An excellent example. Earlier this month, a group of 21 eminent clinicians working across nine countries in the field of gender distress wrote
an excoriating open letter in response to a bold claim from Stephen Hammes, president of the Endocrine Society. In a letter to the
Wall Street Journal, Hammes had stated that more than 2,000 studies had provided a clear picture that gender-affirming care improved the well-being of gender diverse people and reduced the risk of suicide;
if that were true, it would be very reassuring and closer to certainty than we often get in many medical specialities. The authors of the response, who included Dr Anna Hutchinson and Dr Anastassis Spiliadis, two of the original
whistleblowers at Tavistock in the UK, noted that this claim had been contradicted
by every single systematic review of the evidence, not least one published by the Endocrine Society itself. They noted that recommendations for clinical practice should be aligned with the best available evidence, rather than a position that exaggerated the benefits and minimised the risks.
You're going to have to give me gift links if you want me to see their argument.
Or do you just automatically believe that everything you agree with is correct?
Besides, I thought you just said in the first paragraph that the top of the pyramid is clinical practice guidelines.
Shouldn't you be upset at these authors attacking clinical practice guidelines as unscientific?
You refer to ideology. Anyone - but not you of course - can succumb to ideology.
Cute, if stupid.
Of course I can be swayed by ideology and have to take into account my biases.
Why do you think I read so much material and keep demanding primary sources?
All it takes is a sense of one’s own moral superiority for being on the 'right side'; a theory that purports to explain everything; and a principled refusal to see things from the point of view of one’s victims.
You're so close!
If you could step back, look at the people being hurt, and not operate from the position of "Trans people are evil and there is some kind of conspiracy and the LGB community should turn on them and cut them out" you might be able to engage with the science (in all its uncertainty) in an honest way.