The Truth On Iraq: It's Devastated

We are still in an arms race, IMHO.
While the opponent has changed the enemy is still out there. While there might not be the need for more ICM's anymore, there is a need to re-tool the military, and that costs money.

Do I believe we could spend the money somewhere else? Hell Yeah. Do i think that spending money on more arms is stupid? Hell yes.
The problem is, that while we undertsand the need for peace and cooperation, some others don't, and we better be ready to defend ourselves.
 
langeweile said:
We are still in an arms race, IMHO.
While the opponent has changed the enemy is still out there. While there might not be the need for more ICM's anymore, there is a need to re-tool the military, and that costs money.

Do I believe we could spend the money somewhere else? Hell Yeah. Do i think that spending money on more arms is stupid? Hell yes.
The problem is, that while we undertsand the need for peace and cooperation, some others don't, and we better be ready to defend ourselves.

I do not see the value of arming Canada. The only country that could possibly invade Canada is the US, and we would have as much of a chance against them as Denmark had against the germans in 1940.

Instead of a military, Canada should publish a phone number with an answering machine with the message: "we surrender".
 
danmand said:
I do not see the value of arming Canada. The only country that could possibly invade Canada is the US, and we would have as much of a chance against them as Denmark had against the germans in 1940.

Instead of a military, Canada should publish a phone number with an answering machine with the message: "we surrender".

LOL...comical...my first laugh of the day! Thanks!
 
Thanks for the points OTB it must be difficult to back three years and recall the state of mind. However it paints a picture of what rational the average taxpayer from the pro-war side was probably thinking in getting behind Bush and the invasion of Iraq. Here’s a few comments back.

thought Iraq had WMD and would use them again against their neighbours.

It was pretty clear to me, watching the run-up to war that Saddam had no WMD. I think this reason one bought into, because they wanted to go and whip some Arab ass. Emotions where running very high after 9/11 and it was apparent Bush was cashing in, and blatantly so. In defence of the average American person’s viewpoint, the media hyped the WMD story, and made it seem like Saddam was a monstrous demon capable of nuking USA. I found this a ridiculous idea at the time, blown way out of proportion. Almost cartoon-like on a level with Dr. No from the James Bond movies. The anthrax scare was probably a big contributor to the US population’s feeling of vulnerability. I personally am very suspicious of the Anthrax affair, and feel it was likely ‘someone manipulating someone’. There is seems a vacuum of interest in solving this case.

I viewed this as a threat to US interests, a threat to the global economy and eventually Israel and the US.

First, unless you are Jewish, and have an emotional connection, I can’t see fear for Israel as part of any legitimate equation. After all, they have those 200 nukes, and seem entirely capable of looking after themselves, this apart from the 2 billion you guys feed them every year from the war chest. Saddam as threat to the global economy? Go on OTB, you are more informed than that! Saddam was a wet noodle. How could a nation of 25 million, starved to death for 10 years by the coalition, who had not even control of their air space, possibly be a threat to the global economy? Iraq was a third world developing country BEFORE the US decimated its military in ’91.

I belived that after containment Iraq would accelerate it's WMD program (I was most worried about Nuke) and it's delivery options (missle - artillary, terror). In fact a ship going anywhere in the world would be a simple delivery mech for a nule. I'd read an article that one CIA estimate said Iraq was within 5 years of having a nuke - that kind of did it for me.

Some well placed smart bombs, would have eliminated that possibility, very efficiently. You cannot build nukes these days without the big eye in the sky knowing about it. Why were smart bombs invented, if not for this reason.

many would die because Saddam would go back to attacking the Shiits, Kurds and his neighbours.

If you studied the Iran Iraq war at all, you can easily see it was a war of futility, fought to a stalemate by two third rate powers mostly firing old-technology missiles at each other from WWI style trenches . The proxy war was useful to both the US and Soviets, because they dumped arms (note WMD armaments ) not to mention the French and Italians who also sold the two warring neighbours arms.

I don't think Iraq was involved in terrorism (beyond paying kids in Palistine to blow themselves up) it was too incompetant to work outsides it's borders.

This statement cuts the legs off your notion that Saddam was a threat to the global economy, US national interests, etc etc. However, I won’t labour the point.

Your list attempts to find lots of traction on the “ humanitarian concern for Iraqi population argument�. I find it very unlikely somehow (I will not say disingenuous because it’s your story and thanks for telling it.) especially in view of your apparent lack of interest (here) in what today’s war in Iraq is doing to the general population. It’s a nice story however, “America The Good�, implementing it’s war machine for the sake of others well being. Many probably did honestly buy into the idea.

So lets move on, and see how your rational plays out. (See my next post). If your arguments were honest then (true to heart), it follows that they should be honest now. Today we have a pretty clear picture of the situation...so lets see how your past intentions overlay in today's world... shall we?
 
