Surge protector for the house circuit panel

Cobster

New member
Apr 29, 2002
10,420
0
0
Anyone have any installed? If so, any brand recommendations at all?
I'm helping a friend to try and find a good brand to install.
I didn't know about these until I came across a Holmes on Homes show and then I told my friend about it and now she wants one.

Here's a link to an article about them
http://www.hometipsplus.com/home-tech/how-to-choose-the-best-surge-protector-for-your-house/

and this
http://www.feckalona.com/surge.html

But now it's all about brand, our choice are somewhat limited here in Canada, we only seem to carry Schneider in Home Depot and Rona. So I thought I'd ask if anyone had any experience with these here.

Kinda makes sense to have one, considering they run about $200 and protect your circuit panel and in turn all your appliances and electronics plugged in.
I figure if you have 2-3 surge protectors for computers and electronics, that's $75 right there, add another $100 and you protect your entire house.
 
Can't comment on their surge suppressors, but Schneider Electrics breakers are in wide use. Never seen a problem with either the Square D or Stab-Lok ones they make.

You might have to hit an electrical supplies place if you're looking for different brands.
 
I've never installed one (or seen one in the wild) and I don't see the point installing one where I am cause I'm in a condo. If I lived in a house I'd definitely put one in though. The odds are you'll never need it, but that could be said for a lot of insurance. For the price I'm surprised they are not more common.

Schneider make good products. They are all just about as good as each other except I personally don't like federal pioneer panels (the white stablok kind). The breakers are too flimsy inside the panel but that's just personal preference.
 
I installed one after a surge took out my older tube tv,dishwasher, microwave and fridge. I didn't realize that many modern fridges have a computer board in them!

I will have to check the brand when I am back home,

I did a fair bit of research and this is what I learned.

1. Surge protectors don't last for ever. They can only take so many surges and then they must be replaced. I had an old one on my TV that got fried.
2. A whole house protector is a good first defense for a large surge, but you still need smaller protectors on all of your electronics.
3. Size the surge protector correctly for each device.
4. The difference in price on panel protectors was largely the difference in the damage warranty provided.
5. There are plenty of options available from electrical suppliers. Westburne etc.

Cheers
 
I have two surge suppressors mounted directly on the mains panel. Two because I have two panels in this solar almost off the grid house - one is for general loads and one is for "critical loads" with the direct solar and or battery back-up. Some years ago the house took a direct lightning hit and the one suppressors blew out thus saving the entire system. For $100 it was a great investment. Can't think of the brand right now (I am at work) but I will check and report back.

Other systems are designed to act as suppressor and voltage lock, so that each side of neutral remains the same, especially useful if a transformer at the road goes wonky and sends weird levels. These are more expensive and rare. It all depends on the value of the material you are protecting. Think of it as insurance.
 
Surge protectors and breakers are a one shot deal for any short circuit application. If they trip under overcircuit applications they are okay to reset but if they take a short circuit hit they are not reliable and should be replaced.
 
For the life of me, I can't understand how those whole house surge protectors are effective. They are probably useful in that any sacrificial component near a lightning strike will bear the brunt of the strike. Other than that, they do not have the surge capability to either survive the nastier power disruptions, like a broken neutral, or to blow the breaker and cut power.

As an engineer, every time I get involved with a situation involving flaky power (aka: "flickering lights"), the only piece of equipment capable of limiting the damage is a self-regulating isolation transformer. Everything else, like a UPS, or surge-protectors, either does nothing, or burns out after a while. The typical UPS is not rated for continuous use.

Lesson: Never underestimate the usefulness of a well-designed isolation transformer that isolates the load from the supply side problem.
 
Surge protectors and breakers are a one shot deal for any short circuit application. If they trip under overcircuit applications they are okay to reset but if they take a short circuit hit they are not reliable and should be replaced.

Breakers come from the factory in the tripped position. That's because they are tested before being shipped out. I don't know if it's done with over current or short circuit though.
 
For the life of me, I can't understand how those whole house surge protectors are effective. They are probably useful in that any sacrificial component near a lightning strike will bear the brunt of the strike. Other than that, they do not have the surge capability to either survive the nastier power disruptions, like a broken neutral, or to blow the breaker and cut power.

As an engineer, every time I get involved with a situation involving flaky power (aka: "flickering lights"), the only piece of equipment capable of limiting the damage is a self-regulating isolation transformer. Everything else, like a UPS, or surge-protectors, either does nothing, or burns out after a while. The typical UPS is not rated for continuous use.

Lesson: Never underestimate the usefulness of a well-designed isolation transformer that isolates the load from the supply side problem.

Power conditioners have been in use for a couple of decades or so, on the IT side of the industry.
Pretty much does what you are referring to.

