The burning question: So now what?

Some of which brought about good change, not all. Plus it is a very unique reading of even the NT that suggests that it bans war.

Religion has reduced the impact of war, particularly on civilians. The concept of a just war and how a just war should be conducted and the idea that civilians are not legitimate targets have religious origins.

Jesus also said that he does not have a sword should sell his stuff to get one. He was a pretty revolutionary dude.

The NT is also the origin for our ideas about the importance of charity and helping the weak.

Many of our ideas of human rights come from ideas of natural law developed by church thinkers over a thousand years ago.

Religion is a fantastic tool for good when used properly, and can be an equally problematic plague when used improperly.

But for a functioning community, you need communal values and they need to (to a great degree) come from without. Leaving each to make their own moral decisions does not a community or a society make.


War has brought about good change. Their have been countless wars of independence, as well as civil wars, where entire nations stood up against oppressors to fight for their own rights. These wars brought about good change.

And are you declaring that the Geneva conventions were created because of religion? I'm quite certain they were not. You can give credit to religion, but it's simply not the case.

I'm also afraid you have it backwards. Many of our ideas of human rights have come from natural laws that were only adopted by church thinkers, not created.

I also didn't claim that the "NT" bans war. Only that it teaches that killing in war isn't justified. Jesus was very clear when he said "Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, that you may be sons of your Father in heaven." In my opinion that's the son of god telling you that killing in war will result in your not getting into heaven. But still every soldier out there, regardless of their religion, feels that killing in war is justified.

I agree that religion could be a fantastic tool for good, but only in the same way that a nuclear bomb can be a fantastic tool for good (COULD being the operative word).
 
War has brought about good change. Their have been countless wars of independence, as well as civil wars, where entire nations stood up against oppressors to fight for their own rights. These wars brought about good change.

And are you declaring that the Geneva conventions were created because of religion? I'm quite certain they were not. You can give credit to religion, but it's simply not the case.

I'm also afraid you have it backwards. Many of our ideas of human rights have come from natural laws that were only adopted by church thinkers, not created.

I also didn't claim that the "NT" bans war. Only that it teaches that killing in war isn't justified. Jesus was very clear when he said "Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, that you may be sons of your Father in heaven." In my opinion that's the son of god telling you that killing in war will result in your not getting into heaven. But still every soldier out there, regardless of their religion, feels that killing in war is justified.

I agree that religion could be a fantastic tool for good, but only in the same way that a nuclear bomb can be a fantastic tool for good (COULD being the operative word).

As long as you will concede that there were lots of wars that were no good...

There are no "natural laws" in the moral sense. they are a human construct. Are you suggesting that our very sophisticated morality was just lying around in a forest waiting to be discovered?

And yes, if you trace the history of the laws of war you will find that they come very much from religion. It goes back to medieval concepts which were church driven.

Splitting the atom is good and bad. But it is here to stay.
 
While you are working on those other answers, help me with this one.

If man innnately knows right from wrong why did various cultures do things that we now consider universally heinous? Were they just not listening to their true selves?


What other answers? Ask, I'll answer, gladly.

As for the innately heinous acts, because man by nature is violent, however, not EVERY single person is this way, but that doesn't mean they don't have it in them.
Like I said, people have it in them to know right from wrong, they just have to gauge the reactions of others to understand the consequences of their actions.
Again, as the most simple of examples, you don't need religion to tell you that punching the shit out of someone is bad, when their reaction will be to do the same to you, or to scream bloody murder or to cry in pain.
It's really that simple.

While religion's fables are very sweet and lovely (lol) and do have some nice lessons in which man can learn from, these "stories" are written from (the) EXPERIENCE (of man).
 
What other answers? Ask, I'll answer, gladly.

As for the innately heinous acts, because man by nature is violent, however, not EVERY single person is this way, but that doesn't mean they don't have it in them.
Like I said, people have it in them to know right from wrong, they just have to gauge the reactions of others to understand the consequences of their actions.
Again, as the most simple of examples, you don't need religion to tell you that punching the shit out of someone is bad, when their reaction will be to do the same to you, or to scream bloody murder or to cry in pain.
It's really that simple.

