I’m talking just the tune itself, irrespective of which version.
Of course, this is purely subjective, but I wonder if there is any consensus among terb scholars?
My top two would be Danny Boy, and Morning Has Broken. The tune of M.H.B is a Scottish folk-song -- D.B is an Irish folk-song.
My actual #1 most beautiful melody is Morning Has Broken. The Cat Stevens version is the most well-known, but C.S. simply can’t sing. Whatever made him contemplate a career in show business? He certainly does not do Morning any favours. If anything, I favour the Rick Wakeman piano version, in which the words are printed as subtitles! Anybody singing it seemingly cannot bear not to imprint it with their own personality -- which is never an improvement.
In arriving at my number one, I also considered the poetry of the words:
Sweet the rain’s new fall, sunlit from heaven.
Like the first dew fall on the first grass.
Praise for the sweetness of the wet garden,
Sprung in completeness where His feet pass.
Mine is the sunlight, mine is the morning;
Born of the one light Eden saw play.
Praise with elation, praise every morning,
God’s re-creation of the new day.
You don’t have to be religious to understand that, throughout history, the beauty of natural things has overwhelmed humans, and led them to personify Nature, and to worship him (her?) as a god. Any atheist can recognize that.
On the other hand, D.B. has:
But come ye back, when summer’s in the meadow,
Or when the valley’s hushed and white with snow.
’Tis here I’ll be, in sunshine or in shadow.
O Danny boy, O Danny boy, I love you so.
Share my choice? Or what tune (+words) would you choose?
Of course, this is purely subjective, but I wonder if there is any consensus among terb scholars?
My top two would be Danny Boy, and Morning Has Broken. The tune of M.H.B is a Scottish folk-song -- D.B is an Irish folk-song.
My actual #1 most beautiful melody is Morning Has Broken. The Cat Stevens version is the most well-known, but C.S. simply can’t sing. Whatever made him contemplate a career in show business? He certainly does not do Morning any favours. If anything, I favour the Rick Wakeman piano version, in which the words are printed as subtitles! Anybody singing it seemingly cannot bear not to imprint it with their own personality -- which is never an improvement.
In arriving at my number one, I also considered the poetry of the words:
Sweet the rain’s new fall, sunlit from heaven.
Like the first dew fall on the first grass.
Praise for the sweetness of the wet garden,
Sprung in completeness where His feet pass.
Mine is the sunlight, mine is the morning;
Born of the one light Eden saw play.
Praise with elation, praise every morning,
God’s re-creation of the new day.
You don’t have to be religious to understand that, throughout history, the beauty of natural things has overwhelmed humans, and led them to personify Nature, and to worship him (her?) as a god. Any atheist can recognize that.
On the other hand, D.B. has:
But come ye back, when summer’s in the meadow,
Or when the valley’s hushed and white with snow.
’Tis here I’ll be, in sunshine or in shadow.
O Danny boy, O Danny boy, I love you so.
Share my choice? Or what tune (+words) would you choose?

