The Israel Lobby

What difference does your semantic argument make? Does the Israel lobby have far too much influence over the US government? Yes or No?

Yes.
But that is quite a difference from "occupied".
If you honestly think words don't mean things, then you won't care about the word "occupied" and will stop using it.
 
Yes.
But that is quite a difference from "occupied".
If you honestly think words don't mean things, then you won't care about the word "occupied" and will stop using it.
Fair enough, but it makes no material difference. Get the Israel lobby out, and people will stop using the word "occupied". Its not like other lobbies. It acts on behalf of a foreign country.
 
Because if everyone has occupied the American government (using "the government does things that benefit them and not the people") then no one has occupied the American government.
Also, occupied involves a level of power and control that Israel simply hasn't displayed.
I basically go with International humanitarian law on this.

By international law you mean militarily occupied is the only form that counts. Not puppet governments or governments subject to the wills of other states.
Why would you say this means 'everyone' has occupied the american government, Israel is the only country where this argument applies.

Lots of people think it isn't.
I think it is unnecessary and doesn't really do much.
In a democracy in particular, people can vote on whether or not they think that makes a candidate unfit.

It gets rid of the most obvious issue but certainly doesn't stop politicians from being paid off to do the work of other foreign states.

Sure.
People make narratives.
The UK said something, then something bad happened.
Some people are going to immediately say it was a consequence of what they said.
Sometimes it will even be true.

Which means that it can't instantly be dismissed as conspiracy theory anymore.

So only groups who do things you disagree with politically should be forcibly disbanded and not allowed to function?

You think that MSF should be delisted and labelled terrorists?

How about countries lead by wanted war criminals shouldn't be allowed to lobby to delist human rights organizations that report their wrongdoing?
 
Fair enough, but it makes no material difference. Get the Israel lobby out, and people will stop using the word "occupied". Its not like other lobbies. It acts on behalf of a foreign country.

Lots of lobbies act on behalf of a foreign country.
The difference is AIPAC presents itself as a domestic lobby with concerns about a foreign country.
 
By international law you mean militarily occupied is the only form that counts. Not puppet governments or governments subject to the wills of other states.

If you wanted to say "puppet government" I'd still have objections, but I think it would be closer to realistic than the use of "occupied".

Why would you say this means 'everyone' has occupied the american government, Israel is the only country where this argument applies.

How do you figure that?
Lots of foreign governments have ungodly amounts of influence over the US government.

It gets rid of the most obvious issue but certainly doesn't stop politicians from being paid off to do the work of other foreign states.

Having a single citizenship doesn't stop politicians from being paid off to do the work of other foreign states.

Which means that it can't instantly be dismissed as conspiracy theory anymore.

I never said it should be instantly dismissed.
I said that it isn't surprising people immediately jump to conspiracy theories.

You think that MSF should be delisted and labelled terrorists?

Of course I don't.
I also don't think "We think these people should be delisted and labelled terrorists" means the group that proposed it should be disbanded and not allowed to exist.

How about countries lead by wanted war criminals shouldn't be allowed to lobby to delist human rights organizations that report their wrongdoing?

So you will make a list of countries that are not allowed to lobby?
 
If you wanted to say "puppet government" I'd still have objections, but I think it would be closer to realistic than the use of "occupied".

The fact that you are offended by the term is part of what makes it effective.
Puppet government is wrong, since its a government whose mandate has been effectively overtaken by a foreign government. Not a country that has had a leader deposed and installed by another country.


How do you figure that?
Lots of foreign governments have ungodly amounts of influence over the US government.

Post the names of these countries, the amounts they use for lobbying and do a real comparison.

Having a single citizenship doesn't stop politicians from being paid off to do the work of other foreign states.

No, but it eliminates the idea that a politician would do it out of loyalty to their other homeland.

I never said it should be instantly dismissed.
I said that it isn't surprising people immediately jump to conspiracy theories.

But is it at the point where it should be considered just a theory, and not a 'conspiracy theory'?

Of course I don't.
I also don't think "We think these people should be delisted and labelled terrorists" means the group that proposed it should be disbanded and not allowed to exist.

Even if they are acting on behalf of war criminals or a country committing genocide?

So you will make a list of countries that are not allowed to lobby?

You mean the way that we don't accept lobbying from Russia, North Korea and a few others?
 
Lots of lobbies act on behalf of a foreign country.
The difference is AIPAC presents itself as a domestic lobby with concerns about a foreign country.
We've discussed this before. The other foreign lobbies are registered with FARA, and cannot contribute to US elections.

AIPAC spends millions to unseat US candidates who refuse to kiss the ring. Spin this however you want. The US government is a puppet regime.
 
The fact that you are offended by the term is part of what makes it effective.

