T.O. at it again .....

  • Thread starter Thread starter OnTheWayOut
  • Start date Start date
Captain Fantastic said:
I agree. Unless the quarterback is a true franchise-type with no red flags, then I would always go with a qualified, high-end offensive or defensive lineman with a top draft pick.

Sexy doesn't win NFL championships - dominating and rugged line play does.

I agree 100%. Everything starts up-front on both sides of the ball. Line-play is what its about.

Though being a Falcons fan I know that a lot of people in the organization were trying to get Dimitroff to draft Glenn Dorsey as he was the "safe-pick". Dimitroff took a gamble and it has paid huge dividends. Forget about rookie of the year, Matt Ryan is the rookie of the decade. But generally I agree with your rule of thumb. Its hit and miss though, raiders drafted Robert Gallery who was expected to be a big time LT and he has not lived up to expectations and has even been moved to guard.

Last years SB champs, I would argue that the D-Line of the Giants was the difference in that game, that and def coordinator Steve Spagnola.
 
ckupets04 said:
I agree 100%. Everything starts up-front on both sides of the ball. Line-play is what its about.

Though being a Falcons fan I know that a lot of people in the organization were trying to get Dimitroff to draft Glenn Dorsey as he was the "safe-pick". Dimitroff took a gamble and it has paid huge dividends. Forget about rookie of the year, Matt Ryan is the rookie of the decade. But generally I agree with your rule of thumb. Its hit and miss though, raiders drafted Robert Gallery who was expected to be a big time LT and he has not lived up to expectations and has even been moved to guard.

Last years SB champs, I would argue that the D-Line of the Giants was the difference in that game, that and def coordinator Steve Spagnola.
Of course there are exceptions. But if you scratch the surface, you can see why Matt Ryan has been very good and Robert Gallery has not lived up to the hype.

Ryan played for a lousy Boston College team with little talent at the skill positions and on the O-line, but performed exceptionally well in big games anyway and was remarkably mature and prepared leading up to the draft.

Robert Gallery played in the Big-10, an overrated conference with only one exceptional team (THE Ohio State Buckeyes). He has short(ish) arms and was (is) stiff and lacked athleticism. He was slightly below average at tackle, but he can still play in the league at guard, which is more than high draft busts like Tim Couch, Akili Smith, David Carr, etc., were able to do. Even Tony Mandarich became a serviceable guard for the Indianapolis Colts after washing out in Green Bay.

High-end lineman (especially O-linemen) usually succeed or are at least functional on some level in the NFL. Too many top quarterbacks wash out to take a chance on anything less than a sure thing (especially given the money involved - QBs always get paid more and generally take longer to develop than other positions drafted in the same slot.)

As for Glenn Dorsey, the jury's still out. The Chiefs are a lousy team with bad coaching and terrible management. They have no one else on the D-line to take the heat off GD. I would still give him time... the last time I saw a defensive tackle that consistently disruptive in college football was with some guy named Warren Sapp.