 (dough-head lol)... 1,000,000 people, the greater percentage women and children starved or died through lack of medicine and they fought a seven years war with Iran before that. Do some research. By the way, have you actually ever *been* to the middle east? You sound like you grew up on the streets of Baghdad lol

<sigh> It's a pity youth is wasted on the young. - B.R.
 
Yes, born and raised in the West Side of Baghdad.

WEST SIDE!!!!


As for Re-writing history!?!?
You just confirmed what I just wrote....Iraq's infrastructure was in great disrepair before the invasion!!!
Nobody forced Saddam to pursue a war with Iran.... or to invade Kuwait for that matter.
And it was Saddam's refusal to accept UN demands that forced the sanctions on Iraq though Saddam still profited from his country's misery.

Mucluhan, I know you think Saddam was this great guy and all but I think you're on your own if you're trying to start a I-LOVE-SADDAM fan club on this board

<sigh> And I really liked you in the Muppet Show.....
Were you Statler or Waldorf!?!?!
 
Manji said:
Yes, born and raised in the West Side of Baghdad.

Mucluhan, I know you think Saddam was this great guy and all but I think you're on your own if you're trying to start a I-LOVE-SADDAM fan club on this board

<sigh> And I really liked you in the Muppet Show.....
Were you Statler or Waldorf!?!?!

No my son, I do not *love* Saddam. He was a ruthless dictator. But that's all he was. He was no threat to world peace, nor to the future of the world economy. He was just another stongman, illiterate until the age of 16, rose up from poverty with a gun in his hand, to run a country. BTW...how much more *noble* was the Vietnam War as compared to Iraq Verses Iran? Perhaps you can educate me on this, as well..

On the Muppets, you'll have to ask Lange, he's the Muppet expert! lol