Support For One State Solution Grows

So you are ok with Israel picking authors then?

That would depend on who they picked as the authors.
For instance, picking a probable war criminal who was a major client of Israeli arms is bad, but picking ex-ICC judges is good.
 
That would depend on who they picked as the authors.
For instance, picking a probable war criminal who was a major client of Israeli arms is bad, but picking ex-ICC judges is good.

All sides agreed in advance to the SG's panel, you are being a fanatic.
 
All sides agreed in advance to the SG's panel, you are being a fanatic.

Turkey went in with open expectations only to find that Israel didn't.
Somehow I'm not surprised that you so support the words of a probable war criminal, comes with the territory, after all.

And you still haven't found one legit criticism about the authors that were chosen by the UN HRC.
 
Turkey went in with open expectations only to find that Israel didn't.

Turkey fully and completely endorsed the methods and the people. It had NO objection whatsoever until the result came down partly in Israel's favour.

Apparently you are a fanatic who objects to everything that isn't anti Israeli.

When the panel faulted both sides instead of only Israel you found that intolerable.
 
Turkey fully and completely endorsed the methods and the people. It had NO objection whatsoever until the result came down partly in Israel's favour.

Apparently you are a fanatic who objects to everything that isn't anti Israeli.

When the panel faulted both sides instead of only Israel you found that intolerable.

Turkey raised numerous issues during the process, didn't you read it?
That's why they didn't sign it, but then again either did Israel.

Still can't find anything to fault in the authors of the UN HRC report, though, can you?
Probably the ICC will come up with similar findings, should they decide to take the case on, since the authors were also ex-ICC judges.
 
Turkey did not raise any issues until they saw that the panel was going to accept the legal argument that the naval blockade and border closure were different things. That is the first time they objected -- prior to that they had praised the panel, praised the people who were appointed, praised the mandate and the methods. Only at the point it became clear that the panel was going to find the naval blockade fully and completely legal did they start objecting -- which is really pretty transparent, even a fanatic like you should be able to see that for what it is.

Then panel ALSO found that although the blockade was legal, Israel should have shown more restraint in its operation, and taken more care to avoid a violent confrontation. They could have, and should have, found more indirect ways to capture the flotilla ships, without getting into a fire fight with the terrorist thugs on board. The panel also raised some serious questions about the status of those thugs -- though it didn't look into it further, that really should be looked into, and it's amazing that Turkey has utterly failed to do so.

In any case it was a pretty balanced report on the whole. It found the blockade legal, found that Israel should have shown more restraint, and found that Turkey needs to do more to look into what sort of people it's exporting in these conflicts. In short, it found fault with everybody.

However a fanatic like you can't tolerate that -- you hate the idea that everybody might be at fault, you think only Israel should be to blame for everything, because you're a fanatic who doesn't care about facts.
 
Turkey did not raise any issues until they saw that the panel was going to accept the legal argument that the naval blockade and border closure were different things.

At least you are now admitting that they raised issues during the commission.
As for the rest, you know its opinions are worthless and won't even be raised at the ICC.
You know that the ICC will respect the UN HRC report, with its ex-ICC judges as authors, and throw out the SC report that nobody signed and its probable war criminal author.
 
Again, the UN SG's report is the only one that was set up by a consensus of all parties, whose mandate, methods, and members were all fully endorsed by all concerned parties.

And can you quit the ridiculous meaningless propaganda? What exactly does "report that nobody signed" mean? Do you think anybody signed the UNHRC report? No. No one "signed" any of these reports and none of them have any legal standing -- oh except one. Turkel had legal standing.
 
And can you quit the ridiculous meaningless propaganda? What exactly does "report that nobody signed" mean?

It means neither of the countries that took part, and helped select their own judges, could support the findings of the report.
Nobody backs it.
Not Israel, not Turkey and not the UN, who buried it after its release as an embarrassment.
 
It means neither of the countries that took part, and helped select their own judges, could support the findings of the report.
Nobody backs it.
Not Israel, not Turkey and not the UN, who buried it after its release as an embarrassment.

