The Canadian Navy?

I seem to recall hearing that the Brits have some claims to the Northwest Passage because of the Franklin Expedition which, apparently, was flying the British flag (was it the Union Jack at that time or the flag of England?).
 
Truth be told, Canada should be re-thinking is Naval strategies overall, and should likely be adopting an investment strategy more focused on developing extremely robust homeland security capabilities, especially in the north, rather than the development of international 'mission support' capabilities. Unfortunately, Canada simply cannot sustain the latter given it's current domestic political and economic climate. Shame, since the electorate would probably very much support the former, making the Navy's day to day a much simpler and easier challenge to overcome.
 
To all

The cost the PM's photo op up in the artic to find a lost ship that could never be recovered. Cost to the RCN was a naval base up in northern Canada.
The funds used for the PM's little show, could have activated a naval base that would have allowed ships to operate in those artic waters year round.
It not easy to keep ships up there when they have to stage from Halifax.
 
I seem to recall hearing that the Brits have some claims to the Northwest Passage because of the Franklin Expedition which, apparently, was flying the British flag (was it the Union Jack at that time or the flag of England?).

Union Jack.
 
I seem to recall hearing that the Brits have some claims to the Northwest Passage because of the Franklin Expedition which, apparently, was flying the British flag (was it the Union Jack at that time or the flag of England?).
Union of the Crowns of England and Scotland (James VI & I) 1603, The Act of Union 1707 (form one state Great Britain), the Union with Ireland Act 1801 (the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland). (so the modern version of the R.N. Ensign).

The U.K. ceded its rights in the arctic to Canada (technically the same is true of Rupert's Land,the HBC ceded it back to the British Crown which ceded it to Canada.)
 
To all

The cost the PM's photo op up in the artic to find a lost ship that could never be recovered. Cost to the RCN was a naval base up in northern Canada.
The funds used for the PM's little show, could have activated a naval base that would have allowed ships to operate in those artic waters year round.
It not easy to keep ships up there when they have to stage from Halifax.
The base would have to be in an area that was ice free (an icebreaker frozen into the ice is in most cases a stuck icebreaker)

Do you honestly believe that the cost of constructing a forward naval base in the arctic is the same as the cost of a largely privately funded expedition to find the remains of H.M.S. Erebus and H.M.S. Terror?

The U.S. Coast Guard stages its Arctic and Antarctic Ice Breakers from Seattle, Washington.
 
Ships are hyper-expensive and to the GoC it is more important that the spending creates jobs for Canadians than deliver suitable ships in a realistic time frame. Few people will vote for a Party because they gave new ships to the Navy in an expeditious and cost-effective manner. Many people will vote for a Party that creates long-term jobs for Canadians in the ship building industry and its ancillaries. So, we wait.
 
Modern naval warfare (theory) is an incredibly unknown experience and one that seemss that if/when it comes we may be in for another Jutland style mutual massacre. Modern counter-missile systems have shown woefully underwhelming performance in the few situations where they have been needed, and most worryingly this poor showing was in a single-digit (or single, period) incoming threat situation.

Naval doctrine dictates "saturating" the enemy's defenses with a storm of hundreds of anti-ship missiles at once. At the same time we know that modern warships have been down-armoured to a point where any direct hit is generally a mission-kill that will take said ship out of the fight. Even lower-yield ordnance like an Exocet or Silkworm has clearly been shown as capable of knocking a modern destroyer out of action.

As nobody has real carriers except the USN, any 2nd tier powers that have a naval fight will mostly likely do so with opposing surface action groups, exchanging missile volleys as described above. Who knows? Maybe Aegis & missile defenses in general will do better than expected.... IMO it'll be a bloodbath.

Quantitative or equivalent qualitative parity with the Russian navy is financially infeasible, and anything less than rough parity does nothing to deter or stop a determined battle fleet from violating whatever waters it pleases.

For our strictly defensive purposes we'd be much better off with a larger Air Force, properly equipped for maritime strike against warships. China's nascent blue water navy couldn't stand toe to toe with Russia's, Japan's, or even a single battlegroup of the Royal Navy or USN, but nobody among those would actually seriously try to operate within range of chinese land-based air power for long. Denial of access capability is more than sufficient to defend territorial integrity and air power does this more efficiently than anything else.

Some modern submarines would be a good complimentary capability, such as some of the "obsolete" Los Angeles class the USN are retiring. These were born and bred to cross swords with Russian Akula, Sierra, Tango and Alpha class subs, as well as to hunt their warships. A surface action group (or handful of patrolling frigates) can be tracked and checked by deployment of matching or superior assets, or simply ignored and sailed defiantly past by a real battlegroup. Not so much for the deadly hidden threat of an modern combat sub. Again, access denial capability.
 
I seem to recall hearing that the Brits have some claims to the Northwest Passage because of the Franklin Expedition which, apparently, was flying the British flag (was it the Union Jack at that time or the flag of England?).
In addition to what has already been posted for general interest.

The Union Jack has that nickname because King James VI & I after his ascension to the English Throne made it the Jack for his warships in both the Royal Navy and the Royal Scottish Navy. That was a century before it became a national flag at the time of the Act of Union.

English Red Ensign from the mid 1500's to 1707

250px-English_Red_Ensign_1620.svg.png


Scottish Red Ensign from the early 1600's to 1707

250px-Scottish_Red_Ensign.svg.png


British Red Ensign 1707 - 1801

250px-British-Red-Ensign-1707.svg.png


The canton of the above was the Royal Scottish Navy Jack 1603 - 1707 and the Royal Navy Jack 1603 - 1801.

By the way under the Navigation Acts Scotland was a foreign country, and at the time of the Act of Union the Scots were quite anxious to have access to the English Colonies.
 
Last edited:
CCGS John G. Diefenbaker currently scheduled to join the canadian fleet in 2021.
And since this is a thread about our Navy, we should all note that's a Canadian Coast Guard Ship, not a naval warship.
 
Canada's defense policy is simple: Do nothing and let the U.S. handle it.

You're welcome.

Thank U.S. later.
Roughly right, and good sense too when you're a dozen or so beaver 'sharing' the aspen branches with fifty hungry elephants.
 
What happened to the used sub Canada bought that caught on fire? Still in service?