Of the two, if the money doesn't count, it's all personal taste. As a former Jeep owner, I'd go with the Outback. (Even if it was the more expensive of the two, which you advise it is not.)
Have you considered the Volvo xc60? Perhaps not the same space? I love my Volvo interior, with the wood and soft leather. But I hate buying premium at the pump... It's not the extra money, it's the sense (justified or not) that I'm being ripped off by the oil companies.