The Nuremberg Raid

Your lack of historical knowledge is showing.

No, sir, it is your ideology that is screwing with your brain. I just returned from a tour though most of the Habsburg empire.
Correction:
Not bloody likely, unless you were Graf Aardvark von Oberschlesien during the habsburgs, or a jew or gypsy(word at the time) during the Nazis.

Notwithstanding their monumental atrocities, the "socialism" in "national socialism" was more than a catchword. The workers in the Third Reich were given many progressive advantages.
 
However, given the choice most people would likely have preferred those regimes to that of the Nazis.

There's no proof of that, Aardy. There was no political desire to bring back the Kaiser in either Germany or Austria.
 
I don't see any glorifying going on here. It's history, and you would have to be rather obtuse to not recognize the significance of the event. Those who fail to study history are doomed to repeat it.


"History afterall, is the memory of a nation" - JFK
 
Speaking of air wars, I watched the movie "Red Tails" on the History Channel last night. It is the true story of an all black American fighter group escorting heavy bombers deep into enemy territory. They even fought and downed the ME-262 jet fighters.

Was this a documentary because there was an HBO movie made which I PVR'd with a few American black actors including Cuba Gooding Jr. and Laurence Fishburne (no, not Samuel L. Jackson lol). I believe it was called The Tuskegee Airmen and was made in 1995.
 
Was this a documentary because there was an HBO movie made which I PVR'd with a few American black actors including Cuba Gooding Jr. and Laurence Fishburne (no, not Samuel L. Jackson lol). I believe it was called The Tuskegee Airmen and was made in 1995.

The movie was on TV a few days ago. I channel-surfed through it and caught a couple of bad, extended "You're gonna make it, buddy. Don't give up!" scenes which caused me about as much suffering as the wounded airmen in question.
 
I'm sure there were large parts of the German army in quiet sectors of the Western Front which were still "intact" - however you define that after 4 years of soul-sapping, attritive trench warfare and a British blockade which had put Germany (including the army) on a starvation diet. But I think it was a matter of time before those units too would have crumbled.
If I remember my history correctly, the Germans pressed 14 year old boys and 60 year old men into service in the Battle of Berlin. BTW: The Americans stood down and allowed the Russians to take Berlin because they estimated it would cost 80,000 American lives to take the city, thus proving once again that Americans value American lives more than Russian lives.
 
There's no proof of that, Aardy. There was no political desire to bring back the Kaiser in either Germany or Austria.
I'd disagree in that there were significant portions of the populations in Germany as well as within the former Austro-Hungarian Empire who wanted a restoration.

However, needless to say I entirely agree that it did not manage to approach the threshold necessary for success, at least in the case of Germany and Austria because Hitler made damn sure it didn't to the extent of having a number of people including the Imperial German and Prussian Crown Prince (Louis Ferdinand) thrown into Dachau.
 
I just returned from a tour though most of the Habsburg empire.
If you were where I believe you were, it was through a small portion of the Habsburg Empire.


Notwithstanding their monumental atrocities, the "socialism" in "national socialism" was more than a catchword. The workers in the Third Reich were given many progressive advantages.
Industrial and skilled workers in early twentieth century Germany were far from being confined in some work of vast work camp with caricature capitalists from Soviet propaganda posters in charge. Of course if you were a German Socialist or Jew life in the last two decades of the German Empire was a paradise compared with life in Germany 1933 - 1945.
 
If you were where I believe you were, it was through a small portion of the Habsburg Empire.
The central parts.
Industrial and skilled workers in early twentieth century Germany were far from being confined in some work of vast work camp with caricature capitalists from Soviet propaganda posters in charge. Of course if you were a German Socialist or Jew life in the last two decades of the German Empire was a paradise compared with life in Germany 1933 - 1945.

The facts are, that Hitler introduced many benefits for the working people of Germany, which they did not have before.
 
If I remember my history correctly, the Germans pressed 14 year old boys and 60 year old men into service in the Battle of Berlin. BTW: The Americans stood down and allowed the Russians to take Berlin because they estimated it would cost 80,000 American lives to take the city, thus proving once again that Americans value American lives more than Russian lives.

