spayed - neutered vs unspayed - unneutered

Dash

Member
Apr 6, 2003
655
0
16
49
hey,

heres a question for everybody...

I have a cat - who we have delayed in getting the operation of having him neutered - due to the fact that the debate on the ethics of having a cat neutered rages on with regards to my cat - cos of the fact that i regard him as another individual of the household with just as many rights as any of the other members of the same household and no less. With regards to how playful, adoreable and the extreme level of intelligence he possesses. Now as u probably guessed, the cat's a male.

This cat has been with us for a while and he's alot of work to care for as he seems to have alot of personality and never runs out of energy and we adore him.

The question that rages - with regards to him is this -

as a very adored member of the household - if he was to have the same rights as any other living being - like they preach in star trek the next generation - the right of all life is to be left uninterrupted or to that effect - begs the question - wouldn't it be wrong to perform surgery on an animal/living being to remove/take away something that is an essential part of them? Like, can't it be the same as/analogous with say, having surgery performed on them to remove something like an arm or leg or tail, that would be viewed as wrong or inhumane? So how can having their sexual organs removed be defined as just? .

When they have debated and came to the decision, in a civil society, according to a just and lawful society, it is extremely cruel and criminal to remove any part of an individual person's body without their consent. This is regarded as one of the highest forms of cruelty - and is cannot be more highly disapproved of when a person is subjected to having something permanently and irreversible taken/removed that is a part of them, yet when its performed on animals, its hardly discussed/talked about at all.

So who's to say that animals, whom in most cases cannot speak out for themselves, on issues regarding what is done to them, in most cases they are helpless to the conditions or treatment that their master/owner subjects them to, humane or inhumane, viewed exactly as being owned, slaves, objects or property that the master/owner can do with whatever they please.

For example, Paris Hilton got rid of her dog cos he was getting too big? like wtf?

and it pisses me off when i see people carrying little dogs inside their purse...im sure thats against the law.

Anyways, I think I made my point. The question I wanted to ask you guys is, If I choose not to spay/neuter my cat, do any of u guys/girls have non-neutered,non-spayed cats that behave as well/as good as spayed/non-neutered cats- like always remain devoted and always returning home if u let him out. I have a friend who told me that they had cats that wasn't spayed and he always comes back home - if u let him out. But I have had like two cats prior to the cats i have now - and they weren't spayed - they were permitted to run freely outdoors and both two prior cats went outside one day, left and never came back.

And now I'm asking ur opinions on this, cos I'm afraid this beautiful cat we have now, un-neutered, non-spayed might become another cat that goes outside one day, leave and never come back.
 
This is a very thoughtful post...

...Mr. Dash. In my view, you should not have your male cat neutered. In my experience, a male cat can be 'trained' , to be let outside where it will spray(to mark it's territory). To 'neuter' a male animal for the sack of convenience is unethical. If one is not prepared to take responsibility for a creature-in its entire entity-than one should forgo that responsibility. By the way, I like Star Trek(The Next Generation)as well. Mr. Data is my favorite character in that series. Mere opinion only, I realize. Sincerely, Jon .
 
I have a female cat that has been spayed.

I think she would have made a great mother cat, but since she was spayed when I got her, she had no choice.

I think if I was to have owned her since she was a kitten, I probably would have let her have 1 litter of kittens, then had her spayed. Like many humans opt to do.
 
Last edited:
Both male and female pets should be spayed/neutered....It leads to longer life thru fewer reproductive health problems, especially with females. I spent many years in the animal health business, and most of the veterinarians I knew always recomended spaying and neutering unless your intention is to breed. A male cat will always mark his territory, and has likely done it when you are'nt looking, or where you can't see it.

Neuter your cat....You'll both be better off in the long run.....:)
 
Yep, casteration will not change their personality. They won't like you for it, but they will still play chase the string with you.
 
When we remove animals from their natural habitat, domesticate them, make them into pets they are no longer free entities. They become our property and our responsibility. So if we leave them capable of procreation we take responsibility for that too. if you want to breed kittens then don't fix your cat. If you don't want kittens then fix him or leave him in the house isolated from other cats.
 
Last edited:
Its hard for me to believe some of the views posted in this thread. There are too many stray cats and dogs running loose right now. Many of these will have sad, if not horrible, deaths. A main purpose of neutering is to prevent your pet from partaking in the further sad proliferation of unwanted cats and dogs. Its hard for me to imagine any thinking person allowing their unneutered pet out out of doors unsupervised for any length of time. And from all experience I've had, and any info I've gotten, a neutered pet is almost always a better pet.
 
Sheik said:
For those of you with male dogs, their testicles can be replaced with fake ones if thats what you are concerned about.
I've never heard of this. Why would anyone do this? Do the dogs notice? If not then its just added risk for the dog to have anything implanted in its body for the sake of making it esthetically pleasing to the owner..
 
Sheik said:
Having owned several animals over the years I'm a strong advocate for spaying/neutering pets.

