Something every Canadian should watch

It's always interesting to be reminded of the days when the Canadian Army (well, Corps) was the home of some of the best and brightest military thinkers.

Seeing the carvings in the subway always gives me the chills. Sort of wish I was back in school and could make the trip over for the re-dedication of the memorial. (it's on my lifetime to do list to visit)
 
basketcase said:
It's always interesting to be reminded of the days when the Canadian Army (well, Corps) was the home of some of the best and brightest military thinkers.

No offense intended, and truthfully I know little about this,
but I had the impression that the canadians were used by the
british generals as sort of expendable cannon fodder.
Like in the Dieppe Raid.

No offense intended.
 
danmand said:
No offense intended, and truthfully I know little about this,
but I had the impression that the canadians were used by the british generals as sort of expendable cannon fodder. Like in the Dieppe Raid.
Absolutely not. Dieppe was indeed a horror, but valuable lessons were learned and Canadian troops were used NOT to spare British troops, but because they were available.

In the First World War one of the reasons why the Canadian Corps had such high casualties was because they rapidly became the shock troops of the BEF. When the impossible absolutely had to be accomplished it was the Canadians who were asked to do it. It really is peculiar that this “incompetent generals” accusation has become particularly entrenched instead of a sense of being the elite. Perhaps it had to due with the general disillusionment after the war.
 
Aardvark154 said:
Absolutely not. Dieppe was indeed a horror, but valuable lessons were learned and Canadian troops were used NOT to spare British troops, but because they were available.

In the First World War one of the reasons why the Canadian Corps had such high casualties was because they rapidly became the shock troops of the BEF. When the impossible absolutely had to be accomplished it was the Canadians who were asked to do it. It really is peculiar that this “incompetent generals” accusation has become particularly entrenched instead of a sense of being the elite. Perhaps it had to due with the general disillusionment after the war.

Thanks for clearing this up for me, as I said I know very little of this.
 
danmand said:
Thanks for clearing this up for me, as I said I know very little of this.

You could have taken an hour and a half from your busy schedule and watched the program. Then you would have known a little more.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
You could have taken an hour and a half from your busy schedule and watched the program. Then you would have known a little more.

I might have watched it if it weren't for you stating that it would show me the impact the Canadian military has had in forming the Canadian identity.

No offence, but that turned me off the program.
 
danmand said:
I might have watched it if it weren't for you stating that it would show me the impact the Canadian military has had in forming the Canadian identity.

No offence, but that turned me off the program.

Danman,

I'm surprised I have that much of an affect on you or I would have chosen my words more carefully. I should have said, the Canadian identity was demonstrated through the actions of those in the military at Vimy Ridge.

The program was well done and worthy of your time. I hope you take advantage of a future opportunity to see it.
 
enduser1 said:
A very good Book is VIMY by Pierre Burton. Regrettably he blew it in the last paragraph. It would have been a masterpiece. Unfortunately he comes off as a bitter WWII vet who thinks his war was worth more than WWI and his generations sacrifice was more important. Still the first 350 or so pages are fantastic. Really, really well written.

EU
It is an excellent book.
 
danmand said:
I might have watched it if it weren't for you stating that it would show me the impact the Canadian military has had in forming the Canadian identity.

No offence, but that turned me off the program.
It is actually true to a fair extent. The contributions and successes of the Canadian military earned them a seat at the adult table of international relations and showed that Canada was capable of governing it's own people.

It had a huge impact of developing the "helping" attitude that endowed the Canadian focus on Peacekeeping.
 
enduser1 said:
A very good Book is VIMY by Pierre Burton. Regrettably he blew it in the last paragraph. It would have been a masterpiece. Unfortunately he comes off as a bitter WWII vet who thinks his war was worth more than WWI and his generations sacrifice was more important. Still the first 350 or so pages are fantastic. Really, really well written.

EU

I stopped into Chapters today and the book is not in stock in any location?

Anyone know where I can pick up a copy?
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
I stopped into Chapters today and the book is not in stock in any location?

Anyone know where I can pick up a copy?

Dear friend, go to Indigo,com, available for $16.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
I don't use credit cards online. I was hoping I could pick it up the old fashioned way.
Since Chapters has it online, presumably they could get a copy into one of their stores for you.
 
One of the salient points Berton makes is that Canada's significant contribution to the 'victory' at Vimy was made by citizen-soldiers pretty well all the way up to the command level. Not by a professional military.