It doesn't measure up at all. The Ginger Whinger (Chris Evans) has already jumped ship. I think it was trying too hard to be like Top Gear was under Clarkson.
The original Top Gear didn't fail, it ran from 1977 to 2001, in TV terms that is far from failure. Top Gear in the format from 2002 to 2015 was a concept pitched to the BBC by Clarkson and his old school friend Executive Producer Andy Wilman. the camaraderie of the whole crew really showed as to how many quit after Clarkson's contract was not renewed (Let's be clear here, he wasn't sacked, they just didn't renew his contract). Where are they all now? At Amazon Prime with Clarkson, Hammond and May.
Hammond and May sticking around to present with LeBlanc would have been even worse than with Evans. I don't think the BBC really understood what they had with Top Gear and that it needs its independence to work. They thought that retaining the brand whilst loosing the creative driving force along with taking executive control they could curb the naughty schoolboy nature and controversy whilst keeping the branding and overseas rights $$$ flowing in.
In reality, they created more controversy (Donuts round the Cenotaph for example), made a show that felt strained, rushed and desperate to get broadcast before the competition. Lost a huge number of viewing figures and really was a less than half baked version of its former self.