Iraq New Terror Breeding Ground
War Created Haven, CIA Advisers Report

By Dana Priest
Washington Post Staff Writer
Friday, January 14, 2005;


Iraq has replaced Afghanistan as the training ground for the next generation of "professionalized" terrorists, according to a report released yesterday by the National Intelligence Council, the CIA director's think tank.

Iraq provides terrorists with "a training ground, a recruitment ground, the opportunity for enhancing technical skills," said David B. Low, the national intelligence officer for transnational threats. "There is even, under the best scenario, over time, the likelihood that some of the jihadists who are not killed there will, in a sense, go home, wherever home is, and will therefore disperse to various other countries."

Low's comments came during a rare briefing by the council on its new report on long-term global trends. It took a year to produce and includes the analysis of 1,000 U.S. and foreign experts. Within the 119-page report is an evaluation of Iraq's new role as a breeding ground for Islamic terrorists.

President Bush has frequently described the Iraq war as an integral part of U.S. efforts to combat terrorism. But the council's report suggests the conflict has also helped terrorists by creating a haven for them in the chaos of war.

"At the moment," NIC Chairman Robert L. Hutchings said, Iraq "is a magnet for international terrorist activity."

Before the U.S. invasion, the CIA said Saddam Hussein had only circumstantial ties with several al Qaeda members. Osama bin Laden rejected the idea of forming an alliance with Hussein and viewed him as an enemy of the jihadist movement because the Iraqi leader rejected radical Islamic ideals and ran a secular government.

Bush described the war in Iraq as a means to promote democracy in the Middle East. "A free Iraq can be a source of hope for all the Middle East," he said one month before the invasion. "Instead of threatening its neighbors and harboring terrorists, Iraq can be an example of progress and prosperity in a region that needs both."

But as instability in Iraq grew after the toppling of Hussein, and resentment toward the United States intensified in the Muslim world, hundreds of foreign terrorists flooded into Iraq across its unguarded borders. They found tons of unprotected weapons caches that, military officials say, they are now using against U.S. troops. Foreign terrorists are believed to make up a large portion of today's suicide bombers, and U.S. intelligence officials say these foreigners are forming tactical, ever-changing alliances with former Baathist fighters and other insurgents.

"The al-Qa'ida membership that was distinguished by having trained in Afghanistan will gradually dissipate, to be replaced in part by the dispersion of the experienced survivors of the conflict in Iraq," the report says.

According to the NIC report, Iraq has joined the list of conflicts -- including the Israeli-Palestinian stalemate, and independence movements in Chechnya, Kashmir, Mindanao in the Philippines, and southern Thailand -- that have deepened solidarity among Muslims and helped spread radical Islamic ideology.

At the same time, the report says that by 2020, al Qaeda "will be superseded" by other Islamic extremist groups that will merge with local separatist movements. Most terrorism experts say this is already well underway. The NIC says this kind of ever-morphing decentralized movement is much more difficult to uncover and defeat.

Terrorists are able to easily communicate, train and recruit through the Internet, and their threat will become "an eclectic array of groups, cells and individuals that do not need a stationary headquarters," the council's report says. "Training materials, targeting guidance, weapons know-how, and fund-raising will become virtual (i.e. online)."

The report, titled "Mapping the Global Future," highlights the effects of globalization and other economic and social trends. But NIC officials said their greatest concern remains the possibility that terrorists may acquire biological weapons and, although less likely, a nuclear device.

Among the report's major findings is that the likelihood of "great power conflict escalating into total war . . . is lower than at any time in the past century." However, "at no time since the formation of the Western alliance system in 1949 have the shape and nature of international alignments been in such a state of flux as they have in the past decade."

The report also says the emergence of China and India as new global economic powerhouses "will be the most challenging of all" Washington's regional relationships. It also says that in the competition with Asia over technological advances, the United States "may lose its edge" in some sectors.
 
This article is also interesting...particularly on the training of terrorists who are simply trained in iraq, then sent home..to cook up whatever destruction... posting a snip...

Iraq conflict fuels al Qaeda menace, experts say

By Jon Boyle

PARIS (Reuters) -
Iraq has become a recruiting ground for al Qaeda, which is training agents, including Western nationals, and sending them home to set up networks or form sleeper cells, according to two France-based experts.

The advent of "blue-eyed jihadists" is symptomatic of al Qaeda's response to the U.S.-led war on terror, including its mutation into a more decentralised organisation which has made it all the more potent, they said.

Roland Jacquard, a leading French analyst who has worked for a U.N. terrorism panel, and Paris-based Algerian journalist Atmane Tazaghart make their assessment in a new 500-page book: "Bin Laden -- the programmed destruction of the West".

