The Israel Lobby

Neither of those criminalize criticizing Israel.
The closest is adopting the IHRA definition, especially along with the examples.

Oh wait - its probably this: https://www.flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2023/269/?StartTab=BillText#BillText
Take that, combine it with the IHRA definition and a state government that wants to abuse it and you can get to criminalizing criticism of Israel without too much trouble.

Good point, there are so many bills and laws banning boycotts and criticism that its hard to keep track. So much protection for a foreign country....

Of course you view it that way.
You realize just saying "occupied" might require you to back it up and you don't think that's fair.
Of course, if "occupied" is just rhetorical hyperbole and not meant to mean anything literal, then you don't have this problem.

Of course it comes to this, an attack on whether I can use the term 'occupied' rather than a discussion about whether america is occupied.
That's the standard tactic to shut down debate on the subject.


There are lots of countries that ban dual citizenship people from office.
Neither the US nor Canada is among them.
Hell, in Canada, you don't even need to be a Canadian citizen to be prime minister, if I remember correctly.

Well, I guess there is no problem then.
Thanks for clearing that up.

The UK is making steps in the right direction.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Of course it comes to this, an attack on whether I can use the term 'occupied' rather than a discussion about whether america is occupied.
That's the standard tactic to shut down debate on the subject.

LOL!
I've been trying to get you to have a discussion of America is occupied.
You keep refusing to engage in it.
  • You won't say what you mean by occupied.
  • You get mad when I try to pin you down on what you mean by that.
  • Then you pretend that asking what "occupied" means is dodging a discussion of whether the US is occupied.
Let's try the less wrong approach.
Since the idea of the word "occupied" is so terrifying to you, drop the word.

Just say what you mean. We'll ignore your whole rhetorical structure, and you will describe the relationship between Israel and the US in specific factual claims and we can work from there.

Well, I guess there is no problem then.
Thanks for clearing that up.

Wow.
I didn't think just finding out Canada allows it would cause you to just drop it as not a problem.
Surprising.

The UK is making steps in the right direction.

A bunch of countries followed suit. We shall see what the actual follow through is.

The UK announces boycotts of the settlements and then....


Excited to see your follow up on this with evidence of a cyber-attack.
 
LOL!
I've been trying to get you to have a discussion of America is occupied.
You keep refusing to engage in it.
  • You won't say what you mean by occupied.
  • You get mad when I try to pin you down on what you mean by that.
  • Then you pretend that asking what "occupied" means is dodging a discussion of whether the US is occupied.
Let's try the less wrong approach.
Since the idea of the word "occupied" is so terrifying to you, drop the word.

Just say what you mean. We'll ignore your whole rhetorical structure, and you will describe the relationship between Israel and the US in specific factual claims and we can work from there.

Sure, polls are massively in favour against the war in Iran, spending billions on genocide, curbs on freedom of speech and a few other things that would argue that the government acts more often on the interests of Israel rather than america.


Wow.
I didn't think just finding out Canada allows it would cause you to just drop it as not a problem.
Surprising.

So much for sarcasm. It wouldn't be a problem if it were a few people from a few different countries.
But the conflict of interest makes this a bit special.

A bunch of countries followed suit. We shall see what the actual follow through is.

Fair point, its a start but likely there will be too much stalling.

Excited to see your follow up on this with evidence of a cyber-attack.
I doubt there is anything there, except that the security system are Israeli.
But if true, there would likely be massive blowback.

 
How's this?


Excellent.
Buchanan says the comment is ridicule, but not a true statement.
It's a "crack" (joke) to highlight that the Israeli library is too powerful, but not a literal statement.
 
Sure, polls are massively in favour against the war in Iran, spending billions on genocide, curbs on freedom of speech and a few other things that would argue that the government acts more often on the interests of Israel rather than america.

Excellent!
You think the US acts too often in the interests of Israel rather than America.
I agree!

So much for sarcasm. It wouldn't be a problem if it were a few people from a few different countries.
But the conflict of interest makes this a bit special.

