The final six days 1914

Aardvark154

New member
Jan 19, 2006
53,709
3
0
Today (July 30) in the late afternoon Austria-Hungary orders a full General Mobilization. Also, Tsar Nicholas II under severe pressure from his ministers especially his Foreign Minister Sergei Dmitrievich Sazonov finally ordered Russian General Mobilization.


The German Chancellor Bethmann-Hollweg is convinced that Britain will come in against Germany. In a final attempt to pull back from the abyss which he was largely responsible for opening, he telegraphs the Austro-Hungarian Foreign Minister Graf Berchtold von und zu Ungarschitz, Frättling und Püllütz and entirely reversing the previous German position says that Austria-Hungary should accept the British offer of mediation, Graf Berchtold does not.
 
Today (July 30) in the late afternoon Austria-Hungary orders a full General Mobilization. Also, Tsar Nicholas II under severe pressure from his ministers especially his Foreign Minister Sergei Dmitrievich Sazonov finally ordered Russian General Mobilization.


The German Chancellor Bethmann-Hollweg is convinced that Britain will come in against Germany. In a final attempt to pull back from the abyss which he was largely responsible for opening, he telegraphs the Austro-Hungarian Foreign Minister Graf Berchtold von und zu Ungarschitz, Frättling und Püllütz and entirely reversing the previous German position says that Austria-Hungary should accept the British offer of mediation, Graf Berchtold does not.

Which is surprising, given how little military power Britain could project into Europe in 1914.
 
It is one of those great what ifs. What if they had accepted the offer of British, French and Italian mediation.



However, sadly showing how very few grasped what the war would be like, the Tsar struggling with whether to order a General Mobilization said "It's a question of sending thousands and thousands of men to their deaths!"
 
July 31, 1914

Germany issues ultimatums to Russia and France: That Russia cease mobilization within 12 hours or Germany will declare war and that France declare neutrality within 18 hours.

In the late afternoon the French Government issues the orders for a General Mobilization.


The British, Canadian and American press begin to concentrate on the situation in Continental Europe having largely ignored it for the past month.


Also the Norddeutscher Lloyd liner Kronprinzessin Cecilie at sea but a few hundred miles off the Irish Coast and carrying ten million dollars in gold bullion and 3.4 million dollars in silver ingots being transferred from New York to the Bank of England and the Banque de France, to repay loans made by English and French investors to American Companies, receives a coded message from the line ordering her to turn around and head for the United States at all possible speed.
 
Last edited:
Which is surprising, given how little military power Britain could project into Europe in 1914.
However the amount they projected by early 1917 was pretty predictable, even ignoring the other English-speaking part of America. And their control of the seas was the given that spurred the Kaiser's ambitions.

It's why the Germans focussed everything on their knock-out Schlieffen Plan to get France out of the war in the first weeks so they could slowly wipe up Russia. Leaving England on the other side of the Channel with nowhere useful to go.

As if that would have settled anything, had it succeeded.

The only winning strategy any general in the two (three if you count 1870) German Wars ever came up with was the Marshall Plan. Which seems so far to be working reasonably well.

As Israel continues to prove, winning wars just makes more bitter enemies. It's the peace you have to win.
--------------------------

Thanks Aardvark, for these posts. The day itself falls on a holiday weekend here, but it'll make it easy to put some flowers under the plaque at the church down the road, and the poppies have been especially lovely this year.
 
July 31, 1914 continued

The London Stock Market had to close in the mid-morning due to panic selling, the first time it has closed since 1773.


In the late afternoon Jean Jaurès, the French Socialist leader and the leading anti-war voice in Europe is murdered at a cafe.
 
Which is surprising, given how little military power Britain could project into Europe in 1914.

No nation could project power in the way we see today. But Britain had a massive navy that was the equal of any 2 other navies combined. At the time Britannia ruled the waves by quite a margin. Considering how developed international trade was at the time. Germany knew they could not survive a long war.
 
No nation could project power in the way we see today. But Britain had a massive navy that was the equal of any 2 other navies combined. At the time Britannia ruled the waves by quite a margin. Considering how developed international trade was at the time. Germany knew they could not survive a long war.
Indeed based on the Franco-Prussian War and others, most thought that a war would last but a few months - in the German Kaiser's words: "you will be home before the leaves fall from the trees."
 
No nation could project power in the way we see today. But Britain had a massive navy that was the equal of any 2 other navies combined. At the time Britannia ruled the waves by quite a margin. Considering how developed international trade was at the time. Germany knew they could not survive a long war.

Not true. they certainly expected and wished to win quickly. But even in November 1918 with the army in tatters and Ludendorff make strange gibbering noises across the table and rythmically slapping his own forehead with a bratwurst, the Kaiser was not convinced he had lost the war and was going to have to abdicate. Ludendorff himself alternated from morose depression to hypomanic optimism and Hindenburg mainly farted and muttered hearty platitudes about cow-farming in East Prussia. None of them really accepted that they were badly, badly fucked.
 
August 1, 1914

In Saint-Petersburg at 7:10 p.m. (12:10 in Toronto) (two hours after he was supposed to) the German Ambassador Graf Pourtalès delivers the German Declaration of War to the Russian Foreign Minister. Several hours earlier Germany has ordered a General Mobilization.

At the same hour German troops invade Luxembourg.
 
Not true. they certainly expected and wished to win quickly. But even in November 1918 with the army in tatters and Ludendorff make strange gibbering noises across the table and rythmically slapping his own forehead with a bratwurst, the Kaiser was not convinced he had lost the war and was going to have to abdicate. Ludendorff himself alternated from morose depression to hypomanic optimism and Hindenburg mainly farted and muttered hearty platitudes about cow-farming in East Prussia. None of them really accepted that they were badly, badly fucked.
Not being able to recognize defeat is the insurmountable problem with mortal combat as your model for succeeding in the world. Stubborness like that can only work in athletics. It fails everywhere else, devastating nations and wasting whole generations when guns are involved. Wasn't it great to watch the United States projecting power in Viet Nam every night on the news, knowing this time every boy would get buried at home? How long before 'losing' that war, (and Somalia, and Iraq and Afghanistan) no longer distorts every decision 'we' make?

And haven't we all learned to do all that so much more effectively now. Nothing at all August 1914-like about Gaza or Donetsk, is there?
 
August 2, 1914

Germany threatens Belgium demanding (in their eyes requesting) that Belgium should not resist an invasion by German troops. At 9:00 p.m. at a Council of State King Albert of the Belgium's states "Our answer must be No, whatever the consequences. The Belgium Premier states "If Germany is victorious, Belgium, what ever her attitude, will be annexed to the German Empire."

The Ottoman Empire signs a secret treaty of alliance with Germany.

Italy declares her neutrality (stating accurately enough) that Austria-Hungary and Germany are the aggressor powers and that the treaty obligates her only in the event they are attacked.

German warships bombard Libau, on the Latvian coast near the German Russian border.

The SMS Goeben and SMS Breslau are frantically coaling from supplies on German merchant ships in Messina, Italy.

The French Naval Minister, suffers a nervous breakdown, challenges the War Minister to a duel and after being restrained by colleagues is persuaded to resign

The Tsar appears on the balcony of the Winter Palace to the cheering crowd in Palace Square.

In a vociferous British Cabinet meeting, The Prime Minister (Asquith) and Foreign Secretary (Grey) force the neutralist faction of the Cabinet (Liberal Party) to declare they will support British intervention if Germany attacks the north coast of France or violates Belgium neutrality. The Conservative party offer unconditional support to the Prime Minister for British intervention.

The Government of Canada says that it will send troops overseas to aid Great Britain.
 
Slightly off-topic. Putin has now officially endorsed Hitler's "stab in the back theory" and applied it to Russia. Apparently the real reason Russia lost WW 1 was because of bad attitude back in Russia

The Russian President thinks that throughout many centuries Russia has stood for strong and trusting relations between states.

According to Putin, this was the case on the eve of World War I, when Russia did everything it could to convince Europe to solve the conflict between Serbia and Austria-Hungary peacefully and without bloodshed. However, Russia went unheard, and it was forced to respond to the challenge “by protecting its fraternal Slavic people, protecting itself, and its citizens from an external threat.”

“Russia did its duty as an ally. Its advances in Prussia and in Galicia disrupted the enemy’s plans, gave the allies the opportunity to hold the front and defend Paris, and compelled the enemy to send most of its forces to the east, where Russian troops fought fearlessly. And the entire world heard about the legendary Brusilov Offensive. However, this victory was stolen from the country. Stolen by those who called for the defeat of their Motherland, their army, incited animosity within Russia, strived to capture power, betraying national interests,” said Putin.
http://euromaidanpress.com/2014/08/02/putin-claims-russia-had-its-world-war-i-victory-stolen/

Glosses over a # of factors, including the fact that Russia was "done" as a fighting force by late 1916 and was simply holding a defensive line.
 
Look back a month in this century-old history to Gavrilo Prinzip pulling the trigger to murder the Grand Duke and his wife in the name of Serbian independence. Was he the last actor in this massively stupid tragedy who actually could have chosen not to be part of the madness?

His propaganda of the deed certainly advanced his cause, didn't it? Look back just a decade or so when a couple of amateur pilots made similarly rash and desperate choices to kill. For similarly destructive and contrary results that cost thousands of their compatriots and loved ones their lives. But they were unbalanced fanatics, maybe unstoppable lunatics fomenting evil in secret cabals.

We can't say the same for those well-fed, self-important 'decison-makers', in Cabinet Rooms and palaces, surrounded by wise and informed advisors, with the well-being of their peoples formally and officially entrusted to them. They blindly let circumstance compel them to march an entire generation off to certain death. Because a fight is always the easier answer.

No one had to stand up for anything more than human decency and common sense. But no one did.
 
Slightly off-topic. Putin has now officially endorsed Hitler's "stab in the back theory" and applied it to Russia. Apparently the real reason Russia lost WW 1 was because of bad attitude back in Russia

The Russian President thinks that throughout many centuries Russia has stood for strong and trusting relations between states.

According to Putin, this was the case on the eve of World War I, when Russia did everything it could to convince Europe to solve the conflict between Serbia and Austria-Hungary peacefully and without bloodshed. However, Russia went unheard, and it was forced to respond to the challenge “by protecting its fraternal Slavic people, protecting itself, and its citizens from an external threat.”

“Russia did its duty as an ally. Its advances in Prussia and in Galicia disrupted the enemy’s plans, gave the allies the opportunity to hold the front and defend Paris, and compelled the enemy to send most of its forces to the east, where Russian troops fought fearlessly. And the entire world heard about the legendary Brusilov Offensive. However, this victory was stolen from the country. Stolen by those who called for the defeat of their Motherland, their army, incited animosity within Russia, strived to capture power, betraying national interests,” said Putin.
http://euromaidanpress.com/2014/08/02/putin-claims-russia-had-its-world-war-i-victory-stolen/

Glosses over a # of factors, including the fact that Russia was "done" as a fighting force by late 1916 and was simply holding a defensive line.
What about the Brusilov Offensive of 1916?

It would seem to me far more important was the internal turmoil particularly in the major cities - coming from the hard left, combined with the fact that the Army units left in the cities were additional battalions recruited during the war, the real regulars were at the front, this goes in large measure to explaining why Leib Guard Regiments in Saint-Petersburg "mutinied."
 
…According to Putin, this was the case on the eve of World War I, when Russia did everything it could to convince Europe to solve the conflict between Serbia and Austria-Hungary peacefully and without bloodshed. However, Russia went unheard, and it was forced to respond to the challenge “by protecting its fraternal Slavic people, protecting itself, and its citizens from an external threat.”

…However, this victory was stolen from the country. Stolen by those who called for the defeat of their Motherland, their army, incited animosity within Russia, strived to capture power, betraying national interests,” said Putin.
Of course he's using the same national socialist racism as his excuse for his own policies. Pan-Slavism encouraged and fuelled the Serbian extremists in 1914, and gave them the Russian support they wanted. Too bad it came with an entire World War attached. What Russia did not do then or now was declare itself on the side of lawful justice that will not tolerate murderers.

And, like the Germans itching for a rematch in the '30s, he's turning the inept regime that his own replaced into the home-front villains of his propaganda, and resurrecting the fears of foreigners to brace up his own weaknesses. Absent at least one significant ally it doesn't seem likely he'll get past propaganda, but that 'blood is thicker than thinking' stuff is bad enough.

Besides finding an ally was the whole story of the run-up that made 1914 into a war, and we know how that worked out. Putin will find one if we let his sort of thinking prevail. Only question is who.

High time the World proved truth and justice mean something universal and real and do not have to come with someone's national way attached.
 
What about the Brusilov Offensive of 1916?

It would seem to me far more important was the internal turmoil particularly in the major cities - coming from the hard left, combined with the fact that the Army units left in the cities were additional battalions recruited during the war, the real regulars were at the front, this goes in large measure to explaining why Leib Guard Regiments in Saint-Petersburg "mutinied."

The Brusilov Offensive blew itself out by late summer 1916 and then the front recoiled when Rumania entered the war and promptly collapsed, leaving a huge hole in the line that couldn't be plugged.

My Putin-bashing aside, my impression is that the morale on subsidiary fronts, like the Caucasus remained high. It's difficult to get an impression of how long morale lasted at the front in Ukraine, the Baltic and Belarus. The Germans took Riga easily in 1917 against weak opposition and could have kept pushing if the Bolsheviks hadn't taken power and thrown in their hand.

It's clear that the ideas of Soldiers' Soviets had taken root at the Front and the soldiers were losing interest in the War. Was this due to "agitators"? Was this due to the fact that the Germans had kicked Russian ass on every occasion apart from Brusilov and the Russian army had recoiled from the borders of Silesia to the Western edge of the Pripyat Marshes, 500 (?) miles East? Was it due to the fact that the home administration was so inept that there were bread riots and starvation in the cities and the cossacks were riding down the soldiers' wives and mothers when they peacefully protested?

It seems that the situation of the Russian Army was similar to that of the German Army 1 year later. It was just a general collapse, brought about by a number of factors.
 
Of course he's using the same national socialist racism as his excuse for his own policies. Pan-Slavism encouraged and fuelled the Serbian extremists in 1914, and gave them the Russian support they wanted. Too bad it came with an entire World War attached. What Russia did not do then or now was declare itself on the side of lawful justice that will not tolerate murderers.

And, like the Germans itching for a rematch in the '30s, he's turning the inept regime that his own replaced into the home-front villains of his propaganda, and resurrecting the fears of foreigners to brace up his own weaknesses. Absent at least one significant ally it doesn't seem likely he'll get past propaganda, but that 'blood is thicker than thinking' stuff is bad enough.

Besides finding an ally was the whole story of the run-up that made 1914 into a war, and we know how that worked out. Putin will find one if we let his sort of thinking prevail. Only question is who.

High time the World proved truth and justice mean something universal and real and do not have to come with someone's national way attached.

There is a larger context. Putin banned any criticism of the Russian Army in World War Two about a month ago and made it a criminal offence. Yes, you read that correctly. And god knows, there is a helluva lot to criticize in the Russian conduct of WW 2 from both the military and humanitarian aspect.

It's clear that this is all part of an intense nationalist propaganda campaign which is intended to shut down any criticism of the "authorities" - including most importantly of course, Putin's own current kleptocratic regime - and to replace it with a Soviet-style program of endless cheer-leading and flag-waving.
 
There is a larger context. Putin banned any criticism of the Russian Army in World War Two about a month ago and made it a criminal offence. Yes, you read that correctly. And god knows, there is a helluva lot to criticize in the Russian conduct of WW 2 from both the military and humanitarian aspect.

It's clear that this is all part of an intense nationalist propaganda campaign which is intended to shut down any criticism of the "authorities" - including most importantly of course, Putin's own current kleptocratic regime - and to replace it with a Soviet-style program of endless cheer-leading and flag-waving.
Although Soviet-style had a huge component of socialist collectivism that he's disavowed. I really think the better comparison is the other '30s dictator so fond of goosestepping militarist excess, for whom the pretence of a 'people's' anything was about fatherland and blood, not benefit. Certainly Putin's move into Crimea could have been taken right out of that guy's How to Invade Poland in Self-Defence handbook.
 
What about the Brusilov Offensive of 1916?

It would seem to me far more important was the internal turmoil particularly in the major cities - coming from the hard left, combined with the fact that the Army units left in the cities were additional battalions recruited during the war, the real regulars were at the front, this goes in large measure to explaining why Leib Guard Regiments in Saint-Petersburg "mutinied."

Not authoritative, but convenient and timely. The Kerensky Offensive of July 1917. Few wanted to fight anymore and the offensive sputtered out.

https://www.facebook.com/4508225850...41828.450822585061599/493579660785891/?type=1