The final six days 1914

Although Soviet-style had a huge component of socialist collectivism that he's disavowed. I really think the better comparison is the other '30s dictator so fond of goosestepping militarist excess, for whom the pretence of a 'people's' anything was about fatherland and blood, not benefit. Certainly Putin's move into Crimea could have been taken right out of that guy's How to Invade Poland in Self-Defence handbook.

Except Putin is a cynic and doesn't really believe in much of what he preaches - at least IMHO. Hitler unfortunately believed everything he ever said.

Putin might be a little more like Mussolini.
 
Although Soviet-style had a huge component of socialist collectivism that he's disavowed. I really think the better comparison is the other '30s dictator so fond of goosestepping militarist excess, for whom the pretence of a 'people's' anything was about fatherland and blood, not benefit. Certainly Putin's move into Crimea could have been taken right out of that guy's How to Invade Poland in Self-Defence handbook.
In fairness more like how to reconnect Danzig to Germany. No one save Westerners who haven't studied the issue (and Crimean Tartars who conveniently forget their own historic atrocities and die-hard Ukrainian nationalists) sees Crimea as anything other than Russian. It is a completely different historical situation than the eastern Oblasts of Ukraine
 
In fairness more like how to reconnect Danzig to Germany. No one save Westerners who haven't studied the issue (and Crimean Tartars who conveniently forget their own historic atrocities and die-hard Ukrainian nationalists) sees Crimea as anything other than Russian. It is a completely different historical situation than the eastern Oblasts of Ukraine
That last may well be true, but only relevant if you're looking to attach a colour of right to your military invasion. The sham 'Polish attack' the Germans staged on their own radio station to justify the attack on Poland came after the phoney 'recovery' of Danzig and rescue of its German population had withered as a pretext.

Much like the identity difficulties we face in English North America absent natural boundaries, who you are and what is yours can only be decided by agreement or more or less constant aggression and pushback, as is the case on the European plains. When the actual people have intermingled and intermarried across the imaginary lines for generations—like Canucks and Yanks and those who were here before us, who is to say what land 'belongs' to what latest jumped-up gang of bullies calling itself a national government?
 
From a Russian perspective Alexei Eremenko in the Saint-Petersburg Times on ``How and Why Russia Forgot The Great War``


http://www.sptimes.ru/index.php?action_id=100&story_id=40447

[COLOR=``#000080``]Eremenko makes some arguable points. But the issue of the ``shell crisis of 1915`` as the cause of the Great Retreat is not free of controversy, although it is a splendid Russian alibi for military failure, especially if one also alleges that Vickers and other British concerns contracted to supply the missing ammunition and then did not deliver. Evil British capitalists. Good self-sacrificing Russian soldiers. Etc. Etc. Etc. The counter argument is that the Russian army was forced to retreat because it was simply out fought and out generaled by the Germans. See: [/COLOR]
http://www.amazon.com/Breakthrough-...1407034970&sr=1-2&keywords=brusilov+offensive

[COLOR=``#000080``]Poland is also a salient if your opponents are in Galicia and East Prussia respectively. So the Great Retreat may have been a military necessity in any event. The counter-argument is that the Central Powers may have pursued the Russian Army further into Ukraine and Belarus than the Kovel-Brest-Riga line and destroyed it, had they not been deterred by the fact that the Pripyat Marshes would have divided their forces, thus allowing the Russians to use the north-south railway links further east to transfer overwhelming force to either the south or north of the Pripyat for a decisive strategic blow.

I am not aware of any reputable histories of the Brusilov Offensive that indicate that it was any more than a transitory success in a morass of general, overwhelming Russian failures. As far as destroying the fighting power of the Austrian army, the latter did just fine at Caporetto a year later. Here is the only book in English I have come across on the Brusilov offensive. As an interesting side note, Brusilov went Red in 1918. I guess he didn`t subscribe to Putin`s version of the Stab in the Back Theory. I have no issue with the argument that he was a vastly talented guy and basically invented the storm trooper offensive that the Germans adopted and perfected in 1918. [/COLOR] http://www.amazon.com/Brusilov-Offe...1407034970&sr=1-1&keywords=brusilov+offensive

[COLOR=``#000080``]Russia had a plan in 1914 and was fully culpable in the outbreak of the war. Essentially the plan was to seize Western Galicia, thereby completing the old Kingdom of Poland as a Russian vassal province and to knock out A-H as a major power, thus allowing Russia to seize the Darda unopposed. Part of the reason that the Russian army foundered at Tannenberg was that Russia was unwilling to divert sufficient troops to the East Prussia to effectively over-run the province. This was because the focus of Russia attention was Galicia. So the interests of Russia`s western ally, France was largely ignored in favour of a Galician strike.[/COLOR] http://www.amazon.com/Russian-Origi...ER4_1_2?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1407034951&sr=1-2
 
August 3, 1914

At 7:00 a.m. after meetings through much of the night, Belgium notifies Germany that it will not allow the passage of German troops and will resist any such invasion with force.

Four British cabinet members from the pacifist/neutral wing of the Liberal Party give their resignations.

At 3:00 p.m. the Foreign Secretary, Sir Edward Grey speaks to the House of Commons, it is the first time all members have been present in 21 years, chairs need to be set up in the hallway. Parliamentary opposition to intervention collapses.

4:00 pm the British Army is officially mobilized


6:15 pm (12:15 in Toronto) Germany Declares War on France.


Also the Norddeutscher Lloyd liner Kronprinzessin Cecilie racing back across the Atlantic south of the Grand Banks runs into fog, but does not reduce her speed, after several hours the Captain does decide to start sounding her fog horn. Her radio room hears two French cruisers (presumably on the Grand Banks) talking to each other. A group of American Financiers with greater agitation in their hearts than knowledge of Admiralty Law offer to purchase the ship so that she can be reflagged American and continue on to Europe, the Captain refuses saying that he will obey the orders he has received from Norddeutscher Lloyd.

Australia offers its navy and 20,000 troops to the British war effort.

France begins protesting the non-existent movement of Austro-Hungarian troops to Alsace, creating a pretext to declare war on Austria-Hungary (forerunner of Clemenceau scuttling Emperor Karl's peace feelers in both 1917 and 1918).

Looking out a window at the Foreign Office at twilight and seeing the lamplighter below. Sir Edward Grey utters his famous remark: “The lamps are going out all over Europe; we shall not see them lit again in our lifetime.”
 
Last edited:
August 4, 1914

2:00 a.m. The German Admiralty orders the Battle Cruiser SMS Goeben and the Light Cruiser SMS Breslau to “proceed at once to Constantinople.” Rear Admiral Souchon the German Commander in the Mediterranean, however, feels that it would be a shame to be so close to striking a blow and not to do so. Hence he continues west towards French Algeria at 6:00 a.m. as the two ships approach the coast he has them run up Russian colours in violation of article 23 of the Hague Convention to which Germany was a party (but in accordance with the German “War Book”) for about 15 minutes the Breslau bombards Bône (Annaba) while the Goeben bombards Philippeville (Skikda) the two ships then rejoin and begin heading east through the Mediterranean. At about 9:30 a.m. they pass the two British Battlecruisers H.M.S. Indomitable and H.M.S. Indefatigable which had been attempting to catch-up to them. The two British Warships immediately turn and begin following the British Admiralty radioing “Very good. Hold them. War imminent.”

The Germans having worked feverishly all day to get every possible knot from their ships at 5:00 p.m. the Indomitable and Indefatigable drop out of range and at 9:00 p.m. the two German ships disappear into the gathering night (carrying with them as Winston Spencer-Churchill years later wrote "more slaughter, more misery and more ruin than has ever before been borne within the compass of a ship).

8:00 a.m. German troops invade Belgium.

