The new Top Gear - does it measure up?

Ceiling Cat

Well-known member
Feb 25, 2009
30,295
2,700
113
I just watched the new version of Top Gear, the flavor of the old Top Gear is not there. Richard Hammond and James May should have stayed and continued on. If they parachuted in Matt Leblanc, Jeremy Clarkson would soon be a dot in the rear view mirror.

The program may still work out and become a success, but it will take time for the audience to acclimatize themselves to the new format. As it is, any competing TV network can put out a similar product.
 
Watched a few eps and I just don't like it. Leblanc is terrible.... He's like a robot.
 
The original TG failed, Clarkson, et al, took it over and completely changed the format. It became VERY successful.
This TG is trying to be that TG with different hosts. No one is interested.
In order to be successful, they will have to come up with something completely different.
 
It doesn't measure up at all. The Ginger Whinger (Chris Evans) has already jumped ship. I think it was trying too hard to be like Top Gear was under Clarkson.

The original Top Gear didn't fail, it ran from 1977 to 2001, in TV terms that is far from failure. Top Gear in the format from 2002 to 2015 was a concept pitched to the BBC by Clarkson and his old school friend Executive Producer Andy Wilman. the camaraderie of the whole crew really showed as to how many quit after Clarkson's contract was not renewed (Let's be clear here, he wasn't sacked, they just didn't renew his contract). Where are they all now? At Amazon Prime with Clarkson, Hammond and May.

Hammond and May sticking around to present with LeBlanc would have been even worse than with Evans. I don't think the BBC really understood what they had with Top Gear and that it needs its independence to work. They thought that retaining the brand whilst loosing the creative driving force along with taking executive control they could curb the naughty schoolboy nature and controversy whilst keeping the branding and overseas rights $$$ flowing in.

In reality, they created more controversy (Donuts round the Cenotaph for example), made a show that felt strained, rushed and desperate to get broadcast before the competition. Lost a huge number of viewing figures and really was a less than half baked version of its former self.
 
It doesn't measure up at all. The Ginger Whinger (Chris Evans) has already jumped ship. Or maybe he was pushed off the ship.

Where are they all now? At Amazon Prime with Clarkson, Hammond and May. The question is, will they attain critical mass in viewers being that they are in a pay TV stream. They must also re-invent the the TV series as they can not use the previous format that is proprietary to the BBC

Hammond and May sticking around to present with LeBlanc would have been even worse than with Evans. Worse than it us now?

A re-invented Top Gear with Hammond ,May and LeBlanc using the old format and getting back to basics like testing real life cars with the added ingredient of interesting real life people in the show. A test of the Audi A5 or Jaguar XE with a MILF exec living with the car for a month and giving impressions at the start and end of the segment would be interesting to many. People do aspire to own cars like the Bugatti Veyron and the McLaren P1 but putting a mix of sky high priced cars and every day luxury cars that you may see in the street that are more attainable would be a plus to Top Gear.
 
IMHO - no.

As principal host I don't find Ginger Whinger charismatic or interesting enough and as someone above mentioned, he's already left the show. Matt LeBlanc is woodin and the two hosts don't seem to share an "energy" like the original cast did. Sabine Schmitz has potential to be a good host when she learns the trade a bit better although her accent can be a bit tough to understand sometimes.

I liked the episode where the Viper was playing top gun with the Vette. I didn't expect that the viper would so easily outperform the vette, especially in the turns.


A re-invented Top Gear with Hammond ,May and LeBlanc using the old format and getting back to basics like testing real life cars with the added ingredient of interesting real life people in the show. A test of the Audi A5 or Jaguar XE with a MILF exec living with the car for a month and giving impressions at the start and end of the segment would be interesting to many. People do aspire to own cars like the Bugatti Veyron and the McLaren P1 but putting a mix of sky high priced cars and every day luxury cars that you may see in the street that are more attainable would be a plus to Top Gear.

Forget LeBlanc, he can only be a second fiddle character. Clarkson is certainly the better principle character that Hammond and May played off well against (like Seinfeld with George and Kramer). They shared a synergy that showed well on TV.

You would think reviewing "everyday" cars would indeed be a good idea. In reality, it doesn't seem to work at almost all major magazines and TV shows tend to focus 90% of their time of expensive cars - boring cars don't get ratings I guess. That said Driving Televsion (Saturday morning, 11:30, Global) is a pretty decent show and focuses on normal priced cars. http://www.drivingtelevision.com/

The host, Lacey Elliott is pretty easy on the eyes: