Manji said:
American military casaulties had reached a thousand before the US elections; and it was pretty much a non-issue. That demonstrates that the people of the United States will be able to stomach more casaulties. Now, if the number should drastically increase and the US casaulty rate reaches the ten-thousand mark (or even five thousand); the public would definitly be much more vocal in withdrawing the troops from Iraq. Right now strong support for Bush, strong American nationalism and a weak opposition (against the war and Bush) will mean that the United States willl be in Iraq for at least two more years if not until 2008.
Polls continue to show slipping support for the war in Iraq. Election-time is actually a BAD time to guage the public mood an any *one* particular issue. As time goes on and casualties mount, the public will tolerate them less - as has been shown in the polls I've seen.
My guess is that the US will be out, as a major player, within a year.
Manji said:
Also; both Bush supporters and haters know that if the US leaves Iraq prematurly; the Iraqi nation may become another Afghanistan. Another staging point for terrorist attacks to be lauched against America and the Western World.
This is actually contrary to the opinion of "Bush-haters" (which, I guess, is everyone who opposes the invasion). The LONGER the US stays, the worse the situation becomes - that is, the more terrorists will be created. Why do you think that if the US leaves now, Iraq will become another Afghanistan? What will change by the US staying? And, are you saying that it *wasn't* before?
Manji said:
Bush has even stated that he has been given political power and he will use that power to finish what he started in Iraq. Bush may be a fool; but even he realizes (or at least somebody told him...) that this war will define his legacy as President.
Bush has also stated that he has been given *divine* power - he says a lot of things. I agree that this war will define his legacy as President, and that it will almost certainly be a bad one.
Manji said:
The US pull out of Somalia cannot be compared to Iraq. The Clinton Presidency had just come into power and immediatly proved its international inexperience by demonstrating weakness in Somalia (before and after the "BlackHawk Down incident). The US did not invest time, money and lives into Somalia so it figured it was better to cut its losses and head home. It was also the previous Bush Sr. administration that sent the US military into Somalia; so it probably made it much easier for Clinton to cut and run.
Why can't they be compared? Because you don't want them to be? They illustrate that the American public doesn't suffer casualties well except where they've been sold on a mission extremely well. I grant that the Republicans did a great job lying about Iraq. However, that public support has slipped dramatically over the last 18 months. I don't think any President - Bush Sr. or Jr. included - would have seriously committed the troops in Somalia after it was demonstrated that there are people *gasp* who don't want them around in their countries, no matter what the reason. They weren't there to propagate any real American policy - just to help out. Once it became clear that, sometimes, helping out is dangerous - they were gone.
Manji said:
Its true that the Iraqis view the US as "invaders" and "occupiers" but most of those Iraqis believe that the Americans are not there to stay in Iraq or even possess the desire to stay in the Iraq. Most Iraqis realize that the Americans want to be out Iraq as much as the Iraqis want the Americans to be out of Iraq.
It is this belief that will convince most Iraqis that a "sit and wait" policy is much more beneifical than an "attack-the-Americans-now" policy. The Shites of Iraq such as the Supreme Council (the one that is influenced by Al-Sistani) are doing precisely that, sitting and waiting (at the same time consolidating their political power).
<snip>
Mcluhan has stated numbers of enemy insurgents at 40, 000; but really, what do those numbers mean (even if they are correct)?
I don't think you know what "most of the Iraqis" are thinking.
We'll see what happens to the violence, over time. If you are right, it will slacken off considerably.
The problem with all of these operations is that civilian casualties can't be avoided - this FOMENTS opposition to the US occupation, even among moderates. Over time, the only thing that is likely to happen is that the US creates more opposition to their stay, and to representation by entities who came to power while the US was there.
40000 is a large number.