While religion's fables are very sweet and lovely (lol) and do have some nice lessons in which man can learn from, these "stories" are written from (the) EXPERIENCE (of man).

Actually, many people do need an external force to stop them from doing things that are immoral/dysfunctional.

Just look around you.

And a great deal of religion is history and philosophy. Not fable. I am sure you know the difference.

And if a society can be run effectively without religion, why did every culture that existed develop religion, quite often independently?

There is a better argument for religion as universal than specific morals.
 
In the face of a conservative majority government... what will become of the pending court case regarding prostitution laws?

Nothing.

Laws will still be subject to judicial review under the Charter, and constitutional amendments can't be unilaterally made by a majority federal government.
 
By the way Don Draper, that is one pretty sig pic woman.

Yup, she's a looker.

She burns eggs and even fucks up cereal. She dances awful and bites her nails...

ycEbm.jpg


...but she managed to get re-elected.

That's gotta say something!
​
 
Nothing.

Laws will still be subject to judicial review under the Charter, and constitutional amendments can't be unilaterally made by a majority federal government.

I wish it was that simple. If the law is found by the Ont C of A and the Supremes, the government has a couple of options. First they can draft a new law, that may (or may not) be more restrictive that they think passes the constitutional test. Of they can pass a law very similar to the old one and invoke the notwithstanding clause when they draft it. I don't think this federal government will take this loss lying down (if it happens). They have too much of a "family values" and "law and order" bent to do so.

I don't think this government will be good for sex trade workers.
 
Actually, many people do need an external force to stop them from doing things that are immoral/dysfunctional.

This is where civil laws come into play, you don't NEED religion for it.



And a great deal of religion is history and philosophy. Not fable. I am sure you know the difference.

Ahhh, there we go, I was waiting for you to bring up PHILOSOPHY, hook, line, sinker? lol
Miletus, Plato, Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, etc, etc....
MEN contemplating man's mind, their own minds, their will, their inner selves, their personal values, why man acts the way he does.
Did I stress the word "MEN"?

And if a society can be run effectively without religion, why did every culture that existed develop religion, quite often independently?

Fear of the unknown, that's how it all started, fear of the unknown.
You can't honestly tell me you believe that Adam & Eve, an apple tree and a snake were the start of all this now can you?
You just said every culture developed its own religion independently.
There's HUGE irony in that statement because in order to develop their own version of religion, it requires MAN to consider the values, the belief system according to their point(s) of view.
Men thought these things through, a la, philosophy which you so kindly mentioned and was hoping you would. :)



In this day and age, religion is A HUGE business for the Catholic church all over the world, the Vatican is worth billions if not hundreds of billions at this point.
It (religion) more likely than not, started out as MAN'S reasoning and justification for the way things happened around them which they couldn't explain.
Then it turned to be a way to control the masses and now, as I stated earlier, it's a money making machine.
Now I'm not saying every religion is like this (when I say they're money making), but there's no doubt that it certainly plays a part in it.
 
This is where civil laws come into play, you don't NEED religion for it.





Ahhh, there we go, I was waiting for you to bring up PHILOSOPHY, hook, line, sinker? lol
Miletus, Plato, Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, etc, etc....
MEN contemplating man's mind, their own minds, their will, their inner selves, their personal values, why man acts the way he does.
Did I stress the word "MEN"?



Fear of the unknown, that's how it all started, fear of the unknown.
You can't honestly tell me you believe that Adam & Eve, an apple tree and a snake were the start of all this now can you?
You just said every culture developed its own religion independently.
There's HUGE irony in that statement because in order to develop their own version of religion, it requires MAN to consider the values, the belief system according to their point(s) of view.
Men thought these things through, a la, philosophy which you so kindly mentioned and was hoping you would. :)



In this day and age, religion is A HUGE business for the Catholic church all over the world, the Vatican is worth billions if not hundreds of billions at this point.
It (religion) more likely than not, started out as MAN'S reasoning and justification for the way things happened around them which they couldn't explain.
Then it turned to be a way to control the masses and now, as I stated earlier, it's a money making machine.
Now I'm not saying every religion is like this (when I say they're money making), but there's no doubt that it certainly plays a part in it.