So you are against the Canadian policy and feels people with dual citizenship should be banned from public office?

I doubt there is anything there, except that the security system are Israeli.
But if true, there would likely be massive blowback.


That AI response says that the Israeli equipment isn't the National Air Traffic Services (NATS) which is what failed.
 
Excellent!
You think the US acts too often in the interests of Israel rather than America.
I agree!

excellent

So you are against the Canadian policy and feels people with dual citizenship should be banned from public office?

I think given the trade and nationalist issues these days it might be smart.

That AI response says that the Israeli equipment isn't the National Air Traffic Services (NATS) which is what failed.

Like I said, most likely nothing but people will go there first these days.

CIJA needs to be banned now, given Canada's boycotting of settlements.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
excellent

So the issue is just we disagree on whether that counts as being occupied or not.

I think given the trade and nationalist issues these days it might be smart.

As a dual citizen, I'm inclined to disagree.
Would you limit it to natural-born citizens, or are naturalized citizens allowed to run for office?

Like I said, most likely nothing but people will go there first these days.

Of course they will.
The web is full of people who love conspiracy theories and people who are willing to blame Israel for anything and everything they don't like.

CIJA needs to be banned now, given Canada's boycotting of settlements.

I at least appreciate you are consistent - no country can have any group formed of people who have opinions about other countries.
(Not to say that what CIJA is doing here is good. It's scummy bullshit.)
 
So the issue is just we disagree on whether that counts as being occupied or not.

Then you need to describe what your definition of occupied is or why you think it means the american government isn't occupied.

As a dual citizen, I'm inclined to disagree.
Would you limit it to natural-born citizens, or are naturalized citizens allowed to run for office?

If you want to run for office give up your second citizenship.
If that's too much for you, don't run for office.
Why is that too much to ask?

Of course they will.
The web is full of people who love conspiracy theories and people who are willing to blame Israel for anything and everything they don't like.

The world is also full of people watching 'where's daddy' type AI drone warfare become Palantir and Flock.
Where AI could realistically be the start of a big daddy, Orwellian police state and Versificator entertainment.


I at least appreciate you are consistent - no country can have any group formed of people who have opinions about other countries.
(Not to say that what CIJA is doing here is good. It's scummy bullshit.)

'opinions'?
That's not the issue.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Excellent.
Buchanan says the comment is ridicule, but not a true statement.
It's a "crack" (joke) to highlight that the Israeli library is too powerful, but not a literal statement.
Great, we can all forget about it then. Nothing to see here, move along.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Then you need to describe what your definition of occupied is or why you think it means the american government isn't occupied.

Because if everyone has occupied the American government (using "the government does things that benefit them and not the people") then no one has occupied the American government.
Also, occupied involves a level of power and control that Israel simply hasn't displayed.
I basically go with International humanitarian law on this.

If you want to run for office give up your second citizenship.
If that's too much for you, don't run for office.
Why is that too much to ask?

Lots of people think it isn't.
I think it is unnecessary and doesn't really do much.
In a democracy in particular, people can vote on whether or not they think that makes a candidate unfit.

The world is also full of people watching 'where's daddy' type AI drone warfare become Palantir and Flock.
Where AI could realistically be the start of a big daddy, Orwellian police state and Versificator entertainment.

Sure.
People make narratives.
The UK said something, then something bad happened.
Some people are going to immediately say it was a consequence of what they said.
Sometimes it will even be true.


So only groups who do things you disagree with politically should be forcibly disbanded and not allowed to function?
 
Also, occupied involves a level of power and control that Israel simply hasn't displayed.
What difference does your semantic argument make? Does the Israel lobby have far too much influence over the US government? Yes or No?
 
Great, we can all forget about it then. Nothing to see here, move along.

You posted it in response to me saying I wanted to have a discussion of calling the US occupied.
Buchanan, in this clip, says clearly that he doesn't mean that literally.

I repeatedly offered to Frank that if he wants to use it as a metaphor, a bit of political rhetoric, like Buchanan claims he is doing, then fine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: southpaw