Noon, King Albert of the Belgium’s requests British and French aid.

At 6:30 a.m. (11:30 a.m. in London) the Norddeutscher Lloyd liner Kronprinzessin Cecilie arrives in Bar Harbor, Maine having been piloted into the harbor by C. Ledyard Blair an American Financier and Sailor who is familiar with the area frequently sailing there.

2:00 p.m. The British Foreign office sends the ultimatum to Germany, withdraw from Belgium by midnight (Berlin time, 6:00 p.m. Toronto) or a state of war will exist between the British Empire and Germany.

German Chancellor Bethmann angrily tells British Ambassador Goschen that "just for a scrap of paper Great Britain was going to make war on a kindred nation who desired nothing better than to be friends with her." (the 1839 Treaty creating Belgium and guaranteeing her neutrality).

11:00 p.m. (6:00 p.m. Toronto) the ultimatum expires (without any German reply) and Canada, Australia, Newfoundland, New Zealand, Great Britain, and India are at war with Germany.

Lord Kitchener is named British War Minister the first serving officer to be so named since the Restoration.

The U.S.A. declares itself a neutral power.
 
Historian Jack Granatstein refuted Stephen Harper's claim, during the 90th Anniversary of Vimy Ridge, that the battle changed the course of the war. He says that the battle was significant in that Canadians fought for the first time as an independent unit but it was not strategically important. He goes on to say that Canada's true coming of age came during the Ludendorff Offensive of the summer of 1918, when they blunted the German Field Marshall's drive to Paris. The Germans sustained such heavy losses that they called them the Kanadier verruckte (Crazy Canucks).
 
The statement that the Austrians did just fine at Caparetto is false. The offensive was spearheaded by Hindenburg's Russian Divisions backed by German artillery. This caught the Italians completely by surprise since it had not declared war against the German Empire only the Austro-Hungarian Empire. After the disaster at Gallipoli, the British prodded the Italians into declaring war but supplied only ordnance. The Italians only had American and South American mercenaries to back them up. The artillery that the British provided was no match against Germany's Big Berthas.
 
Historian Jack Granatstein refuted Stephen Harper's claim, during the 90th Anniversary of Vimy Ridge, that the battle changed the course of the war. He says that the battle was significant in that Canadians fought for the first time as an independent unit but it was not strategically important. He goes on to say that Canada's true coming of age came during the Ludendorff Offensive of the summer of 1918, when they blunted the German Field Marshall's drive to Paris. The Germans sustained such heavy losses that they called them the Kanadier verruckte (Crazy Canucks).


IIRC, the Canadian corps was not involved in the Ludendorff offensives. They were crucial in the 100 Days, the British counter-offensive that ended the war. That actually WAS a battle that changed the course of the war.
 
IIRC, the Canadian corps was not involved in the Ludendorff offensives. They were crucial in the 100 Days, the British counter-offensive that ended the war. That actually WAS a battle that changed the course of the war.
Indeed so. The whole thing was a learning experience for the Canadian Corps, and on a curve from the Battle of Neuve Chapelle and the Second Battle of Ypres to the 100 Days.
 
Last edited:
IIRC, the Canadian corps was not involved in the Ludendorff offensives. They were crucial in the 100 Days, the British counter-offensive that ended the war. That actually WAS a battle that changed the course of the war.

My mistake I considered the Ludendorff Offensive as part of the 100 days.
 
The Australians refused to allow the Brits to shoot Australian soldiers accused of "cowardice".
 
The Australians refused to allow the Brits to shoot Australian soldiers accused of "cowardice".
Which is only right, both Canada and Australia insisted upon their Regiments serving in their Divisions serving in a unified Corps. When the U.S. entered the War it did largely the same with the exception of a few Black Regiments which served with French Divisions.


Every modern war has taught some horrible bloody medical lessons, one of those of World War I was psychology, such that in World War II most incidents of desertion at the front were treated as psychological issues rather than criminal acts.