The Nuremberg Raid

Do you guys never get tired of glorifying WWII? It is a bit pathetic.

WW2 has been described as "The worst thing that ever happened."

How could that possibly be worth studying?


This was a bad night for Bomber Command...but a good night for thousands of children, women and other civilians...Bomber Command killed more civilians than enemy combatants than all the other British commands combined. I am not saying that the Germans were more humane or something but the Bomber Command was the stain on the British WW2 achievements. I am sorry for the boys sent to die night after night and for their courage they are heros in my books. But the generals and politicians that came with this strategy should have been shot for genocide.

Right, it was anger more than anything, blinding any trace of rationality... That's why the bombing continued when it was obvious that Germany is on their knees and surrendering by tens of thousands in the ladt couple of months of the war. There is no revisionism in my argument, that would be stupid...Britain was not fighting for survival at the end of the war...it was just angry that the Empire was in ashes...what's one more cowardly kick to the fallen enemy

The main reason Britain and US put so much effort into bombing Germany wasn't revenge or anger or wanton genocide, and certainly not cowardice. In 1942, 43, and going on 44, there was nothing else they could do. Stalin was fighting battle after battle, tank div v tank div and army v army, and losing population at the rate of 25,000 per day. S demanded a second front, with taunts of "Why are you so afraid of Germans?" "Sorry Joe, hang on there for a couple of years, till we're ready to invade. We're rooting for ya."

The alliance with Stalin was anything but stable and cooperative and friendly, and most unlikely to survive Britain and US doing nothing in Stalin's eyes. The bombing capaign was more or less the only thing the western allies could do to damage Germany, until D-day.
 
from war criminal butcher Harris himself:

the aim of the Combined Bomber Offensive...should be unambiguously stated [as] the destruction of German cities, the killing of German workers, and the disruption of civilised life throughout Germany.

... the destruction of houses, public utilities, transport and lives, the creation of a refugee problem on an unprecedented scale, and the breakdown of morale both at home and at the battle fronts by fear of extended and intensified bombing, are accepted and intended aims of our bombing policy. They are not by-products of attempts to hit factories...
 
Speaking of air wars, I watched the movie "Red Tails" on the History Channel last night. It is the true story of an all black American fighter group escorting heavy bombers deep into enemy territory. They even fought and downed the ME-262 jet fighters.
 
from war criminal butcher Harris himself:
Isn't it interesting that one never hears of Schlächter Göring or Schlächter Sperrle or Butcher Kesselring or Butcher Jeschonnek.
Although both Göring and Kesselring were both convicted of war crimes. Perhaps this is a form of survivors guilt?
 
Speaking of air wars, I watched the movie "Red Tails" on the History Channel last night. It is the true story of an all black American fighter group escorting heavy bombers deep into enemy territory. They even fought and downed the ME-262 jet fighters.
Unfortunately, like all such movies it takes certain liberties with the truth, because the truth is both complex and seldom "photogenic."

http://www.tuskegee.edu/sites/www/U...rmen/Nine_Myths_About_the_Tuskegee_Airmen.pdf


http://cafredtailsquadron.blogspot.com/2012_01_01_archive.html
 
Yeah, the Brits were horrible people in WW II. Not only did they bomb German cities but they also imposed a naval blockade http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blockade_of_Germany_(1939–45) on the nice Germans, thus depriving Germany of much needed material and foodstuff. Not nice of the Brits.

not only in WWII but after WWI imposed a peace treaty that would break Germany forever -- the result of that was Hitler coming to power by promising to end the payment of war reparations. Without that treaty most likely no NAZIs in power.

I don't know if it is true but I heard from a Brit that England was the first to deliberately target civilians
 
not only in WWII but after WWI imposed a peace treaty that would break Germany forever -- the result of that was Hitler coming to power by promising to end the payment of war reparations. Without that treaty most likely no NAZIs in power.
However, the truly vindictive force behind the Treaty of Versailles was Georges Clemenceau even so France felt that the treaty was not nearly harsh enough.

As Winston Spencer-Churchill rightly stated at the end of World War II:

"This war (World War II) would never have come unless, under American and modernising pressure, we had driven the Habsburgs out of Austria and the Hohenzollerns out of Germany. By making these vacuums we gave the opening for the Hitlerite monster to crawl out of its sewer on to the vacant thrones. No doubt these views are very unfashionable...."
 
