Suing Futureshop

opon asking a friend that workd at fs he told that he had someone that made an online purchace when a mistake was made ..and that the person got the advertised price on line... so good luck..
 
elmufdvr said:
had someone that made an online purchace when a mistake was made ..and that the person got the advertised price on line... so good luck..
the will give with the advertised price for one purchase but I doubt for 71 purchase for 1 person
 
I don’t believe there is any obligation for a store to sell a product at an advertised price. Stores do honor minor mistakes rather then piss off customers.

Also, for a contract to be enforceable, there has to have been a meeting of minds. In this case I doubt that anyone at FS intended to sell computer systems for $29.

You should have ordered one or two computers, and picked them up immediately.
 
Well, I decided to pull up the Competition Act and see what it had to say about this:

74.05 (1) A person engages in reviewable conduct who advertises a product for sale or rent in a market and, during the period and in the market to which the advertisement relates, supplies the product at a price that is higher than the price advertised.

(2) This section does not apply

(a) in respect of an advertisement that appears in a catalogue in which it is prominently stated that the prices contained in it are subject to error if the person establishes that the price advertised is in error;

(b) in respect of an advertisement that is immediately followed by another advertisement correcting the price mentioned in the first advertisement;

So, what we have established is that yes, there is a legal obligation for a store to honour an advertised price, unless they can establish it was an error. From the sounds of things, Future Shop moved quickly to correct the advertisement, so it's unlikely they would have a problem. Now, I don't claim to be a lawyer, nor an expert in these issues, but at first blush it sure looks like Future Shop is free and clear in this. Having said that, you should contact the Competition Bureau and file a complaint if you are so inclined, as they are the ones responsible for investigating misleading advertising practices, and can either take civil action or refer the matter for criminal prosecution.
 
KBear said:
I don’t believe there is any obligation for a store to sell a product at an advertised price. Stores do honor minor mistakes rather then piss off customers.

Also, for a contract to be enforceable, there has to have been a meeting of minds. In this case I doubt that anyone at FS intended to sell computer systems for $29.

You should have ordered one or two computers, and picked them up immediately.

Well, in a sense there IS a law that states that stores have to have items that they have advertised ready for sale or offer rain checks. I don't know if there is a minimum required though. In other words a store can't advertise whatever it likes with no intention of ever stocking or selling an item.

There is also a law about undercutting or pricing an item below cost. There are certain rules that have to be followed in order for a store to do that. That is why walmart hasn't cornered the market in Canada like it did in the U.S. There, they built stores encircling a city or town, cut prices to below cost to drive the competition out of business, then raised the prices to a profitable level.

With that being said I don't believe there is a law that states that a store MUST sell an item to anyone in particular that in some way they reserve the right to a) limit quantities and b) refuse a sale. If they didn't, customers could demand all sorts of things.
 
Sue them and...

stinkynuts said:
Hi,

I am unclear as to what happened my order with Futureshop. I called to confirm my order, and it was verified via an automated system.

For those of you who are not aware of what happened, Futureshop had an online ad for an Acer computer and monitor for $29, marked down from $800+. They corrected the ad, which now has the computer selling for $650, a discount of $150 or so. I placed three separate orders for a total of 71 of them.

I strongly believe that Futureshop deliberately made the error in order to gain publicity and to increase sales. I could understand if they wanted to take $30 off the price and accidently made that the final price instead (even though that seems unlikely). But to have completely different prices being switched is ridiculous.

Someone here mentioned that this has happened before with this company. I think this type of activity is highly deceiving and unethical.

Is there an attorney willing to take my case? I hope to make them pay for their deception, and will seek punitive damages.

Does any lawyer know what my chances are? I have saved copies of the ads before and after, as well as emails saying my orders were successful. When I verified my orders over the phone, the automated system said that my order was verified and that the computers WILL be shipped.
\******************

When they finish with your 71 unit claim they pull your balls out through your nose and have you paying them thousands of dollars.

Do you really think the courts are going to buy into what your selling. Dream on.

You've obviously never been in a court room.

Eat it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
This is Canada, not the US. This kind of blatant, attempted profiteering from an obvious mistake is rather despicable and does not deserve to see the light of day in the Canadian court system when there are other, legitimate cases that need to be heard.

There is nothing innocent about your behaviour in this case. You have not been harmed in any way. It's only your unheralded greed that's going unfulfilled. Even if this case saw the light of day (and I hope it never does) no judge nor any JP could in good conscious grant you punitive damages. On the contrary, punitive damages should be granted to FutureShop for having a money-grubbing individual try to sully an otherwise good corporate name.

FutureShop is not perfect, but at least they don't let greed overcome them by trying to profit from mistakes.
 
From a contract law perspective, there is no obligation for FS to sell an item at the price indicated whether in store or on the web. This is based on old English case law. If you are to sue, it must be for another cause of action - such as a tort.

You may get the remedy you want by complaining to the Competition Bureau (as Thompo suggested) or by writing to Ellen Roseman at TOronto Star. Sometimes, FS may settle to avoid the bad press which may cost them more in the end.
 
FS sometimes, and I mean sometimes have good deals, other than that they seriously overprice their stuff which you could get much cheaper at Canada Computers, Tiger Direct and other small independent computer stores.
 
Yep, 71 is quite excessive.

One or two should have been it.

Plus, they've put up the correction notice right on the main page.
 
You're not going to get anything out of it. They won't even go to small claims court. It was obviously a mistake and no judge will side with you. The only attorney you might get will be on that just wants to bilk you out of money.

These kind of mistakes happen all the time; FS recognized the error and corrected the mistake. I really don't see how it could be classified as bait and switch at all.
 
xarir said:
This is Canada, not the US. This kind of blatant, attempted profiteering from an obvious mistake is rather despicable and does not deserve to see the light of day in the Canadian court system when there are other, legitimate cases that need to be heard.

There is nothing innocent about your behaviour in this case. You have not been harmed in any way. It's only your unheralded greed that's going unfulfilled. Even if this case saw the light of day (and I hope it never does) no judge nor any JP could in good conscious grant you punitive damages. On the contrary, punitive damages should be granted to FutureShop for having a money-grubbing individual try to sully an otherwise good corporate name.

FutureShop is not perfect, but at least they don't let greed overcome them by trying to profit from mistakes.
These kind of lawsuits get thrown out of court in the US too. I remember back when e-tailing was just starting to get big these kind of things happened a lot (selling an item for 10% of it's actual cost and stuff like that). E-tailers were usually quick to spot the mistake but people would throw fits and try to sue them. Nothing happened because nothing illegal was done.
 
stinkynuts said:
Is there an attorney willing to take my case? I hope to make them pay for their deception, and will seek punitive damages.

Does any lawyer know what my chances are? I have saved copies of the ads before and after, as well as emails saying my orders were successful. When I verified my orders over the phone, the automated system said that my order was verified and that the computers WILL be shipped.
I don't think you will get anywhere with punitive damages, but you should be able to receive your computers.

It's not like there was a flyer with a misprint. He actually purchased (and presumably paid for) 71 computers and received e-mail verification. That is a binding contract and FS needs to live up to it.