Stewart, winner in showdown with Cramer

WoodPeckr

Protuberant Member
May 29, 2002
47,086
6,215
113
North America
thewoodpecker.net
Jon Stewart was devastating in his attack on Cramer and essentially discredited Cramer BIGTIME! Could this be the beginning of the end for FAUX and it's affiliate stations to being considered nothing more than shills for Wall Street and well connected business/corporate intersts (a role bottie also seems to relish)? Is FAUX, et al., nothing but entertainment and infomercial no different than El Rushbloe?....;)

Stewart seen as winner in showdown with Cramer

By Lisa Respers France

(CNN) -- By most accounts, the showdown was pretty brutal.

Many watching Thursday night's "Daily Show" on Comedy Central felt that comedian-turned-media-critic Jon Stewart held bombastic financial guru and CNBC "Mad Money" host Jim Cramer's feet to the fire.

And Cramer flinched.

Stewart, known for his zany, satirical take on the news, was serious as he took Cramer's network to task for what Stewart viewed as their "cheerleading" of corporations at the heart of the nation's current economic crisis.

And despite the title of his financial show, Cramer came off as less mad and more apologetic.

"If it was a prize fight, they would have stopped it," said Howard Kurtz, the "Washington Post" media critic and host of CNN's "Reliable Sources." "I was stunned that Jim Cramer kind of did a rope-a-dope strategy and didn't really defend himself against Jon Stewart's assault."

Kurtz is very familiar with the style of both men.

He has appeared on "The Daily Show" and is the author of "The Fortune Tellers: Inside Wall Street's Game of Money, Media and Manipulation," in which Cramer is featured.

Kurtz said Stewart "made clear at the outset that he wasn't going for laughs" and displayed very much the same passion for holding the media accountable as he did when he appeared on, and denounced, CNN's "Crossfire."

"When I went on [Stewart's] show last year, he was so wound up in ripping the media that he went on for another 10 minutes, knowing full well that we were out of time," Kurtz said. "Stewart, as funny as he can be, is a very trenchant media critic who cares passionately about this stuff, and we saw that Thursday night."

iReporter David Seaman of New York said he was surprised at the vigor with which Stewart "attacked Cramer's credibility." Check out David's iReport

The public wants answers as to how the country got into such financial distress, and viewers really want someone to answer for the mess, Seaman said.

"People want to see a lot of the financial gurus on a shish kabob, being skewered," Seaman said. "It's really important to hold people accountable, and as we saw last night, Jon Stewart is a bit of a wild card, so if you aren't living up to expectations, he may call you out."

David Brancaccio, host and senior editor of "Now on PBS," commended Cramer for his bravery in going on the show, though he said he was surprised that the brilliant founder of TheStreet.com seemed ill-prepared for Stewart's very thoughtful questioning.

Brancaccio, the former host of American Public Media's "Marketplace" radio program, echoed the comments of many in that he found the exchange visibly uncomfortable for the usually showman-like Cramer.

"You have the comedian as journalist, and you have the financial journalist as clown, in that on his show, Cramer's goofing around and plays the clown," Brancaccio said. "What a role reversal."

Brancaccio said Stewart's show has emerged as an important vehicle for media criticism. Thursday night's show marked an important moment in journalism, especially financial reporting, Brancaccio said.

"It's really important that tough questions are asked, because when tough questions aren't asked, we end up with Enron," he said. "It's interesting that the tough questions came from Jon Stewart, brilliant comedian that he is."

Brancaccio thinks the episode may serve as a cautionary tale for those in the media who don't do their due diligence. White House approves of smackdown

"I don't think any financial journalist wants to be in Cramer's position," Brancaccio said. "I think [journalists] may redouble their efforts to be dispassionate reporters asking the tough questions."

Steve Krakauer is associate editor of TVNewser.com, one of the leading blogs about the television news industry, and said comments at his site have been mixed about the show.

Although some thought it was one of the best interviews they had ever seen, others found Stewart arrogant and said his outrage might have been a bit staged.

Krakauer said the question now is where Cramer -- who has said he plans to make some changes to his show -- goes from here.

Krakauer said he doubts that there will be a complete overhaul of "Mad Money."

"I can't see things drastically changing," Krakauer said. " 'Mad Money' is one of the most successful shows on CNBC. Despite what has been written about Jim Cramer, the things he's gotten incorrect and the calls he has made, he's still popular and one of the most entertaining for people who are interested in that type of financial news."

If anything, Cramer's appearance on "The Daily Show" may have just stoked the flames. Comedy Central's Web site played it up with clips from the show that it called "an historic moment in basic cable."


The topic is such a hot one that Kurtz will lead "Reliable Sources" with it Sunday, with journalist Tucker Carlson, radio show host Stephanie Miller and "Baltimore Sun" television critic David Zurawik as guests.
"Beyond the entertainment value, and we are not above that, this is a really important moment for holding financial journalists accountable," Kurtz said. "It may have taken Jon Stewart to blow the whistle on some of the hype and shortsightedness at America's top business news channel, but those failings were repeated throughout the business press, which stumbled badly in reporting on what turned into a huge financial meltdown."
 
For me Jon Stewart's act is running a little thin. I am sure he told Cramer that he would just ask a few simple questions and then he ambushes him. Stewart seemed to make a point of not allowing Cramer to defend himself or explain himself. Cramer would say 3-4 words in a reply and Stewart would cut him off and then say something rightoeus that would get his audience of trained seals applauding. I am not defending Cramer in any way I think he's a complete jackass.
 
Cramer contradicted himself, saying the 35 - 1 leverage was good from '99 - '07, then later on said he didn't know when to call the leverage wrong when "blew up" and it collapsed. Seems to be a 180 lie. Lost all credibility there.

