The truth behind wine tasting

Ain't it the truth!!!!

As the Romans said, de gustibus et coloribus non est disputandum.

Perry
 
Ain't it the truth!!!!

As the Romans said, de gustibus et coloribus non est disputandum.

Perry

The Romans were wrong.

People argue ad nauseum about taste and color.
 
The Romans were wrong.

People argue ad nauseum about taste and color.
The Romans were just saying they shouldn't; not much new since. But our taste and colour senses are ever so much better than theirs aren't they?

Point is—as in politics—to discuss, which is fun, not dispute, which is deadly.
 
I think this article is very true within a range of scores for the same varietal. I'm also sure that, for whatever reason (be it aging or "nose" as the article mentions), most people can tell the difference between a red that comes in a 3 litre box with a spout and a 12 year old Barolo.

While I might not agree with wine experts in their scoring between two different wines due to my own "amateur" preferences I take some comfort that something rated a 90 is going to be "drinkable" unless it is corked. It is foolish that vineyards charge vastly different prices based on a few rating points difference. I know I have rarely been able to appreciate the difference between a good $25 wine at the LCBO and one at $75.
 
I've collected wine for about twenty years. Mostly inexpensive to moderate. I definitely like certain wines more than others, but with the exception of very cheap wine (cheaper wine is usually sweeter, and masks some of its flaws), I don't think price matters all that much.

To what degree wine tasters are intentionally dishonest or just get fooled like the rest of us, I don't know. Probably like any other thing involving money.

http://www.ted.com/talks/benjamin_wallace_on_the_price_of_happiness.html

above is a ted talk that has some slight relation to the OP.

Here's a talk about the science of happiness, which may also be similar to why we think we like certain wines over others.


http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_gilbert_asks_why_are_we_happy.html

Regardless, I am gonna get me some chardonnay out of my modest supply :)

Z
 
I am not an expert in Scotches, Cognacs, cigars and especially not wines. I am an expert at what I like, I know it when I taste it, smell it, see it hear it or feel it. I drink Chivas 12 usually and enjoy a Chivas 18 occasionally. These are blended scotch that many people can enjoy. There was a scotch tasting in San Francisco where Chivas 18 was rated 100/100 and Chivas 12 was 88/100. There were many expensive single malt scotches that were rated well below the Chivas 12, and one very inexpensive scotch that was 1/3 the price of Chivas 12 that rated 89/100. One point higher than the Chivas 12.

Tastings should be conducted blind.
 
Wine Tasting

Overall the above contributions were very good and appropriate.
I thought it would be interesting to relate to you that I attended a wine tasting seminar at a LCBO store for which you had to pay to participate. We were offered a selection of red wines made from two types of grapes but made in different countries. As I recall the price range was from about $15.00 to $ 45.00
Among the 25 or so partakers there was no overall preference or directional agreement for any particular wine and there was no correlation to the price.
 
Gaston De Legrange X.O. Cognac sells for $110 a bottle. It is a fine Cognac that compare very well with a $250 Remy Martin X.O. or Courvoisier X.O.
The extra cost is for brand snobbery.

2w3c3nb.jpg
 
Personally I can tell the difference between $7 plonk and $20 "excellent value". But it's a lot tougher to distinguish between $20 "excellent value" vs $50 "classic".
Agreed. I have a refined palate for wine and can tell the difference between cheap and decent very easily but have a harder time with high ends wines.
 
I love wine but when I hear the experts rambling on about flavour characteristics, my bullshit detector starts to tingle. It is an annoying blend of pretentious psycho babble and flagrant marketing hype.
 
Agreed. I have a refined palate for wine and can tell the difference between cheap and decent very easily but have a harder time with high ends wines.

Once you get past you $25 range in wines, the differences are small. People like what they know and what is familiar to them, constancy sells. That is why people like to smoke the same cigarette brands, drink the same beer. Some people like to claim they have a sophisticated nose for wine, therefore their noses makes the whole person sophisticated.


 
As a waiter for a number of tears I was always quite amused. By the antic of some people. I actually have a decent palette but anyone I see sniffing a cork or doing any of the other little rituals......well I just had to play along. And laugh in the back.
 
Personally I can tell the difference between $7 plonk and $20 "excellent value". But it's a lot tougher to distinguish between $20 "excellent value" vs $50 "classic".

Bingo
 
Personally I can tell the difference between $7 plonk and $20 "excellent value". But it's a lot tougher to distinguish between $20 "excellent value" vs $50 "classic".
This.

I remember poured a glass of wine, turned to the hostess and said "WOW. This is good." She turned to me and said "It should be, it cost $1,000 a bottle." That was the first time I ever drank a wine that expensive. What I noticed was that things in it were just a bit better than say a $50 bottle of wine, but I thought to myself "This is $1,000? It's not worth it."
 
As a waiter for a number of tears I was always quite amused. By the antic of some people. I actually have a decent palette but anyone I see sniffing a cork or doing any of the other little rituals......well I just had to play along. And laugh in the back.

So the sniffing of a cork is an antic, or just the way they go on about it?
 
This.

I remember poured a glass of wine, turned to the hostess and said "WOW. This is good." She turned to me and said "It should be, it cost $1,000 a bottle." That was the first time I ever drank a wine that expensive. What I noticed was that things in it were just a bit better than say a $50 bottle of wine, but I thought to myself "This is $1,000? It's not worth it."

Much of the cost is often the rarity factor and hasn't got that much to do with the quality. You're right, a $1000 bottle isn't 50x's better than a $20 bottle.
 
So the sniffing of a cork is an antic, or just the way they go on about it?

Sniffing a cork is mainly to check for mould. So on most commercial wines it is useless. On some old ones sure but you can usually see it anyway. If they wave it around....that's a haha.
If a wine has turned some people can smell ahead of time with a quick glass swirl and sniff. Personally when I test a wine its quick swirl, sniff, taste and yep that's fine. But I don't make a production out of it.
And yes I will spend money on a good wine, although as a rule if I'm out fine dining with my spouse I let the chef pairings usually be the choice with any meal. They already matched it nicely for me,and I don't have to buy a bottle then either.