In this case I must ask "where are the intermediary forms?" ;-)
You mean like this?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoroaster
In this case I must ask "where are the intermediary forms?" ;-)
Yes, fable stories from hundreds of years ago are nice and fluffy but again, it boils down to MAN.
Man created religion with the so called "dos and dont's" of life.
The common DENOMINATOR is......*drum roll*................................................MAN!
Yes, please don't bore me with the benefits of religion, because there are none.
I was brainwashed enough in my early and teen years going to a Catholic school.
Thankfully when I left H.S., life started and my eyes opened.
Then why did so many pre-Christian cultures do things that we find completely abhorrant?
I notice you didn't bother to bother to answer any of the direct questions. Oh well.
You see, you paint yourself a radical by saying there are no benefits to religion, when they are so obvious and scientifically proven. It might be rational to say "the cons outweigh the pros" but to say there are none just shows that you are motivated by something other than reason, some sort of emotional bias that the vast majority of the world does not share.
i see where your coming from..capitalism is GREAT!...only problem is the religious right are a MAJOR supporter and backer of Haper's gov't.....i'm sure he will pay back those who supported him the strongest, by doing their will...what does the religious right want to do in this situation?...IDK, but i'm pretty sure things like abortion, gay marriage and prostitution are gonna be something those people will want to see legislated (or made illegal)...no?
Ask again, I'm not home and in a rush, I'll MORE THAN gladly answer them later today.
Religion is fine as long as people keep it to themselves, but as we see in today's society, a lot of people don't and hence it causes problems.
As long as you keep it to yourself that's fine.
Again, religion didn't just come out of NOWHERE, man created it, M---A---N.
So man innately knew and still knows how to behave, you don't need fabled stories to tell you how to behave, right from wrong.
Abortion should not be legislated. I work in social services. I've seen kids that were born to mothers who didn't want them. Trust me, most of these kids wish they were never born. The lucky ones escape into the system where they become OUR problem, and are often still abused at less than adequate foster homes.
Leave abortion where it is.
While you are working on those other answers, help me with this one.
If man innnately knows right from wrong why did various cultures do things that we now consider universally heinous? Were they just not listening to their true selves?
I got this one. Because people are assholes!!!
Although despite what rld would like to admit, people are assholes regardless of religion.
Right and wrong is universal. It is not a uniquely religious concept.
It existed long before religion and will continue long past the time that we find no more use for religion.
Your constant arguing that people committed heinous acts prior to the inception of religion is irrelevant. It has been proven that people (whether they are Christian, Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, or whatever) continue to commit atrocities and often in the name of god.
Simply because some people chose to ignore the fact that something is morally wrong, prior to religion, doesn't mean the concept wasn't there. It only means that that particular person was an asshole.
i hope not too..and Harpo promised no major changes..i feel better now...but then again ,now the Fords are witch hunting!!...No!
You are making some progress but I still have to disagree on a few of the important points.
Firstly you are talking about individuals. I am talking about entire cultures. IF right and wrong is universal (careful you are starting to sound religious) than how can entire cultures have practices that we now consider universally abhorrant? The odds of all the assholes ending up in one culture are pretty slim...
And if right and wrong are universal, what are those parameters? And who sets them? If you are suggesting that it just comes from a place inside of us...are you not arguing for the soul? Or making an argument with as little evidence as the evidence for god?
But there is no doubt I agree that many people are assholes and will not accept what others suggest is right and wrong. That is what enforcement mechanism are for.
1) "Entire cultures have practices we now consider universally aborrhant". Like the witch hunts? Was that not in the name of god? Was that not "aborrhant"
2) "What are the parameters? And who sets them?" Each man/woman sets their own parameters. For instance, most of us probably feel that cheating on our wives will not damn us to hell. The concept of there being a right and wrong isn't designed by God, but rather an universal understanding that to live in a community of other humans it is necessary to sympathize with your fellow man, and therefore not agitate him unnecessarily.
If man innnately knows right from wrong why did various cultures do things that we now consider universally heinous? Were they just not listening to their true selves?
Note, including our own culture. We also have done, and continue to do, things that are considered universally heinous. For example, the holocaust, Japanese internment camps, or torturing people at Guantanamo Bay.
The "witch hunts" although overplayed in pop culture were terrible and not biblical at all. In fact in many instances they were carried out by secular authorities and courts that the religious authorities tried to stop. The legendary Spanish inquisition is a perfect example.
Your second point actually confuses the hell out of me. Either right and wrong is universal, or right and wrong is set by each man. Which is it? It surely cannot be both. And if it is your "community rule" what does it say about relationships with other communities or members of other communities? Or is the universal truth that man is just one big community?
With regards to my second point. The concept that there is right vs wrong is universal. By concept I mean that the understanding that there is a difference between right and wrong. It has evolved from the need to live in harmony with other humans. It wasn't bestowed upon us, it is ingrained in us from years of evolution. For example, if a pack of prehistoric people were living in a jungle and one killed another over a piece of food, their pack would be weakened. The pack would now be that much less likely to defend themselves from attack, or gather enough food, or hunt large enough animals. So the ones that felt sympathy helped the pack grow, and their pack was able to survive better. The idea that one act is bad, and another is good becomes ingrained in humans.
Incidentally there are actually studies that show that many pack animals exhibit signs of guilt when working against the pack. If presented with food a particular dog might lunge forward and eat before it is his turn, but he will exhibit signs of guilt afterward.
As far as WHAT is considered right and wrong, well that is determined by the individual man. A man living on the street would likely not feel guilty about stealing a loaf of bread. The concept of right and wrong still exists within him, but he feels no guilt over stealing. Simply because he feels no guilt over stealing doesn't mean he will not feel the same way over murder. He himself has established his own parameters for right and wrong acts.
Likely the cultures you speak of were likely trying to survive themselves, or appease some "god". Either way, they will have done it for reasons that they felt justified with.
Now there are also people who have no reason to commit atrocities (murder, rape, theft), those people are assholes.
Okay, that makes sense. I thought by universal you meant that all folks had some sort of inner code. But what you are saying is that people (perhaps taking out certain people with certain mental illnesses) have some sense of right and wrong, but the specifics of what is right and wrong is determined by the individual.
I agree with you on this. But I would suggest that it is only the defeat of this type of individualism through exterior norms of right and wrong that have allowed our species to be so successful.
I disagree. We all naturally choose the most appropriate version of right and wrong. Religion has, if anything, only stood in the way.
The perfect example of this is war. I'm quite certain that the new testament considers killing your fellow man as a sin, even in war. Jesus Christ taught to love and forgive your fellow man, and only to pray for those who persecute you. But men are demonstrably quite capable of feeling very little guilt about killing in war. That's because in a war it is quickly deemed acceptable to kill. It is becomes acceptable because if you do not kill, then you might be killed yourself. Because a soldier is able to change what he considers an acceptable version of right and wrong, he is able to function as a soldier when necessary. And war can be a good thing. There have been revolutions, rebellions and civil wars, all of which brought about good change.