You will note that nowhere did I suggest my view of the value in religion requires any supernatural force. I plan to discuss it purely pragmatically.

I don't know off the top of my head, but I think all of the philosophers you named believed in a power greater than they. They embraced religion and its value.

I am not suggesting that there is one true religion (there might be but I will be damned if I know), I am suggesting religion has a high value.

Do you have a problem with religions accumulating money? Do you think capitalism is bad?

People's comments about how it is used to control the masses are fairly ignorant of history. The vast majority of historical churches taught things because they believed they were the word of god. It is secular institutions that tend to use power for its own sake. It is not to say there were not bad apples, but overall most historical religious leaders seem to be genuine, even if we disagree with what they think.

And the profit level and greed of the church is way down. But by focusing on their income you are unfairly only telling one side of the story. While the Catholic Church may indeed have a lot of capital, how much does it expend each year in charitable endevours? And the fact is that religious people tend to give more to charities and do more volunteer work than do secular people.
 
When speaking of religion, it's 99.999% of the time implicit that behind whatever religion is being discussed there is a deity of sorts, name him/her/it whatever you like, but there is a "supernatural force".
But, you're taking the pragmatic route on this one, gotcha, nice way to cover your behind now. lolll

My point in regards to the philosophers was, they were thinkers, they thought about anything and everything, from the basics of math, to understanding the things around them, understanding man's mind and how man did and should live his life.
Not sure if you heard of this one, but Plato is notorious for his work called The Republic, it had to do with the understanding of man and living in a just society.
Ever hear of his allegory of the Cave? I was impressed when I studied this in school because of its simplicity yet how effective it was in explaining things to this day.
So keep this in mind when reading about it, it's man trying to understand man and his behaviour, universal "truths", etc...


As for religions accumulating money, I do have a problem with it yes.
When the Pope (I'll attack this one since I was raised as a Catholic, so no bias) preaches to help the poor, I'm thinking to myself, sell the gold that the Vatican owns, forget the Prada shoes, forget all the fancy shit, wear a simple robe and practice what you preach.
Nothing wrong with capitalism.


As for profit level and greed being down? Probably because people are smartening the hell up, maybe you should as well. :)

The Catholic church is a money making machine and while its intentions on the surface may be to "help people find God, bla bla bla", underneath it all, it's about creating a following, holding that following and getting money from that following...
...oh and controlling the masses.

As for their wealth...
http://www.chick.com/reading/books/153/153_10.asp
http://www.rumormillnews.com/cgi-bin/archive.cgi?read=68927

'If anyone wishes to be perfect, sell what you have, and give it to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven (Mark 10:21

Jesus: "How hard it is for those who have wealth to enter the kingdom of God!'"


Need I go on about the hypocrisy and the Catholic church? Just one of the many Christian variants full of it.


Man created religion out of unknown factors way back when.
 
Last edited:
When speaking of religion, it's 99.999% of the time implicit that behind whatever religion is being discussed there is a deity of sorts, name him/her/it whatever you like, but there is a "supernatural force".
But, you're taking the pragmatic route on this one, gotcha, nice way to cover your behind now. lolll

My point in regards to the philosophers was, they were thinkers, they thought about anything and everything, from the basics of math, to understanding the things around them, understanding man's mind and how man did and should live his life.
Not sure if you heard of this one, but Plato is notorious for his work called The Republic, it had to do with the understanding of man and living in a just society.
Ever hear of his allegory of the Cave? I was impressed when I studied this in school because of its simplicity yet how effective it was in explaining things to this day.
So keep this in mind when reading about it, it's man trying to understand man and his behaviour, universal "truths", etc...


As for religions accumulating money, I do have a problem with it yes.
When the Pope (I'll attack this one since I was raised as a Catholic, so no bias) preaches to help the poor, I'm thinking to myself, sell the gold that the Vatican owns, forget the Prada shoes, forget all the fancy shit, wear a simple robe and practice what you preach.
Nothing wrong with capitalism.


As for profit level and greed being down? Probably because people are smartening the hell up, maybe you should as well. :)

The Catholic church is a money making machine and while its intentions on the surface may be to "help people find God, bla bla bla", underneath it all, it's about creating a following, holding that following and getting money from that following...
...oh and controlling the masses.