The book argues that al Qaeda is now capable of striking the West and its allies with chemical, biological and radiological weapons -- so-called "dirty bombs" -- that could wreak havoc on humans and the global economy.

http://in.news.yahoo.com/050113/137/2izvj.html
 
Ranger68 said:
These people weren't being killed until the Americans invaded. So, yes - it's the Americans' fault. It is the Americans' fault that many insurgents feel the need to fight.


in your opinion. They don't need to fight- the americans are not going to stay. the ones fighting are a mixture of terrorists, gangsters and the naive being taken advantage by the others.
 
"They don't need to fight"? Well, you're right.
Any time a nation is invaded, they can always just roll over and surrender.
"the ones fighting are a mixture of terrorists, gangsters and the naive being taken advantage by the others"
in your opinion ........
 
langeweile said:
We are still in an arms race, IMHO.
While the opponent has changed the enemy is still out there. While there might not be the need for more ICM's anymore, there is a need to re-tool the military, and that costs money.

Do I believe we could spend the money somewhere else? Hell Yeah. Do i think that spending money on more arms is stupid? Hell yes.
The problem is, that while we undertsand the need for peace and cooperation, some others don't, and we better be ready to defend ourselves.

Who are you in an arms race with? What enemy? What would be the best weapons to deal with that enemy?
A "race" implies that there is a competition of research and expenditures. Towards what?
The US could spend half what it does, and STILL be able to defend themselves against any reasonable threat.
The missile shield is a great example of waste.
 
Ranger68 said:
Do you really think that a similar number of people was being killed on a daily basis in Iraq before the invasion? If you do, there's probably no hope for you.

Again, do you have anything to back up *your* opinion? ...... No? ...... Not surprising.


not sure why you are so defensive. but as i said- i don't know what the real story is, or how many people died of violence before the invasion versus after - and in reality, while you can provide links to studies done by well meaning people - you don't know either. who knows what the real situation in iraq was or how many were killed by the regime.

something to back up my opinion that I don't know? not sure how to answer that one
 
danmand said:
I think that the Iraqis working for the american occupation forces are trying to support their families in a desperate situation. I also think that they will be abandoned when the US leaves, and that they then will be considered collaborators and delt with rather harshly. Personally, I would not judge them.

PS: And I am sorry I misinterpreted your position on the war.

ok - then we agree on this
 
Okay, well I have *numbers* to back up "my opinion".
You just have your opinion.
And, as they say, opinions are like OT-- er, assholes.
;)
 
Ranger68 said:
Civilian populations have generally *not* been "put to the sword", except during "barbarian" invasion.

The Second World War reached new lows of genocide and *massive* civilian massacre. NEVER in warfare have such a high percentage of the casualties been civilian. Never.


yes WWII did reach new levels. but there have been many pogroms against civilian populations before- and not just by barbarians- they just were not as systematic or as horrific. the romans, the russians, etc
 
Cobra1 said:
and further to this point, the US rolled a secular state, which allowed women the right to education, right to careers and religous freedom probably into a Shiite controlled theocracy that will emerge after some brutal civil war in 6 years. Sometimes you have to be arbitrary in these high minded objectives, and keeping the Baath party in power, possibly without Saddam would have been the way to go. Women are increasingly being forced to accept Sharia law, wear hajib or chadour and are at person risk on the streets, which didnt exist before. So no, the quality of life in Iraq has not been enhanced by any measure.

The US had a perfect overthrow under Clinton, and failed the Iraqis division that would have taken out Saddam the opportunity - which is how it should have been done, - not at the cost to the world economy, or US lives.

you are comparing a year or so, with what- a year of relative peace under saddam- who knows how many were killed or tortured during his reign? I am sure the kurds think things are better
 
danmand said:
Because everybody on this planet should recognize that the US knowns (guided by the God of the white people) what is best for them, and has the moral obligation to invade and occupy any territory it sees fit.

The US military is incapable of violence?

OTB didn't say that. he said, correctly, that the violence continues because of the insurgents. why don't they wait until the americans fix what they broke and then leave
 
Ranger68 said:

"the ones fighting are a mixture of terrorists, gangsters and the naive being taken advantage by the others"
in your opinion ........

yep
 
Ranger68 said:
Okay, well I have *numbers* to back up "my opinion".
You just have your opinion.
And, as they say, opinions are like OT-- er, assholes.
;)

if you have so many facts and great arguments- why always try to make it personal?
 
red said:
OTB didn't say that. he said, correctly, that the violence continues because of the insurgents. why don't they wait until the americans fix what they broke and then leave

I can remember that the commander in chief of the american forces encouraged the fighters to "bring it on". But he is of course safe and well on a ranch in Texas.
 
Ranger68 said:
Okay, well I have *numbers* to back up "my opinion".
You just have your opinion.
And, as they say, opinions are like OT-- er, assholes.
;)

if you have so many facts and great arguments- why always try to make it personal? you have numbers- so did Nortel- doesn't make them right
 
danmand said:
I can remember that the commander in chief of the american forces encouraged the fighters to "bring it on".

i don't think OTB is the chief of the american forces

though I may be wrong