Stewart, winner in showdown with Cramer

JohnLarue said:
2. Claim to be successful until you ask them enough questions to know they are exaggerating the wins & downplaying the loses

Standard operating procedure for Gambling Addicts
 
anon1 said:
Standard operating procedure for Gambling Addicts

Oh , this is another form of gambling for sure

"A Little bit of knowledge can be a dangerous thing" and day trading is probably the perfect example
 
Both seem to be gambling for sure.
The big difference lately seems to be the 'regulated' legal Casinos are giving better payoff rates than Wall St....:o
 
As usual, Tom Brown has it right......

I know this will be hard to read for those who go to Comedy Central for their news....

Jon Stewart: Cable Blowhard
Jim Cramer doesn't need any lectures from guys like this
Thomas Brown

Here's the emotional crescendo a finger-wagging Jon Stewart reached last Thursday, in his run-in with Jim Cramer on the Daily Show:


You knew what the banks were doing, and yet were touting it for months and months. The entire network was. And so now to pretend that this was some sort of crazy, once-in-a-lifetime tsunami that nobody could have seen coming is disingenuous at best and criminal at worst. [Emph. added]

Come again? CNBC should have foreseen the implosion of the country’s financial system, and warned its viewers ahead of time? Sure, Jon, if you say so. News flash: if the people at CNBC could have seen the mess coming, they wouldn’t be working in cable news. As far as that goes, look at how good a job even hyper-sophisticated Wall Street types, people like Jimmy Cayne, Dick Fuld, and Hank Greenberg, did in anticipating the mess. Greenberg, for one, told CNBC last week his personal losses from the meltdown so far add up to $2 billion. Two investment banks have collapsed as a result of the crisis, and a third was forced into a sale. A big chunk of the mortgage lending industry has disappeared. The two GSEs have been nationalized, as has the world’s largest insurer. Wachovia, Countrywide, Washington Mutual, National City—all gone. If this was supposed to be some plot Wall Street hatched to enrich itself at Main Street’s expense, as Stewart seems to think, things didn’t go well. Some conspiracy.

The fact is, Cramer is right, and Jon Stewart is full of it: the credit crunch really is a once-every-hundred year event, that 99.5% of investors of all stripes, even the insiders, didn’t see coming. Stewart’s fulmination to the contrary might whip his studio audience into a mini-lather, but it’s idiotic, just the same. And where does he get off suggesting that Cramer is somehow criminally liable for not warning his viewers about the meltdown in advance? That’s not just idiotic—it’s outrageous.

There seems to be no bottom to the depth of moral outrage Jon Stewart can now suddenly summon when it comes to what’s going on on Wall Street these days. The guy says he has just had it. In addition to being ticked off at CNBC for its sin of failing to predict the collapse of the financial system, Stewart now also says he’s shocked by the fact that on Wall Street a) not every investor is buy-and-hold investor, b) a lot of shares of stock trade every day, c) some people are interested in short-term profits rather than long-term profits, and d) heavy leverage can be bad. Oh, and Stewart doesn’t like the promos CNBC does for Mad Money, either. Is there no end to the horror?

I have a question. Who died and made Jon Stewart pope? Jim Cramer is an honest, admirable man who was nowhere near any of the excesses that went on as the subprime bubble inflated. He did an honorable thing by even showing up on Stewart’s show on Thursday. And for his effort, he got to put up with a sanctimonious blowhard for 20 minutes. For myself, I think Cramer’s response to Stewart’s hectoring was way too solicitous. If it had been me, I’d have told the guy to go stick it. Jon Stewart has suddenly set himself up as the moral arbiter ready to pass judgment on Wall Street’s sins. In fact, he’s a know-nothing indulging himself in a bunch of moral preening.

The collapse of the financial markets has caused a lot of pain and anguish over the past 18 months. Jon Stewart doesn’t do anyone any favors by inventing new bogeymen to blame it all on, or writing a fake history of how it all came about. The guy ought to go back to telling jokes
 
so it took a week for you to find an opinion? i thought you were better than that woodpecker guy. i kid, i kid....
 
onthebottom said:
The fact is, Cramer is right, and Jon Stewart is full of it: the credit crunch really is a once-every-hundred year event, that 99.5% of investors of all stripes, even the insiders, didn’t see coming..