As for their wealth...
http://www.chick.com/reading/books/153/153_10.asp
http://www.rumormillnews.com/cgi-bin/archive.cgi?read=68927

'If anyone wishes to be perfect, sell what you have, and give it to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven (Mark 10:21

Jesus: "How hard it is for those who have wealth to enter the kingdom of God!'"


Need I go on about the hypocrisy and the Catholic church? Just one of the many Christian variants full of it.


Man created religion out of unknown factors way back when.

You can go back and check all of my posts, none of them rely on the supernatural. Whether or not god exists is unprovable and doesn't lead very far in a discussion. If you are curious if I think there is a god, I will tell you quite honestly that I don't know.

I have read Plato, and Socrates and Aristotle, but not the other chap so I didn't want to lump him in. The other three were surely believers in god.

How much do Catholic charities give out each year? Do they save and improve lives? Why is it that religious people are more charitable? There are also studies that show religion is good for your health and mental health.

Your quotes from scripture don't match your argument. The church does not get access to heaven, individuals do. And while many televangelists in the US spend the money on lavish living, which I think is wrong, the RC's do not.

What is the improper motive behind the church's accumulation of capital? They arn't blowing it on strippers and coke. They are using it for what they believe on legitimate religious ends. There is nothing inherently wrong with that.

Besides, they need the money to pay lawsuit settlements...
 
I like how you just simply say the philosophers believed in God and that's it. LOL
NOTHING in regards to their contribution to present day philosophy, ideas of justice, universal truths, etc, WOW.
Guess it's hard to admit that they (MEN), contributed to society in what man's role is, should be and how he should act - as well as the profound impact they had on modern day societies.

The quotes match just fine, because those leading the church should lead by example, don't wear the prada, sell the Vatican, move into smaller dwellings, sell the priceless art, the gold, the whatever else they own that's tangible and valuable.
If they did this, then maybe they'd garner more support and less attacks for clearly obvious reasons.

Strippers and coke? Wouldn't put it past them.
As for the lawsuits, they settled a few times did they not? Wonder why.

They need to shut shop up, clean house and refocus what they're preaching and what they're doing.
Sell off the real valuable stuff and time to buck up and donate, do as the guy who walked on water said to do.

...and this is just ONE religion and denomination of many.
Imagine if all the others cleaned house?
 
I like how you just simply say the philosophers believed in God and that's it. LOL
NOTHING in regards to their contribution to present day philosophy, ideas of justice, universal truths, etc, WOW.
Guess it's hard to admit that they (MEN), contributed to society in what man's role is, should be and how he should act - as well as the profound impact they had on modern day societies.

The quotes match just fine, because those leading the church should lead by example, don't wear the prada, sell the Vatican, move into smaller dwellings, sell the priceless art, the gold, the whatever else they own that's tangible and valuable.
If they did this, then maybe they'd garner more support and less attacks for clearly obvious reasons.

Strippers and coke? Wouldn't put it past them.
As for the lawsuits, they settled a few times did they not? Wonder why.

They need to shut shop up, clean house and refocus what they're preaching and what they're doing.
Sell off the real valuable stuff and time to buck up and donate, do as the guy who walked on water said to do.

...and this is just ONE religion and denomination of many.
Imagine if all the others cleaned house?

I don't denigrate what all the great philosophers or scientists have done for society, we just were not talking about that. We can have a philosophy science love in any time you like.

Does the Pope wear Prada, and if he does...does he pay for it?

It strikes me a tad presumptuous that you are telling an organization to sell all of its tangible assets now, when you can't even answer basic questions about how much Catholic Charities spend every year and how they are financed.

And if they sold all that stuff, then they would just have cash and have to manage it some way for the long term.

They pay settlements because they have members who committ wrongs that have to be compensated for. Just like any other organization.

Do you have a problem with what they are preaching and doing? Their moral teachings are legitimate and sound, even if I don't agree with some of them.
 
Nice to see you have softened your stance in that man innately knows the difference between right and wrong and doesn't NEED religion to figure that out, maybe YOU have finally seen the proverbial "light".
More irony, see how that works?