There is a good reason to do so. There are too many wild cats trying to survive in the great outdoors (go into any industrial area in the GTA and just sit and watch for a couple of hours in some quiet areas). Pets are not intended to be released into the wild or outside without a leash or fenced in area. The unfortunate fact is, when pets do get pregnant and have their litters, what do you think is going to happen to the new ones? You do realize that both dogs and cats are capable of having 6 or more little ones at a time? Are you going to take care of all these new borns? Going to give them away?

One look in the animal control centers would tell you that there are so many unwanted and or abused pets. Many have been abandoned. Many come from new litters that people wanted their pets to have so their own kids can experience a birthing.

Sorry folks, responsible pet owners will either make sure their pets cannot concieve new ones or will breed them specifically to get more of the same breed.

All the female dogs I've owned when they go into heat, they bleed all over the place. Twice a year. Male dogs will spray, same with cats and nothing is stopping them from doing inside as well.

I've yet to see any of them experience a major or even minor change in their personalities. For those of you with male dogs, their testicles can be replaced with fake ones if thats what you are concerned about.

Name of the game is to prevent reproduction of the unwanted kind.

Like he said!!
 
Interesting post Dash.... because I have always wondered the same thing. How humane it is to neuter your pet.

I have always found it somewhat ironic that animal rights groups like PETA who argue that pets deserve (close to) the same rights as humans yet they support spaying/neutering of your pets. Yes the spaying/neutering of pets is good in terms of controlling population and such but would you support the spaying/neutering of humans for the same role? Remember the one US judge who made some off-hand comment about how if he could, he'd neuter men convicted of rape as their punishment? Or the crazy article on one sociologist who proposed the spaying/neutering or people with genetic defects to keep the gene pool clean. And you have the people who feel men who father too many illegitimate children (and cannot financially support them) get three warnings then get neutered? All those proposals got absolutely slammed as violating human rights and proposing physical mutilation... so how can an animals rights group support spaying/neutering of pets?

Also spaying/neutering pets do change their behavior. They become more passive with other animals. This is a fact.
 
Don said:
Remember the one US judge who made some off-hand comment about how if he could, he'd neuter men convicted of rape as their punishment? And you have the people who feel men who father too many illegitimate children (and cannot financially support them) get three warnings then get neutered?

The judge should have included child molesters in his comment as well. And the father who is helping to promote problems to society by having irresponsible sex, should have his sexual function revoked.

Your last comment doesn't bear logically on the topic of this thread. Except in very special circumstances and for the reasons best explained by sheik, pets should be neutered.
 
WhaWhaWha said:
Those appear to be stock photos and not actual photos ofthe animals in need. It seems that for each breed that is repeated the image is the same. Makes me feel less weepy somehow.

And you would know this how?

In the case of the cats, the photos sometimes show 2 cats in the same cage. So first you have cat A description then you have cat B description, but the photo is the same.

In the case of the dogs, they look like different dogs to me. The descriptions are also different, including the length of time the animal has been in the facility.

There are two types of people in this world. Animal people and nonanimal people. My guess is you are not an animal person.
 
WhaWhaWha said:
I've never heard of this. Why would anyone do this? Do the dogs notice? If not then its just added risk for the dog to have anything implanted in its body for the sake of making it esthetically pleasing to the owner..
This isn't done for the dogs benefit and is not a matter of aesthetics. Breeders who show their dogs will do this if one of the dog's testicles doesn't drop or is missing completely. Believe it or not but this is checked during judging.

I heard a story, I don't know if it's true, where a breeder did this to one of their show dogs whose testicle hadn't dropped. At the judging they found three testicles because the second testicle had finally dropped. The dog was disqualified.
 
pets are a waste of time and money:
the billions of dollars a year wasted on pets could cure cancer,aids,poverty etc. put your money to good use spend in on whores or disease fighting or just your neighborhood SP:D
 
whynotme said:
pets are a waste of time and money:
the billions of dollars a year wasted on pets could cure cancer,aids,poverty etc. put your money to good use spend in on whores or disease fighting or just your neighborhood SP


I think you should be spayed or neutered...immediately!:mad:
 
Dash, if you don't let the cat outside, then not getting it fixed would be similar to torture, ie it would still go into heat, but be unable to have the craving satisfied. This is not something that can be controlled any other way.

My (female) cat was spayed when she was 5 yrs. old. She lost none of her spunk. It's well-documented that fixed cats are happier as strictly-indoor pets.
 
being a sucker for animals. I currently have two dogs and two cats, all of them are humane society pets, and they are all neutered/spayed.

Unless you are a responsible breeder there is no need, not to spay and neuter.
The pictures of the animals are just the tip of the iceberg. Those were deemed adoptable, the rest has been destroyed already.
Some shelters have a thirty day policy, meaning if an animal has not been adopted by then, it will be killed.

These procedures are necessary to stem of the wave of unwanted animals. There is no way that any shelter can manange all the pets being dropped off. Unfortunately the list of unwanted pets, get's bigger after Christmas.

To make it short.
Please be responsible and neuter/spay your pet, unless you are a breeder.(Geez I sound like Bob Barker now)

Please don't buy any pets in those mall stores. Most of them are from puppy mills. if you are absolutely sure that you have the time and money to have a pet. Please go the shelters.

They are cheaper. They have been screened and tested for temperament and usually make great pets.

That's my two cents...and a half