The Nuremberg Raid

Aardvark154

New member
Jan 19, 2006
53,709
3
0
This the deadliest Bomber Command night of the war, was I'm ashamed to say utterly unknown to me before reading this article. The conflicting pressures of shortening nights, the need to shortly begin to shift to targets supporting the Invasions of France and a clear cloudless night with a full moon lead to the bloodiest day in the history of the RAF.


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...545-men-raid-Nuremberg-So-going-unmarked.html
 
Last edited:
http://www.amazon.com/Other-Battle-...d=1396103770&sr=1-1&keywords=the+other+battle

1 of the best analytical war histories I have ever read. It puts it all in context.

IIRC, the issue w the Nurenburg Raid was the full moon, plus the long distance over the European land mass that flying to and from N'burg entails. The further you fly, the more opportunity for the Nachtjagd to kill you. At the opposite end of the spectrum was Hamburg which could be approached entirely over the undefended North Sea and which the RAF absolutely obliterated in late '43. The 8th USAAF had its own catastrophic experiences hitting targets in Southern Germany with the Schweinfurt and Regensburg raids.
 
Do you guys never get tired of glorifying WWII? It is a bit pathetic.
 
Do you guys never get tired of glorifying WWII? It is a bit pathetic.

Lighten up Francis. Use the block/ignore function if you don't want to read about it.
 
Do you guys never get tired of glorifying WWII? It is a bit pathetic.

I don't see any glorifying going on here. It's history, and you would have to be rather obtuse to not recognize the significance of the event. Those who fail to study history are doomed to repeat it.
 
Maybe we need a Hitler section on terb.
Perhaps, but having started this thread what was on my mind was a) the brave aircrew of Bomber Command, b) surprise that I'd never before heard of this "black day" the largest single loss of aircraft and aircrew in Commonwealth history c) interest as to why it was scheduled when it was, and wasn't cancelled.

None of those things have any but the most remote connection with Hitler.
 
Do you guys never get tired of glorifying WWII? It is a bit pathetic.

As opposed to the endless pathetic threads that you start? Get over yourself. Better still, go get laid and post a review.
 
Denmark and Norway bent over and let the Germans do what they wanted to do. Probably two of the safest places for German troops were in these two countries during WWII. The governments of these two countries were pretty much puppet regimes run by Hitler.

Do you guys never get tired of glorifying WWII? It is a bit pathetic.

danmand,

Vidkun Quisling of Norway during WWII had the same bend over and spread your cheeks for the Germans ideas as you do.
 
The answer is in, a loud and clear "NO".
So you DO want to compare the Netherlands and Denmark during World War II.

I hate to say that I'm not surprised, given that your entire thrust in past discussions of Operation Carthage (the Shellhus raid) has been not how the Danish Resistance repeatedly pleaded for the raid which the RAF had said would pose entirely too great a risk to civilians; nor the b r a v e r y of the aircrews (four Mosquitoes and two escorting Mustangs with nine aircrew were lost); nor that the raid destroyed Gestapo headquarters, severely interrupting their operations throughout Denmark and enabling the escape of 18 members of the resistance held prisoner; but rather entirely on the Mosquito which crashed into the French School and follow on aircraft mistakenly bombing the burning school.
 
So you DO want to compare the Netherlands and Denmark during World War II.

I hate to say that I'm not surprised, given that your entire thrust in past discussions of Operation Carthage (the Shellhus raid) has been not how the Danish Resistance repeatedly pleaded for the raid which the RAF had said would pose entirely too great a risk to civilians; nor the b r a v e r y of the aircrews (four Mosquitoes and two escorting Mustangs with nine aircrew were lost); nor that the raid destroyed Gestapo headquarters, severely interrupting their operations throughout Denmark and enabling the escape of 18 members of the resistance held prisoner; but rather entirely on the Mosquito which crashed into the French School and follow on aircraft mistakenly bombing the burning school.

I honestly think you people should find another hobby than the glorification of WWII. But it is of course your choice, if you want to continue.