As for the Pope, get rid of the Prada, the gold encrusted (fill in blank here _______), keep things simple, keep the message simple and then maybe he (and the rest of the Catholic church) won't be seen as such hypocrites.
Something I came across in regards to gold and the Vatican.
http://www.godlikeproductions.com/forum1/message1426710/pg1
Video near the bottom.


Done here, since you've softened your stance a fair bit, accepted (albeit indirectly, don't blame you) that man inherently knows right from wrong (philosophers were the proof of this), etc, etc.

Btw, you said earlier "Then why did so many pre-Christian cultures do things that we find completely abhorrant?"
How about those Christian Crusades? Some pretty nasty stuff they did in the name of religion, so much for "love thy neighbour" or "turning the other cheek". lol

Anyways, great debate though, enjoyed it. :)
 
My thought is that the conservatives want to stay in power after this Term, so they won't do anything drastic that would put that in danger.
 
My thought is that the conservatives want to stay in power after this Term, so they won't do anything drastic that would put that in danger.

You're right, but I would still expect them to do something obnoxious towards the end of their first year, so that by the time of the next election it's 3 year old news and no longer drives votes.
 
Nice to see you have softened your stance in that man innately knows the difference between right and wrong and doesn't NEED religion to figure that out, maybe YOU have finally seen the proverbial "light".
More irony, see how that works?



As for the Pope, get rid of the Prada, the gold encrusted (fill in blank here _______), keep things simple, keep the message simple and then maybe he (and the rest of the Catholic church) won't be seen as such hypocrites.
Something I came across in regards to gold and the Vatican.
http://www.godlikeproductions.com/forum1/message1426710/pg1
Video near the bottom.


Done here, since you've softened your stance a fair bit, accepted (albeit indirectly, don't blame you) that man inherently knows right from wrong (philosophers were the proof of this), etc, etc.

Btw, you said earlier "Then why did so many pre-Christian cultures do things that we find completely abhorrant?"
How about those Christian Crusades? Some pretty nasty stuff they did in the name of religion, so much for "love thy neighbour" or "turning the other cheek". lol

Anyways, great debate though, enjoyed it. :)

Quite enjoyed it as well. Hope to chat again in the future.
 
It will be about another 18 mths. before this gets to the Supreme Court, and i would think it would be pretty much status quo until then. If the SC decides that these laws are unconstitutional then the gov't will be hard pressed to put anything in its' place that would pass a charter challenge. If the SC upholds the laws as they are, then it will be business as usual.
This should get to the SC before Harper gets to stack the court.
The large majority of Canadians are socially liberal and economic conservatives and they voted in the Cons for their economic policies and for stability, they didn't vote them in to legislate morality. Canadian governments have to govern from the centre, if Harper doesn't do this and he follows a right wing ideologically driven agenda over the next few years, he'll be voted out of office.
 
If the SC decides that these laws are unconstitutional then the gov't will be hard pressed to put anything in its' place that would pass a charter challenge.

Why ever would you believe that? Certainly they couldn't pass the SAME laws again. The issue put forward is harm, the government would need to understand the exact sort of harm the SC was worried about, and legislate around those specific issues. Again, a law criminalizing pimps and customers might cut it.

In any case you can bet the government will have a whole raft of lawyers look at it and come back with an analysis of exactly what they can legislate, and you can bet they will do so, if it comes to that point.
 
It will be about another 18 mths. before this gets to the Supreme Court, and i would think it would be pretty much status quo until then. If the SC decides that these laws are unconstitutional then the gov't will be hard pressed to put anything in its' place that would pass a charter challenge. If the SC upholds the laws as they are, then it will be business as usual.
This should get to the SC before Harper gets to stack the court.
The large majority of Canadians are socially liberal and economic conservatives and they voted in the Cons for their economic policies and for stability, they didn't vote them in to legislate morality. Canadian governments have to govern from the centre, if Harper doesn't do this and he follows a right wing ideologically driven agenda over the next few years, he'll be voted out of office.

My question is, if the SPs lose the appeal at the C of A, will they go the next step?