Suing Futureshop

here's the legal mumbo jumbo on the FS site:

Link: http://www.futureshop.ca/informationcentre/en/onlinepolicies.asp?logon=&langid=EN

Most important section:

Misprints

We do our best to provide you with the most up-to-date and accurate information. In the event that an error does occur, we reserve the right to correct or cancel an order at any time, and/or edit an order to reflect the correction, and/or correct the error on our web site. In the event that you are shipped an incorrect product, we will gladly accept the unit back and offer you a full refund.
 
MarkII said:
here's the legal mumbo jumbo on the FS site:

Link: http://www.futureshop.ca/informationcentre/en/onlinepolicies.asp?logon=&langid=EN

Most important section:

I quoted that in his other thread on this subject but as he has "chosen" to ignore it, he wants to go ahead with his legal battle.

Can you imagine what kind of trouble we'd be in if a judge will allow someone to break a contract because they "chose" to ignore a clause? Reminds me of jamie hynamen from Mythbusters when he said "I chose to ignore your reality and substitute it with my own...."
 
tboy said:
Reminds me of jamie hynamen from Mythbusters when he said "I chose to ignore your reality and substitute it with my own...."

*cough* Adam Savage *cough* "I reject your reality and substitute my own!" *cough* ;)
 
Meister said:
I don't think you will get anywhere with punitive damages, but you should be able to receive your computers.

It's not like there was a flyer with a misprint. He actually purchased (and presumably paid for) 71 computers and received e-mail verification. That is a binding contract and FS needs to live up to it.

Even with the disclaimers, I would imagine (I am no lawyer thank God) that it would make a difference if FS took his money, and therefore executed a sale.

Logically (and legally ???), they should have the right to refuse as sale based on a mistake in the flyer or on the web page, but if they accept the sale, ie. take the money, I don't quite see why they should be able to not honor it.
 
danmand said:
...I don't quite see why they should be able to not honor it.

Why not? It was an obvious mistake. Made all the more obvious by the fact they guy purchased a gazillion of them to capitalize on the mistake.

Futureshop made a mistake. They refunded the guy's money. He's not out anything.

It's not like Futureshop gained from a bait n' switch; if anything, they're pissing customers off.
 
It doesn't matter what FS policy is. What matters is competition act. While I couldn't find anything exact I found this. Unfortunately they don't talk about a case where an error occurs, but maybe somebody else can find something.

My view is, if you go to a store and they have a 50 dollar wine bottle for sale for 5 dollars, the store can not turn around and say you can not buy these bottles because we made a mistake on the label.

Double ticketing
Section 54 of the Competition Act, which is a criminal provision, prohibits the supply of a product at a price that exceeds the lowest of two or more prices clearly expressed in respect of the product.

Any person who contravenes section 54, is guilty of an offence and liable to a fine of up to $10,000 and/or imprisonment up to one year on summary conviction.

Additional information

The definition of "supply" includes an offer to sell. This section does not affect shelf stock revaluation if the old price is removed or is obscured so that it is no longer clearly expressed.

In the past, questions have been raised relating to whether the double-ticketing section would prohibit the pricing and sale of identical items of a product at different prices. Retailers have noted that they sometimes may have some older stock, (which may have been received at a lower cost), on display with newer, although identical, stock. They have asked whether a price sticker of $X may be affixed to items of the older stock while a slightly higher price of $Y would be affixed to the newer stock.

In the Commissioner’s view the purpose of the section is to prevent incidents which might deceive or confuse consumers about the price to be charged for a product. In the circumstances described above, it would seem to be clear to potential customers which price was being charged for particular units of the product. Consequently, the Bureau would not take enforcement action under this section where a price of $X was marked on one unit of a product and a price of $Y was marked on another, so long as each was sold at its marked price. This view is also based on the assumption that only one price is clearly expressed on each unit and that there are no other prices displayed at point-of-purchase. It should also be noted that, if the lower price has been advertised, supplying the product at the higher price would be in contravention of section 74.05 respecting sale above advertised price.

Prosecutions under this section have rarely occurred.
 
I think Stinky Nuts is working for Future Shop to give them free publicity. He is doing a good job. He has us all thinking about Future Shop. Good work Stinky!
 
Meister said:
...My view is, if you go to a store and they have a 50 dollar wine bottle for sale for 5 dollars, the store can not turn around and say you can not buy these bottles because we made a mistake on the label.


There is no obligation for the store to sell the product at that price, where a mistake is made. Where the store could get into trouble is if they advertised the $5 wine, only to get publicity and customers in the store, with no intention of selling $5 wine, and then tried to sell you more expensive wine. The stores intent would be to deceive the public. B&S.