But as you know that if you experience a floating transformer ground, on the supply side it will go crispy critter.
As will anything that requires regulated power.
 
For the life of me, I can't understand how those whole house surge protectors are effective. They are probably useful in that any sacrificial component near a lightning strike will bear the brunt of the strike. Other than that, they do not have the surge capability to either survive the nastier power disruptions, like a broken neutral, or to blow the breaker and cut power.

As an engineer, every time I get involved with a situation involving flaky power (aka: "flickering lights"), the only piece of equipment capable of limiting the damage is a self-regulating isolation transformer. Everything else, like a UPS, or surge-protectors, either does nothing, or burns out after a while. The typical UPS is not rated for continuous use.

Lesson: Never underestimate the usefulness of a well-designed isolation transformer that isolates the load from the supply side problem.

Please enlighten me as to how and why a broken neutral is so nasty. I'm curious.

Also, if you wanted to protect a typical 100 amp residential service, how is that best accomplished? I have no idea what an Isolation Transformer is, or how one would go about hooking it up to a residential service.
 
Please enlighten me as to how and why a broken neutral is so nasty. I'm curious.

Also, if you wanted to protect a typical 100 amp residential service, how is that best accomplished? I have no idea what an Isolation Transformer is, or how one would go about hooking it up to a residential service.


Isolation transformer sounds pricey, but I'm with James, enlighten us. :)
 
Breakers come from the factory in the tripped position. That's because they are tested before being shipped out. I don't know if it's done with over current or short circuit though.

They come in the tripped state but are not short circuited, they are tested for tripping at the rate set by the breaker. They come in the tested state, if they suffer a fault current they are done. If you continue to use a breaker in this condition it provides no use as a protection device. I have personally seen a 15 amp breaker not trip out at 56 amps measured by a amp meter. They will provide power but will not protect the circuit or the wire that it feeds.
 
Please enlighten me as to how and why a broken neutral is so nasty. I'm curious.

The broken neutral is pretty nasty. Essentially, power comes into the house as 240 (V) with a center Neutral (Common) conductor, which corresponds to the 1/2 way point (240V * 1/2 = 120V). The 120(V) plugs around the house hook to the 240 (V) blacks, and the Neutral (Common) white conductor, which only contains one half of the 240(V) potential.

If you lose the Neutral, then any voltage between 0 and 240(V) can appear on any plug throughout the house. Often, the loads vary depending on which appliances are consuming current, and the precise voltage on any given load is unpredictable. Often 80-90(V) and 140-180(V) are seen on each side of the line.

The issues with many surge suppressors are:
(1) most surge suppressors are rated at 300(V) so they will do nothing, and
(2) most surge suppressors lack the wattage / power dissipation to blow a breaker, and will burn out rather than disconnecting the power.
Additionally, I suspect surge suppressor designers deliberately use 300(V) components so as to minimise warranty claims.

Another issue with broken neutrals is that they can be "flaky". People can endure a rather large number of equipment failures before anyone notices. Broken neutrals are very rare. However, when they occur, they are very expensive.

Isolation transformers can convert 240(V) into 120(V), and establish a new neutral. A self-regulating transformer can convert a wide range of input power levels into 120(V). Both transformers can be very effective at suppressing severe EMI disturbances, like nearby lightning strikes, by simply saturating and refusing to pass the energy into the secondary. A sufficiently close lightning hit will simply destroy everything in its path to ground, so the protection is not perfect.

In industrial settings, large motors are notorious for generating severe problems on the ground and neutral conductors. Measuring 300(V) and 70(A) on a ground conductor is not uncommon. Most PCs will not survive a neutral to ground voltage of 300(V). An isolation transformer will make neutral=ground again.
 
I have personally seen a 15 amp breaker not trip out at 56 amps measured by a amp meter.

Fuses will not blow instantly until the load consumes 5 times the rated current, in this case 75 Amps. A fast blow fuse can take over 1/2 hour to blow against a 2 times rated current overload.

Circuit breakers are poorer overload devices than fuses.

It is likely that if you test brand new 15 (A) circuit breakers, most will not disconnect instantly against a 56 (A) load.
 
They come in the tripped state but are not short circuited, they are tested for tripping at the rate set by the breaker. They come in the tested state, if they suffer a fault current they are done. If you continue to use a breaker in this condition it provides no use as a protection device. I have personally seen a 15 amp breaker not trip out at 56 amps measured by a amp meter. They will provide power but will not protect the circuit or the wire that it feeds.

Hence the beauty of good ole fashioned fuses.

They blow 100% of the time.
 
The broken neutral is pretty nasty. Essentially, power comes into the house as 240 (V) with a center Neutral (Common) conductor, which corresponds to the 1/2 way point (240V * 1/2 = 120V). The 120(V) plugs around the house hook to the 240 (V) blacks, and the Neutral (Common) white conductor, which only contains one half of the 240(V) potential.