As far as the Shell House raid, your attempt at misrepresenting our previous discussion is less than honourable. The ONLY point I made in the previous discussion was, that the raid did not represent the finest hour of the RAF, as they clearly screwed up and killed a group of school children by mistake. I never argued, that the resistance did not ask for the raid, or that many Resistance members did not escape, or that the bombers were cowards; I simply stated the fact that it was not the RAF's finest hour. Misrepresenting someones posts is dishonorable, even if you disagree with the posts..
 
This was a bad night for Bomber Command...but a good night for thousands of children, women and other civilians...Bomber Command killed more civilians than enemy combatants than all the other British commands combined. I am not saying that the Germans were more humane or something but the Bomber Command was the stain on the British WW2 achievements. I am sorry for the boys sent to die night after night and for their courage they are heros in my books. But the generals and politicians that came with this strategy should have been shot for genocide.
 
I have no interest in discussing how Denmark did compared to the UK or the Netherlands during WWII. None of us here were alive at the time.

But maybe it is worth mentioning that 100,000 dutch jews (plus a large number of german jewish refugees living in the Netherlands) were murdered during WWII , while only 60 danish jews were murdered during WWII.
 
This was a bad night for Bomber Command...but a good night for thousands of children, women and other civilians...Bomber Command killed more civilians than enemy combatants than all the other British commands combined. I am not saying that the Germans were more humane or something but the Bomber Command was the stain on the British WW2 achievements. I am sorry for the boys sent to die night after night and for their courage they are heros in my books. But the generals and politicians that came with this strategy should have been shot for genocide.

What a lovely revisionist perspective from the detached safety and comfort of the 21st century. Your glossover philosophy really shows when you use the word humane in any context with the Germans of that era.

Allied bombing of German cities was a direct reaction (and anger) over the blitz of major British cities, particularly London and Coventry. After the blitz the Germans resorted to more humane methods like the V1 and V2 missiles. WW2 was a fight to the death for survival and victory, not some namby pamby piece of UN style sophistry or the postulations of those that Stalin referred to as "useful idiots".
 
Right, it was anger more than anything, blinding any trace of rationality... That's why the bombing continued when it was obvious that Germany is on their knees and surrendering by tens of thousands in the ladt couple of months of the war. There is no revisionism in my argument, that would be stupid...Britain was not fighting for survival at the end of the war...it was just angry that the Empire was in ashes...what's one more cowardly kick to the fallen enemy
 
I simply stated the fact that it was not the RAF's finest hour. Misrepresenting someones posts is dishonorable, even if you disagree with the posts..
If all you had done was say that it was tragic that the one Mosquito hit a factory chimney lost a wing and cartwheeled into the school and that it was a continuing tragedy that some of the follow on aircraft bombed the larger fire - the school, I wouldn't be nearly so fired up. Perhaps you didn't mean to sound the way you did, however, you certainly did give every impression that you thought that it was a monumental screw-up and that it was entirely the fault of some bunch of British Empire butchers at Bomber Command.
 
I have no interest in discussing how Denmark did compared to the UK or the Netherlands during WWII. None of us here were alive at the time.

But maybe it is worth mentioning that 100,000 dutch jews (plus a large number of german jewish refugees living in the Netherlands) were murdered during WWII , while only 60 danish jews were murdered during WWII.
The Danish evacuation of its Jews to Sweden in early October 1943 should indeed be honoured. Then again the Dutch did not have a neutral country but a couple, in some cases less than a hour's sail away.

On the other side of the coin, I doubt in the extreme that there will ever be a Danish version of the Dutch Soldaat van Oranje.
 
Right, it was anger more than anything, blinding any trace of rationality... That's why the bombing continued when it was obvious that Germany is on their knees and surrendering by tens of thousands in the ladt couple of months of the war. There is no revisionism in my argument, that would be stupid...Britain was not fighting for survival at the end of the war...it was just angry that the Empire was in ashes...what's one more cowardly kick to the fallen enemy

You should have been born in another age. Stalin would be proud of you.