However, the truly vindictive force behind the Treaty of Versailles was Georges Clemenceau even so France felt that the treaty was not nearly harsh enough.

100% correct. The Brits (Lloyd George) were against the treaty but Clemenceau managed to cajole President Wilson into supporting him. This is why Hitler made the French sign the act of surrender in the same railway carriage that Clemenceau used after WW1 to have the Germans sign the terms of surrender. It was a humiliating time for Germany as they has not actually been defeated on the battlefield. The winds of discontent and retribution were sown by the French not the Brits.
 
100% correct. The Brits (Lloyd George) were against the treaty but Clemenceau managed to cajole President Wilson into supporting him. This is why Hitler made the French sign the act of surrender in the same railway carriage that Clemenceau used after WW1 to have the Germans sign the terms of surrender. It was a humiliating time for Germany as they has not actually been defeated on the battlefield. The winds of discontent and retribution were sown by the French not the Brits.

Err, they had. The British, Canadians and Aussies had thrashed the shit out of them at the Battle of Amiens and the German army just wasn't fighting anymore. They were hungry, demoralized, beaten up and absolutely exhausted and were rushing to surrender. Ludendorff called it "The Black Day of the German Army". They were done. We could have strolled to Berlin after that. And the US had barely started fighting and had a 1,000,000 guys who had just arrived in Europe 3 months before and were looking for some action.

If the Germans hadn't caved, it would have been a walkover. There just wasn't any point.
 
However, the truly vindictive force behind the Treaty of Versailles was Georges Clemenceau even so France felt that the treaty was not nearly harsh enough.

As Winston Spencer-Churchill rightly stated at the end of World War II:

"This war (World War II) would never have come unless, under American and modernising pressure, we had driven the Habsburgs out of Austria and the Hohenzollerns out of Germany. By making these vacuums we gave the opening for the Hitlerite monster to crawl out of its sewer on to the vacant thrones. No doubt these views are very unfashionable...."

Of course, the Hohenzollerns and the Habsburgs would never start a world war, would they?
 
not only in WWII but after WWI imposed a peace treaty that would break Germany forever -- the result of that was Hitler coming to power by promising to end the payment of war reparations. Without that treaty most likely no NAZIs in power.

I don't know if it is true but I heard from a Brit that England was the first to deliberately target civilians

The Germans started doing it in World War 1 with the zeppelin raids. And then the Luftwaffe deliberately bombed civilians in 1940 in Amsterdam and then in London. The British did it later and a lot more efficiently with a lot more aircraft.
 

If the Germans hadn't caved, it would have been a walkover. There just wasn't any point.

I agree, but they had a standing army that was not yet defeated and the allies had not set foot in Germany. I agree about the inevitable outcome if the war had continued.
 
I agree, but they had a standing army that was not yet defeated and the allies had not set foot in Germany. I agree about the inevitable outcome if the war had continued.

I think we are used to a pattern in 20th Century warfare wherein the winner defeats the loser by over-running his country and seizing it. But this is not the only way of winning. For instance, the USA defeated Japan without having to physically invade and seize it.

I'm sure there were large parts of the German army in quiet sectors of the Western Front which were still "intact" - however you define that after 4 years of soul-sapping, attritive trench warfare and a British blockade which had put Germany (including the army) on a starvation diet. But I think it was a matter of time before those units too would have crumbled.
 
However, given the choice most people would likely have preferred those regimes to that of the Nazis.

Huh? From the mid-1930s until D-Day, to the people living under a regime, Hitler and the nazis were the most popular regime the world has ever known.
 
However, given the choice most people would likely have preferred those regimes to that of the Nazis.

Not bloody likely, unless you were Graf Aardvark von Ober Schlesien.
 
Not bloody likely, unless you were Graf Aardvark von Ober Schlesien.
Your lack of historical knowledge is showing.

Both Germany and Austria-Hungary were rapidly changing places in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Was there lots of tension between liberalizing and conservative elements in society - indeed there was, but the tide although it ebbed and flowed - was running against the reactionary elements.




p.s. Oberschlesien is one word in German
 
Huh? From the mid-1930s until D-Day, to the people living under a regime, Hitler and the nazis were the most popular regime the world has ever known.
Which I suppose is why Hitler spent as much time as he did worrying about restoration?* What most people liked about the Third Reich was normality, particularly economic normality, not some great love of National Socialism.

* For instance his reaction to the funeral of Prince Wilhelm of Prussia (eldest son of then Crown Prince Wilhelm).