If you lose the Neutral, then any voltage between 0 and 240(V) can appear on any plug throughout the house. Often, the loads vary depending on which appliances are consuming current, and the precise voltage on any given load is unpredictable. Often 80-90(V) and 140-180(V) are seen on each side of the line.

The issues with many surge suppressors are:
(1) most surge suppressors are rated at 300(V) so they will do nothing, and
(2) most surge suppressors lack the wattage / power dissipation to blow a breaker, and will burn out rather than disconnecting the power.
Additionally, I suspect surge suppressor designers deliberately use 300(V) components so as to minimise warranty claims.

Another issue with broken neutrals is that they can be "flaky". People can endure a rather large number of equipment failures before anyone notices. Broken neutrals are very rare. However, when they occur, they are very expensive.

Isolation transformers can convert 240(V) into 120(V), and establish a new neutral. A self-regulating transformer can convert a wide range of input power levels into 120(V). Both transformers can be very effective at suppressing severe EMI disturbances, like nearby lightning strikes, by simply saturating and refusing to pass the energy into the secondary. A sufficiently close lightning hit will simply destroy everything in its path to ground, so the protection is not perfect.

In industrial settings, large motors are notorious for generating severe problems on the ground and neutral conductors. Measuring 300(V) and 70(A) on a ground conductor is not uncommon. Most PCs will not survive a neutral to ground voltage of 300(V). An isolation transformer will make neutral=ground again.

I'm not an electrical Engineer, but I'm trying to get my head around this broken neutral thing.

You've got a red wire and a black wire coming into a house. They come off the secondary side of the transformer at opposite ends of the coil, with the neutral (white) in the middle.

Devices that run on purely 240 volts (like my Central Air) only need the red and the black, they don't need the white. They then operate at 240 volts. Some things like ovens and driers have a neutral because some components of the oven (maybe the clock or control head) operate at 120 volts, but the burners probably operate at 240. Hence why you see a black, red, and white conductor in the cable.

Now I can understand if a neutral were to break you'd end up with 240 to your clock (say) on the oven and caboom.

But what I don't understand is say a conventional wall recepticle where you only have 2 conductors. A black and white. If the white breaks, you cannot have 240 volts because A) the circuit cannot be completed and B) you've only got one conductor coming off the secondary of the transformer, so you can't complete the circuit to get 240 volts.

I can only see how the broken neutral would affect major appliances where you've got both the black, the red, and the neutral coming in.

But I don't see how if you've got just either black or red and a neutral.

Disconnect the neutral on a single pole 15 amp breaker and your light just goes dark.

I'm Confused???

When I had the old 60 amp service at my house replaced with a 100 amp service, I recall the Toronto Hydro technician telling me that:

First you connect the neutral
Second one of the hot phases
Third, the other hot phase.

He didn't really explain it, but now I think I understand.

BTW, my house was built in 1920 and it had knob and tube wiring when I moved in. The old fuses were actually "fuse pairs" in a ceramic holder. They featured a fused hot AND a fused neutral. I'd never seen anything like that before.
 
But what I don't understand is say a conventional wall recepticle where you only have 2 conductors. A black and white. If the white breaks, you cannot have 240 volts because A) the circuit cannot be completed and B) you've only got one conductor coming off the secondary of the transformer, so you can't complete the circuit to get 240 volts.

BTW, my house was built in 1920 and it had knob and tube wiring when I moved in. The old fuses were actually "fuse pairs" in a ceramic holder. They featured a fused hot AND a fused neutral. I'd never seen anything like that before.

The white breaks outside the house, not at the receptacle. As such, all wires in the receptacle are still connected. The white wire in the fuse box is not connected to anything outside the house. The white wire can float to whatever voltage it likes, depending on what loads are connected inside the house.

At first, the significance of the broken neutral problem was not appreciated. As such, early fuse boxes featured a fused neutral. The fused neutral has since been banned, because if the neutral fuse ever blows, it is possible to have 240(V) on the 120(V) receptacles.
 
The white breaks outside the house, not at the receptacle. As such, all wires in the receptacle are still connected. The white wire in the fuse box is not connected to anything outside the house. The white wire can float to whatever voltage it likes, depending on what loads are connected inside the house.

At first, the significance of the broken neutral problem was not appreciated. As such, early fuse boxes featured a fused neutral. The fused neutral has since been banned, because if the neutral fuse ever blows, it is possible to have 240(V) on the 120(V) receptacles.

Traditionally the NEUTRAL and GROUND are mechanically bonded in the panel.
 
So in talking to a friend, he mentioned I should be concerned with how many KAs it can handle, his cousins said 80KAs should be sufficient, but my friend said 100KAs or more.

Anyone, anyone?