I am not offended by the term.
But thank you for admitting this is just rhetorical tactic, designed to get a rise out of people.
That was my whole point - was this a factual claim you were making, or just a rhetorical one.

We've now settled the question.

Puppet government is wrong, since its a government whose mandate has been effectively overtaken by a foreign government. Not a country that has had a leader deposed and installed by another country.

Now you're nitpicking definitions. :D
But sure, if that's not the idea you want to convey, then fine.
This is your rhetorical flourish, so you should use whichever term you think best.
If "Occupied" sounds more sinister to you, you should use it.

Post the names of these countries, the amounts they use for lobbying and do a real comparison.

China, the UAE, Saudi Arabia, just to name the "bad" ones.
And we don't have the lobbying amounts.
The whole point of dark money and next to no limits on billionaire donors is to make money hard to track.

No, but it eliminates the idea that a politician would do it out of loyalty to their other homeland.

Which is the argument that has always been used.
It's not one I put stock in.
Everyone has multiple loyalties.
There is a reason Catholics couldn't win office for a long time. Too loyal to the Pope.

But is it at the point where it should be considered just a theory, and not a 'conspiracy theory'?

When people immediately go "Israel did it" and have no plausible explanation for how, it is pretty much a conspiracy theory until they start constructing an argument other than "Israel is bad" and "vibes".

Even if they are acting on behalf of war criminals or a country committing genocide?

How are you going to prove that?
It's very difficult to restrict speech in an open society.
It can be done, of course, but it needs to be done carefully.

You mean the way that we don't accept lobbying from Russia, North Korea and a few others?

Yes.
I assume we are talking about Canada here, since US laws are much more open about this.
Honestly, your rule of "the country has to be led by an accused war criminal and it is banned from lobbying about humanitarian groups" is quite narrow and I wouldn't have much objection to it.
 
We've discussed this before. The other foreign lobbies are registered with FARA, and cannot contribute to US elections.

AIPAC spends millions to unseat US candidates who refuse to kiss the ring. Spin this however you want. The US government is a puppet regime.

And that's valid, that AIPAC can donate openly and other countries launder the money when donating to candidates is a big deal.
But "donating to elections" is not lobbying.
We were talking about lobbying.
 
But "donating to elections" is not lobbying.
We were talking about lobbying.
First you argue about the definition of occupied. Now you argue about the definition of lobbying. The subject of this thread is the Israel Lobby. They do a lot more than just lobbying.
 
I am not offended by the term.
But thank you for admitting this is just rhetorical tactic, designed to get a rise out of people.
That was my whole point - was this a factual claim you were making, or just a rhetorical one.

We've now settled the question.

That it gets a rise out of and is accurate is the point.


Now you're nitpicking definitions. :D
But sure, if that's not the idea you want to convey, then fine.
This is your rhetorical flourish, so you should use whichever term you think best.
If "Occupied" sounds more sinister to you, you should use it.

First you want a definition, then you don't.

China, the UAE, Saudi Arabia, just to name the "bad" ones.
And we don't have the lobbying amounts.
The whole point of dark money and next to no limits on billionaire donors is to make money hard to track.

You want to ask how much money america sends them?
Do they have ICC warrants for their leaders?

Which is the argument that has always been used.
It's not one I put stock in.
Everyone has multiple loyalties.
There is a reason Catholics couldn't win office for a long time. Too loyal to the Pope.

Its still useful.

When people immediately go "Israel did it" and have no plausible explanation for how, it is pretty much a conspiracy theory until they start constructing an argument other than "Israel is bad" and "vibes".

Except for how much crap Israel has actually done.


How are you going to prove that?
It's very difficult to restrict speech in an open society.
It can be done, of course, but it needs to be done carefully.

Now you want me to come up with the policy as well?

Yes.
I assume we are talking about Canada here, since US laws are much more open about this.
Honestly, your rule of "the country has to be led by an accused war criminal and it is banned from lobbying about humanitarian groups" is quite narrow and I wouldn't have much objection to it.

That used to be a Canadian diplomatic thing, that Canada wouldn't make deals with despots and war criminals.
Doesn't seem too odd to bring it back.

 
First you argue about the definition of occupied. Now you argue about the definition of lobbying. The subject of this thread is the Israel Lobby. They do a lot more than just lobbying.

I agree.
They certainly do.
But the argument that no other foreign country lobbies is laughable.
 
Which brings up an interesting issue.
Is the solution "Ban Israel from lobbying" or "control foreign lobbying"?
The solution is to register AIPAC under FARA. That's what JFK was trying to do before he was assassinated.

Funny how people critical of Israel keep getting assassinated, like Charlie Kirk. I'm sure its just a big coincidence.