Which any competent government should and would do. I believe that taking Berlin cost the Russians 250,000 lives.

In addition, Washington expected to lose 1,000,000 American lives invading Japan. It wasn't until August that they knew Japan would surrender. They couldn't use up American lives in Europe when there was another war to win in the Pacific.
 
Was this a documentary because there was an HBO movie made which I PVR'd with a few American black actors including Cuba Gooding Jr. and Laurence Fishburne (no, not Samuel L. Jackson lol). I believe it was called The Tuskegee Airmen and was made in 1995.

The movie was on TV a few days ago. I channel-surfed through it and caught a couple of bad, extended "You're gonna make it, buddy. Don't give up!" scenes which caused me about as much suffering as the wounded airmen in question.
The 2012 Lucasfilms movie. Cuba Gooding, Jr., Terrence Howard and Andre Royo have major roles but Laurence FIshburne isn't in it.
 
If I remember my history correctly, the Germans pressed 14 year old boys and 60 year old men into service in the Battle of Berlin. BTW: The Americans stood down and allowed the Russians to take Berlin because they estimated it would cost 80,000 American lives to take the city, thus proving once again that Americans value American lives more than Russian lives.

Yes, the German Volkssturm's ranks were filled out with the many of those that fell into the too old or too young category. There were already many young soldiers fighting in the war. In Normandy, the Hitlerjugend or 12th SS Panzer division fought Canadian troops around Caen. This division went on to fight against American's in the Battle of the Bulge as well.

To think that the American's stood down is erroneous on your part. At a previous conference, between the Allied powers, the Elbe River was the agreed upon stopping point for the invading armies to meet at. This would effectively cut Germany in half and seeing that Berlin was east of the Elbe, it was effectively in the Soviet zone and theirs for the taking.

Many American generals did not want to stop and they wanted Berlin for themselves, knowing that this would be an historical event.

Which any competent government should and would do. I believe that taking Berlin cost the Russians 250,000 lives.

In addition, Washington expected to lose 1,000,000 American lives invading Japan. It wasn't until August that they knew Japan would surrender. They couldn't use up American lives in Europe when there was another war to win in the Pacific.


I remember that discussion on Japan and the American planners no doubt took the invasion of Berlin into account as well, knowing that it would cost them far too much this late in the war. With the war on Japan still in doubt they had to let the Soviets take the prize that was agreed upon and stop at the River Elbe.
 
Yes, the German Volkssturm's ranks were filled out with the many of those that fell into the too old or too young category. There were already many young soldiers fighting in the war. In Normandy, the Hitlerjugend or 12th SS Panzer division fought Canadian troops around Caen. This division went on to fight against American's in the Battle of the Bulge as well.

To think that the American's stood down is erroneous on your part. At a previous conference, between the Allied powers, the Elbe River was the agreed upon stopping point for the invading armies to meet at. This would effectively cut Germany in half and seeing that Berlin was east of the Elbe, it was effectively in the Soviet zone and theirs for the taking.

Many American generals did not want to stop and they wanted Berlin for themselves, knowing that this would be an historical event.




I remember that discussion on Japan and the American planners no doubt took the invasion of Berlin into account as well, knowing that it would cost them far too much this late in the war. With the war on Japan still in doubt they had to let the Soviets take the prize that was agreed upon and stop at the River Elbe.

General George Patton might have gone to Moscow if they gave him enough munitions and supplies.
 
General George Patton might have gone to Moscow if they gave him enough munitions and supplies.

I find it hard to believe that the soviets would have capitulated to Patton, after having defeated most of the german panzer divisions.
 
I find it hard to believe that the soviets would have capitulated to Patton, after having defeated most of the german panzer divisions.

Probably not but he was on a roll (and he also shot his mouth off more than he should've).
 
Probably not but he was on a roll (and he also shot his mouth off more than he should've).

If he was half as good as George. C Scott...