The same is true of the UNHRC report. Nobody backs it, nobody signed it, and it had no legal standing.

But you don't care because you are a fanatic and you like the propaganda value of that one

The UNHRC report was set up by partisans from one side, with panelists selected by one side, totally excluded the other side, concluded Israel's guilt in its mandate, admitted to having only one side of the story, continued with that mandate anyway, and was ultimately rebuffed in the final report from the UN.

Even if you dislike the final report from the SG, the UNHRC "report" is worse in every way.
 
The same is true of the UNHRC report. Nobody backs it, nobody signed it, and it had no legal standing.

.

That's because the UN HRC report was an actual investigation, where they could call witnesses and look at evidence, instead of the SC report where they were only allowed to see what the two countries wanted them to see, and they couldn't actually call any witnesses. The HRC report didn't need to have the victims or perpetrators sign off on agreeing to the charges, just as you don't at court.
The SC report was supposed to mend diplomatic issues, instead it set them off.
 
That's because the UN HRC report was an actual investigation, where they could call witnesses and look at evidence, instead of the SC report where they were only allowed to see what the two countries wanted them to see, and they couldn't actually call any witnesses. The HRC report didn't need to have the victims or perpetrators sign off on agreeing to the charges, just as you don't at court.
The SC report was supposed to mend diplomatic issues, instead it set them off.

There your go again talking about "charges". There are no charges, the UNHRC does not have that power, it is not a court, not a police force, not a prosecutor, it has no legal standing whatsoever.

It has nothing more than an opinion, one that is incredibly biased and representative of one side.

But thanks for admitting that no one backs it, no one signed off on it, no one supports it.
 
There your go again talking about "charges". There are no charges, the UNHRC does not have that power, it is not a court, not a police force, not a prosecutor, it has no legal standing whatsoever.

It has nothing more than an opinion, one that is incredibly biased and representative of one side.

They said there was enough evidence to support charges:
The three-member mission said there is clear evidence to support prosecutions of crimes such as wilful killing, torture or inhuman treatment, and wilfully causing great suffering or serious injury to body or health.
http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=36086&Cr=flotilla&Cr1#.UZrryOsi0kc
 
That is their biased opinion, an opinion no one endorsed, no one signed off on, that had no legal standing, and was produced by a biased organization that wrote up a biased mandate,entirely excluded one side, admitted it was one sided, and was ultimately rebuffed by the UN in the final report.
 
That is their biased opinion, an opinion no one endorsed, no one signed off on, that had no legal standing, and was produced by a biased organization that wrote up a biased mandate,entirely excluded one side, admitted it was one sided, and was ultimately rebuffed by the UN in the final report.

The UN accepted the report.
The ICC is considering whether to take on the case as we type.
 
The UN accepted the report.

Nope. No one endorsed it, no one supports it, and in fact it was rebuffed by the SG report.

International consensus is with the SG report, that the blockade is lethal but that Israel should have been more careful in carrying out the operation.
 
International consensus is with the SG report, that the blockade is lethal but that Israel should have been more careful in carrying out the operation.

Its true that the international community recognizes that the blockade is lethal, I'll give you that one.

International consensus with the SG report? There isn't even consensus with either of the two participating countries, both of which refused to sign the report.
 
Its true that the international community recognizes that the blockade is lethal, I'll give you that one.

International consensus with the SG report? There isn't even consensus with either of the two participating countries, both of which refused to sign the report.

Lol, legal. That was a typo.

The UN accepted the report.

Nope. No one endorsed it, no one supports it, and in fact it was rebuffed by the SG report.

International consensus is with the SG report, that the blockade is legal but that Israel should have been more careful in carrying out the operation.
 
Lol, legal. That was a typo.



Nope. No one endorsed it, no one supports it, and in fact it was rebuffed by the SG report.

International consensus is with the SG report, that the blockade is legal but that Israel should have been more careful in carrying out the operation.

Which report was submitted to the member nations of the UN and which one was not, lickspitte?