It is like the $60 incalls that advertise "young slim beautiful open minded gfe 20yrs girls, no extra charges". and when you arrive they try to sell you a girl that is 50yrs, fat, and has no teeth, and they want $100. This you could report.
 
KBear said:
There is no obligation for the store to sell the product at that price, where a mistake is made. Where the store could get into trouble is if they advertised the $5 wine, only to get publicity and customers in the store, with no intention of selling $5 wine, and then tried to sell you more expensive wine. The stores intent would be to deceive the public. B&S.

It is like the $60 incalls that advertise "young slim beautiful open minded gfe 20yrs girls, no extra charges". and when you arrive they try to sell you a girl that is 50yrs, fat, and has no teeth, and they want $100. This you could report.

Don't you think it makes a difference that they took his money and therefore executed a sale? I agree that they could have refused the sale.
 
they never took his money, when his statement comes there will not be a charge, anyone that has bought from f/s knows the charge comes upon shippng not acceptance.

this thread should be locked for stupidity.
 
kooley said:
they never took his money, when his statement comes there will not be a charge, anyone that has bought from f/s knows the charge comes upon shippng not acceptance.

this thread should be locked for stupidity.

Sorry about annoying you, I was just asking a question, Jeessh.
 
kooley said:
they never took his money, when his statement comes there will not be a charge, anyone that has bought from f/s knows the charge comes upon shippng not acceptance.

this thread should be locked for stupidity.

Wouldn't they run his credit card when he ordered it online?
 
Meister said:
Wouldn't they run his credit card when he ordered it online?

No, the payment isn't processed until the order is processed NOT taken. This way they avoid all kinds of headaches in case their inventory isn't accurate.

Home Depot, F/S, Best Buy, Tenaquip and others are like this.
 
danmand said:
Don't you think it makes a difference that they took his money and therefore executed a sale? I agree that they could have refused the sale.

Don't think it would make a difference. For the contract to be enforceable, both parties have to agree in their minds to the same thing that is on paper. . Something like that anyway. If it is an important issue, would talk to a lawyer, but for this issue, would not waste a lawyers time.
 
This thread shows yet one more example about what is wrong with society and people in general. Decline and fall of western civ and all that. We really need a Minister of Chlorine to clean out that gene pool

But hey, I am a helpfull kinda guy. So if you want to abuse the legal system to steal from others, might I suggest following this role model.


I sued Taco Bell
'Cause I ate half a million Chalupas
And I got fat!

I sued Panasonic
They never said I shouldn't use their microwave
To dry off my cat

Huh, I sued Earthlink
'Cause I called them up
N' they had the nerve to put me on hold

I sued Starbucks
'Cause I spilled a Frappucino in my lap
And brrr, it was cold!

I sued Toys'R'Us
'Cause I swallowed a Nerf ball
And nearly choked to death

Ugh, I sued PetCo
'Cause I ate a bag of kitty litter
And now I got bad breath!

I sued Coca-Cola, yo
'Cause I put my finger down in a bottle
And it got stuck!

I sued Delta Airlines
'Cause they sold me a ticket to New Jersey
I went there, and it sucked!


If you stand me up on a date
If you deliver my pizza 30 seconds late
I'm gonna sue, sue

I sued Duracell
They never told me not to shove that double-A
Right up my nose

I sued Home Depot
'Cause they sold me a hammer
Which they knew I might drop on my toes

I sued Dell Computers
'Cause I took a bath with my laptop
Now it doesn't work

I sued Fruit of the Loom
'Cause when I wear their tightie-whities on my head
I look like a jerk

I sued Verizon
'Cause I get all depressed
Any time my cell phone is roaming

I sued Colorado
'Cause you know, I think it looks a little bit too much
Like Wyoming

I sued Neiman Marcus
'Cause they put up their Christmas decorations
Way out of season

I sued Ben Affleck
...
Aw, do I even need a reason?


If I sprain my ankle
While I'm robbing your place


If I hurt my knuckles
When I punch you in the face
I'm gonna sue, sue


Weird Al Yankovic - I'll Sue Ya Lyrics [edited]
 
Very good one Fatty....VERY good and how, so appropo don't cha think?

Hell, this guy wants to sue because he couldn't rip em off for 71 computers AND make a profit by it.
 
tboy said:
Very good one Fatty....VERY good and how, so appropo don't cha think?

Hell, this guy wants to sue because he couldn't rip em off for 71 computers AND make a profit by it.
FREAKING CAPITOLIST..........and I was pissed they wold not send 100 of them to me in Buffalo. :p
 
Stinky you go for it! I am sure some"ambulance chaser" will see an opportunity to make a buck and will contact you.If he fails, hell sue him for incompetence!