1. The credit crunch will be back more often if the banks are deregulated and don't have stringent capitalization requirements

2. The bonuses based on volume not results allowed the executives to clean up while running the business into the ground.

3. Stewart was not complaining about the inability to forecast this but by the soft ball interviews and the touting of the stocks all the way into the ground.

CNBC touted itself as a leading financial reporter and all they did was kiss butt to corporate America, they did not ask the hard questions or do the research or investigate.

Crammer admitted this and promised to do a better job.
 
lenharper said:
so it took a week for you to find an opinion? i thought you were better than that woodpecker guy. i kid, i kid....

The thread was started three days ago, by Pekkkr.... that's not a week.

OTB
 
guelph said:
CNBC touted itself as a leading financial reporter and all they did was kiss butt to corporate America, they did not ask the hard questions or do the research or investigate.

Crammer admitted this and promised to do a better job.

I always have CNBC in the background and it really wasn't until Stewart cast the spotlight on them did I notice what hacks they really are.

The most informative information they give I already get on the newswires. Beyond that, their rah-rah cheerleading and commentating is of such poor quality, I am questioning why having the channel on is even necessary in the first place.
 
Jon stewart

is a personality no not a journalist.



He reads a script.
 
Thomas Brown, great source

onthebottom said:
I know this will be hard to read for those who go to Comedy Central for their news....

Jon Stewart: Cable Blowhard
Jim Cramer doesn't need any lectures from guys like this
Thomas Brown

As usual, Tom Brown has it right......if you are OxyContinized.....

Who the fark is Tom Brown?
One of the Banksters bottie is probably palin' around with???....:D

http://www.bankstocks.com/ArticleViewer.aspx?ArticleID=5723&ArticleTypeID=2
 
JohnLarue said:
More likely they were generating profits for the counterpart on the other of their trade.
I have yet to meet one honest day trader (using thier own capital) who can consistently make profits in all markets & make enough to sustain a good living over an extended period

While they may be out there I have not met them.
I have met quite a few who
1. Made a boat load in 1998 & 1999 only to lose the whole boat lead in 2000
or
2. Claim to be successful until you ask them enough questions to know they are exaggerating the wins & downplaying the loses

There are traders and there are investors, they are mutually exclusive.
Traders do not care about the long term prospects of an economy, they can make as much or more in a bear market. For a trader this market is action central, trade baby trade. Four or five rallies left until bottom.

For an investor, its a volatile mine field, and they should stay in cash. I am in cash and gold, period. Keeping still, keeping the powder dry.. dow 2,800 will not be a long wait. Pack a lunch.


BTW John, how's that buy and hold strategy working out for ya? (This might be a bad time to ask, given the last 750 pt dow bear rally regain).
 
WoodPeckr said:
As usual, Tom Brown has it right......if you are OxyContinized.....

Who the fark is Tom Brown?
One of the Banksters bottie is probably palin' around with???....:D

http://www.bankstocks.com/ArticleViewer.aspx?ArticleID=5723&ArticleTypeID=2

He's an extremely well thought of bank analyst... who is very critical of bankers most of the time. If you ever want to move beyond simple repetitive slogans and name calling and actually understand an issue (I'm not holding my breath) this wouldn't be a bad place to start.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
He's an extremely well thought of bank analyst... who is very critical of bankers most of the time. If you ever want to move beyond simple repetitive slogans and name calling and actually understand an issue (I'm not holding my breath) this wouldn't be a bad place to start.

OTB
Never heard of him!
Besides if Brown was that good wouldn't he be on CNBC?....:D
 
WoodPeckr said:
Never heard of him!
Besides if Brown was that good wouldn't he be on CNBC?....:D

He runs his own firm, he was so critical of First Union a few years ago they had him fired from an analyst position....

As usual, you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about....

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
He runs his own firm, he was so critical of First Union a few years ago they had him fired from an analyst position....As usual, you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about....
OTB

You forgot the link, OTB. So "Tom Brown, he ain't no ordinary guy.....dicksucker", remember those lyrics in that late '79 R&B funk song?

Gyaos Baltar.
 
onthebottom said:
He runs his own firm, he was so critical of First Union a few years ago they had him fired from an analyst position....

As usual, you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about....

OTB
Now that is funny!!!
Yet you give NO link where this can be verified!
So we will just file this in with your 'Dubya delivers real economic performance', credibility dustbin!....:D