Start their Own League???

Esco!

Banned
Nov 10, 2004
12,603
1
0
Toront Ho
Can somebody please tell me why the player dont start their own League???
All you need is a stadium contract, new jerseys and lots of money which they could borrow.
Is there anything legally the owners can do to stop them?????
I dont think so but I could be wrong
:cool:
 
They do not have the deep pockets to carry losing teams, therefore if they started their own league they would have to have less teams, therefore less players, lower salaries, not to mention no TV deals.

Any deal with the NHL would put more money in their pockets than starting their own league.
 
dreamer said:
They do not have the deep pockets to carry losing teams, therefore if they started their own league they would have to have less teams,
But thats the whole idea because the NHL has too many teams as it is right now.

dreamer said:
therefore less players
Which is why the top players should just start their own league with say 12 teams or so. You weed out fringe players this way.

dreamer said:
not to mention no TV deals.
TV deals would surely follow.

dreamer said:
Any deal with the NHL would put more money in their pockets than starting their own league.
In the short term yes but long term, no,
At least thats IMHO
 
I do not think the NHL Players Union is for less players.

The union would have to fold or basically be inempt before the top players decided to start their own league.

I do believe the players, including the top players will get a better deal with the NHL than starting their own league.

Most players only think in the short term not the long term.
 
No offense Escohort....you're kidding right?

First things first, most of the players aren't exactly MENSA candidates - they basically couldn't put together the logistics of something like that. It usually takes years to negotiate - stadium rights, hire management, scouts, farm organizations, even uniforms design, league endorsement contracts, individual team endorsement etc, etc.

Most of the owners of teams now are corporations and for good reason. Gone are the days of the individual owners. You need a high power law firm, accountants, front office management, trainers, team doctors, state of the medical equiptment (or at least access to it) etc...etc...

In the current CBA the PA won't even take the risk of profit sharing (because if the team loses money - no profit to share) what makes you think these guys are willing to put up...hmmm...what? 70 - 100 million to start a team, nevermind a league.

It would almost be impossible for the players to borrow money as well, it's a bad business proposition. And at best - they'd be ranked below Arena Football, Golf, any of the College games and Poker. Why? Because those guys have a tv contract - hockey doesn't. They're practically giving the tv rights to NBC - nobody in the states gives a crap about hockey, its a fringe sport. At best they'd be like the NLL, and if that's the case the players would be getting what? 20,000 per year?...sounds about right.

Nevermind a dispersal draft if teams contract - that would be a nightmare! Then theres salaries - do you think these guys will take less money? not a chance.
 
Chief Problem

The problems they would have with starting their own league:

Stadium deals: Most stadiums are owned by the NHL teams and therefore they are not about to let the players start up a rival league. In the case of leased stadiums.....there are non-compete clauses in the agreement preventing the building from renting to a competitive league.


Sponsorship and TV: A new league would not have the credibility and proven long term success to attract sufficient revenue streams.

Union: The NHLPA would dissolve if its players left the NHL and started a rival league. That would play into the hands of the NHL ownwers and I'm sure Goodenow would be convincing all players/members that a rival league would be bad.


Intelligence: I don't think there are enough bright enough hockey players to actually run a league.


Money: There is no way a new start-up league would be able to pay these guys the salary's they're already rejecting from the NHL.
 
healer677 said:
No offense Escohort....you're kidding right?
No I'm dead serious and the same idea was raised in the Toronto sun a few months ago (wish I had the link).

But you guys bring up good arguments.
I never said it'd be easy but I think it could be done.

First of all you dont let the actual players construct the league but you hire people with brains to do it.

I really think it could be done
 
"First of all you dont let the actual players construct the league but you hire people with brains to do it."
And who's going to hire the people with hte brains- the players. And then they'll let them tell the players what they can and can't do. I don't think so.
Fuck the players...and the owners too! :mad:
 
Fuck the NHL

Escohort said:
First of all you dont let the actual players construct the league but you hire people with brains to do it.

I really think it could be done
http://slam.canoe.ca/Slam/Columnists/Strachan/2005/02/13/929882-sun.html :eek:

Perhaps the combined forces of the best players in the world, successful NHL franchises, oportunistic European entrepreneurs, and the WHA could bury the NHL.

The threat of the NHL using replacement players is a joke.
This would help the players' cause.
 
I'd like to see the players negotiating contracts for eachother. Watch them start fighting amongst themselves.
 
Malibook said:
http://slam.canoe.ca/Slam/Columnists/Strachan/2005/02/13/929882-sun.html :eek:

Perhaps the combined forces of the best players in the world, successful NHL franchises, oportunistic European entrepreneurs, and the WHA could bury the NHL.

Al Strachan has been wrong so many times in the past about rumours and "what he has heard".

A super league in Europe would not be followed by the North American market. Certainly it would help them to start this league by signing unhappy NHL's, however in the long run players will still want to play at home.

If the labour dispute does result in a new "Super" league in Europe it would certainly have an impact on European players coming to the NHL in the future, however some may still be lured by $$$$. Could an European team still compete dollar wise even with an NHL with a salary cap? I do not know.
 
Last edited:
European Super League

A European super league wouldn't be able to pay the players the kind of money the NHL did/could because it wouldn't be able to have the same outrageous ticket prices and box seats, etc.......attending elite league soccer matches in europe are far cheaper than NHL games.

If european leagues could pay NHL type dollars they would have already done that to stop the top europeans from coming to north america in the first place.

Furthermore european sports leagues don't generate TV revenue in europe the way the do in America. Main revenues over there are merchandise, ticket sales and team/uniform sponsorships.

Finally.....a european super league wouldn't be followed in North America for the simple fact of time zones....games played in Europe would be televised while we're all at work.....and north americans have never taken to watching tape delayed events for which we already know the score.

Just look at the Olympic games......north american networks pay far more for broadcast rights when the events are held in north american time zones.
 
Oh God here we go again. Referencing Strachan again Malibook? :rolleyes:
This will never fly. Not for the money that the NHL-less players want. yes attendace is up but these arenas are basically the size of the OHL rinks, with the occasional one pushing 12,000-15,000. Add to that alot of the better older estasblished clubs play in town/cities of less then 50,000. Strachan should serously do himself a favour and shut the fuck up!!. Better yet, Toronto Sun -FIRE HIM!!.