I knew, I pumped it, it was great, it tanked, I didn't know, when I did, I was late. What a farkin' fake. Isn't this criminal behavior using the media to inflate stocks and commodities? Isn't that a form of insider trading.

I will say Stewart didn't show anything from CNBC, except 1 promo. What was that all about? His March 4 rant was all CNBC footage. When it came to presenting evidence, Stewart went with something else, rather than showing all the bad calls CNBC made and then commenting on them in front of Cramer.

The interview was civil. Still probably better getting the truth than anything else currently on US media.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
Gyaos said:
The interview was civil. Still probably better getting the truth than anything else currently on US media.

Gyaos Baltar.
Stewart stands head and shoulders above FAUX.
Jon was brilliant....;)
 
Cramer is extremely important to the investment community and to day traders alike. Yes sir. Just do the opposite to what he recommends and you're sure to make great money. :)
 
Agreeing with Woodpecker sends a shiver down my spine.
However I have long felt that Cramer is a showboat hack and provides information & stock recommendations in a very irresponsible manner.
It is probably a good thing if he was brought down a notch or two
 
BottomsUp said:
Cramer is extremely important to the investment community and to day traders alike. Yes sir. Just do the opposite to what he recommends and you're sure to make great money. :)


Show me a day trader that actually listens to Cramer and I'll show you a loser who will soon be parted with his/her money. Even doing the opposite of what this guy says can be costly because even a broken watch is right twice a day.

Real traders laugh at this clown prince of Wall Street and have for years. I absolutely loved what Stewart did, CNBC should be assumed for passing Cramer off as news.


sean
 
seaniam said:
Show me a day trader that actually listens to Cramer and I'll show you a loser who will soon be parted with his/her money. Even doing the opposite of what this guy says can be costly because even a broken watch is right twice a day.

Real traders laugh at this clown prince of Wall Street and have for years. I absolutely loved what Stewart did, CNBC should be assumed for passing Cramer off as news.


sean

Cramer's show is watched by the home investor. No real market professional listens to Cramer other than to be entertained. I don't know if people actually act on this guy's recommendation but if they do/did, they sort of deserve what they got.
 
Barca said:
Cramer's show is watched by the home investor. No real market professional listens to Cramer other than to be entertained. I don't know if people actually act on this guy's recommendation but if they do/did, they sort of deserve what they got.


I think I said "day" trader which generally means the average joe or as you called them "home investor". Professional traders, if they admit they got an idea from Cramer would be enough to get them fired.


sean
 
There is also a difference between professional day traders and home day traders. Which is why in this particular case, I distinguished them with the "home investor" tag. Even professional day traders probably ignore Cramer as well. To be honest...I don't know a single person that watches his show.

I was agreeing with you.
 
Those non-pro home day traders may have been usefull in generating some 'swing movement' for other interests Cramer may have been shilling.
 
Possibly. Traders actually count on that flow. Was Cramer shilling for other people's positions? I don't believe so. Was he shilling for friends? Probably yes. At this point, I think he had become nothing more than a marketing or promotion machine. He provided no analysis whatsoever...that should have been the very first obvious flag to all investors. But people see what they want to see.
 
While never watching Cramer's show I thought he had a little more on the ball than that, to get his show on TV in the first place.
 
WoodPeckr said:
Those non-pro home day traders may have been usefull in generating some 'swing movement' for other interests Cramer may have been shilling.


More likely they were generating profits for the counterpart on the other of their trade.
I have yet to meet one honest day trader (using thier own capital) who can consistently make profits in all markets & make enough to sustain a good living over an extended period

While they may be out there I have not met them.
I have met quite a few who
1. Made a boat load in 1998 & 1999 only to lose the whole boat lead in 2000
or
2. Claim to be successful until you ask them enough questions to know they are exaggerating the wins & downplaying the loses
 
LOL!
Day traders did well in the 90s but then it was easy since pretty much everything was going up.
 
JohnLarue said:
However I have long felt that Cramer is a showboat hack and provides information & stock recommendations in a very irresponsible manner.

Well, when you have a viewing audience that can pass info via the net and through financial terminals (for instance: Bloomberg L.P.) when Cramer, on-air, says plow money into Google because "it's going at 21x multiples", so everyone does it with or without financial education, and it inflates to $747.00 a share, then I question whether this type of manipulation, using CNBC (i.e.: GE) is legal. Especially when Bernard Madoff loses $64 BILLION, Google claims to make billions rather quickly.....too quickly.....and in the end Google releases everything and I mean everything for free, has all their ads blocked by web-browser plug-ins but claims to be making a billion from it, does not enforce ownership clicking (i.e.: ad merchants and webmasters click their own ads to get paid), create and buy businesses with the inflated stocks, are business models of copyright infringement so all the newspapers and media industries collapse, then claim to have billions in rotating revenue, nevertheless, equal to Microsoft which doesn't release "everything for free".

I just think those Madoff "bogus" investment transactions we see that say money went into Google, actually did go to Google and then disappeared inside Google and was cooked as if it was a return. My gut feeling says it, and I always trust my gut. I use Japan as an example. Yahoo owns Japan and doesn't do what Google does, but Google can't even crack Japan.....but Google is larger than Yahoo in Japan? From what? Overpriced Ginza chicks? I don't buy it.

Cramer should be cuffed.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
The three rules I follow in life:

1) never play poker with a guy named SLIM

2) never buy a rolex from a guy who is out of breath

3) never take investment advice from someone who shouts


sean
 
seaniam said:
The three rules I follow in life:

1) never play poker with a guy named SLIM

2) never buy a rolex from a guy who is out of breath

3) never take investment advice from someone who shouts


sean

You and George Will?